Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I believe that the minimum wage should be enough to enable a working couple to feed and clothe a family of four and keep a roof over their heads.

279 replies

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 18:21

I don’t think I am BU for a moment, interested to see how many agree with me.

OP posts:
ChillysWaterBottle · 04/11/2022 19:50

Yes. If you are working and contributing to society you should be able to have a decent standard of living. Doesn't matter if you're a solicitor or a road sweeper or a bus driver or a shop assistant or a financial management consultant or a doctor or a binman. If you are working and helping society run smoothly you should be properly compensated.

Topgub · 04/11/2022 19:48

@AloysiusBear

The labour market values the wrong things though.

I've got 2 professional qualifications, 1 a post grad degree. 20 years experience. Senior role with lots of stress and responsibility.

I'm not a higher earner

Mezmer · 04/11/2022 19:46

I think a household needs £40k to live a decent and dignified life. I say this because this is how much it costs my household to get by. It’s not easy, but then no one has ever said it would be. Two wage earners at the minimum wage will make that so….

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 19:46

Eastangular2000 · 04/11/2022 19:30

So what figure do you have in mind? Where in the country are this family? Are they in central london (high housing costs, low transport costs), rural (possibly cheaper housing, expensive transport). Is it a 2 bed or 3? If it's a two bed are teenage opposite sex siblings sharing a room? If the children are young who is providing childcare and what is the cost? So many variables

It’s a point of principle I am making here.

I fully appreciate that it is currently impossible in many parts of the UK.

I think a 2 bed house is the bare minimum. Yes opposite sex teens would share - hardly ideal, but I think the general principle of two people per room is a fair basic minimum.

The childcare is being provided or paid for by the couple. If one parent wished to stay at home then they could do so, and if both parents wished to work then their salary would be enough to pay for the care required.

I think this should be possible in every part of the UK.

OP posts:
AloysiusBear · 04/11/2022 19:46

I do think childcare costs are a huge issue though. Childcare needs to be much more heavily subsidised.

AloysiusBear · 04/11/2022 19:45

Bellac but the wages for those jobs stay low because people are willing to take those jobs despite the poor pay.

Possibly because
a) they have a high earner partner topping up the family income
b) they have benefits topping them up
c) they don't require many skills or experience so young people who haven't yet acquired any skills/experience can do them

Leaving aside disability, people should gain skills and experience that enable them to be more productive and earn more. To me its an odd assumption that two people at say, age 28 should have acquired no skills/experience in 10 years leaving school so as to be worth more in the labour market.

Eastangular2000 · 04/11/2022 19:43

bellac11 · 04/11/2022 19:40

Certain jobs never pay much more than the minimum and never have (no matter what or how minimum levels of wages were in the past)

Cleaners, care takers, dinner ladies, carers, usually some social care positions, some admin positions, etc etc

Thats not because they havent worked their way up, its because thats their job and thats what it pays

They are some of our most valuable positions

Rather than minimum wage being increased we should be arguing for all these roles to be valued and rewarded much more highly. Minimum wage should be exactly that, a minimum, not a basic benchmark for lots of jobs.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 04/11/2022 19:43

Eastangular2000 · 04/11/2022 19:42

It's all very well saying you don't want to be pinned down over details but without detail it's a meaningless statement. i would like for everyone to have Universal basic income that affords them all of life necessities but without detail it's meaningless.

Why is it meaningless? Seems quite clear to me. Those who are asking for more detail are just looking for an excuse to say no.

Eastangular2000 · 04/11/2022 19:42

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 19:39

I stand by my original post.

I would be thoroughly supportive of a nmw that provided enough for an annual holiday, the children to have a room each and some birthday presents.

But that’s not a hill I’m going to die on, if you want to pin me down over details.

The position that I am defending here is that the minimum wage should be enough to provide adequate housing, food, clothing and necessary childcare for an average sized family.

It's all very well saying you don't want to be pinned down over details but without detail it's a meaningless statement. i would like for everyone to have Universal basic income that affords them all of life necessities but without detail it's meaningless.

bellac11 · 04/11/2022 19:40

AloysiusBear · 04/11/2022 19:37

Hmm not sure.

Because young inexperienced people need to start somewhere, and if you can pay minimum wage & get either an older person with 10 years work experience, or an 18 year old looking for their first job, you will never ever hire the latter.

Minimum wage is the bare minimum, ie reflecting simply time, no skills, experience etc. Its a bit sad to think that someone could have been working for several years and not acquired any skills or experience such that they are worth a little more than a school leaver going for their first job.

Certain jobs never pay much more than the minimum and never have (no matter what or how minimum levels of wages were in the past)

Cleaners, care takers, dinner ladies, carers, usually some social care positions, some admin positions, etc etc

Thats not because they havent worked their way up, its because thats their job and thats what it pays

They are some of our most valuable positions

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 19:39

Topgub · 04/11/2022 19:28

Didn't you say support a basic lifestyle?

Home, warmth, healthy food?

Have you changed your mind?

I stand by my original post.

I would be thoroughly supportive of a nmw that provided enough for an annual holiday, the children to have a room each and some birthday presents.

But that’s not a hill I’m going to die on, if you want to pin me down over details.

The position that I am defending here is that the minimum wage should be enough to provide adequate housing, food, clothing and necessary childcare for an average sized family.

OP posts:
Topgub · 04/11/2022 19:39

AloysiusBear · 04/11/2022 19:37

Hmm not sure.

Because young inexperienced people need to start somewhere, and if you can pay minimum wage & get either an older person with 10 years work experience, or an 18 year old looking for their first job, you will never ever hire the latter.

Minimum wage is the bare minimum, ie reflecting simply time, no skills, experience etc. Its a bit sad to think that someone could have been working for several years and not acquired any skills or experience such that they are worth a little more than a school leaver going for their first job.

Yes, this is what I was trying to articulate earlier

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 04/11/2022 19:39

27% of people don’t think that two people working full-time deserve to have some kind of normal life or to be able to have children. What utter fuckers, I hope you all get what you deserve.

MissAmbrosia · 04/11/2022 19:38

Housing has a lot to do with this. My parents were both from large families with both grandfathers working. Luxuries might have been short supply but everyone was fed and clothed and there were occasional holidays. Both my parents went to grammar school along with some of their siblings. They were not poverty stricken. Expectations have changed though. I noticed from a list above things like cars, Halloween, school lunches, trips, dress up days, activities etc. None of this would have happened. Maybe Scouts. There would have been simple birthday and xmas gifts. Life has moved on. What is normal - central heating, reliable hot water, TV, phones etc are things that no one ever dreamed of in the past, but these things are equally not luxuries these days, but part of 21st century life. The idea that some think people should manage without them is just cruel.

AloysiusBear · 04/11/2022 19:37

Hmm not sure.

Because young inexperienced people need to start somewhere, and if you can pay minimum wage & get either an older person with 10 years work experience, or an 18 year old looking for their first job, you will never ever hire the latter.

Minimum wage is the bare minimum, ie reflecting simply time, no skills, experience etc. Its a bit sad to think that someone could have been working for several years and not acquired any skills or experience such that they are worth a little more than a school leaver going for their first job.

PeloFondo · 04/11/2022 19:36

Florenz · 04/11/2022 19:16

NMW should be about £30,000 a year. It's stupid to have artificially low wages that are then topped up by benefits. Just pay people enough in the first place.

Or not topped up. I'm single, no DC and the min wage (or just above) is a struggle to pay all the bills now with how much everything has gone up
19k to pay for household bills, mortgage, car insurance plus everything else is tough. I do get 25% off council tax...

BorisJohnsonsHair · 04/11/2022 19:36

I agree OP. Topping up with universal credit just means tax payers are subsidising huge companies.

All companies over a certain size should pay a wage you can actually live on. Smaller companies could be given subsidies in order to do so.

As476 · 04/11/2022 19:33

I work a 40 hour week just above minimum wage. I earn approximately £1300 a month. My husband works a 50 hour week and earns approximately £2300 per month. With childcare costs to enable us both to work, plus general living expenses, funding 2 old cars to get us about and paying a mortgage, we are just keeping our heads above water. It’s utterly ridiculous. And I’m in an extremely lucky situation of being an apprentice on minimum wage for my age, rather than minimum wage for an apprentice which is just over £4.50 per hour I believe.

I was working 2 part time jobs previously but the tax situation was awful. I was paying more tax than I should have been, regardless of HMRCs standpoint on it. I gave up one to do more hours at the other and although I’m better off, it’s not by much. I’m considering a part time job on top of my full time one, and so is DH, although god knows how much more of that will be eaten up by further childcare costs. I can’t see a light at the end of the tunnel.

2 adults working full time on minimum wage should absolutely be able to afford to live comfortably but I can’t see a way to make that happen. If wages go up, costs will go up, and we’ll all be back at square one with no end in sight where everything continually rises, pricing out those on minimum wage again.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 04/11/2022 19:31

Eastangular2000 · 04/11/2022 19:30

So what figure do you have in mind? Where in the country are this family? Are they in central london (high housing costs, low transport costs), rural (possibly cheaper housing, expensive transport). Is it a 2 bed or 3? If it's a two bed are teenage opposite sex siblings sharing a room? If the children are young who is providing childcare and what is the cost? So many variables

Op if you answer this, you'll just get told you're wrong and asked why you think you get to decide. She'll then deny everything she's ever said and pretend not to understand.

Lotsofowls · 04/11/2022 19:31

@NoDairyNoProblem
we have a huge household income and we don’t have a window cleaner and my DCs halloween costume was a very old (threadbare) sheet with 2 holes cut for eyes…..3 years in a row. Neither of those are even vaguely essential.

Eastangular2000 · 04/11/2022 19:30

So what figure do you have in mind? Where in the country are this family? Are they in central london (high housing costs, low transport costs), rural (possibly cheaper housing, expensive transport). Is it a 2 bed or 3? If it's a two bed are teenage opposite sex siblings sharing a room? If the children are young who is providing childcare and what is the cost? So many variables

Topgub · 04/11/2022 19:28

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 19:26

I don’t think it’s doable either, but I think it should be. I am in favour of a higher minimum wage.

Didn't you say support a basic lifestyle?

Home, warmth, healthy food?

Have you changed your mind?

whiteroseredrose · 04/11/2022 19:27

I agree. Housing prices have gone seriously awry.

In the 1960s my DGF bought a 3 bedroomed semi in a decent area. He was able to support his family on his wage alone - he was an engineer at Findus; he fixed the fish finger machine.

No way in a million years could a blue collar worker provide for a family alone nowadays.

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 19:27

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 19:26

I don’t think it’s doable either, but I think it should be. I am in favour of a higher minimum wage.

… or lower housing / childcare costs. One of these three things.

OP posts:
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 04/11/2022 19:27

oviraptor21 · 04/11/2022 19:23

School.

Baby school?

Swipe left for the next trending thread