Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Albanian migrants question

461 replies

Notthetoothfairy · 05/11/2022 11:52

Everyone knows the U.K. is really short of staff since Brexit and that is pushing up prices for food etc. If we now (like it or not) have a huge influx of Albanian young men who actually want to work, wouldn’t we be better off letting them legally get jobs here and treating them like the Europeans who left?

Maybe I’m being too simplistic here but I’m not sure how keeping them unhappily detained for long periods in processing centres then spending something like £7m a day putting them in hotels without letting them work is helping anyone. Obviously it’s different if someone has just come over to claim benefits and has no intention of working but I get the impression that’s not the case for a lot of these young men.

If you think I’m wrong, you can explain why and still be nice about it 😁

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LizzieW1969 · 07/11/2022 10:21

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 14:38

Oh dear. My British child wasn’t born in Britain. My British friend’s British child wasn’t born in Britain. Neither was Boris Johnson.

Yet they’re British. That’s not uncommon at all. So before you start a xenophobic rant about “not being born in Britain = mass immigration of foreigners” you might want to think it through a bit.

I know what you mean. My DB wasn’t born in the UK, as my parents were working overseas at the time. But he’s lived in this country almost all his life. My DSis and I were born here, does this mean we should have more right to live here than he does??

One of my closest friends is Scottish. She happened to be born when her parents were in Australia. Does that give her less right to be here?

It really doesn’t imply mass immigration, one in six not having been British born. Because this is an age where there is a lot of travelling.

MarshaBradyo · 07/11/2022 07:29

No not trying to shut discussion down, the opposite trying to get a reference which is clearer - a figure helps.

Xing good luck I’m sure you’ll find something nice, sometimes on mn I feel like the few feels so positively about U.K., wants to stay and will be last here - with all that space ;

I do have another option but hope to not feel I need it as the dc and we are happy here.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 22:32

@Notthetoothfairy It really depends on the school. It’s much more common that non-English speaking students get left behind to figure it out than the whole class stopping to translate things, but I know what you mean about numbers. I think there’s been a positive change recently in teaching non-English speaking students in a non-disruptive way, as sites like Twinkl have EAL resources teachers can print out, powerpoint & Word have functions that automatically translate slides/texts, or teachers/EAL leads translate class work beforehand, or lead small group lessons where the children learn English together in a small group for part of the day/week. Some schools are lucky enough to have TAs who speak the kids’ language and can provide in-class support. Basically, it really depends on the resources and staff the school has.

Schools in multicultural areas tend to be excellent at this, but I do worry about schools that aren’t used to having non-english speaking students, and if they’re aware of all the above. If you’re worried about your children’s school, it’s worth asking your school about their EAL policy (should be on their website) and asking them to be aware of resources to support EAL students (for everyone’s benefit). Bell Foundation seems to be quite highly recommended for free training and resources.

(The dfe also gives extra funding for unaccompanied asylum seeking children, which can be used to buy in language learning online programs and dictionaries etc so it doesn’t have to come out of the schools regular budget.)

Sorry, I’m exhausted and that was a complete stream of consciousness but I hope it helps a bit!

Notthetoothfairy · 06/11/2022 21:52

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 20:48

@XingMing for some visas, there’s already a requirement to pass an English language test (and pass a “Life in the UK” which I couldn’t pass despite being British!)

But you’re absolutely right that learning and speaking English can be vital for people’s safety, and needs to be combined with outreach/awareness - like people knowing they can report domestic abuse for eg, or forced labour conditions at work. (Multilingual posters at the GPs surgery/hospitals sometime do this for the same reasons).

In schools with higher numbers of EAL students (students needing support with English language) they sometimes also run parents clubs, where parents (usually mums) come in and learn English together with a coffee, and ask qs about school etc. This can also be a safe place to sensitively raise awareness of those issues. They are few and far between though, unfortunately.

That’s good to hear about schools, but won’t high numbers of non-English speaking students slow down the whole class?

OP posts:
BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 20:48

@XingMing for some visas, there’s already a requirement to pass an English language test (and pass a “Life in the UK” which I couldn’t pass despite being British!)

But you’re absolutely right that learning and speaking English can be vital for people’s safety, and needs to be combined with outreach/awareness - like people knowing they can report domestic abuse for eg, or forced labour conditions at work. (Multilingual posters at the GPs surgery/hospitals sometime do this for the same reasons).

In schools with higher numbers of EAL students (students needing support with English language) they sometimes also run parents clubs, where parents (usually mums) come in and learn English together with a coffee, and ask qs about school etc. This can also be a safe place to sensitively raise awareness of those issues. They are few and far between though, unfortunately.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 20:15

If we are aiming for a fair society for the immigrants granted leave to stay, then learning English to a competent standard for women especially should be a big part of of the implied contract IMO. A town in the Midlands I visit regularly has a large migrant community, and there are hundreds of middle aged women who have been sequestered from the mainstream because they cannot speak English.

AloysiusBear · 06/11/2022 20:15

The shortage of unskilled workers is also pushing up wages which have been too low for too long in the UK.

Generally speaking constant inflow of unskilled labour creates an oversupply & leads to degradation of working conditions and wage supression, and contributes to employers unwillingness to train to improve productivity because wages are kept low.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 20:08

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 19:33

@BewareTheLibrarians i think we are both trying to discuss the situation in a way that gets to the bones of it. But yes, it’s polarising and difficult to talk about.

Very true! I’m hopeful that it will be possible though. 🙏

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 20:06

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:58

I'm not bothered by the colour of your skin or your religious beliefs but I do want everyone to know that one person has one vote, and that it must be voted individually.

Well, asylum seekers can’t vote, and iirc refugees can’t unless they have citizenship.

“Refugee status in itself does not confer the right to vote, no matter how long you’ve been in the UK.
Usually you’ll need to have been granted citizenship to qualify (unless you’re from a qualifying Commonwealth country.)”

Is your post in reference to another group of immigrants? That’s another area where integration is vital - in particular, English lessons for female family members as it’s vital they know their rights. Unfortunately conservative governments have hugely cut the funding for English language lessons for immigrants, which is like “yay we saved money!” But also “no we made people’s lives worse which also impacts on their community!” so <wails and gnashes teeth>

XingMing · 06/11/2022 20:03

Gosh @Mycatsgoldtooth ,thank you. you made me a bit teary.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 20:02

@XingMing I don’t think anyone’s called me rational before 😂 Thanks! I hope it’s ok to copy paste something I posted earlier in the thread that I hope goes a little bit of the way to answering the philosophical part of your question.

“In the community, asylum seekers can be supported with English lessons and cultural awareness - especially around safeguarding and sexual behaviour and the consequences of illegal behaviour. Mentor schemes can be set up between settled people of the same nationality/religion to promote community ethos and cultural understanding.
Leaving people in a centre with nothing to do, no job, no hope and surrounded by an increasingly hostile population is not good for anyone.”

This is where the schemes I mentioned in another post are vital. You’ll get some men who have a less western view of women, and some men who are more protective and respectful of women than the average British man would be. Asylum seekers aren’t stupid or evil, but they’re also not mind readers about cultural differences. Education is incredibly important, and small scale studies (they have to be, as there’s no nationwide government program for this!) show success in helping with integration. Likewise, the people who run these programs or who work with asylum seekers are best placed to spot anyone with worrying sexual behaviour/intentions. In my time I’ve only had to report someone once and I’m incredibly glad he was deported (not solely due to my report sadly).

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 19:59

@XingMing 💐

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:58

I'm not bothered by the colour of your skin or your religious beliefs but I do want everyone to know that one person has one vote, and that it must be voted individually.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:53

And honestly, casting political correctness to the winds. I want to live in a modern democracy.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:48

I've been on this thread for a while and you are are both being very rational. I've weighed in with my personal perspective and derailed.

But this is an important question, both practically (how many people can the UUK accommodate?) and philosophically: should they share a similar religious/ethical framework?? how do the immigants arriving regard women's social standing and position?

Personally, I really do not want to live in an emigre version of the country I ws born in.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:34

I do actually love where we currently live, and would stay, but DH doesn't. I think we need to see what else there is out there so he can feel we've investigated.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 19:33

@BewareTheLibrarians i think we are both trying to discuss the situation in a way that gets to the bones of it. But yes, it’s polarising and difficult to talk about.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:27

Sunshine will be considered as part of the equation, along with a language related to Latin, some history, and nice walking. Decent food and wine also matter. Atlantic Spain is currently appealing. It will be (a bit) less wet than our UK home, if not a lot.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 19:20

@XingMing I hope you end up somewhere with more sunshine at least! :)

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 19:20

@Mycatsgoldtooth i agree that if people are called racist and xenophobic it can shut the conversation down. Equally, anyone who doesn’t say immigration is terrible/too much is told they’re destroying the country, they want to let everyone in, they want open borders, they can’t even give a solution etc… it’s honestly tiring. There needs to be calm conversation on both sides.

(with the caveat that anyone promoting racist and xenophobic attitudes needs to be shut down, and anyone who says we should have open borders and must take everyone needs to be called an idiot.)

Ive responded nicely to posters here (not all posters, obviously) who have the opposite opinion to try and further the discussion and dig down into their worries in the hope of helping them be less worried about some things, but they just ignore me. What can I do about that? They don’t want to hear it.

XingMing · 06/11/2022 19:11

It's a valid question. we shall be two out. Don't know where we shall end up. But we have worked and earned and saved for 45 years to have options.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 19:09

@BewareTheLibrarians not trying to shut anyone down… I’m actually trying to find out other peoples opinions. I said earlier I’m having this conversation in good faith.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 06/11/2022 19:08

I think we are passed the optimal number. I think over 10% of a country being born abroad has a detrimental effect on social cohesion and puts pressure on services, especially as it is as unplanned as our system. If we had a national conversation about the benefits, costs and provisions for immigration then we could manage things better. But anyone trying to discuss it is called racist and xenophobic. Interesting to see what has happened in the Nordic countries, which were seen as so progressive for their policies. I see the same happening here in the next few years if we do not actually address the issue in a respectful and grown up manner.

BewareTheLibrarians · 06/11/2022 19:01

@Mycatsgoldtooth what do you think the optimal number is? Not because I want to criticise it, but because I don’t know how the average person on mumsnet can know enough about immigration, emigration and the economy to give an exact number.

(But isn’t it a lovely way to shut down a discussion? “You can’t give me an exact number, therefore you have no solution and your opinion is irrelevant.”)

@MarshaBradyo You come across as having a very analytical mind, what number do you think is acceptable?

woodhill · 06/11/2022 18:54

Yes and being told we don't take our fair share is particularly irritating