Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely gutted at getting the lowest payrise in the organisation?

171 replies

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 12:59

I am the only person, out of 130 staff to be getting less than 5%.

I have a senior support staff role on a school, the most senior. It's a tough job juggling conflicting priorities and basically any problem that isn't directly related to teaching and learning lands on my desk. I do a good job and always get excellent reviews. Pay is comparable to an upper scale teacher without allowances.

This year teachers are getting a minimum of 5% with some of the lower paid getting more. Good.

Support staff points are all getting the same amount in pounds. For some staff this is up to 10%, also good for the lowest paid, but doing it that way means that people higher up the scale get a lower %.

I'm happy that ridiculously low paid staff will be getting a decent rise for a change, but to be getting significantly less than anyone else in the organisation, including some paid a lot more than me is really hard to take.

It's no one at the school's fault (LA school tied to national payscales) but to say I'm feeling unvauled and unmotivated would be putting it mildly.

AIBU and how do I get over it?

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 05/11/2022 14:42

People voting to accept the pay offer doesn't mean "the union" isn't sticking up for its members.

The union is its members. The people in the union voted to accept an offer which represents a significant real terms pay cut those at the top of the pay scale.

I would hope that my teaching colleagues on the lower rungs of the main pay scale won't just vote to accept an offer that's 8.9% for them, but lower for more experienced teachers because they're ok.

SparklyFoot · 05/11/2022 14:40

JustPickleRick · 05/11/2022 14:27

So you're support staff but get paid similar amounts to a teacher on the UPS? 🤔
If I've read that correctly then you need to stop moaning 😅

Why? I am equally well qualified and have loads more responsibility than a class teacher.

endlesscraziness · 05/11/2022 14:34

It's the same in the NHS. Having a fixed amount for all rather than a % fucked over the higher bands

WelshNerd · 05/11/2022 14:33

People voting to accept the pay offer doesn't mean "the union" isn't sticking up for its members. They are representing the views of the majority of their members.

It would be totally wrong, and actually illegal, for unison and GMB to push for strike action that their members don't support.

FinallyHere · 05/11/2022 14:32

Applications I know are strong aren't even getting interviews.

It's a market.

The offer is what they are prepared to pay you and the answer if it doesn't suit you is to find another role which suits you better.

Keep trying snd network furiously. There will be better roles out there for you, you just need to find them.

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 14:30

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 14:20

Not just because of that, no. As I said, final straw.

Yes, some kind of drip feed which you didn’t mention earlier on in the thread. You posted about the payrise. You’d be incredibly unreasonable to go off sick for 6 months and then resign because the govt didn’t give you a pay rise. I’m not saying the govt manage their money well but paying 6 months sick pay to someone who has gone off in a strop won’t help the public purse

JustPickleRick · 05/11/2022 14:27

So you're support staff but get paid similar amounts to a teacher on the UPS? 🤔
If I've read that correctly then you need to stop moaning 😅

restisall · 05/11/2022 14:24

I'm in local government and also frustrated that people on my, higher grade are getting 3% while the lower grades are getting 9%. Not a race to the bottom, I don't begrudge them their raise but think it should be across the board.

The higher grades also have to contribute a higher % to the pension scheme as well, to not have an increased benefit, and I'll go into that bracket this year so the 3% will be wiped out immediately!

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 14:20

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 14:08

So you’d take 6 months sick leave in protest and leave the school in the shit because of a pay decision that they didn’t even make??

Not just because of that, no. As I said, final straw.

OP posts:
MassageGun · 05/11/2022 14:14

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/11/2022 14:06

SBM on TTO? Really? How do you do Year end, Safer Recruitment procedures over the summer and everything else if you're not there for the times that they're most likely to crop up?

I've never met a poor one before, either. It's always been a case of the biggest Mercedes in the car park.

You've always been paid more than anybody else in support - just because you're only getting 5%, it doesn't change the fact you're still earning more than everyone else.

I'm getting less than 5%. I'm not paid more than everyone else, others with similar responsibilities are paid a lot more (I have 20 line reports and as you say, safeguarding responsibilities). The role is undervalued though and one of the hardest in schools to fill/retain. I'm constantly asked to help out local schools whose SBM is either long term sick or has left.

I'd bet that any SBMs with 'the biggest Mecedes' are doing the job for pin money because their DH has a good job. Or work in Acadamies.

I do term time plus three weeks. Year end is in April, most of the recruitment paperwork is done before we break up in July. Premises work is the only reason I need to be there in holidays, but thanks for your concern 😆

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 05/11/2022 14:12

I have been applying for other jobs, but after a lifetime of pretty much being successful every time I applied, I'm finding it harder now, which I'm putting down to being in my 50s

I started to be concerned about this as I reached my 60s, but haven't found it an issue in the slightest.
Try not to think about it, review your CV and make sure you don't come across as stuck in your ways.

Another issue with across the board percentage uplifts can be keeping up with minimum and living wage levels - I work for a small charity, the London Living Wage increased by 8% this year, there is no way we could afford that across the board without redundancies.

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 14:08

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 14:05

Yes, obviously it's not the only issue I'm facing currently, but it does feel like the final straw. I'm sorely tempted to take my six months' sick leave and retire, which is an attitude that shocks me myself, having been thoroughly contientious my entire life.

So you’d take 6 months sick leave in protest and leave the school in the shit because of a pay decision that they didn’t even make??

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/11/2022 14:06

SBM on TTO? Really? How do you do Year end, Safer Recruitment procedures over the summer and everything else if you're not there for the times that they're most likely to crop up?

I've never met a poor one before, either. It's always been a case of the biggest Mercedes in the car park.

You've always been paid more than anybody else in support - just because you're only getting 5%, it doesn't change the fact you're still earning more than everyone else.

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 14:05

Yes, obviously it's not the only issue I'm facing currently, but it does feel like the final straw. I'm sorely tempted to take my six months' sick leave and retire, which is an attitude that shocks me myself, having been thoroughly contientious my entire life.

OP posts:
Notacompetitiveundereater · 05/11/2022 14:03

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 13:58

Op you asked how to get over it, people are explaining that it’s not personal etc and that’s it’s not a bad pay rise etc but you’re determined to continue complaining about people getting more than you.
you need to make peace with it or leave, they’re really your only options

This. Stunned at what I’m reading. It’s all but but but. Either get over it or quit. That’s it.

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 13:58

Op you asked how to get over it, people are explaining that it’s not personal etc and that’s it’s not a bad pay rise etc but you’re determined to continue complaining about people getting more than you.
you need to make peace with it or leave, they’re really your only options

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 13:56

RockyOfTheRovers · 05/11/2022 13:53

If it helps you feel better, remember your pay rise will be substantially more than most of the support staff because the £1925 is the raise for full time roles only. Anyone on a term time only part time salary, which as you’ll know is most support staff in most schools, will be given much less. The difference in my take home pay is actually less than £30 per month.

I'm on a part time (term time) contract too. My site managers and a couple of others will get more cash than I do.

OP posts:
RockyOfTheRovers · 05/11/2022 13:53

If it helps you feel better, remember your pay rise will be substantially more than most of the support staff because the £1925 is the raise for full time roles only. Anyone on a term time only part time salary, which as you’ll know is most support staff in most schools, will be given much less. The difference in my take home pay is actually less than £30 per month.

noblegiraffe · 05/11/2022 13:52

I know, for a change schools, are getting a proper payrise. That's a reflection on how hard it to retain staff, except me, apparently.

We're not though, we're getting a real terms pay cut over 5% when inflation is taken into account.

That's why we are balloting for strike action. I understand your union accepted your pay offer, so your beef is with them for not standing up for you.

It is shit. But teachers aren't getting a good deal either and are also unhappy with the situation.

PinkFrogss · 05/11/2022 13:45

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 13:41

I won't get the full amount, it will be pro rata because I don't get paid for all the holidays.

I know, for a change schools, are getting a proper payrise. That's a reflection on how hard it to retain staff, except me, apparently.

Well individuals aren’t really considered when it’s a national pay award, they don’t sit there and think we should increase pay by £1925. Oh hold on that’s not fair because of a specific individual.

You are taking it personally when it could not be any less personal.

FWIW your pro raga holiday pay will go up too soon as an additional day of annual leave has been agreed for next year.

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 13:44

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 13:41

I won't get the full amount, it will be pro rata because I don't get paid for all the holidays.

I know, for a change schools, are getting a proper payrise. That's a reflection on how hard it to retain staff, except me, apparently.

I’m not sure how this all works but you say it’s tied to LA rather than the school so isn’t it just the way it is? No-one in the school is undervaluing you or making any negative judgements on you at all as they haven’t made the decision. It sounds a bit woe is me quite honestly when you’ve got a pay rise of almost £2k

katmarie · 05/11/2022 13:42

I get why you're a bit fed up op, that's the issue with set value pay awards rather than percentage awards. If you're on a higher rate, they represent a smaller overall percentage of your salary, and that can feel a bit demoralising.

I had a similar thing in my previous role, and to be honest that was one of the catalysts to me leaving that role and moving on. They gave everyone who's performance was considered acceptable the same pay award amount. This was everyone from people who had completed probation that month to people like me who had been there over 18 months without a pay review. I didn't feel the award reflected the work I'd done or my performance over the period, which I was assured was excellent, they agreed I had regularly gone above and beyond. They were not moving on that set amount though and there was no performance bonus or incentive, so ultimately I moved on instead to a role which offered a higher salary and better pay structure for me.

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 13:41

Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 13:39

If you’ve got £1925 then I’d say that’s really good in any case. I’m in the private sector and would get nowhere near that or anywhere near 5% either

I won't get the full amount, it will be pro rata because I don't get paid for all the holidays.

I know, for a change schools, are getting a proper payrise. That's a reflection on how hard it to retain staff, except me, apparently.

OP posts:
Everyoneandeverything · 05/11/2022 13:39

If you’ve got £1925 then I’d say that’s really good in any case. I’m in the private sector and would get nowhere near that or anywhere near 5% either

Quveas · 05/11/2022 13:38

Takingabreakagain · 05/11/2022 13:11

Local authority pay award will be the same and like you I am disappointed. The further up the scale you progress it seems like 'they' value your contribution less.
I fully understand that lower paid workers need to earn more in order to afford the cost of living but I do wonder at what point will it be pointless paying out for degrees, training etc because you won't get that money back. The whole workplace will then suffer because it's not worth anyone progressing

Speaking as a local authority worker, local authority workers deserve what they are getting. Not because I think the pay is good - I don't. But because for well over a decade both UNISON and the GMB have overwhelmingly voted to reject industrial action of any kind to support their services, pay and conditions. If you are going to act like a doormat, then you will be treated as one. And they have just done the same thing again, knowing for a fact that other workers have had enough and are fighting for pay and conditions and also knowing fully about the cost of living and energy prices.

It isn't "they" who don't value you - it's "you" who don't value yourselves.

And if anyone wants to know my union voted overwhelmingly for strike action on local authority pay but regrettably it's a case of two out of three unions accepting being binding nationally.