Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think some people just aren't competent and won't fit into any 2022 workplace?

156 replies

majellalos · 04/11/2022 19:27

The skills that are required in so many professions these days don’t come easily or naturally to everyone and most jobs require a fairly advanced level of technological talent and a certain set of social skills that don’t come easily to everyone.

I really am not good at anything and despite being University educated I've struggled to hold down jobs because of performance issues in many jobs since I was 17. I'm 40 now and off ill but before that was doing temp work and agency jobs but just never felt right in any workplace. I'd always make a mess somehow or say the wrong thing.

AIBU to think some folk just aren't made for the workplace?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 22:32

It is horrible horrible feeling to feel like you don't belong at all, like you are looking in from the outside.. like you have failed as an adult human being

I totally get this. The problem with our society is that there is such huge pressure to conform. You MUST get married, MUST have kids or if you have failed at these you MUST have a career. Ofcourse life is never so simple and some people will struggle/not be suitable with these roles or even all of these roles. They will be told then they have failed in life.

XenoBitch · 07/11/2022 22:15

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 21:26

Empathy? OP is a teacher who by her own admission is not able to teach....I think all the students she's had over the years probably deserve some empathy

At least she's tried to do it but appears to struggle along with her other jobs...if she didn't try and sat on benefits you'd moan she was a scrounger but she tries to work and she still gets slated. You can't win.

Exactly what has happened to me on this thread. And I have tried too.

It is horrible horrible feeling to feel like you don't belong at all, like you are looking in from the outside.. like you have failed as an adult human being.

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 21:46

you seem to have an empathy bypass

as do many on mn

blueshoes · 07/11/2022 21:42

Arayes · 07/11/2022 13:45

Empathy? OP is a teacher who by her own admission is not able to teach....I think all the students she's had over the years probably deserve some empathy?

@Arayes you seem to have an empathy bypass.

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 21:26

Empathy? OP is a teacher who by her own admission is not able to teach....I think all the students she's had over the years probably deserve some empathy

At least she's tried to do it but appears to struggle along with her other jobs...if she didn't try and sat on benefits you'd moan she was a scrounger but she tries to work and she still gets slated. You can't win.

Arayes · 07/11/2022 13:45

Empathy? OP is a teacher who by her own admission is not able to teach....I think all the students she's had over the years probably deserve some empathy?

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 13:35

Interesting thread and the lack of empathy for the op speaks volumes which is what makes it so much harder for her situation and others like her. I do agree that some people,albeit a minority, will struggle in many types of work due to personality etc. But there appears to be a consensus here that it's just her in the wrong job when op said she tried many and all were the same outcome.

I don't know what the solution is really.

blueshoes · 07/11/2022 02:08

OP, it sounds like you could be neurodiverse. Your difficulties have affected your self esteem and confidence and probably causing you anxiety.

Autism and ADHD is under diagnosed in women because women do not present typically at school and are often good at masking. Is this something worth exploring? A diagnosis does not magically open doors but it could help you understand yourself. You are not rubbish at things. It hurts to think you are blaming yourself.

If your condition affects your daily life enough, you can claim Personal Independence Payments (PIP), even if you are working.

Hawkins001 · 07/11/2022 01:40

JennyAdlington · 06/11/2022 22:12

Pair of twats

Such charm, did you learn from the dictionary ?

NewNovember · 07/11/2022 01:39

@JennyAdlington wow, you can disagree with me that's fine, but no need to speak like that.

Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 23:07

JennyAdlington · 06/11/2022 22:12

Pair of twats

That’s a normal way to talk to people!

JennyAdlington · 06/11/2022 22:12

Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 15:02

Erm… no they haven’t? They’ve made it possible FOR women to work, not impossible for women to be unemployed. If you can find a man who’s happy to support you indefinitely, and you’re happy to take the chance on that, then you’re still perfectly able to be unemployed if you want to!

Pair of twats

majellalos · 06/11/2022 20:00

How do people like this manage to pay their bills? Because truth be told 90% of the reason why I can't be like this is because I don't want to end up on the streets with nothing so I've had to 'make it work'. I really dislike being in the office and interacting with colleagues and team work. I generally cannot be bothered with working. I do it so that I can have the kind of life I have. WFH is also one of the best things to ever happen in this world

you make it sound like we are incompetent by choice.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 19:27

I know what you mean. I would love to be one of those ultra competent people who just gets it. I lack really basic common sense sometimes, and struggle with things that should be easy

this, I often sat and silently cried at work watching others do the job so well. It's soul destroying.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 19:23

With the colleague who was better at PowerPoints - why did you feel embarrassed and get caught up on that? You could have just copied whatever he was doing that you weren’t

Because I realised how out of my depth I was. We were both doing supply but he was a professional at work and could design solid lessons etc and effectively do his job well and I realised how shit I was. I got fired soon after anyway.

Have you tried less stressful/high pressure jobs? There are other options. I do agree that the workplace is very difficult for some but I also think there’s things to do and try before you write yourself off

I have, I'm just kind of shit.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 19:20

I have a friend who sounds like you and I know she could do my job pretty well if she just didn’t over think it

see that's the problem, people think we overcomplicate things or overthink it but to us it just is an impossible task which seems so easy to others.

OP posts:
SommerTen · 06/11/2022 19:17

It's worth remembering that if you have any actual physical or mental illnesses that could be called a disability then you are entitled to 'reasonable adjustments' from your employer under the Equalities Act. (Which I think the current leader wants to get rid of!!!)

I couldn't do my job without the adjustments I'm legally entitled to. For example, more sick leave allowed for if it's due to my chronic illness; being able to work 8 hour shifts not 12 hours, no night shifts.
But generally I try to be as flexible as possible within my limitations.

The key to a good working life when you are ND or have mental / physical illness or disability is to know your rights and limitations, to tell the right people eg HR or senior manager but definitely not everyone as especially with my illness there's a stigma.

Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 19:09

With the colleague who was better at PowerPoints - why did you feel embarrassed and get caught up on that? You could have just copied whatever he was doing that you weren’t?

Have you tried less stressful/high pressure jobs? There are other options. I do agree that the workplace is very difficult for some but I also think there’s things to do and try before you write yourself off.

majellalos · 06/11/2022 19:01

I mean teaching might not be for you - it isn’t for many, many people. That’s why it’s so hard for schools to retain staff

but the problem is that even before teaching I had a string of jobs I floundered in.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 19:00

*fairly advanced level of technological talent

um what do you consider this to be? At the end of the day, children learn how to do the basics at school now so your viewpoint of advanced might not match what the baseline is

and a certain set of social skills

like what? There’s job where you don’t have to socialise with people. But again, being able to build rapport and influence others will take you far in life*

Well technological talent would be needed in teaching, I thought I was ok doing powerpoints but was in a planning session with colleague and realised how much better he was. I was embarrassed and felt like shit.

Social skills is building rapport with colleagues and bosses and others like clients or students. I struggled with that.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 18:57

I mean teaching might not be for you - it isn’t for many, many people. That’s why it’s so hard for schools to retain staff!

majellalos · 06/11/2022 18:57

Can I add too that even the jobs I was given heavy support and extra training in I still floundered. From 27-38 I taught and never really seemed to learn, many schools fired me.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 18:55

The thing with doing lots of temp work is it takes a while to gain experience and confidence in doing most jobs and the permanent people who are already there have that while you’re still learning. You get good at what you’re doing, then your temporary contract ends and you move on. Then you have to learn all over again

I worked in the family business from 19-24 after getting sacked from several jobs. I was useless in the family business as well but because it was family I wasn't fired. My parents closed it when I was 23 and I did teacher training then but was really bad at that and did supply. Been off 2 years now due to ill health but at 40 I think I was just useless and that some people just aren't really made for the workplace.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 18:51

*Maybe you haven’t found your fit yet oP?

is it the drudgery of it all? If there anything you might enjoy such as a library*

wherever I go, whatever I do I just say and do the wrong thing. I wish I could explain it to people but I think this issue is massively understood.

OP posts:
majellalos · 06/11/2022 18:49

I get it. It’s frustrating because I’m smart but I struggle to stay organised and have a real issue with procrastination. I can talk the talk in an interview but it rapidly falls apart when I start

sounds somewhat like me, I'm just useless but I think from the tone of this thread many people don't get it or what I'm saying.

OP posts: