Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else’s nursery pulling this stunt at the moment?

490 replies

Skinnermarink · 04/11/2022 12:14

Let me preface this by saying I KNOW nursery work is hard and it’s long and it’s woefully underpaid. It was a long time ago but I’ve worked in one myself. I can totally see why there’s a recruitment crisis with it at the moment.

DS is one and we thought we’d found a good nursery. Long established, nice staff etc. I wasn’t keen on sending him at all because I wanted him at home with me but it’s not financially viable. So four days a week he goes, at a cost of £1100 a month.

The amount of calls we’ve had to go and collect him over something or other have ramped up in the past eight weeks to the point of ridiculousness. They include

-a temperature that we never managed to catch at home and he was completely well. That happed 3x
upset stomach that magically we never saw at home, but came with a 48 hour exclusion. This went on for weeks. At worst he had a few soft nappies, certainly nothing anyone could describe as diarrhoea. I eventually got a stool sample to clear him for this at their insistence before they’d have him back. He missed days and days of nursery for this.

Teething pain which meant he was ‘not himself’ (I didn’t collect for this, as he was playing, eating and drinking, and I told them I wasn’t going to collect for something as flimsy as this and they were welcome to give calpol)

a head injury that we had to come immediately for or they’d call an ambulance, threw myself into a taxi in sheer panic to find him running around with a tiny bump on his head, but they wanted me to take him home to be checked out and not return him for 24 hours. I’m not under reacting by the way, it really was in no way anything other than a typical toddler bump.

This week has been the final straw. He had his MMR vaccine last week and developed a few tiny spots- a side effect listed on the NHS website. They called and said we had to collect and he couldn’t return today unless a doctor cleared the ‘rash’.

Luckily our GP is fab and had him in this morning, cleared him in seconds with a note so I took him straight to nursery because I had to get to work. There were already 9 babies in the room, mine would take it to ten. 3 members of staff. They looked pissed off and a bit panicked and said he couldn’t come in unless I had a doctor’s clearance - which I produced. The manager was called down who said they had staff sickness but she would be covering herself until an agency worker arrived.

I felt shit leaving him to be honest but it’s no exaggeration to say our jobs have been on the line due to dropping things to pick him up, staying off with him at short notice etc. we’ve used practically all remaining annual leave we had for Christmas so that’s scuppered plans to visit family. We don’t have any outside help, it’s just us, no grandparents to call in an emergency etc.

So I want to know has anyone else been in this situation? I’m not being paranoid (although I did tell myself I was at first) and I honestly think they have to pick babies to send home to stay within the ratios and then hope they stay off the next day.

I’ll add that DS has been genuinely unwell with things on occasion and of course we’ve kept him off. But we are at our absolute limit now and have pissed hundreds up the wall on unnecessary pick ups and days off.

Think I have found an alternative setting and are looking on Monday, but they have no availability until January.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 11:27

HotCoffee22 · 10/11/2022 10:52

I have also never commented to say childcare is TOO expensive or providers charge TOO much in terms of what it costs to deliver.

What I have said is that cost, whether justified or not, is prohibitive for many people in being able to access that childcare.

I can afford my childcare, I see it as an investment in my children’s future. It’s not just supervision it’s their first educator.

But that does not alter or detract from other women (or families), who can’t and who are forced out of the workplace and to be that is not acceptable.

I agree with you entirely on your last two paragraphs but your first two paragraphs do not make any sense to me as you have said it’s the childcare costs that are the problem.

I will say this one more time and then I’ll leave it - it is the government that need to help people that have to make the choice between childcare or work.

The government wants to pit parents against the (cost of) childcare providers. In fact they’re delighted with this.

If it were up to them, they’d de-regulate childcare settings and as per Liz Truss idea - make childcare settings take on more children, increase ratios for the same money for providers and less quality settings for babies. That way it shuts the parents up and they don’t have to spend a penny but make it look like they’re doing something to ‘help’ parents out. Driving childcare settings further into the ground.

So the only difference between you and I, is that I don’t blame ‘childcare costs’ for pricing women or lower earners out. I blame this government.

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 11:25

Why wouldn’t you ‘dream of sending’ your child to the £120 nursery? I thought you said as long as you are willing to pay more the standard would be better, and since that’s almost double what I pay for my nursery I’m curious to know why you feel the cost doesn’t translate to quality care?

Great that you have such a lovely childminder option available to you- sadly they are few and far between. What about if your childminder didn’t have a place? Would you then have to dream of sending to nursery? Or would you relocate?

Give up your career?

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 11:19

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 10:52

Is your provider, in fact, a nanny @Tillsforthrills

Its just that you say ‘her’ and I do t know of a childminder that would generally charge that amount, unless it’s a very long day. If you have a nanny that’s actually under market rate for a full day but perhaps you don’t need full time hours?

CM in London. Home cooked meals, daily outings and a small family like set up. I could get cheaper and save on the bills but I really like the set up as does DH and we would pay around £15 p/h for a good nanny, have to provide food and our home which would distract us. Our local nurseries are 120 per day but I’d never dream of sending DC there.

HotCoffee22 · 10/11/2022 10:52

I have also never commented to say childcare is TOO expensive or providers charge TOO much in terms of what it costs to deliver.

What I have said is that cost, whether justified or not, is prohibitive for many people in being able to access that childcare.

I can afford my childcare, I see it as an investment in my children’s future. It’s not just supervision it’s their first educator.

But that does not alter or detract from other women (or families), who can’t and who are forced out of the workplace and to be that is not acceptable.

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 10:52

Is your provider, in fact, a nanny @Tillsforthrills

Its just that you say ‘her’ and I do t know of a childminder that would generally charge that amount, unless it’s a very long day. If you have a nanny that’s actually under market rate for a full day but perhaps you don’t need full time hours?

OP posts:
HotCoffee22 · 10/11/2022 10:48

Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 09:06

Spare me.

I’ve never said it’s easy for us - it isn’t for anyone. Those are your words not mine.

But I’m happy to sacrifice for a few years to further my career and pay my provider a wage that doesn’t disadvantage her hard work so I can progress.

Shoot me if I’m not one of the parents blaming ‘extortionate childcare fees’.

What you’re saying, if I understand, is that a high cost of childcare is justified and if that prices some women out of work that is an acceptable, naturalist consequence. Or you’re denying it does price women out of work. So in essence childcare being either unaffordable or inaccessible is acceptable.

Jarofhoney · 10/11/2022 09:27

Yanbu. They shouldn't be taking kids on if they dont have the staff anyway.

Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 09:06

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 09:03

Jesus Christ! I give up. I think the feeling is mutual @Tillsforthrills

I really don’t know what else I can say to you but there’s no way our opinions are going to align.

i am happy for you that you can easily afford high cost childcare. That is great. Well done you.

Spare me.

I’ve never said it’s easy for us - it isn’t for anyone. Those are your words not mine.

But I’m happy to sacrifice for a few years to further my career and pay my provider a wage that doesn’t disadvantage her hard work so I can progress.

Shoot me if I’m not one of the parents blaming ‘extortionate childcare fees’.

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 09:05

We are going round in circles.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 09:04

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 08:56

Where are you getting this £6/7 nonsense from?!

Plenty of literature out there that disproves your (very short sighted) points, as a PP points out.

But unfortunately you don’t seem able to think beyond your own situation.

I was referring to what @HotCoffee22 pays.

Skinnamarink - plenty of literature proving that nurseries are on their knees and can’t take less pay.

Parents that can’t afford what they do charge and on their knees too.

People are very offended when I point out nursery and provider fees are reasonable because they can’t afford that.

Do you disagree with me that the government should subsidise childcare?

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 09:03

Jesus Christ! I give up. I think the feeling is mutual @Tillsforthrills

I really don’t know what else I can say to you but there’s no way our opinions are going to align.

i am happy for you that you can easily afford high cost childcare. That is great. Well done you.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 09:00

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 18:24

That isn’t a moot issue! Childcare costs are an issue. But you’re lumping the issue of the cost of providing care with the separate issue of affordability.

They are two separate but interdependent issues! If Bill Gates decided to pay my childcare bill it would be more affordable to me, that doesn’t alter the cost of delivering it.

I’m really struggling to understand what point you’re trying to make?

my god if you haven’t got what I’m saying by now then I don’t know how else to explain

You think the cost of delivering childcare and affordability for parents are two separate things?

You can’t focus on the affordability for yourself then when questioned about how nurseries would survive on less than you’re paying ‘I don’t know’

Most providers aren’t overcharging and in your case they certainly aren’t. You’ve mentioned that each childcarers would get 3 fees, which implies the simplistic view you’re taking.

The crux of the problem is not childcare costs which broadly speaking are reasonable.

The problem is that many don’t factor in these costs when having children and the ones that can’t afford the fees aren’t being given government support.

Skinnermarink · 10/11/2022 08:56

Where are you getting this £6/7 nonsense from?!

Plenty of literature out there that disproves your (very short sighted) points, as a PP points out.

But unfortunately you don’t seem able to think beyond your own situation.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 10/11/2022 08:48

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 18:23

@Tillsforthrills

Firstly, paying more doesn’t always mean a higher standard of care. It isn’t like paying into BUPA.

Secondly, if I were to pay £97 a day, I wouldn’t be working for a pittance, I wouldn’t be working for nothing, it would COST me to work. So obviously I wouldn’t be able to afford to go to work.

How can you argue that childcare costs are not pricing women out of the workplace?

Although, I fear I could predict you’re ‘I’m alright Jack’ response- you’ll probably say all women in that situation need to get a better paid job.

Yes we had factored this in before having children that we’d need to pay a lot for childcare.

If you read my posts you’d understand I’m not against the government subsidising childcare for parents that can’t afford £6 odd an hour for their childcare.

If the govt want to help people stay in work and not have to leave and go on benefits then they need to step in.

But £6/£7 fees for a nursery is crazy to say that’s pricing women out.

HotCoffee22 · 10/11/2022 08:19

Not denying it happened but intrigued how anyone can doze in a room full of kids!

momlette · 09/11/2022 22:51

There were multiple nurseries, multiple behaviour issues, some safeguarding and some other conduct issues. In many nurseries there was a problem with selling a lifestyle of Exclusive lessons but it really wasn’t what it was cracked up to be. Of course some places will be just fabulous and will do what they say on the tin. However you can’t deny the reality of the issues that happened over the years just because you don’t like them. I gave the sleeping nursery nurse as an example of an issue that occurred. A real life actually happened example. Not a made up story example. I never had that one more than once . There were many others though a wide range of issues accross sites. Some of which seemed to occur repeatedly and others that were a one off

Kanaloa · 09/11/2022 22:14

momlette · 09/11/2022 21:58

for the last time it’s not a lie! A young modern apprentice was hungover and dozed off on the floor of the room she was working in! Just because you don’t or haven’t done these things why does it have to be a lie? This is one of the lesser areas of misconduct I’m sure you must realise that? Every single day in every work place there are cases of poor behaviour by employees. Nurseries are not exempt. The worst of the lot will make headlines but the misdemeanours will not

Well maybe it’s how you presented it. You talked about lies about activities and staff ‘snoozing on the floor hungover.’ You didn’t mention these as one off misdemeanours that were appropriately dealt with - you presented them as if you were trying to imply this was normal nursery work procedure. When questioned you then revealed that in fact one apprentice did this one time.

It’s extremely unusual for a member of staff to be lying asleep on the floor hungover. I wouldn’t say it’s a ‘lesser misdemeanour.’ Most places I’ve worked you could get in real trouble for that. The grand majority of childcare practitioners work extremely hard for very low pay - they’re not lying asleep on the floor and lying that the kids have had French lessons when they haven’t accessed that activity at all.

NurseryNurse10 · 09/11/2022 22:13

If @momlette is lying then I must be as well as have seen similar in nurseries.
Of course there are some well run settings but also some terrible ones. Seeing as I'm agency staff, I'm more likely to see the worst ones because they cannot retain staff due to how bad the nursery is. But I agree, let's not be fooled that all nurseries are wonderful because they most definitely are not which saddens me to say but it is true.

momlette · 09/11/2022 21:58

Rosebel · 09/11/2022 21:50

What are you talking about? If you have ever seen that then you have been incredibly unlucky.
Of course we let the kids make a mess. We have gloop and times where the children have to be changed twice a day because of soaking wet clothes but that's part of the job.
We don't have time to stand and chat and as for having a nap, I assume that's a fucking joke?!
I really despair. No wonder we get zero respect with attitude and lies like this.

for the last time it’s not a lie! A young modern apprentice was hungover and dozed off on the floor of the room she was working in! Just because you don’t or haven’t done these things why does it have to be a lie? This is one of the lesser areas of misconduct I’m sure you must realise that? Every single day in every work place there are cases of poor behaviour by employees. Nurseries are not exempt. The worst of the lot will make headlines but the misdemeanours will not

2pinkginsplease · 09/11/2022 21:58

The previous nursery I worked in which was private said that if a child had 3 loose nappies they had to go home. A serious bump to the head parents had to collect and a temperature over 38 degrees then again parents had to collect.

This setting if temp is over 38 and a serious bump to the head they need to go home. We don't deal with nappies as ots a 3-5 setting so unsure of that policy.

Most nurseries are the same.

Rosebel · 09/11/2022 21:50

momlette · 08/11/2022 23:08

And saying the kids had done special singing classes, or French lessons or baking. Mostly a load of bollocks. The staff don’t want a huge mess to clean up so usually give the impression of the kids having fun to get the photos. A more realistic view was the staff standing about chatting about blokes or their night out while the kids sit around the toys. Or staff having a snooze on the floor when hungover. Pay staff shit pay that’s what happens. Not the parents fault, not the government. Just greed .

What are you talking about? If you have ever seen that then you have been incredibly unlucky.
Of course we let the kids make a mess. We have gloop and times where the children have to be changed twice a day because of soaking wet clothes but that's part of the job.
We don't have time to stand and chat and as for having a nap, I assume that's a fucking joke?!
I really despair. No wonder we get zero respect with attitude and lies like this.

momlette · 09/11/2022 19:55

It’s not bullshit at all. All issues that were noted in any nursery were dealt with. Those that were noted that is. You can kid yourself but there are some crappy nursery staff and some amazing ones for sure. It does happen though but if you want to pretend it doesn’t go ahead and keep looking the other way. You might be protecting your own self from entertaining that such things happen but you sure as hell aren’t helping the nursery kids that suffer because of it.

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 18:26

OP I think we are going round in circles…! There’s enough literature out there which irrefutably supports our assertion that women are priced out of childcare.

PP seem to be confusing their own feelings around whether or not that’s acceptable with the facts surrounding the issue.

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 18:24

Tillsforthrills · 09/11/2022 18:00

You have said that childcare costs are the problem, repeatedly.

That isn’t a moot issue! Childcare costs are an issue. But you’re lumping the issue of the cost of providing care with the separate issue of affordability.

They are two separate but interdependent issues! If Bill Gates decided to pay my childcare bill it would be more affordable to me, that doesn’t alter the cost of delivering it.

I’m really struggling to understand what point you’re trying to make?

Skinnermarink · 09/11/2022 18:23

@Tillsforthrills

Firstly, paying more doesn’t always mean a higher standard of care. It isn’t like paying into BUPA.

Secondly, if I were to pay £97 a day, I wouldn’t be working for a pittance, I wouldn’t be working for nothing, it would COST me to work. So obviously I wouldn’t be able to afford to go to work.

How can you argue that childcare costs are not pricing women out of the workplace?

Although, I fear I could predict you’re ‘I’m alright Jack’ response- you’ll probably say all women in that situation need to get a better paid job.

OP posts: