Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else’s nursery pulling this stunt at the moment?

490 replies

Skinnermarink · 04/11/2022 12:14

Let me preface this by saying I KNOW nursery work is hard and it’s long and it’s woefully underpaid. It was a long time ago but I’ve worked in one myself. I can totally see why there’s a recruitment crisis with it at the moment.

DS is one and we thought we’d found a good nursery. Long established, nice staff etc. I wasn’t keen on sending him at all because I wanted him at home with me but it’s not financially viable. So four days a week he goes, at a cost of £1100 a month.

The amount of calls we’ve had to go and collect him over something or other have ramped up in the past eight weeks to the point of ridiculousness. They include

-a temperature that we never managed to catch at home and he was completely well. That happed 3x
upset stomach that magically we never saw at home, but came with a 48 hour exclusion. This went on for weeks. At worst he had a few soft nappies, certainly nothing anyone could describe as diarrhoea. I eventually got a stool sample to clear him for this at their insistence before they’d have him back. He missed days and days of nursery for this.

Teething pain which meant he was ‘not himself’ (I didn’t collect for this, as he was playing, eating and drinking, and I told them I wasn’t going to collect for something as flimsy as this and they were welcome to give calpol)

a head injury that we had to come immediately for or they’d call an ambulance, threw myself into a taxi in sheer panic to find him running around with a tiny bump on his head, but they wanted me to take him home to be checked out and not return him for 24 hours. I’m not under reacting by the way, it really was in no way anything other than a typical toddler bump.

This week has been the final straw. He had his MMR vaccine last week and developed a few tiny spots- a side effect listed on the NHS website. They called and said we had to collect and he couldn’t return today unless a doctor cleared the ‘rash’.

Luckily our GP is fab and had him in this morning, cleared him in seconds with a note so I took him straight to nursery because I had to get to work. There were already 9 babies in the room, mine would take it to ten. 3 members of staff. They looked pissed off and a bit panicked and said he couldn’t come in unless I had a doctor’s clearance - which I produced. The manager was called down who said they had staff sickness but she would be covering herself until an agency worker arrived.

I felt shit leaving him to be honest but it’s no exaggeration to say our jobs have been on the line due to dropping things to pick him up, staying off with him at short notice etc. we’ve used practically all remaining annual leave we had for Christmas so that’s scuppered plans to visit family. We don’t have any outside help, it’s just us, no grandparents to call in an emergency etc.

So I want to know has anyone else been in this situation? I’m not being paranoid (although I did tell myself I was at first) and I honestly think they have to pick babies to send home to stay within the ratios and then hope they stay off the next day.

I’ll add that DS has been genuinely unwell with things on occasion and of course we’ve kept him off. But we are at our absolute limit now and have pissed hundreds up the wall on unnecessary pick ups and days off.

Think I have found an alternative setting and are looking on Monday, but they have no availability until January.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 18:00

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 17:44

Ive not made comment about how much providers charge, only acknowledged the fact that many mothers are priced out of the workforce. That is not a value or moral judgment of mine - it’s just a fact of the matter!

You have said that childcare costs are the problem, repeatedly.

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 18:00

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 17:17

Ok @Tillsforthrills

Incase I’ve missed it, would you mind telling us what YOU pay for childcare per hour/day? Do you think it’s enough, or do you top it up every month from the goodness of your heart?

I pay £67 a day. Of course, I’m not just paying that for the sole care of my child as the ratio is 1:3. So that is £201 a day for accepting 3 babies for one worker. How that is then spent/filtered down is totally out of my control.

Your turn.

I pay 95 per day.

Why so angry?

Your costs are VERY reasonable at presumably what works out at £6.50 an hour.

You’re correct to say that calculating 3 childrens fees per worker isn’t an accurate reflection on what they get paid and that you have no idea the overheads involved.

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 17:44

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 15:32

My point is and has been the lack of government funding and subsidy. That is a given.

But to say it’s the price of childcare implies something else, which is - providers are charging too much.

It is subtle but it’s an overwhelming sentiment as it seems from you. Truth is there are many issues such as why it always falls to the mother.

But I’d love to know what you deem an acceptable hourly amount for you personally? And I hope you don’t avoid this question…as others have. Explicitly state what is fair and right in your eyes to be charged please.

Ive not made comment about how much providers charge, only acknowledged the fact that many mothers are priced out of the workforce. That is not a value or moral judgment of mine - it’s just a fact of the matter!

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 17:42

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 15:24

No one has answered me on what they think a fair hourly rate of childcare is?

How much do you think is fair to pay an hour?

I have no idea - I’d have to understand the nurseries overheads and the quality of care vs the budget.

what I do know, is that I have to have some money left over after childcare for it to be viable for me to use it.

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 17:17

Ok @Tillsforthrills

Incase I’ve missed it, would you mind telling us what YOU pay for childcare per hour/day? Do you think it’s enough, or do you top it up every month from the goodness of your heart?

I pay £67 a day. Of course, I’m not just paying that for the sole care of my child as the ratio is 1:3. So that is £201 a day for accepting 3 babies for one worker. How that is then spent/filtered down is totally out of my control.

Your turn.

OP posts:
AbreathofFrenchair · 09/11/2022 15:40

momlette · 08/11/2022 23:08

And saying the kids had done special singing classes, or French lessons or baking. Mostly a load of bollocks. The staff don’t want a huge mess to clean up so usually give the impression of the kids having fun to get the photos. A more realistic view was the staff standing about chatting about blokes or their night out while the kids sit around the toys. Or staff having a snooze on the floor when hungover. Pay staff shit pay that’s what happens. Not the parents fault, not the government. Just greed .

Its bullshit horror stories like this that also damage nurseries.

No wonder we get treated like the scum of the earth when lies like these get circulated.

If this "story" is even slightly true, I hope you reported them to Ofsted?

AbreathofFrenchair · 09/11/2022 15:36

Skinnermarink · 04/11/2022 12:14

Let me preface this by saying I KNOW nursery work is hard and it’s long and it’s woefully underpaid. It was a long time ago but I’ve worked in one myself. I can totally see why there’s a recruitment crisis with it at the moment.

DS is one and we thought we’d found a good nursery. Long established, nice staff etc. I wasn’t keen on sending him at all because I wanted him at home with me but it’s not financially viable. So four days a week he goes, at a cost of £1100 a month.

The amount of calls we’ve had to go and collect him over something or other have ramped up in the past eight weeks to the point of ridiculousness. They include

-a temperature that we never managed to catch at home and he was completely well. That happed 3x
upset stomach that magically we never saw at home, but came with a 48 hour exclusion. This went on for weeks. At worst he had a few soft nappies, certainly nothing anyone could describe as diarrhoea. I eventually got a stool sample to clear him for this at their insistence before they’d have him back. He missed days and days of nursery for this.

Teething pain which meant he was ‘not himself’ (I didn’t collect for this, as he was playing, eating and drinking, and I told them I wasn’t going to collect for something as flimsy as this and they were welcome to give calpol)

a head injury that we had to come immediately for or they’d call an ambulance, threw myself into a taxi in sheer panic to find him running around with a tiny bump on his head, but they wanted me to take him home to be checked out and not return him for 24 hours. I’m not under reacting by the way, it really was in no way anything other than a typical toddler bump.

This week has been the final straw. He had his MMR vaccine last week and developed a few tiny spots- a side effect listed on the NHS website. They called and said we had to collect and he couldn’t return today unless a doctor cleared the ‘rash’.

Luckily our GP is fab and had him in this morning, cleared him in seconds with a note so I took him straight to nursery because I had to get to work. There were already 9 babies in the room, mine would take it to ten. 3 members of staff. They looked pissed off and a bit panicked and said he couldn’t come in unless I had a doctor’s clearance - which I produced. The manager was called down who said they had staff sickness but she would be covering herself until an agency worker arrived.

I felt shit leaving him to be honest but it’s no exaggeration to say our jobs have been on the line due to dropping things to pick him up, staying off with him at short notice etc. we’ve used practically all remaining annual leave we had for Christmas so that’s scuppered plans to visit family. We don’t have any outside help, it’s just us, no grandparents to call in an emergency etc.

So I want to know has anyone else been in this situation? I’m not being paranoid (although I did tell myself I was at first) and I honestly think they have to pick babies to send home to stay within the ratios and then hope they stay off the next day.

I’ll add that DS has been genuinely unwell with things on occasion and of course we’ve kept him off. But we are at our absolute limit now and have pissed hundreds up the wall on unnecessary pick ups and days off.

Think I have found an alternative setting and are looking on Monday, but they have no availability until January.

I'm a deputy in a nursery.

We have 48 hour exclusion for loose nappies and sickness. If there are 3 loose nappies or 3 vomiting incidents in 1 day, theres a call to collect then they need to be 48 hours clear before they can come back. Same for staff too.

Following routine childhood vaccines, we expect temps. If a temp occurs after them, it's a call for permission for calpol. If temp hasn't gone down within the hour, they need to go home but can come on the next day.

Newly prescribed antibiotics, they need to have been on them for 24 hours before they can come in.

By loose nappies,.we mean the ones that are like water where they soak into the nappy and you barely need a wipe to clean the bottom.

We also can't give calpol for teething pain as we can only give it for temps so if you don't send anything in, your child won't get anything to help teething pain. We would keep them but always let you know at handover that they need something for their teeth.

I've done it long enough now to know if the smell of a nappy is teething or upset stomach.

If you genuinely think it's because ratios are not being met, then maybe a call to Ofsted with your concerns. Ratios are 1:3 for under 2 1:4 for under 3 and 1:8 for over 3s, though if you have a Level 6 member of staff, it can be moved up to 1:13 for the over 3s.

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 15:32

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 14:41

you are very wrong to think that whatever hourly rate you’re paying is too high and pricing you out of work.

Can you explain why you disagree that childcare is pricing women out of work? The value of quality childcare and the cost to deliver it are two different issues.

There are women in the UK who cannot afford to work because of the cost of childcare - that’s a fact.

amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jun/15/childcare-costs-women-britain-work-mothers

My point is and has been the lack of government funding and subsidy. That is a given.

But to say it’s the price of childcare implies something else, which is - providers are charging too much.

It is subtle but it’s an overwhelming sentiment as it seems from you. Truth is there are many issues such as why it always falls to the mother.

But I’d love to know what you deem an acceptable hourly amount for you personally? And I hope you don’t avoid this question…as others have. Explicitly state what is fair and right in your eyes to be charged please.

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 15:24

RedWingBoots · 09/11/2022 14:42

@Tillsforthrills of course the cost of childcare is pricing parents, mainly mothers, out of work and limiting the size of families.

Or what did you think the protest at the weekend was about?

No one has answered me on what they think a fair hourly rate of childcare is?

How much do you think is fair to pay an hour?

RedWingBoots · 09/11/2022 14:42

@Tillsforthrills of course the cost of childcare is pricing parents, mainly mothers, out of work and limiting the size of families.

Or what did you think the protest at the weekend was about?

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 14:41

you are very wrong to think that whatever hourly rate you’re paying is too high and pricing you out of work.

Can you explain why you disagree that childcare is pricing women out of work? The value of quality childcare and the cost to deliver it are two different issues.

There are women in the UK who cannot afford to work because of the cost of childcare - that’s a fact.

amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jun/15/childcare-costs-women-britain-work-mothers

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 14:36

Then you pay more because you have more.

I’m pleased for you.

OP posts:
NurseryNurse10 · 09/11/2022 14:16

I can relate to @momlette experience actually going by what I have seen in various nurseries.
Also agree with the food. The kids at the nursery I went to last week get 1 dry Jacobs cream cracker at snack time. Other times it's cheap yogurt, beans on toast etc.

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 13:45

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 09:50

Childcare is absolutely pricing women out of work!! I can’t understand how you can’t see that. If the hourly rate for nurseries should be higher, than this should be subsidised by the government. We are way behind in this compared to almost every other country in Europe.

I go to work for a pittance really once childcare, commute costs and mortgage/food/bills come out. It’s JUST ABOUT worth me working- only just. If I could, I’d Jack it in while DS is still so small and not rely on a nursery in the first place.

I don’t know what fantasy land you live in @Tillsforthrills that working parents have all these options available to them, financially and practically.

You’re wrong, firstly I pay more than you do.

You’re confusing the issue, I’ve tried to explain. Yes you are right that the govt should step up but no you are very wrong to think that whatever hourly rate you’re paying is too high and pricing you out of work.

What do you think would be an acceptable amount per hour to charge to care for your young child? Please do answer. To see of the two of us which is living in fantasy land.

RedWingBoots · 09/11/2022 10:50

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 09:54

Oh, and I went on the Pregnant Then Screwed March and although there was an amazing turnout, it received practically no attention or press whatsoever, because society as it is right now couldn’t give a shiny shit about the struggles working parents or the childcare they rely on are facing.

It received no media attention because you were all well behaved.

I remember the student marches about tuition fees. There were lots in London as there are lots of universities in London. The only ones that got media attention were the ones where people misbehaved.

This is why Just Stop Oil are doing attention seeking activities.

Mysterian · 09/11/2022 10:01

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 08:08

Omg what?! That’s awful.

I know my children are well fed and have yummy food at the CM I use, they really look forward to meals and I think a considerable chunk of money is spent on it.

I see meal delivery vans pulling up to nurseries around here and I’ve always assumed it’s good quality.

I temped in one place that employed a cook who came from a Michelin starred restaurant. Food was very good. Another place had food I would happily pay £15 for in a restaurant. One dish was chicken in creamy sauce topped with chopped fresh tarragon!

But... one major chain sometimes did starter and main rather than main and pudding. (I don't agree with that but won't go into that now.) For their starter one day they had "garlic bread", which was half a slice of cheap white bread slightly impregnated with garlic butter.
Another tiny nursery had all kinds of exciting menus. Lunch would come around and it was chips, beans and value ham. Or mash, mixed veg and nuggets. No relation to the menu at all. It closed.
My current nursery do no added salt when cooking. The sausages however, were so cheap and full of salt I could hardly eat one.

The problem is that parents never get to experience the food in their nursery so there's not the incentive to be good. Just to sound good.
(For a similar reason many nurseries are taking advantage of the Covid 'dropping off at the door' rule and have carried it on. If parents can't come into the nursery they can't check the quality, so you don't need it. My advice is never use a nursery that doesn't let you in.)

My other bug bear is nurseries giving children food that's healthy but that they don't like. One nursery did natural yogurt with fresh crushed raspberries. It was so sour it was inedible. My current one likes to give babies dry pita bread with hummus, and crudités: hard carrot sticks, cucumber sticks, and tomatoes. One child once ate a tomato. One or 2 like the other things, but mostly tea that day is dry strips of pita. Healthy food that children don't eat is not good for them. It just looks good on the menu.

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 09:54

Oh, and I went on the Pregnant Then Screwed March and although there was an amazing turnout, it received practically no attention or press whatsoever, because society as it is right now couldn’t give a shiny shit about the struggles working parents or the childcare they rely on are facing.

OP posts:
HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 09:52

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 09:38

Again, there are many posters complaining about £9 an hour childcare. If a low wage is earned and there’s genuine need then benefits are given.

It is not childcare pricing women out of work ffs. What is an acceptable hourly rate to you?

Are you reading the costs involved for nurseries?

Other countries governments subsidise and therefore incentivise women to work. The issue isn’t the daily rate of nurseries and to be honest people want to pay a pittance for their childcare, fees that they wouldn’t work 50 hours per week for.

So again, it’s not the hourly rate of childcare that’s the problem. When will this get through I wonder?

If you’ve any interests in learning about the actual issues and just your own perception listen to this podcast.

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001ddw9

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 09:50

Childcare is absolutely pricing women out of work!! I can’t understand how you can’t see that. If the hourly rate for nurseries should be higher, than this should be subsidised by the government. We are way behind in this compared to almost every other country in Europe.

I go to work for a pittance really once childcare, commute costs and mortgage/food/bills come out. It’s JUST ABOUT worth me working- only just. If I could, I’d Jack it in while DS is still so small and not rely on a nursery in the first place.

I don’t know what fantasy land you live in @Tillsforthrills that working parents have all these options available to them, financially and practically.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 09:38

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 09:05

Won’t or can’t? Childcare is already pricing women out of work. They can’t afford to
work. I’m not sure how you’ve reached the conclusion they’re unwilling to pay.

Again, there are many posters complaining about £9 an hour childcare. If a low wage is earned and there’s genuine need then benefits are given.

It is not childcare pricing women out of work ffs. What is an acceptable hourly rate to you?

Are you reading the costs involved for nurseries?

Other countries governments subsidise and therefore incentivise women to work. The issue isn’t the daily rate of nurseries and to be honest people want to pay a pittance for their childcare, fees that they wouldn’t work 50 hours per week for.

So again, it’s not the hourly rate of childcare that’s the problem. When will this get through I wonder?

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 09:05

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 08:51

Around here it’s more expensive for nursery naturally. However I agree with your point that people just don’t want to pay a decent hourly rate for childcare.

Won’t or can’t? Childcare is already pricing women out of work. They can’t afford to
work. I’m not sure how you’ve reached the conclusion they’re unwilling to pay.

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 08:51

Tumbleweed101 · 09/11/2022 08:23

It's more expensive to pay for a dog to go into doggy daycare than a child to go into nursery. Think on that. People are willing to pay more for their pet than their child without complaint. So crazy.

Personally, I think each child under five should be given the money for childcare that government would offer for funding and then give nurseries the freedom to charge fees without restrictions so they can cover their costs for their own setting. Perhaps then the market would be more fair and each child would still get the same funding money and nurseries could stay open as they can meet their overheads.

Around here it’s more expensive for nursery naturally. However I agree with your point that people just don’t want to pay a decent hourly rate for childcare.

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 08:47

What doggy day care is charging upwards of £1100 a month?!

And it’s not a question of not being ‘willing’ to pay more- we can’t. It’s a huge struggle as it is.

OP posts:
HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 08:36

Tumbleweed101 · 09/11/2022 08:23

It's more expensive to pay for a dog to go into doggy daycare than a child to go into nursery. Think on that. People are willing to pay more for their pet than their child without complaint. So crazy.

Personally, I think each child under five should be given the money for childcare that government would offer for funding and then give nurseries the freedom to charge fees without restrictions so they can cover their costs for their own setting. Perhaps then the market would be more fair and each child would still get the same funding money and nurseries could stay open as they can meet their overheads.

Is it? I pay £20 for doggy daycare including collection and delivery, my nurseries day rate is £62.50….
With funded hours for my eldest it’s still £31 a day.

Tumbleweed101 · 09/11/2022 08:23

It's more expensive to pay for a dog to go into doggy daycare than a child to go into nursery. Think on that. People are willing to pay more for their pet than their child without complaint. So crazy.

Personally, I think each child under five should be given the money for childcare that government would offer for funding and then give nurseries the freedom to charge fees without restrictions so they can cover their costs for their own setting. Perhaps then the market would be more fair and each child would still get the same funding money and nurseries could stay open as they can meet their overheads.

Swipe left for the next trending thread