Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Albanian migrants question

461 replies

Notthetoothfairy · 05/11/2022 11:52

Everyone knows the U.K. is really short of staff since Brexit and that is pushing up prices for food etc. If we now (like it or not) have a huge influx of Albanian young men who actually want to work, wouldn’t we be better off letting them legally get jobs here and treating them like the Europeans who left?

Maybe I’m being too simplistic here but I’m not sure how keeping them unhappily detained for long periods in processing centres then spending something like £7m a day putting them in hotels without letting them work is helping anyone. Obviously it’s different if someone has just come over to claim benefits and has no intention of working but I get the impression that’s not the case for a lot of these young men.

If you think I’m wrong, you can explain why and still be nice about it 😁

OP posts:
woodhill · 05/11/2022 19:08

I could live without the car washes and nail bars tbh

jennakong · 05/11/2022 18:55

Lincslady53 · 05/11/2022 15:39

Albania is not in the EU. So, how are they allowed to enter the Schengen Zone, with access to the whole of Europe, without proper security checks at the border leaving Albania?

A very good point.

How is border control in the Schengen Zone policed anyway? Isn't it like us entering the EU post Brexit? Do you remember the six hour queues at Dover this summer, and most people probably perfectly straightforward British born, UK passport holders just going on holiday? There is something so distinctly rat-smelling here and it doesn't make sense.

user29 · 05/11/2022 18:55

These fit young men have elderly, female and minor family members in Albania to support. How does it help the British economy to send all this money out of the country to spend in Albania?

Jippers · 05/11/2022 18:47

There are a lot of Albanian illegals near me. They come over on fake Greek passports and work cash-in-hand on building sites. £100 a day tax free. The one that I know personally told me about his living arrangements. His brother came over first and rented a one bedroom flat and now there's 7 of them sharing it. They sleep cheek-by-jowl, three in the bedroom, 3 in the lounge & one in the hallway.

LesterBiggott · 05/11/2022 18:42

User963 · 05/11/2022 18:24

I never said what my opinion about immigration was in my post. I was simply pointing out that if you think this is bad you haven’t seen anything compared to the future when entire countries might become inhospitable.
what would you do if the U.K. became inhospitable?

If it gets to that level then everyone will be fighting for survival. And most will probably die.

User963 · 05/11/2022 18:38

woodhill · 05/11/2022 18:33

The food isn't cheap anyway and what services exactly

Well food has been cheap till recently (talking about fruit pickers etc) and I mean services like car washes and nail bars; many of which are staffed by immigrants.

woodhill · 05/11/2022 18:33

The food isn't cheap anyway and what services exactly

woodhill · 05/11/2022 18:32

It is their fault if they are economic migrants

They need to take some responsibility and pay for themselves

User963 · 05/11/2022 18:25

Also that the cheap food and services we want come at a price and that price is people seeking to come to the U.K. to work on those poorly paid jobs paid cash in hand with no questions asked.

User963 · 05/11/2022 18:24

LesterBiggott · 05/11/2022 14:12

Do you think the UK is Noah's ark? Where exactly do you plain on putting, say, an extra billion people? Have you got room where you live? And who should decide who comes? Who do you think should pay for all this? Do you think it's ok for people who can afford the thousands of pounds for the boat push ahead of those who haven't. Have you thought about it?

The native population of the UK was actually going down slightly. Yet it's population has increased from a steady 48 million for years to around 60 million. Don't you think that would be a better idea if you want people to deal with climate change to start by having far less children? Rather than piling into the UK at great detriment to the existing population.

I never said what my opinion about immigration was in my post. I was simply pointing out that if you think this is bad you haven’t seen anything compared to the future when entire countries might become inhospitable.
what would you do if the U.K. became inhospitable?

BewareTheLibrarians · 05/11/2022 17:47

@Picklepiepop That sounds really dire. Is there any chance we’re going to put the blame where it lies, at the feet of the government for overloading certain communities, and not at the feet of the asylum seekers who have no choice about where they’re moved to?

Tbh, your example proves exactly why the current system of the Home Office dumping people in “centres” doesn’t work. Because

  1. genuine asylum seekers may be carrying physical and mental trauma, and centres are known for delaying or denying medical treatment.

  2. men, women and children living in close quarters with no safeguarding is incredibly risky.

  3. In the community, asylum seekers can be supported with English lessons and cultural awareness - especially around safeguarding and sexual behaviour and the consequences of illegal behaviour. Mentor schemes can be set up between settled people of the same nationality/religion to promote community ethos and cultural understanding.

Leaving people in a centre with nothing to do, no job, no hope and surrounded by an increasingly hostile population is not good for anyone.

But all of that is a complex issue which no one here will really give a shit about. Much easier to throw in a pithy one liner or pretend there aren’t any answers.

lollipoprainbow · 05/11/2022 17:25

Maybe we would have the infrastructure and services if we allowed those people to work. People awaiting processing include doctors, dentists and nurses - we have a desperate shortage of those.

Ah yes all those Albanian doctors dentists and nurses! Wake up ffs.

Picklepiepop · 05/11/2022 17:21

I will never welcome huge amounts of men purely because they are men. Two hotels in my town have been turned in to centres for asylum seekers. So far after just three weeks there have been three allegations of sexual assault and they have been hanging around the local secondary school. The police are now patrolling near the school because of the level of harassment, I live just around the corner from this school. 500 men.

One of the hotels had been used for Afghan families for quite a while, they were evacuated becuse they had worked for the British military. No problems whatsoever over those many months but lots of single young males have replaced them and it’s awful.

@Theunamedcat its dire isn’t it, I dare not walk my usual routes which are quite near the hotels because I don’t fancy being heckled or approached.

HoppyHorse · 05/11/2022 17:07

Yabu. Many aren't here to take paid employment, unless you include drug and prostitution gangs in that. They need to be deported.

Clavinova · 05/11/2022 17:01

BewareTheLibrarians
No idea re EU countries. But if they don’t, is that good enough reason for us to also not? (Just pretend that grammar makes sense…)

I think that depends entirely on numbers - are we talking 20,000 per year or 200,000 per year? Labour Party MPs have so far refused to say.

Ilovemycatalot · 05/11/2022 16:56

The only thing I often find is everyone seems ok if it is women and children coming here. The fact is that would cost more for the tax payer in the long run as opposed to a single male. Children taking more resources such as needing school places doctors etc and women who are mothers less likely to work due to caring responsibilities. Women with kids can be economic migrants as well they are just looked more favourably upon.

RamblingEclectic · 05/11/2022 16:51

If they're to be treated as migrants, surely they'd be treated like all other migrants, not just like the EU ones who left.

Non-EU migration has involved background checks and ID cards and more for many years. Whether that's enough has been debated, but I'm struggling to understand why they should be treated any different to any other migration group.

And yeah, the government is not doing enough, just like they weren't doing enough pre-Brexit or making any plans to deal with it during the Remain campaign. There are benefits to them saying how terrible is and that they'll deal with it and then doing fuck all.

so if foreign workers can't get a DBS, how are so many of the care workers in this country not born here?

Foreign-born workers can get a DBS. However, where ever you are born, if you've lived more than 6 months in another country as an adult as many migrants have, they can require additional paperwork that gives a similar level of assurances from that country. Not all do, but for some places that's the standard.

BewareTheLibrarians · 05/11/2022 16:36

@Clavinova oh good catch, there is indeed. I think the numbers are quite low (but no doubt “low” will mean different things for different people!) If googling, remember that family reunification for legal immigrants and for asylum seekers are different schemes. Sometimes the numbers get conflated.

No idea re EU countries. But if they don’t, is that good enough reason for us to also not? (Just pretend that grammar makes sense…)

Clavinova · 05/11/2022 16:28

BewareTheLibrarians
aside from the Ukraine scheme and HK visas, that’s it
For the rest of the world, the only way to claim asylum is on British soil, which as we’ve seen is cruel and unsustainable

Family reunion scheme here?

help.unhcr.org/uk/family-reunion/

absolutely agree that safe routes for asylum are essential

Which EU countries have safe routes?

woodhill · 05/11/2022 16:24

Absolutely. I've thought that for years

And they are not like Peter Pan

Comedycook · 05/11/2022 16:23

woodhill · 05/11/2022 16:18

I agree to some extent but then the migrants need somewhere to live themselves

Then lots of homes become multiple occupancy and reduces the n.o. of family homes etc

I'm sure the young adults already living here would like larger families but they can't afford the housing and they are being done a disservice as far as I am concerned

It's basically a vicious circle/pyramid scheme. More migrants needed to build houses and work in farming/NHS/care equals more people. More people equals more migrants needed and on it goes...

woodhill · 05/11/2022 16:21

Mamamia7962 · 05/11/2022 15:25

We need to put a stop to these migrants coming across in boats. I don't care if they want to come here to work. Imagine if a group of British people went across in a boat to France just because they wanted to live there. Can't see the French putting them up in hotels and welcoming them.

Well said

It's become ridiculous

woodhill · 05/11/2022 16:18

Echobelly · 05/11/2022 15:24

Yeah, my thinking is very desperately need builders etc, which is something a lot of these guys can do!

I think the best way to stop illegal immigration is just create a simple pipeline to come and fill shortage jobs; it's really not rocket science to find now which employers are short of people and not finding people coming forward or qualified here (building, care, catering, nursing etc) and offer straightforward visas for people who can. Which was exactly why we needed EU membership, where we were always able to 'control our borders' if we wanted to, but there you go.

And to those who say we should 'look after our own' - that's exactly why we need migrants. With an ageing and growing population, we need someone to build homes, to look after the older people etc.

I agree to some extent but then the migrants need somewhere to live themselves

Then lots of homes become multiple occupancy and reduces the n.o. of family homes etc

I'm sure the young adults already living here would like larger families but they can't afford the housing and they are being done a disservice as far as I am concerned

Clavinova · 05/11/2022 16:12

even poorer than Albania - per capita.

Clavinova · 05/11/2022 16:11

The people on boats are not doctors, nurses and dentists. Some people are so daft and gullible

Indeed - we only had 149 Albanian nationals working in the NHS as of March 2021 - plenty of scope to apply through the usual channels.

You know the UK always had a veto? Could always have said No to Romania and Bulgaria, for example. If still a member of the EU, the UK could always say No to Albania, Moldova and Turkey

Will EU members say No to Ukraine in 10 -15 years' time (assuming Ukraine wins the war against Russia)?

Ukraine (population 43 million) was the poorest country in Europe even before the war - even poorer than Albania (population 2.8 million).