Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely gutted at getting the lowest payrise in the organisation?

171 replies

MassageGun · 05/11/2022 12:59

I am the only person, out of 130 staff to be getting less than 5%.

I have a senior support staff role on a school, the most senior. It's a tough job juggling conflicting priorities and basically any problem that isn't directly related to teaching and learning lands on my desk. I do a good job and always get excellent reviews. Pay is comparable to an upper scale teacher without allowances.

This year teachers are getting a minimum of 5% with some of the lower paid getting more. Good.

Support staff points are all getting the same amount in pounds. For some staff this is up to 10%, also good for the lowest paid, but doing it that way means that people higher up the scale get a lower %.

I'm happy that ridiculously low paid staff will be getting a decent rise for a change, but to be getting significantly less than anyone else in the organisation, including some paid a lot more than me is really hard to take.

It's no one at the school's fault (LA school tied to national payscales) but to say I'm feeling unvauled and unmotivated would be putting it mildly.

AIBU and how do I get over it?

OP posts:
Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 10:43

Or indeed their performance warrants one

Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 10:43

My point re private versus public sector

is the entitlement of so many in the public sector to pay rises, irrespective of whether there’s actually any money in the coffers

Badnewsoracle · 06/11/2022 10:42

YABU.

This is a nationally set pay increase of a fixed amount. It's not like the school have decided you weren't worthy of a better pay rise.

CecilyP · 06/11/2022 10:40

Because there is always someone worse off than you, that doesn't mean that you should be content with being treated badly or unfairly.

It doesn't bring perspective, it's just a trite argument to try to make people stop making valid complaints while pitting people against each other about who has it the worst.

But the whole point of these lump sum pay rises (agreed by the unions) is to help the lower paid. Which of course means the better paid get a lower percentage increase. I don’t think they are really too hard done by.

CatsEatDogs · 06/11/2022 10:40

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:37

Plenty of people on this thread have said that they think the pay rise is fair and that they would get a lot less.

No one has managed to explain why it is fair that the OP gets a bigger pay cut than her colleagues.

Other people getting a lot less in other organisations is irrelevant.

Actually i think a lot of people have said that they do think the flat amount across the board is fair and helps out those who have earned much less in percentage pay rises historically than higher earners, redressing the balance. Just because you disagree doesn’t mean that people haven’t explained why they think it’s fair

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:37

Plenty of people on this thread have said that they think the pay rise is fair and that they would get a lot less.

No one has managed to explain why it is fair that the OP gets a bigger pay cut than her colleagues.

Other people getting a lot less in other organisations is irrelevant.

CatsEatDogs · 06/11/2022 10:32

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:28

I don’t get the race to the bottom argument that always gets used. Debate is about pointing out other perspectives and experiences, nothing wrong with that.

Because there is always someone worse off than you, that doesn't mean that you should be content with being treated badly or unfairly.

It doesn't bring perspective, it's just a trite argument to try to make people stop making valid complaints while pitting people against each other about who has it the worst.

"I'm not happy about my working conditions"

"Yeah? Well think about those people who go into sewers and break up fatbergs before you start complaining"

🤷‍♀️And your argument just shouts down those who have worse experiences than the op.
Plenty of people on this thread have said that they think the pay rise is fair and that they would get a lot less. Plenty have said the opposite. All entitled to their opinions and to express them.

CecilyP · 06/11/2022 10:31

You say you are getting the lowest % pay rise in your organisation but presumably that is because you are the only member of staff in your school with your particular role. However as it is a nationally agreed pay rise, there will people with your role in state schools up and down the country getting exactly the same pay rise as you! So you are not as hard done by as you seem to believe.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:28

I don’t get the race to the bottom argument that always gets used. Debate is about pointing out other perspectives and experiences, nothing wrong with that.

Because there is always someone worse off than you, that doesn't mean that you should be content with being treated badly or unfairly.

It doesn't bring perspective, it's just a trite argument to try to make people stop making valid complaints while pitting people against each other about who has it the worst.

"I'm not happy about my working conditions"

"Yeah? Well think about those people who go into sewers and break up fatbergs before you start complaining"

CatsEatDogs · 06/11/2022 10:25

I don’t get the race to the bottom argument that always gets used. Debate is about pointing out other perspectives and experiences, nothing wrong with that.

needabreak5 · 06/11/2022 10:24

YABU because a £2k pay rise isn’t bad. And you’d have to be getting a decent enough pay for it to be less than 5 %.

i work in the most senior support role (private sector), and our company gave fixed amounts of £2k each to all support roles and 7% to those who are qualified in the profession. I think it’s fair, even though I’m in the same position as op as a result of the model.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:19

I’m just pointing out that a huge amount of private sector employees earn very little and have very few benefits.

Is it a race to the bottom? Why are those employees not moving to the public sector if it's so much better? Why are TAs leaving schools to work in supermarkets?

SquashesPumpkinsAutumnBliss · 06/11/2022 10:15

Unfunded

SquashesPumpkinsAutumnBliss · 06/11/2022 10:14

But are teachers getting that pay rise? As it is unfounded by Government and schools don’t have that extra money? If so, you have done well.

Everyoneandeverything · 06/11/2022 10:12

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:07

It does seem like a lot to me as I get an awful lot less than that. I’m not sure how I could feel differently about it

Like I said, come and work in the public sector! Enjoy the benefits! There are loads of jobs going.

Just pointing out that it’s not all roses in the private sector, that’s all. Which is true, some companies in the private sector pay bonuses, bankers are rich etc etc, I’m just pointing out that a huge amount of private sector employees earn very little and have very few benefits.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:10

"Paul Gosling, president of the National Association of Head Teachers, said: "The government haven't funded the pay rises that have come in. We've had to fund it out of resources we have already got, which we can't possibly do. School leaders are in a real bind.
"We do need better pay for everyone working in our schools, including teaching assistants, who we can't recruit at the moment in a lot of schools because we don't pay well enough.
"We are losing people to supermarkets. Our teachers' pay has been degraded by about a fifth since 2010.
"We are losing good people and we're not able to retain them. If you want to run a good education system you need good people in it."

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-63429171

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:07

It does seem like a lot to me as I get an awful lot less than that. I’m not sure how I could feel differently about it

Like I said, come and work in the public sector! Enjoy the benefits! There are loads of jobs going.

Everyoneandeverything · 06/11/2022 10:06

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:02

Yes, Everyone, you said 5% seems like a lot.

It is, however, a pay cut coming after a decade of pay cuts in a crumbling sector that is desperately underfunded by the government and propped up by the huge efforts of the people working in it. So from that perspective it's just more of a piss take.

It does seem like a lot to me as I get an awful lot less than that. I’m not sure how I could feel differently about it 🤷‍♀️

SavingsThreads · 06/11/2022 10:05

I get it OP. We're doing a flat award so that those earning least get the most difference. But because of tax they also take home more.

So everyone gets £2500, which means our most junior staff are taking home £2000 after tax which is 8% bump.

The most senior are taking home £1500 post tax which is 2%.

I'm conflicted as I know it's good for those on a low wage. But equally the most senior work more hours and take on a lot more stress and responsibility. Feels like they get hit twice this way.

In somewhere in the middle before I get yelled at.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:02

Yes, Everyone, you said 5% seems like a lot.

It is, however, a pay cut coming after a decade of pay cuts in a crumbling sector that is desperately underfunded by the government and propped up by the huge efforts of the people working in it. So from that perspective it's just more of a piss take.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:00

maybe we need to really think about whether you can place a value on whether someone deserves to be paid more for an hours work than someone else.

Communism has never worked....

If you think that the OP, with her massive remit and line management responsibilities should be paid the same as someone who sweeps floors, then I think you'll find the OP sweeping floors.

Everyoneandeverything · 06/11/2022 10:00

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 09:57

The current pay rises of ~5% (which are massive pay cuts because of inflation) are coming on the back of 12 years of pay freezes and below inflation pay rises.

If you think the public sector is getting a good deal on pay, do feel free to apply for a job here, because for some reason, we are haemorrhaging staff to the private sector.

Was that in reply to me?

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 09:57

The current pay rises of ~5% (which are massive pay cuts because of inflation) are coming on the back of 12 years of pay freezes and below inflation pay rises.

If you think the public sector is getting a good deal on pay, do feel free to apply for a job here, because for some reason, we are haemorrhaging staff to the private sector.

Princessglittery · 06/11/2022 09:56

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 09:42

I've worked in the private sector, I even remember getting bonuses for successfully completing a project. Funnily enough I also know people who work in the private sector and there have been plenty of threads on MN about people in the private sector pissed off at inequality in pay, or payrises or bonuses so I don't think that people in the private sector are somehow saintly when it comes to accepting unfairness in their pay packet.

I can attest to how much thought and hard work goes in to spending the available budget as fairly, and legally, as possible.

Yes, well, you think it's fair that the OP gets a big pay cut while others don't, so don't be surprised if she disagrees.

@noblegiraffe maybe we need to really think about whether you can place a value on whether someone deserves to be paid more for an hours work than someone else. If everyone got the same hourly pay everyone would get the same pay rise etc. Much easier one National Wage Rate?

After all a cleaner in a hospital could have saved lives during covid by cleaning the infection from surfaces.

Everyoneandeverything · 06/11/2022 09:53

It does vary in the private sector though. I get 2 weeks sick pay then ssp, stat mat pay, never had a bonus and get a tiny pay increase each year, around 1%. Always been similar to this in any organisation I’ve worked for. So 6 months full sick pay and pay increases of almost 5% does sound a lot to me

Swipe left for the next trending thread