Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Albanian migrants question

461 replies

Notthetoothfairy · 05/11/2022 11:52

Everyone knows the U.K. is really short of staff since Brexit and that is pushing up prices for food etc. If we now (like it or not) have a huge influx of Albanian young men who actually want to work, wouldn’t we be better off letting them legally get jobs here and treating them like the Europeans who left?

Maybe I’m being too simplistic here but I’m not sure how keeping them unhappily detained for long periods in processing centres then spending something like £7m a day putting them in hotels without letting them work is helping anyone. Obviously it’s different if someone has just come over to claim benefits and has no intention of working but I get the impression that’s not the case for a lot of these young men.

If you think I’m wrong, you can explain why and still be nice about it 😁

OP posts:
funnymummmy · 05/11/2022 15:22

GCAcademic · 05/11/2022 11:58

One of the main reasons we don’t have infrastructure and services is a labour shortage.

We don't have a labour shortage. There are millions of working age people either not working on benefits or working part-time. The problem is wages are too low. Importing more people will do nothing to solve this and just pushes down wages even further whilst increasing demand for housing, NHS, education etc. Lose-lose for anyone who is not a landlord or wealthy business-owner.

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:22

I’ve read enough of your posts @IcedPurple to know that I don’t really care what your opinion is one way or another. It’s blatant what it’s rooted in.

inamarina · 05/11/2022 15:21

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 14:55

What do you think would happen if you were in debt to the mafia and you ‘declined’ to do what they asked you?

No traffickers aren’t going to let them just work in legitimate jobs but it has also never existed as an option for trafficked people to take up legitimate employment.

We’re going round in circles here.

I initially responded to someone saying we should let people work because many of them are doctors, dentists and nurses.

I asked why in that case they didn’t apply for work visa.

Answer was, they couldn’t because they were asylum seekers.

I asked why they applied for asylum given that they were coming from Albania.

The answer to that was “they were trafficked”.

So I wondered how trafficked people would be able to opt for a job in the NHS.

You say they wouldn’t be, which is probably the case, but it brings as back to the initial post saying we should let the doctors and nurses work.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 05/11/2022 15:19

So for the people who are saying it’s great we have 1/2% of Albania’s male population arriving here in a year, then what would be the ideal amount. Let’s say the same amount or double arrive next year. Will they be too much? No I’ve ever had an answer to exactly what is too much migration. Some people wouldn’t still be saying we are a racist shit hole if we only took 70% of the male population of a country.
My high street has been mentioned on this thread. Are many of the posters here living in the areas where these men are settling, sat around all day smoking outside cafes and driving Audi’s. They are not vulnerable young things, they are men with money and lots of time in the day…

Theunamedcat · 05/11/2022 15:18

The only Albanians that came to my area are the sort who heckle the school girls (clearly in uniform) asking if they want to make money they also attacked a phone shop randomly didn't seem to understand we actually have cctv and even if we didn't they did it in broad daylight people just filmed them and plastered it on Facebook the police couldn't catch them all only got three of them but rumour has it they were just sent to another hotel out of area

My town is apparently unfriendly (I live here there is no apparently about it)

BewareTheLibrarians · 05/11/2022 15:17

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 15:06

But hey, Brexit got done so cool shit bro

If Albania, Moldova and various other desperately poor countries join the EU, I think we'll all be pretty grateful that Brexit got done.

Doesn’t this ignore that fact the joining the EU has certain criteria? Like for eg

“stable institutions guaranteeing democracy, the rule of law, human rights and respect for and protection of minorities;
a functioning market economy” etc.

Meaning, Albania under the EU wouldn’t get away (as easily) with such widespread corruption and running uncontrolled crime gangs. Rather than being a security risk, these countries joining the EU would reduce the problems we’re seeing now in the UK with international crime gangs.

Leaving the EU, however:
“This week a report has highlighted how Brexit and immigration policy could result in more forced labour exploitation.”
amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/oct/22/britain-hostile-environment-modern-day-slavery-brexit

IcedPurple · 05/11/2022 15:16

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:11

Yes, I don’t even need to ask you what your stance is though do I?

Given 80%+ of asylum claims by Albanians are granted that rather backs up my thoughts doesn’t it?

I'm going to resist your attempts to make this into a personal spat.

And given that the unsourced statistic you have claimed is false then no, it does not back up your thoughts at all.

According to the BBC "In the year to June 2022, 7,267 asylum applications were submitted by Albanian migrants, double the number the previous year.

In general, 53% of claims by Albanians are accepted.

About 14% of successful claims were by single, adult men. Most were by women and children."

So the facts actually directly refute your 'thoughts'. The vast majority of asylum applications by Albanian men are rejected.

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 15:15

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:11

Yes, I don’t even need to ask you what your stance is though do I?

Given 80%+ of asylum claims by Albanians are granted that rather backs up my thoughts doesn’t it?

Women have mostly been granted refugee status. The males arriving atm will most likely not be given asylum as they disappear into the population and don’t wait in the hotels for the process

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/11/2022 15:14

that's because we lost so many European workers to (a) pay tax to fund that infrastructure, and (b) be the actual workers in that infrastructure eg the NHS

Did we lose that many though? 200,000 thousand have left, and they would not have been necessarily workers, all of them, over 6,000,000 have applied for settlement here. As for tax, most of the those jobs we need workers for are minimum wage, they not only don't pay tax, but are in receipt of benefits and other support.

There are no takers for those jobs because they don't pay better than benefits, not because of Brexit.

AutumnCrow · 05/11/2022 15:14

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:06

Whilst I’d agree that most traffickers are men it’s nonsensical to think they don’t traffic other men alongside women an children.

Exactly. They end up as field hands, fruit & veg pickers, shellfish pickers, laundry workers, kitchen workers and drug deliverers. Some of them end up being forced to become the minders of trafficked women and children, and in the sex trade. They're not all 'head traffickers'.

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 15:13

There is not much known about the recent influx Ie 10,000

Picking up on interviews etc - in some cases recruitment takes place (guy said no with no extra threat), pics on boats of mostly men looking celebratory, weapons sharpened in migrant centre, many leaving hotels after 24 hours

We need new information re who makes up the figures. The above does build a picture but it is still hard to confirm it

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:11

IcedPurple · 05/11/2022 15:07

Give over. I asked you to support a statement you made. I'm not trying to 'shut anything down' so stop trying to make this into a personal spat.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but you seem to be suggesting that many of the 10000 Albanian men arriving in Britain by boat this year have been trafficked. Do you seriously believe this to be the case?

Yes, I don’t even need to ask you what your stance is though do I?

Given 80%+ of asylum claims by Albanians are granted that rather backs up my thoughts doesn’t it?

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 15:10

I'd have voted remain if we had had a cast iron guarantee that Albania and various other poor countries were not going to join in the next fifty years .

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:09

PotentiallyPolly · 05/11/2022 14:59

Don’t understand why they’re even coming here, not like they’re being bombed by Russia. They should apply for visas the correct way, not just arrive and expect a warm welcome. Especially since we now have issues in Kent etc where there are so many immigrants local English people can’t get a place in their own school ffs.

Again, this is a domestic issue exacerbated and twisted into propaganda so anger is diverted away from the actual culprits. School places aren’t going to magically appear if we turn every asylum seeker away;

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 15:09

AutumnCrow · 05/11/2022 15:07

I think the word 'done' is doing a lot of heavy lifting there

True. But the idea of freedom of movement between the UK and Albania is absolute insanity.

LemonSwan · 05/11/2022 15:08

As far as I understand it over 1% of the male population of Albania has arrived this summer.

Now the question to me is who is the 1% most likely to be the ones to leave first?

If the average person is qualified, works hard and is on average a late adopter of a new movement. Who are these? Extremely entrepreneurial, resourceful and motivated individuals? It may be but surely those would be succeeding in Albania already. Or are they those who don’t mind doing something illegal to get their way? Also potentially.

AutumnCrow · 05/11/2022 15:07

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 15:06

But hey, Brexit got done so cool shit bro

If Albania, Moldova and various other desperately poor countries join the EU, I think we'll all be pretty grateful that Brexit got done.

I think the word 'done' is doing a lot of heavy lifting there

IcedPurple · 05/11/2022 15:07

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:04

No, you trying to shut down conversation about men is you acting like a moderator. Why does it bother you so much to include men in the conversation, especially since most of the accusations of criminality are against them?

not all of the below specifically concentrate on men, but none exclude them or fail to recognise them as a group also at risk of trafficking. That seems to be an individual problem.

www.asylos.eu/albania-report

www.nationalworld.com/news/politics/why-people-fleeing-albania-home-office-figures-27-uk-modern-slavery-victims-albanian-3902724?amp

www.gardencourtchambers.co.uk/news/albanian-boys-and-young-men-the-risk-of-trafficking-and-re-trafficking-on-return

www.lancs.live/news/lancashire-news/albanian-men-trafficked-uk-forced-24741457.amp

Give over. I asked you to support a statement you made. I'm not trying to 'shut anything down' so stop trying to make this into a personal spat.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but you seem to be suggesting that many of the 10000 Albanian men arriving in Britain by boat this year have been trafficked. Do you seriously believe this to be the case?

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:06

LK1972 · 05/11/2022 14:58

@Cornettoninja Considering an abundant proof that Albanian mafia is based on clans of extended families and controls world-wide trafficking networks I'd say it's rather logical that they are the traffickers, or are related to the traffickers.

Whilst I’d agree that most traffickers are men it’s nonsensical to think they don’t traffic other men alongside women an children.

AutumnCrow · 05/11/2022 15:06

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 14:30

Albania is an official candidate for ascension into the EU....has been since 2014. One of the key principles of the EU is freedom of movement. It can only work if the countries involved have similar economies and living standards imo. I wonder if and when Albania will be accepted?

Maybe the Right Hon Penny Mordant MP can tell us a pack of lies about it to influence public opinion! It's been too long since she did her extra special dishonesty thing.

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 15:06

But hey, Brexit got done so cool shit bro

If Albania, Moldova and various other desperately poor countries join the EU, I think we'll all be pretty grateful that Brexit got done.

Cornettoninja · 05/11/2022 15:04

IcedPurple · 05/11/2022 14:56

I'm not sure how asking you to support your own statements is acting as a 'moderator'.

My own statement is opinion, hence the 'probably'.

No, you trying to shut down conversation about men is you acting like a moderator. Why does it bother you so much to include men in the conversation, especially since most of the accusations of criminality are against them?

not all of the below specifically concentrate on men, but none exclude them or fail to recognise them as a group also at risk of trafficking. That seems to be an individual problem.

www.asylos.eu/albania-report

www.nationalworld.com/news/politics/why-people-fleeing-albania-home-office-figures-27-uk-modern-slavery-victims-albanian-3902724?amp

www.gardencourtchambers.co.uk/news/albanian-boys-and-young-men-the-risk-of-trafficking-and-re-trafficking-on-return

www.lancs.live/news/lancashire-news/albanian-men-trafficked-uk-forced-24741457.amp

AutumnCrow · 05/11/2022 15:03

YellowTreeHouse · 05/11/2022 11:56

No. We don’t have the infrastructure or services to support our own nevermind letting in anymore.

That's because we lost so many European workers to (a) pay tax to fund that infrastructure, and (b) be the actual workers in that infrastructure eg the NHS

But hey, Brexit got done so cool shit bro

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 15:03

LikeTearsInRain · 05/11/2022 14:56

They should be turned around and dropped off back at Calais. Women and children fine.

Don't be ridiculous. Women and children need to either go through official channels or claim refugee status and then be assessed. You can't just say yes come on in without any form of process.

PotentiallyPolly · 05/11/2022 14:59

Don’t understand why they’re even coming here, not like they’re being bombed by Russia. They should apply for visas the correct way, not just arrive and expect a warm welcome. Especially since we now have issues in Kent etc where there are so many immigrants local English people can’t get a place in their own school ffs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread