Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else’s nursery pulling this stunt at the moment?

490 replies

Skinnermarink · 04/11/2022 12:14

Let me preface this by saying I KNOW nursery work is hard and it’s long and it’s woefully underpaid. It was a long time ago but I’ve worked in one myself. I can totally see why there’s a recruitment crisis with it at the moment.

DS is one and we thought we’d found a good nursery. Long established, nice staff etc. I wasn’t keen on sending him at all because I wanted him at home with me but it’s not financially viable. So four days a week he goes, at a cost of £1100 a month.

The amount of calls we’ve had to go and collect him over something or other have ramped up in the past eight weeks to the point of ridiculousness. They include

-a temperature that we never managed to catch at home and he was completely well. That happed 3x
upset stomach that magically we never saw at home, but came with a 48 hour exclusion. This went on for weeks. At worst he had a few soft nappies, certainly nothing anyone could describe as diarrhoea. I eventually got a stool sample to clear him for this at their insistence before they’d have him back. He missed days and days of nursery for this.

Teething pain which meant he was ‘not himself’ (I didn’t collect for this, as he was playing, eating and drinking, and I told them I wasn’t going to collect for something as flimsy as this and they were welcome to give calpol)

a head injury that we had to come immediately for or they’d call an ambulance, threw myself into a taxi in sheer panic to find him running around with a tiny bump on his head, but they wanted me to take him home to be checked out and not return him for 24 hours. I’m not under reacting by the way, it really was in no way anything other than a typical toddler bump.

This week has been the final straw. He had his MMR vaccine last week and developed a few tiny spots- a side effect listed on the NHS website. They called and said we had to collect and he couldn’t return today unless a doctor cleared the ‘rash’.

Luckily our GP is fab and had him in this morning, cleared him in seconds with a note so I took him straight to nursery because I had to get to work. There were already 9 babies in the room, mine would take it to ten. 3 members of staff. They looked pissed off and a bit panicked and said he couldn’t come in unless I had a doctor’s clearance - which I produced. The manager was called down who said they had staff sickness but she would be covering herself until an agency worker arrived.

I felt shit leaving him to be honest but it’s no exaggeration to say our jobs have been on the line due to dropping things to pick him up, staying off with him at short notice etc. we’ve used practically all remaining annual leave we had for Christmas so that’s scuppered plans to visit family. We don’t have any outside help, it’s just us, no grandparents to call in an emergency etc.

So I want to know has anyone else been in this situation? I’m not being paranoid (although I did tell myself I was at first) and I honestly think they have to pick babies to send home to stay within the ratios and then hope they stay off the next day.

I’ll add that DS has been genuinely unwell with things on occasion and of course we’ve kept him off. But we are at our absolute limit now and have pissed hundreds up the wall on unnecessary pick ups and days off.

Think I have found an alternative setting and are looking on Monday, but they have no availability until January.

OP posts:
ThatsGoingToHurt · 05/11/2022 18:07

I have the same problem with DS. DS goes to nursery W-F. At one stage I was receiving calls every Wednesday afternoon as he had a diahorrea nappy (just one) but no temp, eaten all his lunch, was playing happily and running round the garden. This would then result in an exclusion until 48 hours later meaning it wiped out the whole week. After picking DS up multiple times only to find out that DS was fine and no more diahorrea nappies for the rest of the week. I eventually had to take him to the GP who confirmed it was toddler diahorrea (meaning that he wasn’t ill or infectious). They accepted this and strangely enough the yucky nappies have stopped on a Wednesday as well.

mincen · 05/11/2022 18:05

If nurseries are making so much money, why are so many having to close down? So many are making a loss/ making no money at all. Especially smaller settings and independents. It really doesn't help that the government don't pay enough in funding for the 'funded' spaces- yet parents are led to believe that childcare will be 'free' in those situations.

There's lots of expenditure involved- not just staffing, utilities, rent etc. You should see how many boxes of tissues we go through for a start!

smilingontheinside · 05/11/2022 18:04

Find yourself a good reliable childminder worth their weight in gold

LongLostTeacher · 05/11/2022 18:01

My daughter’s nursery has had on and off staffing issues since covid but to their credit, they are upfront about it and just straight up ask parents who can do so to keep their children at home for the day. Then it feels like the nursery community pulls together so the children of those parents who need to work can be cared for. This has only happened two or three times.

Gemcat1 · 05/11/2022 17:57

@BusyAllWeek The office for national statistics can say that but it means that there are a lot of people earning a lot less than £38,000.

mamshan · 05/11/2022 17:55

We had a similar "phantom diarrhea" situation at our nursery school - our LO had to leave kindergarten twice for diarrhea which never repeated itself at home. We kept him home for the required 48 hours each time, but we found the solution the second time - I called the head caretaker and told her that there was no hint of diarrhea when LO was at home, and asked in a very concerned voice whether there mightn't be something at the nursery that was causing LO to get sick and whether we might need to check out conditions there. Never got another call to take him home for diarrhea after that...

Gemcat1 · 05/11/2022 17:47

I would talk to Ofsted and tell the nursery that that is what you are going to do. I would also talk to the local authority who licences them as well as making a formal complaint through their procedures. If they were short of staff then they could hire temporary help but that would cost money. I think that you and your DS deserve better,

Dveos · 05/11/2022 17:41

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 17:11

I’m not saying governments should just pick up the tab indiscriminately. But ultimately, it does cost more than 1100 a month to provide this service properly - so the UK risks seeing more and more parents just stay home as they realise that economically it makes no sense to work after having children. And when women exit the workforce it has an economic impact and that is a problem government has a responsibility to help address.
In France and most European countries governments provide subsidies or rebates - that is why more women are able to work.
but this seems to be a country run without any regard for the longterm wellbeing of its people - very short termist politicians and for reasons beyond my comprehension a lot less driven to support families.

I’ve just demonstrated that it doesn’t cost more than £1100pm to provide the service and this is also supported by the fact that the OP is paying £1100pm currently.

Happy to be proven otherwise with facts and figures 😊

Dveos · 05/11/2022 17:38

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 17:15

office for national statistics says average uk wage is 38k - but since that can be influenced by some outliers at the top (eg London wages), better to take median wage as a comparator.
Median wage is about 33k in 2022.
🤷‍♀️ Probably a lot higher in London.

Not sure where you’re getting data from but directly from ONS website average uk wage is £617 per week which is £33k a year.

www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/averageweeklyearningsingreatbritain/october2022

Aside from that I challenge you to find a full time permanent childcare role that isn’t classed as a senior position paying more than £25k outside of London. In my area (Essex) roles pay anything between Minimum wage - £23k. So feel I’ve been quite generous.

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 17:15

office for national statistics says average uk wage is 38k - but since that can be influenced by some outliers at the top (eg London wages), better to take median wage as a comparator.
Median wage is about 33k in 2022.
🤷‍♀️ Probably a lot higher in London.

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 17:11

I’m not saying governments should just pick up the tab indiscriminately. But ultimately, it does cost more than 1100 a month to provide this service properly - so the UK risks seeing more and more parents just stay home as they realise that economically it makes no sense to work after having children. And when women exit the workforce it has an economic impact and that is a problem government has a responsibility to help address.
In France and most European countries governments provide subsidies or rebates - that is why more women are able to work.
but this seems to be a country run without any regard for the longterm wellbeing of its people - very short termist politicians and for reasons beyond my comprehension a lot less driven to support families.

alwaysfrazzled · 05/11/2022 15:56

Christ this is what I dread. My partner works away from home and I'm sending my daughter to nursery three days from March whilst I go back to work.
I'm in a job that makes it difficult to just drop what I'm doing. I also have no family help that can go and get her if anything was to happen.
My boss is not the most empathetic of people either. Honestly dread this.
I would be seriously pissed off if I were in your shoes. Kids will be kids, all sorts of bumps and scrapes, drippy noses etc.
The staff shortages shouldn't be your problem, you are paying out your arse to be treated like this!
The system is all wrong. Childcare workers should be paid more, parents should be charged less and employees need more support/lenience for when things like this happen.

Kanaloa · 05/11/2022 15:48

Winterfires · 05/11/2022 10:52

Read the actual circumstance or stop quoting/tagging me 🤫

I did read the circumstance. Regardless of whether she gave it to him or if she had other children there, childcare practitioners don’t exist to care for your sick child.

Changerofthename1 · 05/11/2022 15:07

Having previously managed and then later owned a childcare setting I can absolutely assure you that after corporation tax if I was left with 40 grand a year profit I would give up and go and manage a childcare setting instead of owning one.

it used to be profitable it absolutely is not now, especially if you’re not A “see you next Tuesday” and actually want to feed the children nutritious food that you would feed your own.

I’ve worked for big chains where I’ve been told baked beans, mash potatoes with cheese covers all the food groups and was an acceptable lunch this was at a place where we were charging the parents $120 a day.

Dveos · 05/11/2022 14:49

TrippinEdBalls · 05/11/2022 13:31

Lets just say a childcare worker is on £25k per year that leaves approx another £25k per year for share towards rent, bills, etc.

Tell me you've never employed someone or been involved in payroll or budgets without telling me you've never employed someone or been involved in payroll or budgets.

Considering I employ 10 people and broke down the budget / expenditure above clearly demonstrates there’s logic behind the initial statement which is still valid. 🙄

Dveos · 05/11/2022 14:48

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 13:12

You haven’t included National Insurance which is 16 percent of gross salary - also, I’m not sure why you assume a nursery worker would be on 25k when the average UK wage is 33k these days.
Yes some of the nursery workers may be in their first year at work but surely you need a good mix of experienced and less experienced people looking after very small children.
I just don’t understand people who expect childcare professionals to be earning literally 25% less than average wage, yet somehow doing a stellar job bringing up other people’s children, and also having solid common sense, pragmatism, and putting parents’ interests and jobs first when they are overstretched… there is no free lunch, you really get what you pay for and sadly, paying childcare professionals 25k on average will just generate an exodus of anyone with any common sense and ambition from that sector. In my view, this is one of the main reasons why OP is having the experience she has…

National insurance is covered by small business relief so isn’t really an actual cost until you exceed the relief amount.

Average UK wage is £33k in London but not across the UK… if was average wage for a childcare worker then think I’m in the wrong industry..

Also I’m not arguing that the role doesn’t come with its trials and tribulations as like any other position , merely demonstrating on the original statement of there needs to be help from the government to cover costs is false if the business is managed correctly is self sustaining.

In response to your reply on utilities, even if we do match your quoted figures were only talking an extra £400 per annum.

TrippinEdBalls · 05/11/2022 13:31

Lets just say a childcare worker is on £25k per year that leaves approx another £25k per year for share towards rent, bills, etc.

Tell me you've never employed someone or been involved in payroll or budgets without telling me you've never employed someone or been involved in payroll or budgets.

WhiteFire · 05/11/2022 13:29

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 13:12

You haven’t included National Insurance which is 16 percent of gross salary - also, I’m not sure why you assume a nursery worker would be on 25k when the average UK wage is 33k these days.
Yes some of the nursery workers may be in their first year at work but surely you need a good mix of experienced and less experienced people looking after very small children.
I just don’t understand people who expect childcare professionals to be earning literally 25% less than average wage, yet somehow doing a stellar job bringing up other people’s children, and also having solid common sense, pragmatism, and putting parents’ interests and jobs first when they are overstretched… there is no free lunch, you really get what you pay for and sadly, paying childcare professionals 25k on average will just generate an exodus of anyone with any common sense and ambition from that sector. In my view, this is one of the main reasons why OP is having the experience she has…

Yes the average wage may be 33k but lots of people will earn less, even nurses etc won't be on that kind of wage for quite a few years.

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 13:17

Also why would it be 480 on utilities per worker, when the media meeps telling us an average family’s energy bill will now exceed 4k.
Surely with water, energy, internet, phone lines a nursery is looking at over 4k in utilities per annum.
This is just bad maths - clearly it’s not as easy as you’d like to make out.
and by the way, none of the nurseries I’ve ever sent my children to charged for food on top. It’s usually included in the fees…

BusyAllWeek · 05/11/2022 13:12

You haven’t included National Insurance which is 16 percent of gross salary - also, I’m not sure why you assume a nursery worker would be on 25k when the average UK wage is 33k these days.
Yes some of the nursery workers may be in their first year at work but surely you need a good mix of experienced and less experienced people looking after very small children.
I just don’t understand people who expect childcare professionals to be earning literally 25% less than average wage, yet somehow doing a stellar job bringing up other people’s children, and also having solid common sense, pragmatism, and putting parents’ interests and jobs first when they are overstretched… there is no free lunch, you really get what you pay for and sadly, paying childcare professionals 25k on average will just generate an exodus of anyone with any common sense and ambition from that sector. In my view, this is one of the main reasons why OP is having the experience she has…

Dveos · 05/11/2022 12:37

Changerofthename1 · 05/11/2022 12:09

£25,000 profit 🤣 to cover, pension, holiday, sickness, NI, corporation tax, before we even get to building maintenance, resources, food, heating, water etc.

Didn’t say profit though did I? “Unallocated funds” for other business expenses that you listed (which most are the same for every business)..

Pension is 3% - so £750 per annum

Holidays / sickness 25-30 days a year - approx. £2.5k - £3k per year for cover

Rent (dependent on area obviously) - say £3k per annum / 14.4k per year split across 5 workers

Utilities - £480 per annum per worker

Building maintenance - would be covered by the rent etc. but let’s say £500 per annum per worker.

Food - £3000 per annum for 3 children - although I’m sure this would be an added extra charged to the parent(s) 😉

which still leaves over £14k for further expenses not noted, but let’s just call it a nice even £10k per annum per worker.

Leaving a grand total of £50k per annum profit which would then see corporation tax applied (as it’s profit).

obviously you’re not going to become a millionaire with 5 workers but as we’ve proven it’s easily feasible…

Changerofthename1 · 05/11/2022 12:09

Dveos · 05/11/2022 12:00

Does it though?

3300 per month for 3 children over 4 days on a 5 day working week is £49,500 per year?

Lets just say a childcare worker is on £25k per year that leaves approx another £25k per year for share towards rent, bills, etc.

Multiply by 5 workers / 15 children per year (as a minimum) you’re talking c£125k to allocate towards rent / bills / materials etc.

Not sure how this isn’t seen to be easily feasible and why the government 😴 should get involved?

It’s a private business at the end of the day.

£25,000 profit 🤣 to cover, pension, holiday, sickness, NI, corporation tax, before we even get to building maintenance, resources, food, heating, water etc.

Dveos · 05/11/2022 12:00

BusyAllWeek · 04/11/2022 12:43

This really highlights how difficult it is for nurseries to make ends meet.
they need a 1:3 ratio for children under 2. But if they get 1100 pounds per child per month, this means that the fees for 3 children (3300 per month) needs to cover

  • salary of 1 staff member
  • Share of rent, utilities, insurance
  • Share of toys, equipment, materials
  • Share of any management & admin overhead (systems, payroll, etc)
can’t be easy to pay a decent wage! government not parents should be fixing this though.

Does it though?

3300 per month for 3 children over 4 days on a 5 day working week is £49,500 per year?

Lets just say a childcare worker is on £25k per year that leaves approx another £25k per year for share towards rent, bills, etc.

Multiply by 5 workers / 15 children per year (as a minimum) you’re talking c£125k to allocate towards rent / bills / materials etc.

Not sure how this isn’t seen to be easily feasible and why the government 😴 should get involved?

It’s a private business at the end of the day.

HotCoffee22 · 05/11/2022 11:40

Skinnermarink · 04/11/2022 18:57

Definitely making the financial decision to stick at one- couldn’t manage this with two practically or financially sadly. Plus we are on our late thirties (not saying that’s a massive barrier, just that we’d have to crack on and have two needing full time childcare like @Xenia said

Having a second is what’s unstuck me. Not only the financial aspect but the fact that every incidence of illness is x2 as the other picks it up straight after, then I get it. So it feels like continuous disturbances to my ability to
work-the latest bout has been 3 weeks with one or the other at home with me.

maryberryslayers · 05/11/2022 11:17

Ours text the other day asking for parents to keep their kids off if possible due to staff sickness leave and said they'd either s swap days or refund if you took them up.