Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young Voices - Really?

56 replies

StaunchMomma · 04/11/2022 23:14

DS's primary routinely send upper year classes to this and now he's of that age.

AIBU to just not get the point of tens of thousands of kids all singing at the same time? It's hardly a choir situation when thousands of kids are belting out Taylor Swift songs, en masse?

I hear people saying it's an opportunity to 'perform' at a huge venue but it's not really, is it? With that many people singing, it's the equivalent of singing along at a concert, surely?

My son hates singing and loud noises and absolutely hates it when they are made to sing/do dance moves in assemblies. I'm not sure why I should force him to do it.

Surely these things would be better as optional?

I certainly wouldn't be happy to spend out on tickets for it (I've watched a few videos and it looks awful - plus it's a sea of kids so you're not going to see your own) and I don't see that it's fair to force my DS to do it when he won't get anything out of it.

Am I missing something?

YABU - It's a great opportunity, just go and put up with it.

YANBU - It's ridiculous, avoid at all costs.

OP posts:
Kite22 · 04/11/2022 23:37

I haven't voted as neither of your options apply.

All of mine did it and thoroughly enjoyed the experience.
However, at their school, it was the choir that went, and it was up to each child to opt in, only if they want to.

Overall though, I think it is a good thing for dc to grow up taking as many opportunities as are presented - not everything has to be lifechanging or even of a particularly high standard. There actually is something emotional and wonderful about singing with thousands of others. Not everyone has the opportunity to go to a big pop concert or a big sports stadium and do that, so this is another way to do it.

FlibbertyGiblets · 04/11/2022 23:36

You know your child, and you know that he will not enjoy an event like this, it isn't for him. It is right to not sign him up, I agree.

I will say though, that for others, to be part of a choir of thousands of voices is an unbelievably uplifting and powerful experience, ineffably affecting, it isn't naff or awful.

Coldilox · 04/11/2022 23:36

Completely optional here. My son is going, he’s in Year 3. He’s very excited.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 04/11/2022 23:34

I haven't voted but purely because it's always been optional here so I don't think you should have to endure it but also don't think it's a ridiculous event.

Are you sure they send all the children? I'm surrounded by 8 primary schools and know none of them make it compulsory

TheaBrandt · 04/11/2022 23:33

Ours loved it but not for everyone. At our primary only the kids that self selected and joined the choir went seems much better way of doing it

Blueboys77 · 04/11/2022 23:31

My daughter went this year and had a great time and I thoroughly enjoyed watching her (binoculars and school banners). They were at the o2 and the whole day involved beat box lessons and similar activities. This was only for children who joined the choir club and wanted to go though. Surely they can’t make your child go though. It did all work out very expensive and it was a very long day and late night for them. She’s not signed up again this year, no complaints from me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread