Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Railway strikes- I think they are overdoing it

114 replies

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 17:11

So, many people in UK commutes for work, many take the trains. I am one of them.
I do love the service, the apps are great to buy tickets and find train timetables, they run really well, even if delayed tend to be just 30 min or so, it is comfy. Also, it is electric, so better for the environment. I walk from and to the station, so it keeps me fit.
When the strikes started I just ut up with the inconvenience thinking that they were facing some redundancies, so protesting against that or low pay, I support.
But it has turned since las set of strikedays and this week into a strike against the consumer, from my point of view.
When they walked out last time, I got stuck in the city I work for 4 hours. The buses were fully booked and ran with delays. There had cancelled all the trains, not even a single one was on the timetable. I witness a large amount of people stuck for hours on end after a full days work or travelling with huge cass and children. The buses were fully booked till after 12 at night! So what I witnessed was actually only a fraction of it. When I caught the coach next day, the driver was warning passengers that on Wednesday London was so packed that coaches were delayed for 5 hours to get into London.
This time aroud, they published a set of dates, then they changed them, but I have read that in London they have walked out one day early. Changing the dates was to accomodate a busy weekend in London. So there must be another huge amount of people left stranded.

Trains are a vital service to me.
But they are cancelling a huge amount of trains on week long strikes.
Changing dates means they affect people who had planned around the original dates. They cost the commuter more money and stress. People are using buses and coaches yamming roads and polluting. People arrive late to work or back home, missing important things.
Newspaper today mention 600 million of cost to this country, to the tax payer, us who struggle with the cost of living.
I do not see this affecting anyone else bit the user. The train company will only return the money from the train ticket, not cover for the cost of the bus or driving or other alternative.
If they were reducing services, like running one train per hour instead of 30 min, then nobody would be stuck for hours on end, it will be only an inconvenient. The train company will have to return the ticket price if you train is in the delayed lot. But they are cancelling all trains at some points in UK.

Now, they know very well what they are doing. They know what is happening to all those stranded passengers. They know that the buses cannot cope with the amount of people, let alone the traffic due to people driving.

I think they should not be allowed to cancel more than 10% of the services, that they should grant alternative routes within 60 min of the trains they cancel, that strikes should not last more than one day per week and they should publish the revised detailed timetables for each station as soon as the strike date is set, so we can plan our commute.
So, what do you think?

AIBU- You support the strikes as they are currently
AINBU- They need to calm it down and provide a good basic service on strike days

OP posts:
MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:35

Oh, thanks for the links! I will have a look to them, but I cannot now as I am in a public place and have no headphones

OP posts:
creideamhdóchasgrá · 04/11/2022 18:34

creideamhdóchasgrá · 04/11/2022 18:18

As I understand it the rail strikes are about job cuts, changes to terms and conditions and pay - and rail workers include station staff and guards for example.

For insight into why pay fro train drivers may be higher than your salary read this thread www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4668635-anyone-a-train-driverneed-a-career-change

(for example 70% of drivers experiencing a person under their train and the trauma impact, and the rigorous selection process / level of knowledge and skill required )

and see here www.traindriver.org

Finally see here for a perspective on the strikes that contextualises the industrial action as beneficial / for all working people including the travelling public m.youtube.com/watch?v=QeXy-WxYG28&feature=youtu.be

I hope this gives some further background and context :)

@MushMonster Thank for clarifying your understandings which is helful :) Having looked at these links, what are your thoughts?

stopringingme · 04/11/2022 18:34

Almost all Train Drivers are in ASLEF not the RMT.

Please do a bit of research to see what they were striking about and most importantly the actual people who were striking and losing pay for standing up for their rights.

Stop believing the headlines.

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:31

Try to leave work at 5 pm and find any kind of transport to go back home when buses are running up to 5 hours late and fully booked till after 12 pm. Be there with other hundreds of people around you in the same situation.
See how an ambulance can move around through the resulting traffic.
It is putting people at risk.

I did clearly say, but I repeat, that when strikes were an inconvenience of one or two hours, a bit more money spent, I was ok. I am against redundancies and poor working conditions.
But, to me, they took it too far by providing zero service (without any notice, of course, for higher impact), changing dates, walking on a day that they had agreed to work.

OP posts:
christmaspudding43 · 04/11/2022 18:30

Hadtonameychangey · 04/11/2022 18:22

No, but they do have the obligation to provide a reasonable minimum of service, enough not to put people at risk

At risk? Have you considered that getting rid of essential staff and changing the terms and conditions of operational and maintenance staff so that they are even more pressured might make a difference to ‘risk’?

Just a thought.

If only there were a like function!

christmaspudding43 · 04/11/2022 18:29

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:13

I have not focused on drivers bar gor saying I do like the number published as their salary, I wish it was mine.
I have not inyended to ban anyone from striking.
You made that one up!

You want to limit the numbers of people who can strike. If you're not allowed to strike to ensure the service levels you deem fit you're banned from striking...

And if driving is so attractive you should apply! Less flippantly, focusing so heavily on drivers salaries when the grades most affected are much lower paid staff is playing right into the government's hands.

BananaBlue · 04/11/2022 18:29

I agree that trains are essential and the strikes are a pain.

I think it’s the train company’s responsibility to invest and support their resource to ensure they provide a good service.

If they weren’t constantly trying to eek out further profit via reduced staff, T&C’s, pension arrangements, salaries then staff prob wouldn’t be striking.

Hadtonameychangey · 04/11/2022 18:22

No, but they do have the obligation to provide a reasonable minimum of service, enough not to put people at risk

At risk? Have you considered that getting rid of essential staff and changing the terms and conditions of operational and maintenance staff so that they are even more pressured might make a difference to ‘risk’?

Just a thought.

creideamhdóchasgrá · 04/11/2022 18:18

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 17:24

Train drivers are well paid, by comparisson to my salary.
I did see the publishing of their pay scale, and to be honest, it looked great to me! At least if ypu do not live in London itself.

The trains are hugely expensive as it is. I agree they should be a national asset.

As I understand it the rail strikes are about job cuts, changes to terms and conditions and pay - and rail workers include station staff and guards for example.

For insight into why pay fro train drivers may be higher than your salary read this thread www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4668635-anyone-a-train-driverneed-a-career-change

(for example 70% of drivers experiencing a person under their train and the trauma impact, and the rigorous selection process / level of knowledge and skill required )

and see here www.traindriver.org

Finally see here for a perspective on the strikes that contextualises the industrial action as beneficial / for all working people including the travelling public m.youtube.com/watch?v=QeXy-WxYG28&feature=youtu.be

I hope this gives some further background and context :)

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/11/2022 18:18

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:13

I have not focused on drivers bar gor saying I do like the number published as their salary, I wish it was mine.
I have not inyended to ban anyone from striking.
You made that one up!

I bet lots of drivers wish that salary was theirs as well. The media will always skew a figure or present the highest possible figure for dramatic effect.

Hadtonameychangey · 04/11/2022 18:16

You are entitled to your opinion OP.

But don’t worry about the rail companies losing money. It is the staff that lose their wages during strikes for the privilege of trying to keep necessary jobs and not having their pension attacked.

If you think striking is for fun and just to mess the public about you are mistaken. They, like many others, worked through the pandemic. Operational staff cannot work from home and therefore kept accruing costs where others could save.

And for what? To be told that their terms and conditions are being attacked along with pensions, essential staff are being cut (when they are short now) and when they already run on goodwill?

No one wants to disadvantage the public. No one. Do they sit there and take it?

And they don’t all earn the money you read in the newspaper. Speak to those on a picket line. They’ll tell you.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/11/2022 18:15

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:11

I bet you, if there was a fire, they would have turned up.
Minimum service does not mean anyone has to put up or shut up, just that strikes include a lesser amountt of the workforce in practice as someone needs to be there. Those professions still strike and claim improvements.
I have clearly said that I am willing to be inconvenienced. But I am not willing to be left stranded till past midnight in the middle of the street.
There is quite a difference!

Er, no, thats not what happened. The army had to provide cover. They were on strike.

What you've described would be ridiculous, so there'd be a striking rota? I don't agree with all strikes but if it doesn't cause any disruption then it can't really make the point they want to make. And even if they did have some kind of skeleton staff agreement, there's no guarantee that your service wouldn't have been affected.

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:13

I have not focused on drivers bar gor saying I do like the number published as their salary, I wish it was mine.
I have not inyended to ban anyone from striking.
You made that one up!

OP posts:
MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:11

I bet you, if there was a fire, they would have turned up.
Minimum service does not mean anyone has to put up or shut up, just that strikes include a lesser amountt of the workforce in practice as someone needs to be there. Those professions still strike and claim improvements.
I have clearly said that I am willing to be inconvenienced. But I am not willing to be left stranded till past midnight in the middle of the street.
There is quite a difference!

OP posts:
christmaspudding43 · 04/11/2022 18:11

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:04

No, but they do have the obligation to provide a reasonable minimum of service, enough not to put people at risk

Perhaps then, those industries you wish to see banned from striking should be guaranteed pay rises etc?

christmaspudding43 · 04/11/2022 18:10

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:06

I have noticed that all of them are striking, thanks

No, they are not all striking. And the fact that you focus so exclusively on drivers show that you have not understood the basics of how the railway works and where the disputes are.

Lovetotravel123 · 04/11/2022 18:09

I totally agree with you.

Nevermorethis · 04/11/2022 18:09

ButterflyBiscuit · 04/11/2022 17:21

I thought training drivers were really well paid last term this came up!

But it would be much better if it was run nationally again and not for profit.

Railway staff are well paid for the jobs they do.
I find it hard to have sympathy for the strikes tbh.

Whereisthehugeteddybear · 04/11/2022 18:09

I commute on the train every day. To be fair on most of the strike days our very expensive train line did run a reduced service so it was possible to get to work, and lots of people I think wfh so it wasn't overly crowded. Normally the day after the strike is more of a PITA.

However saying this, the whole point of strikes is to cause maximum disruption to prove that its an essential service and use that as leverage.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/11/2022 18:06

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:04

No, but they do have the obligation to provide a reasonable minimum of service, enough not to put people at risk

To what extent? Are you saying once you join certain professions you have to put up and shut up? I recall the fire service strikes 20 or so years ago were quite well supported.

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:06

I have noticed that all of them are striking, thanks

OP posts:
madnesss · 04/11/2022 18:05

Whitegrenache · 04/11/2022 17:56

Even though they have ben cancelled LNER are still saying no availability for a journey I wish to take next Wednesday

They have to rework and update the timetable, give them a chance.

anniegun · 04/11/2022 18:05

The strikes are not all about the relatively well-paid train drivers - they are a small part of the workforce. In our area of the SE they cannot recruit cleaners and ticket collectors on just above the minimum wage. They have to work all types of shifts in some pretty difficult circumstances and have not had a rise for 3 years

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/11/2022 18:04

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 17:24

Train drivers are well paid, by comparisson to my salary.
I did see the publishing of their pay scale, and to be honest, it looked great to me! At least if ypu do not live in London itself.

The trains are hugely expensive as it is. I agree they should be a national asset.

It's not just pay they are striking over.

It's not just drivers that are striking.

MushMonster · 04/11/2022 18:04

No, but they do have the obligation to provide a reasonable minimum of service, enough not to put people at risk

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread