Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why I look like a sack of spuds at my weight

93 replies

Boiledpotatowitchbitch · 04/11/2022 18:43

Been looking at before and after pictures on social media adverts for diets etc. (I know) The before photos look like me very out of shape etc but their weights are about 6 stone more and then the after photos are either the weight I am now or slightly less. So how come I look like 20 stone when I am 11stone 8 and how come the after photos are about that and I look nothing like that? I know everyone's different body shape heights etc but I am seriously all out of proportion. I 100% look like a sack of spuds I think larger women look amazing and thinner ones too but mostly carry their weight fairly evenly I just look like a melted cake with bulges everywhere I am 5 foot 5 was slim curvy. Measurement is 34f waist 32 hips 44 size 12-14 top 14-16 bottom but really 14 jeans too small and 16 trousers too big I know this isn't huge but I am just so lumpy and bumpy nothing looks nice at all.

OP posts:
BloodAndFire · 05/11/2022 12:01

You're carrying 2 to 3 stone of excess weight. That's why. Pilates and exercise are great, but you are significantly overweight and standing up straight or pulling your core in isn't going to change that.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 05/11/2022 12:00

I have been doing core exercises a lot over the last year, it doesn't spot reduce, I am still fat so no muscle shows through but my posture is a lot better so I look better

LimeCheesecake · 05/11/2022 11:57

Agree posture and underwear can make a massive difference to the appearance to two woman with the same measurements.

shoulders back and down, head straight, tits forward. Underwear doesn’t need to be sucking you in shape wear, but simply a bra that fits well, knickers that fit properly and are big enough you don’t have them digging in and therefore bulges over the top/round the sides. A slip under a dress can give a smoother appearance with little effort (and an extra layer of warmth!

CookPassBabtridge · 05/11/2022 11:49

Yes could you post a photo with your head cut off (😂) as I bet you don't look 20 stone! I bet some good smoothing underwear would help a lot.

LikeTearsInRain · 05/11/2022 11:39

Could you post a photo it may be easier to give advice on how to improve posture or exercises etc

Angelicapickles1 · 05/11/2022 11:38

check out pilatesbygeorgia. She is fab, and will create a plan for you if you explain your back issues as she is also a chartered physio ... you'll be amazed at the difference by just doing a 20 min class a day does

5128gap · 05/11/2022 11:21

Being more overweight can make you look firmer because the fat is filling out your skin. You will also have lost some hard fat and be left with the soft fat just below the skin that does have a tendancy to be 'floppier'. You might also have looked smoother as a solid rectangle or apple than as the more defined shape your weight loss had revealed. I agree, toning and posture should help, as would losing any further weight you may still have to lose, which is often the the hard to shift flab that hangs on around the belly.

RewildingAmbridge · 05/11/2022 11:12

I find swimming helps me tone all over, proper lane swimming, I like the self competition too, I can definitely do more than I could six months ago and faster, bingo wings near gone too!

nonstoprenovation · 05/11/2022 11:06

Boiledpotatowitchbitch · 04/11/2022 19:04

Thanks yes OK this is good. I have come to conclusion
I am small built (ha ha) and have different (none) muscle tone therefore I look more bulging.
I am not fit at all and yes I do need to tone up as of course it is all just going to hang duhhh
Yes I probably do wear wrong underwear
So there are several exercise regimes I cannot do due to back issues (no planks stomach crunches running and no weights either) so how do I lose the flabby stomach without doing sit ups weights and crunches? Maternity smock? Tummy tuck or is there an exercise solution for this?

You can't loose weight just on one area, so the exercises you mention you can't do won't matter at all, leave them out.

Maybe start with swimming for the sake of your back, the water will help and then you can build up to yoga Pilates and when you get an appetite for fitness and feel more energetic you could get a PT session or two and start lifting and training at the gym.

I'm the same btw I'm on 5"3 but I'm lumpy.. I have rolls under my boobs, pouches on my hips, tummy rolls and cellulite when I'm at my heaviest, I don't have toned curves I have lumpy areas.

I see women bigger, taller and heavier then me wand they have beautiful toned curves, and I just feel smaller but lumpy.

The above is all on my list for the next year as I'm an ex- weightlifter but I've had some downtime and injury's so I will ease back up to training again, it's the safest way.

Good luck!

k1233 · 05/11/2022 10:51

Sorry, silly phone cut me off

Scales aren't a good guide due to the difference in volume between the same weight of fat and muscle

To ask why I look like a sack of spuds at my weight
k1233 · 05/11/2022 10:49

This picture should explain your issue. The pics you are seeing are most likely a combination of exercise and diet. Exercise tones and builds muscle. It's very

VladmirsPoutine · 05/11/2022 10:49

I've recently returned to running to shift the pounds; exercise plus mindful eating has helped. But the great thing for me was the improvement in my mental health - it worked wonders. Don't compare yourself to social media pics for all the obvious reasons but then have a look at your lifestyle and see what you can change. You aren't massive imo.

Icannoteven · 05/11/2022 10:41

How is your posture? This can make a huge difference to how spud-like you look in my experience.

I am about a stone heavier than you and I also suffer with the sack-of-spuds problem. The puffiness from hypothyroidism really compounds the issue. In all honesty though, and I know this is not a popular opinion, it is very hard for ANYONE to not look like a sack of spuds once they hit a size 14 or so (it's been a long time since I was that small myself mind).

My advice: wear dresses that flair over the tummy area, stand up nice and tall (shoulders down and back, imagine there is a piece of string running upwards from the crown of your head lifting it up)

BakeSaleSunday · 05/11/2022 10:35

Yes, toning up and loose skin. If you have slopping shoulders or a some body shape types need to work harder to look more toned but it's doable. Good underwear and the right clothes help immeasurably.

RaraRachael · 05/11/2022 10:29

@Giraffesandbottoms that's exactly the weight loss I need to achieve. Can I ask how you achieved yours as I seem to be at a standstill on 10 and a half stone.

SheWoreYellow · 05/11/2022 10:26

Stand up straight and find some flattering clothes. 😊

SavoirFlair · 05/11/2022 10:23

Why do people focus on “spot” exercise and total wishful thinking on physical activity…

…when the answer can always, invariably be found in diet?

many people eat too much in the way of processed food. They then bemoan all manner of things, but are happy to always excuse the food intake.

green82 · 05/11/2022 10:11

I'm 5ft5 and need to be under 10st to look "slim" I'm big chested which I really don't think helps. When I was over 10st6 I looked really overweight in photos because my face was very puffy. Weight on the face makes such a difference. 11st at 5ft5 is overweight but I will look it much before 11st.

cathyandclare · 05/11/2022 09:48

My DD's dance teacher says that you can strengthen your abs without doing crunches or sit ups by engaging your core/pulling in your tummy muscles throughout the day. It may be too much to start with but you could make a point of doing or while brushing your teeth/cooking/driving snd then increase.

Giraffesandbottoms · 05/11/2022 09:31

As someone who has just lost 2 stone from 11 to 9:

you look like a sack of spuds because, generally speaking, 11 stone + is a large amount of extra weight to be carrying around. I am not finished dieting at my current weight because I still have wobbly bits but I’m now at a size where I can work on toning/everything isn’t covered by a layer of fat!

the more you lose the less you’ll look/feel like spuds. Well done on the weight loss already 💪🏻

Greblegable · 05/11/2022 08:50

You don’t need “tummy fat removing exercises” . Spot reduction just doesn’t work like that and any muscle you build isnt going to be visible if you remain overweight. Exercise is good for you but abs are made in the kitchen.

I’m sure you don’t look 20 stone. But you probably don’t look “slim curvy” either and you won’t even if you buy some new clothes or change your posture (although I think this is still good advice) because you are overweight. the models you are looking at will either be taller or photoshopped or both.

Id put money on you feeling much better about yourself if you lost enough weight to get down to a healthy bmi and got into an exercise routine

Quitelikeacatslife · 05/11/2022 08:23

Wear clothes that fit, nothing is more unflattering and uncomfortable than tight clothes . I'm much fatter than you and same height. It's about dressing for your shape too. If you've got big boobs then nothing too baggy on top or tighter fitting top layered with longer cardi or shirt. Dresses are your best friend , I'd bet you'd look amazing in wrap dresses, can wear them with thick shirt and trainers maybe .
Post some pics of you in outfits and happy to help

Mymoneydontjigglejiggle · 05/11/2022 08:15

I've been losing weight and I find when you're between sizes, it's really easy to look a bit shit! Everything is either a bit too big or a bit too small and consequently you never look put together. For me, I found sizing down but going for an elasticated waist really helped until I'd dropped down into the size properly. Also shapewear! I like M & S shapewear. Also apparently Primark have a good shapewear range but I haven't managed to go recently to try it out. Have seen some good reviews though!

trailrunner85 · 05/11/2022 07:37

My theory is that you’ve got a touch of body dysmophia op. You sound very in proportion and curvy and not at all like a sack of spuds

Comments like this were extremely unhelpful to me when I was overweight. Managed to convince me that I wasn't just fat, I was curvy (no); it was normal to do no exercise (it's not) and as I was a size 14, not the so-called average 16, I wasn't fat (again, no). It took a long time for me to drop the weight but I'm so much happier now I have, and have kept it off.

OP, as pps have said, exercise will make all the difference here, along with eating better. But it has to be a permanent lifestyle change and not a "quick fix." Your back issues are also likely to get much better if you're stronger and carrying less weight. I was plagued by horrendous back problems at a size 14 but now, as an 8, I have no issues at all.

OnlyFannys · 05/11/2022 00:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Swipe left for the next trending thread