Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need advice on this possibly terrible/weak parenting decision of mine.

488 replies

KidsArt · 04/11/2022 10:14

Really want brutal opinions pls.

DS1 is 3 years old. He can be pretty challenging, in his own world, never listens, doesn't want to play with others, and his nursery have talked about ASD.

DH doesn't work on Fridays. He takes DS1 and DS2 (18 months) swimming. They all love it.

I work from home on Fridays.

DH just couldn't get DS1 ready. He wasn't listening. Refusing to get dressed. Playing with his trains. Running away from DH. this went on for 20 mins

DH left without him. Took DS2 and just walked out. He did give DS1 warning that he would leave unless he got dressed.

DS1 lost his mind. I mean, sobbing, wailing, throwing himself at the door. "I want my daddy. Where is daddy? I want to go swimming. Why not me? Please please. Where is Daddy. I'm sorry I'm sorry"

I don't think I've ever seen him that upset. He was shaking. He got all his clothes and was trying to put his own pants on, falling over, crying, collecting his towel, trying to get out the front door, looking for the car out the window.

I made DH come back and get him.

DH thinks this the reason DS1 is the way he is. That he needed to suck it up.

Is he right?

OP posts:
EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 06/11/2022 12:02

There's no easy or one way fits all in these situations.

I remember at 3 walking to school as a different animal every day for about a year as it was the only thing that would get ds out the house 😔

He didn't get his own way , you kept calm moving him would have caused a bigger meltdown and woken his brother. Unfortunately when dealing with a small child who probably has asd you spend lots of time dealing with situations like this

With the pda I learnt not to ask directly that he do something, so for example I'd say I wonder where ds shoes are? I wonder if we can find them? Or who's shoes are these? They don't fit on my feet , while trying to put them on and hoping he'd have a go next!

Read up on pda , you might find some things that work for you and ds

From a mother of a child who has asd
And a grandmother of a child with asd because us grandmother's know it all obviously 🙄

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 06/11/2022 12:00

This made me feel really sad for your DS. He is still only little. I would have made DH come home too

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 11:44

BiasedBinding · 06/11/2022 11:28

Why, are you worried it had a long term negative impact on your own children? It probably didn’t. It did on my husband, we go by the experience we have.

What impact did it have on him?

Blueink · 06/11/2022 11:41

Your 2nd example is a bit different. He got something in his head, logic along with determination of a 3 year old. Perhaps he didn’t want to leave his brother out, who knows. You have been given some good advice, like distraction or simple A/B choice that doesn’t involve a stand off between the two of you. All children are different so we can only parent the one(s) we’ve got, it seems like you have a good instinct but need to build up your own confidence (which the parenting course might help). It is challenging when the other parent has different ideas as well, but sign of partnership in your OP, although your DH complained, he did listen as come back for DS.

BiasedBinding · 06/11/2022 11:28

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 11:24

What impact did it have on him?

His parent was probably locking him alone for long periods of time.

I'm talking about staying in the same room. Time out maximum of 3 minutes.

Why, are you worried it had a long term negative impact on your own children? It probably didn’t. It did on my husband, we go by the experience we have.

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 11:26

Does is he better at listening to his father?

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 11:24

BiasedBinding · 06/11/2022 11:00

I wouldn’t do it with my NT child, having seen the impact on my NT husband

What impact did it have on him?

His parent was probably locking him alone for long periods of time.

I'm talking about staying in the same room. Time out maximum of 3 minutes.

BiasedBinding · 06/11/2022 11:20

Never too early Grin

to a crying newborn “it’s not all about you, you know” Grin

Barbie222 · 06/11/2022 11:15

I can see how it comes across as harsh but sometimes natural consequences can't be dialled down, and some children only make the connection when it impacts them this much. I can see how it would have been a pain for you to work through it but Id have supported the decision and seen how things panned out next week when it's time to get ready for swimming again.

I do think it's never too early for children to learn to decentre themselves.

GloomyDarkness · 06/11/2022 11:11

PP mention parenting course to you - I'd really suggest find some and you go on some.

I kept saying "DS1 let's go downstairs and have breakfast" but he was getting more and more irrate.

Why- if it's not working why keep saying anything it ends up as background noise and contributes to you being ignored.

Be short ie short and very clear words - ie stop- and clear and firm - no (that doesn't mean shouting but there is a authoritative tone to strive for)- and if that doesn't work move on to next technique distraction - lets gets some food - or can you beat me down the stairs - make a fun game - try something else and try and head off meltdowns.

Your posts give impression of being verbose - using more complex language than necessary to a small child - and perhaps being tentative wanting to explain and cajole rather than issue clear firm instructions.

I think you clearly have a harder to parent than average child - the nursery clearly have concerns - and PP mentioned hunger being a trigger and DS had that in droves - you may well need to look for triggers and avoid.

Once DD1 got worked up - and there did seem to be difference between tantrums not getting her own way and meltdowns when all we could do was leave her somewhere safe and quite - and let her calm down - anything else prolonged it something MIL drove us mad by ignoring - she'd hover and make it all worse.

There are SEN boards on here - full of parents with their own hard won experiences - may well be worth posting there for better tips than may work with your child.

Blueink · 06/11/2022 11:00

I didn’t/don’t give in to tantrums, ‘no means no’, but actually think you were right here. I had something similar happen to me when I was a young child and it was traumatising. Abandonment shouldn’t be used as a punishment. You were right to pick up on this being distress not a tantrum. The fact your husband came back for him will make him more secure.

BiasedBinding · 06/11/2022 11:00

Rainbowandbirdhouse · 06/11/2022 10:55

I'm sorry to say @emptythelitterbox, but your approach would simply not have worked with my child with ASD. At all. We did try because the grandparents here also told us we were doing things all wrong. It made things so much worse.
Their criticism really hurt and didn't help, quite the opposite. Flexibility was key with our DC, and professional guidance confirmed that.

I wouldn’t do it with my NT child, having seen the impact on my NT husband

Rainbowandbirdhouse · 06/11/2022 10:55

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 09:23

Yes, you are being too wet.
You're teaching him that tantrums and violence he gets his own way.
He gets zero consequences from behaving like that as you give in every time.

He needs consequences every single time. It will be hard at first as you've let it go on far too long.

You don't have to shout or yell. Just pick him up and put him back in his room.
He doesn't get to sit their and pester his brother and do whatever.

Back in his room. He trashes the room, take everything out but his bed.

Do you actually say No hitting in a firm voice?
Every time he hits or kicks repeat no hitting and he get's time out.

He's 3 so 3 minutes max time out. If he sits quietly or calms down quickly you can end the time out earlier. But remember only 1 minute per year. Not too long.

No eye contact or talking. If he continues to tantrum and refuses time out then take away favorite toy, screen time, whatever is meaningful.

It'l be a rough week but he'll understand the rules and things will go much better.

Then we he has calmed down you can give hug and gently say we don't hit or kick people cause it hurts and then let it go.

You'll get to the point of giving one warning and most of the time a time out won't be needed.

Good luck.
from a Grandma

I'm sorry to say @emptythelitterbox, but your approach would simply not have worked with my child with ASD. At all. We did try because the grandparents here also told us we were doing things all wrong. It made things so much worse.
Their criticism really hurt and didn't help, quite the opposite. Flexibility was key with our DC, and professional guidance confirmed that.

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 10:54

Looks like you’re on totally different pages. To me it seems like he is “rules and boundaries at ANY cost”, and you’re “anything for an easier life”. You both need to meet somewhere in the middle. Would you do a parenting course together?

KidsArt · 06/11/2022 10:49

@WanderingSouls Yeah - he is loving towards the kids, but in tough moments isn't v helpful. Also, we are both a bit extreme - i spend ages reading thing online, posting on MN, talking to the GP - whether he doesn't do any of that but is much more "you just need good, strong, parenting with boundaries - i don't need to read anything or listen to some expert to know that" - but in the moment - it's lots of 'for god's sake' and walking out the room or the house!

OP posts:
Suleika · 06/11/2022 10:27

Just to add - and sorry if this has been said before and I missed it...once an ASD child has gone into tantrum/meltdown mode it is virtually impossible to get through to them and reason with them - they are incapable of "receiving". Hence all the advice for trying to avoid this situation. I remember a health professional coming to visit me at home about my DS when he was about 4: he came up to me and said he wanted something to eat. Before I could reply, dear professional said "not now, mummy's talking". I groaned inwardly, and 45 minutes later he was still screaming, incapable of listening ...I do like the advice about talking about the importance of sleep etc when your DS is calm; and the advice about breaking things into small steps, eg choose your tea shirt, now choose your shorts...etc. Which reminded me - has anyone mentioned looking up and using Social Stories - these can be really useful for getting messages across in a non confrontational, non head-on way when things are calm?

BiasedBinding · 06/11/2022 10:20

Yeah my husband was shut in his room with nothing but his bed as a punishment for 3yo behaviour just like emptythelitterbox suggests.

the longer term impact on him means that we won’t be taking that advice.

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 10:17

It’s difficult isn’t it. Your approach worked today, but on a typical day(work, nursery etc) do you have 30 mins to cajole him? I really don’t know the answer, op. I think both you and your husband have had a hard time on here in different ways. Sounds hard. Wish you the best.

WonkasBooboofixer · 06/11/2022 10:16

Ffs he is 3 years old of course he isn't going to be ready on the dot he's got no concept of time he's easily distracted because he's 3

WanderingSouls · 06/11/2022 09:52

@KidsArt I think some people maybe extrapolate a bit too much from what would have worked with their own kids, in fact maybe we all do. But as you’ve seen, what works with one child won’t work with another. It sounds like you’re doing a very good job in difficult circumstances. Your partner doesn’t sound terribly helpful, don’t know if that’s unfair.

LittleMy77 · 06/11/2022 09:49

At that age with a likely ND kid, we had the same issues. We used a lot of simple instructions using the words now and then, and presenting a choice (which wasn’t really a choice)

it was key for us not to have too many instructions with too many steps, or trying to over explain stuff

so in the case with waking up his brother, it’d be something like

‘now we’re going to walk down stairs, and then find the cereal / have breakfast etc’

or

‘when we go downstairs do you want cereal or toast for breakfast?’

it seemed to help shift the rigid stuck in the circle behaviour (getting dressed and ready was a huge issue for us) i empathise with you and your dh’s response as we had similar, I used to rage at dh for not being able to see past the ‘you’re spoiling him / letting him get away with it’ etc

KidsArt · 06/11/2022 09:47

That's pretty fair @WanderingSouls I know no one has the answer. That's why I find it baffling when people say "you can't let him act that way" I'm just confused as it makes it sound like I just need to do this or that and it would be fixed. But you're right I've got to work out what feels right for us and just keep going.

DS2 is only 18 months but honestly it's like chalk and cheese. If I ask him to go get his shoes or stop doing something...he just does it...DS2 seems keen to do the right thing and if i do need to talk sternly he reacts. Whereas DS1 couldn't really care less about my tone my voice. The only thing he hates is being left. If you walk out the room or put him alone he go absolutely mad, like beyond upset but words do nothing.

OP posts:
Katemax82 · 06/11/2022 09:45

Hun I feel your pain. I have an autistic 16 year old and a 4 year old who is so special needs it's really hard to deal with but the assessment hasn't been done. The battles are really hard, but worse is the husband thinking he knows it all and saying stuff like "be in control of him" and other crap like that. At the end of the day you can't just make a SEN child behave how you want, it's always really hard so don't feel like your doing anything wrong by being loving to your son rather than really strict. Hopefully a diagnosis will make things easier to understand but it's always hard. My 16 year old was a nightmare as a 3 and 4 year old. He smashed me in the forehead with a rock once because his dad entered a code into a gate we were using but my son had wanted to do it. Stay strong

ladycarlotta · 06/11/2022 09:42

KidsArt · 06/11/2022 09:37

Thank you @emptythelitterbox But I didn't give in? He didn't get to wake up his little brother. He did go downstairs and have his breakfast. I just didn't physically force him downstairs. Is that giving in?

no it is not! You got the exact outcome you wanted, while still acknowledging your child's thought process. I think that's nailing it to be honest. Please don't let anyone shame you for being patient and attentive with a ND 3yo who is overwhelmed.

ladycarlotta · 06/11/2022 09:39

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 09:23

Yes, you are being too wet.
You're teaching him that tantrums and violence he gets his own way.
He gets zero consequences from behaving like that as you give in every time.

He needs consequences every single time. It will be hard at first as you've let it go on far too long.

You don't have to shout or yell. Just pick him up and put him back in his room.
He doesn't get to sit their and pester his brother and do whatever.

Back in his room. He trashes the room, take everything out but his bed.

Do you actually say No hitting in a firm voice?
Every time he hits or kicks repeat no hitting and he get's time out.

He's 3 so 3 minutes max time out. If he sits quietly or calms down quickly you can end the time out earlier. But remember only 1 minute per year. Not too long.

No eye contact or talking. If he continues to tantrum and refuses time out then take away favorite toy, screen time, whatever is meaningful.

It'l be a rough week but he'll understand the rules and things will go much better.

Then we he has calmed down you can give hug and gently say we don't hit or kick people cause it hurts and then let it go.

You'll get to the point of giving one warning and most of the time a time out won't be needed.

Good luck.
from a Grandma

do you know that there is a difference between tantrums and violence, and meltdown and overwhelm? This child's suspected ASD is a huge contributing factor regarding how he should be treated, as others in this thread with far more knowledge have also pointed out. However, a lot of children this age become explosively overwhelmed and frustrated, and it is not manipulative! They are learning how to self regulate and they won't do that healthily if the only response they ever get is being punished and rejected for expressing their feelings. I really can't stand this school of parenting that regards a small child's inability to control themselves as purposeful, malicious disruptiveness.

Yes, children need to learn appropriate ways to express themselves. They need to learn that not everything is about them, eg baby brother is still sleeping, and his rest is more important than the older brother's desire for him to wake up. But there is nothing wrong with a parent responding as OP did, by recognising their child's feelings and trying to talk about it and find a non-disruptive solution. I respect a parent who puts that sort of time in. It's not rewarding a tantrum, it's actually bothering to see the child as a whole human being.