Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not ban my friends from smoking on my deck ?

93 replies

Tigertigertigertiger · 04/11/2022 21:18

I’ll explain.
I live in the lower flat of a converted semi detached house with a retired couple living in the flat above.

I have a small deck with garden chairs out my front door - directly above it the neighbours have a small balcony - half my deck is covered by their balcony which is great as I can sit outside If it’s raining and stay dry.

I don’t smoke but two of my friends do ( cigarettes, not hash ) and when they visit (a few times a year) if they want to smoke they go out onto the deck.

my upstairs neighbours have asked me not to let anyone smoke on the deck because they can smell it if they are on their balcony.

I think my neighbours are being unreasonable .
Please can I have your opinions

YABU - you should not let your friends smoke outside on the deck
YANBU - your neighbours should not be dictating the smoking rules in your property .

OP posts:
houseonthehill · 04/11/2022 22:29

Covered smoking space outside is a nice thing to provide for guests who smoke - good, even basic, hospitality. YANBU in the circumstances you describe, but smoke does drift upwards, so on a nice evening could you move chairs a bit further out into the garden, maybe?

surreygirl1987 · 04/11/2022 22:26

frothing that it’s sooooo selfish and filthy and disgusting. ... but it is...

Gemstar2 · 04/11/2022 22:24

SkylightSkylight · 04/11/2022 22:13

You'd go out if your own home becayse downstairs were being inconsiderate? That's ok if it's convenient for you, but it's often not convenient to just go out for a day/night/weekend, especially for elderly people.

having asked nicely, if it continues, I might find it necessary to water my plants, paint my balcony....

No that’s not what I said at all - I said the exact opposite. If the smoke were affecting me outside I’d simply go inside. My neighbours smoke on their patio a lot. It travels to my decking it…doesn’t mean I have a right to tell them not to smoke in their own garden, so I just go back inside until they’re done. The neighbour in the OP’s post is on their balcony so I think it’s safe to assume they can also get back into their flat.

SpookyWookyBoo · 04/11/2022 22:24

As someone who doesn't smoke and never has your neighbors are being over the top.

It's a few times a year.

I'm sure they do stuff to annoy you.
If you live in close proximity to anyone you're going to have things that annoy you but that's just life.

surreygirl1987 · 04/11/2022 22:24

Legally the neighbour has no grounds but OBVIOUSLY anyone with any decency would not smoke there, knowing the neighbour can smell it. It is absolutely disgusting. I can't stand people who smoke in public places - I know this isn't a public place but it is affecting someone in the same way. If people are going to have such a foul habit they need to do it in a way that only impacts on themselves not others!

TellMeWhere · 04/11/2022 22:18

As an ex smoker I ask any smoking guests of mine to smoke away from my neighbours - so either at the end of the garden or a good way away from everyone's front door. It's a gross habit and shouldn't be inflicted on others.

I would bbq at will, but not directly under anyone's balcony.

Luredbyapomegranate · 04/11/2022 22:15

If it’s a few times a year and you all sitting out there YANBU

But if it’s regular, or you are actually hanging indoors, send them out the front. With an umbrella if necessary

SkylightSkylight · 04/11/2022 22:13

Gemstar2 · 04/11/2022 22:03

Personally I really despise smoke and would not be able to enjoy a balcony with someone smoking downstairs…so in your neighbours’ shoes I would simply go inside on those occasions. They can’t dictate people not smoking in your garden, however much they dislike it. Sometimes we just can’t have it all our own way!

You'd go out if your own home becayse downstairs were being inconsiderate? That's ok if it's convenient for you, but it's often not convenient to just go out for a day/night/weekend, especially for elderly people.

having asked nicely, if it continues, I might find it necessary to water my plants, paint my balcony....

RewildingAmbridge · 04/11/2022 22:12

We have two friends who smoke, when they come we ask them to use the patio at the bottom end of the garden, our garden is 100ft and so is the one that backs on to ours so at least they are all day as possible from anyone's home. Right under someone's window is a bit much

SkylightSkylight · 04/11/2022 22:10

AhNowTed · 04/11/2022 22:08

The usual sanctimonious claptrap.

It's always the same - if you'd enjoyed a few drinks you're an alcoholic on here.

OP the neighbours need to get a grip. They can't dictate that someone can't smoke on their own patio. That's ridiculous.

What next.

@AhNowTed Great that you've seen the rental contract. Maybe the OP could share it with all of us.

perhsphs the upstairs neighbour will take up tap dancing lessons to loud music

SkylightSkylight · 04/11/2022 22:08

ClocksGoingBackwards · 04/11/2022 21:28

If it’s only a few times a year, they are being ridiculous to even have mentioned it. They shouldn’t be living in a flat above other people if they can’t cope with other people smells occasionally.

If it's let out as a non smoking flat, they have every right to not expect to have to deal with people smoking on the decking.

@Tigertigertigertiger it's massively inconsiderate, let your friends know to go off the property. If they want to sit and drink, go to a pub garden.

AhNowTed · 04/11/2022 22:08

The usual sanctimonious claptrap.

It's always the same - if you'd enjoyed a few drinks you're an alcoholic on here.

OP the neighbours need to get a grip. They can't dictate that someone can't smoke on their own patio. That's ridiculous.

What next.

Gemstar2 · 04/11/2022 22:03

Personally I really despise smoke and would not be able to enjoy a balcony with someone smoking downstairs…so in your neighbours’ shoes I would simply go inside on those occasions. They can’t dictate people not smoking in your garden, however much they dislike it. Sometimes we just can’t have it all our own way!

jiggleypuff · 04/11/2022 22:03

It just seems a bit rude of me to not let my friends smoke in my garden

It’s not a garden though. It’s a small space.

I would just ask friends to go out on to the street to smoke.

BittenontheBum · 04/11/2022 21:57

I smoke in my own home. I live alone. In other people's homes I ask and go where they point me.
It's entirely up to the house owner/leaser imo.
Your neighbours definitely can't complain about you having a bbq in your garden, that's a step too far...

AuroraBoreaIis · 04/11/2022 21:49

Let them smoke in your house, windows shut, if you want to be so accommodating. Don't impose it on your neighbours.

TheHauntedPencilCase · 04/11/2022 21:48

It annoys me when my neighbours smoke and bbq on their ridiculously high raised deck as it all blows straight into my kitchen. It would be better if they didn't lean on my wall to do it as they could sit at the other end. However, I think it's reasonable use of their garden even if slightly inconsiderate. Your neighbours are being unreasonable.

Priminister · 04/11/2022 21:48

Your neighbours need to get a grip. It’s not as though people are smoking constantly on there. Tell them you’re sorry it bothers them but point out it’s extremely rare and you’ll try and mitigate any effects.

Ignore all the usual MN sanctimonious twats hand-wringing about anyone smoking ever anywhere. They’d whinge if someone smoked in a desert 500 miles from another living being while frothing that it’s sooooo selfish and filthy and disgusting. Honestly, mention smoking on here and it’s as though a bat signal goes out to the self-righteous. And no, I don’t smoke.

LoobyDop · 04/11/2022 21:47

Our downstairs neighbours have parties where guests smoke on their deck. It comes directly up and in through our bedroom windows. It’s fucking disgusting, and I don’t give a shit about the comfort of visitors, I give a shit about people whose home it is, and them being deprived of fresh air. Tell them to walk two minutes down the road so that your neighbours don’t hate you.

lifeinthehills · 04/11/2022 21:45

I hate smoking with a passion and I think four times a year is nothing. Annoying but allowable. Unless it's not just a regular day visit (like they stay for days) or they are doing it continually, all day long.

The BBQ request is not on. That doesn't affect their own health, so I don't think they can really complain fairly about that. You should be able to use your garden to BBQ.

Smokers visiting my house go down onto the street. Otherwise it still drifts in my front windows.

willithappen · 04/11/2022 21:44

Second hand smoke is not only disgusting but also dangerous! If it's travelling up to neighbours then I would tell your friends to go elsewhere to smoke

LBFseBrom · 04/11/2022 21:42

"popcorncandy · Today 21:25
It's a few times a year and you have the right to enjoy your house as do your guests. If you were a chain smoker I'd sympathise more with your neighbours but no, yanbu to let your friends smoke when they visit."

Quite agree!

Tigertigertigertiger · 04/11/2022 21:41

can I ask the smokers on here where they smoke when at their own home ?

OP posts:
Tigertigertigertiger · 04/11/2022 21:40

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 04/11/2022 21:32

so when they're not on their balcony (eg during the winter/ when it's raining) it's probably ok to smoke there? I'd let the friends do it then, but on a hot sunny day when the neighbours are using the balcony (and/or have the doors to it wide open) ask them to move a bit further away from the house...

Yes, that’s fair enough. I don’t think my friends have ever actually sat outside smoking on a hot sunny day though and yet the neighbours still politely complained.

You have just reminded me they also asked me not to have a barbecue in my garden because they don’t like the smell of that either. They asked me this soon after I moved in - the previous owners had built a brick barbecue in the garden.
I have had one barbecue in the 15 or so years I have lived here and they were on holiday

OP posts:
nilpois · 04/11/2022 21:37

Rather than you thinking it's rude not to let them
smoke I think it's actually more rude of your friends to think it's ok for other people to smell their cigarette smoke whilst at home.

Can't your friends just move out further away down the garden or onto the street to smoke?