Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Albanian migrants question

461 replies

Notthetoothfairy · 05/11/2022 11:52

Everyone knows the U.K. is really short of staff since Brexit and that is pushing up prices for food etc. If we now (like it or not) have a huge influx of Albanian young men who actually want to work, wouldn’t we be better off letting them legally get jobs here and treating them like the Europeans who left?

Maybe I’m being too simplistic here but I’m not sure how keeping them unhappily detained for long periods in processing centres then spending something like £7m a day putting them in hotels without letting them work is helping anyone. Obviously it’s different if someone has just come over to claim benefits and has no intention of working but I get the impression that’s not the case for a lot of these young men.

If you think I’m wrong, you can explain why and still be nice about it 😁

OP posts:
BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 18:53

@MarshaBradyo I don’t think anyone is comfortable with ever-increasing numbers. On this thread and others, nobody (as far as I’m aware) has demanded open borders or for us to take all asylum seekers. So I’m no sure what the question is in relation to. It’s possible to believe that asylum seekers shouldn’t be thrown back in the sea, but also that open borders are a ridiculous idea.

And it’s worth remembering too that not all visas are permanent. Student visas are a relatively large proportion but are also relatively short term. People who have immigrated to the UK may prefer to retire in their home country, or when they get married/have kids. British people emigrate out of the UK. There’s may be an increase in people coming here while the UK is a more attractive place to work, but in a few years other countries may be more attractive. Already Polish immigrants have spoken positively about returning to Poland as the economy has improved.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 18:53

@MarshaBradyo I have asked and asked but no one can tell me what an optimal amount of immigration is. Apparently 7 million is “not enough, and we are all racist and the country is shit anyway so don’t think they actually want to live here and if they do live here anyway it’s a sort of punishment for having an empire also mass immigration is great”. There is no clarity at all when discussing this issue as it is so taboo. If you ask anyone to clarify anything they disappear off the thread.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 18:38

@MarshaBradyo , as far as I am bothered, we hit that point a few years ago. We're old, we've lived in multiple countries and made new lives each time. We shall just take our ball somewhere else.

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2022 18:26

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 15:36

@MarshaBradyo the numbers I am using are net migration. I think that’s the most useful for looking at pressure on services.

Going back to this ‘seven million people in 18 years’

Is there a point where people feel uncomfortable with increasing numbers?

XingMing · 06/11/2022 18:16

And I am going to do my bit to balance the numbers, because I am going to take my (private and privately earned) pension overseas. I shall pay for health insurance so as not to be a burden on the country I live in.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 18:11

If there’s (only ever!) one thing I’ll always agree with @lollipoprainbow on, it’s that communities that are already in need in many ways are facing unsustainable pressure due to the asylum seekers being channelled through Kent (and sent to other equally struggling areas). I don’t know how the government can justify this.

I‘m saying that as someone who lives in an underserved, struggling community that looks after a high number of asylum seekers! But if I go to my mum’s comfortable, Tory town, it’s like asylum seekers don’t exist. One old area of 50+ houses there was due to be demolished, then it was decided to be repurposed for asylum seekers. Then that plan disappeared, all the properties were renovated and sold at +£450,000 to who knows who, (despite a promise to allocate some as affordable housing - in the end the only 3 terraced houses were converted into 6 1 bed flats and that was it.)

I know most people in my area can’t afford houses that expensive. Neither can most first time buyers. That development didn’t benefit local people, it only benefited people rich enough to afford a nearly half a million pound basic 4 bed house. If that development had been used for asylum seekers, they only would have deprived top earners, not struggling people. That town also has a brand new primary, a new secondary in the next town, both with spaces, and 2 and a half doctors surgerys. No new schools in my city, yet it’s our council that’s asked to stretch itself.

None of this though, is the fault of asylum seekers, who can’t decide where they go and don’t know some areas are struggling. But I understand and the stress and frustration for local people.

Asylum seekers need to be spread more evenly through the country as a first resort, and into the community, not stuck in a hotel room with no job, and nothing to do but hang around on street corners. That’s not safe for them, it’s not what they want, and it can be hard and scary for the communities. I’m lucky that where I am, we have great schemes and a mostly wonderful diverse community that helps people start to integrate and eases community tensions. All that takes effort, and people who care enough to understand that supporting asylum seekers also supports the community.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 18:10

Wirh the best will in the world, I don't see how a smallish crowded island can accommodate everyone who speaks a little English and thinks it would be a nice place to live.

lollipoprainbow · 06/11/2022 17:23

@lljkk ah yes a tweet from Dan Snow who is extremely rich and privileged as are the people he is quoting in his tweet. What would any of them know about the issues mass immigration causes it's absolutely laughable.

LesterBiggot · 06/11/2022 16:11

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 15:40

Far from boring you with the details of my family, I was attempting to point out that this overly simplistic interpretation of the “one in six” leaves a lot of crucial information unsaid. (Dual nationality, parents’ nationality etc ). But as you’re more interested in imagining agendas and insulting people than backing up your assertions, I’m happy to leave you to it.

It demonstrates the minimum numbers. The points of which you speak actually point to the numbers being far higher, but not included in this data. Its not clear whether you just don't understand or are incapable of doing so. Your method of engagement by holding back bits of information for some kind of failed gotcha, along with the lazy xenophobia accusations, makes me think it's the later. Anyway, I'll note your user name and stop engaging with you. Kindly do the same.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 15:48

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 15:45

@BewareTheLibrarians hmmmm, I think you were going for a ‘gotcha’ moment there tbh

i don’t think I denied that 😁

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 15:45

@BewareTheLibrarians hmmmm, I think you were going for a ‘gotcha’ moment there tbh

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 15:40

LesterBiggot · 06/11/2022 15:10

I'm not really interested in the details of your family tbh. I'm more interested in the impact mass immigration is having on the UK, and the ONS data around me. If your child has a British passport he is not included in the ONS data for this. Not sure why you're withholding bits of information as part of some kind of gotcha. It makes you look silly. Don't bother engaging directly with me with your petty accusations. I'm truly not interested in your agenda.

Far from boring you with the details of my family, I was attempting to point out that this overly simplistic interpretation of the “one in six” leaves a lot of crucial information unsaid. (Dual nationality, parents’ nationality etc ). But as you’re more interested in imagining agendas and insulting people than backing up your assertions, I’m happy to leave you to it.

woodhill · 06/11/2022 15:37

Yes it has been suggested about the points system but it never seems to be implemented

The boat situation wouldn't be linked to this

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2022 15:37

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 15:36

@MarshaBradyo the numbers I am using are net migration. I think that’s the most useful for looking at pressure on services.

Ok thanks I wasn’t sure

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 15:36

@MarshaBradyo the numbers I am using are net migration. I think that’s the most useful for looking at pressure on services.

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2022 15:33

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 13:48

@Cornettoninja seven million people in 18 years is, I think, mass immigration. You may not. What would you consider mass immigration in a population, in terms of percentage?

This is a fair question.

I’m also wondering about net migration as people coming in and leaving isn’t so much an issue if you get the skills you want coming in and don’t get a brain drain going out.

So use a points system, make people feel they are being heard (whatever place in strata) and really crack down on gang related migration before it is here, so it doesn’t imbed.

If you look at other countries similar discussions are happening and in some cases voters shifting towards higher controls.

ConsuelaHammock · 06/11/2022 15:30

They should be sent back home ! Straight off the boat and onto a waiting plane !

Conkersareback · 06/11/2022 15:18

YellowTreeHouse · 05/11/2022 11:56

No. We don’t have the infrastructure or services to support our own nevermind letting in anymore.

Do you think the aborigines in Australia have the resources and infrastructure?

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2022 15:10

lljkk · 06/11/2022 14:55

I'm one of the 14.5%. I've lived in UK 30 yrs.

I do like this tweet...

One thing I heard about the recent Albanian arrivals: most of them left Albania years ago, too. Sorry, too long thread didn't read, maybe someone else said this. But basically, Albania is not experiencing a huge exodus now. These are long time ex-pats coming here lately, too. They literally have an established lifestyle going around getting work where they can outside Albania.

Are you sure about not experiencing an exodus now?

‘High emigration from Albania is creating a concerning situation in terms of the local labour market with shortages in key sectors to be apparent by 2030, according to a new report.

Albania is in the midst of a demographic crisis as tens of thousands of people leave every year, and the population that remains is plagued by ageing and a decreasing birth rate. As many as 42,000 people emigrate annually.

The study carried out by the European Training Foundation notes that countries in the Western Balkans, in particular Albania, will face an intensifying labour crisis caused by the emigration of young people.’

LesterBiggot · 06/11/2022 15:10

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 15:02

Interesting! He also has another passport (dual nationality) and a foreign dad. I didn’t see how that would exclude him but I’m happy to be corrected if I’m wrong.

I'm not really interested in the details of your family tbh. I'm more interested in the impact mass immigration is having on the UK, and the ONS data around me. If your child has a British passport he is not included in the ONS data for this. Not sure why you're withholding bits of information as part of some kind of gotcha. It makes you look silly. Don't bother engaging directly with me with your petty accusations. I'm truly not interested in your agenda.

MurmurationOfDinosaurs · 06/11/2022 15:09

Useful summary, maybe?

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/internationalmigration/bulletins/internationalmigrationenglandandwales/census2021#:~:text=Out%20of%20the%2059.6%20million,were%20born%20outside%20the%20UK.

I can't see anything specific about exactly many of those born outside of the UK hold a British passport, as opposed to those being two separately collected data sets, but it might be retrievable from the data tables.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 15:02

LesterBiggot · 06/11/2022 14:47

Then the stats don't refer to your child. You might want to think that through a bit before accusing people of xenophobia for simply stating ONS facts.

Interesting! He also has another passport (dual nationality) and a foreign dad. I didn’t see how that would exclude him but I’m happy to be corrected if I’m wrong.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 15:00

So if they left Albania years ago why are they coming to the UK now and what difference does that make to the conversation we are having about the situation?

lljkk · 06/11/2022 14:55

I'm one of the 14.5%. I've lived in UK 30 yrs.

I do like this tweet...

One thing I heard about the recent Albanian arrivals: most of them left Albania years ago, too. Sorry, too long thread didn't read, maybe someone else said this. But basically, Albania is not experiencing a huge exodus now. These are long time ex-pats coming here lately, too. They literally have an established lifestyle going around getting work where they can outside Albania.

Albanian migrants question
Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 14:53

@funnymummmy completely agree. @OneTC so what level of immigration would you consider mass immigration - let’s say in percentages? If you think my concerns are driven by the media rather then the eyes in my head and the ability to research the actual figures and the fiscal/societal impacts of the demographic changes I see in my community then can you do me the decency of answering my question about what level of immigration is mass immigration?