Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need advice on this possibly terrible/weak parenting decision of mine.

488 replies

KidsArt · 04/11/2022 10:14

Really want brutal opinions pls.

DS1 is 3 years old. He can be pretty challenging, in his own world, never listens, doesn't want to play with others, and his nursery have talked about ASD.

DH doesn't work on Fridays. He takes DS1 and DS2 (18 months) swimming. They all love it.

I work from home on Fridays.

DH just couldn't get DS1 ready. He wasn't listening. Refusing to get dressed. Playing with his trains. Running away from DH. this went on for 20 mins

DH left without him. Took DS2 and just walked out. He did give DS1 warning that he would leave unless he got dressed.

DS1 lost his mind. I mean, sobbing, wailing, throwing himself at the door. "I want my daddy. Where is daddy? I want to go swimming. Why not me? Please please. Where is Daddy. I'm sorry I'm sorry"

I don't think I've ever seen him that upset. He was shaking. He got all his clothes and was trying to put his own pants on, falling over, crying, collecting his towel, trying to get out the front door, looking for the car out the window.

I made DH come back and get him.

DH thinks this the reason DS1 is the way he is. That he needed to suck it up.

Is he right?

OP posts:
viques · 04/11/2022 12:26

3 is a tricky age, at just three they are still toddlers , martyrs to their emotions, but when they are nearly 4 they should be starting to understand about consequences.

zurala · 04/11/2022 12:25

Also OP, join the Facebook group Gentle parenting for autistic children UK, you'll get some great help and support there.

TheodoreMortlock · 04/11/2022 12:24

He's three AND he's (suspected) autistic. He is not developmentally going to be able to work out how much time he has to play, how long it will take to get dressed, or what the consequences will be of not getting dressed.

Plus getting dressed is a sensory nightmare - PJs off, new clothes on, new clothes are colder, might feel tight or scratchy.

I think you did the right thing on this occasion. It doesn't sound as though he was given very much advance warning that he was at risk of missing swimming - however obvious it might seem to NT adults, it's not obvious to an ASD three year old. He was "told" - did he process this information? His reaction suggests he didn't.

My child is 8 and still finds it very hard to get dressed and to understand how time works. She just seems oblivious to the concept that time will move forward whether she is participating or not - it's almost as though she thinks she can pause the 'getting dressed' stream while doing the 'staring out of the window' stream or 'lining up socks' stream.

We try to avoid having toys in the bedroom, we have a visual print out of what 'dressed' looks like, and these days she will passively let me dress her which is a huge bonus because at 3 she was the same as your DS.

Can I ask, is there any reason he can't go to the pool in his PJs, if your DH packs his clothes to change into after swimming? Cut out the whole difficult transition.

Also, please don't assume that his smile at getting to go swimming indicates he's manipulating the situation. He was happy, he smiled, he doesn't have the social awareness to know that the proper NT response is to pretend to be abashed and keep a low profile for an unspecified amount of time.

ShutYerYapAndGetOnWithIt · 04/11/2022 12:23

emptythelitterbox · 04/11/2022 10:34

He is right. Your DS needs consequences.

Amazing when his dad left, he knew exactly what he should have been doing and did it quickly.

Next time. See how fast he gets his things and gets ready. He won't be faffing about.

That's right. The boy did what had been asked of him. Perhaps he'll get ready without a song and dance next time.

zurala · 04/11/2022 12:23

I haven't read the thread. I'm autistic with autistic children and reading what your DH did has made me feel sick. You can't treat autistic children the way you would allistics. OP you were right, your DH was borderline abusive. He needs to learn how to deal with autistic children. Did they inherit it from him? He has need strategies to help him parent well, it's definitely more challenging as an autistic parent.

Rainbowandbirdhouse · 04/11/2022 12:23

I think a lot of people are forgetting that OP was working! DH shouldn't have left her trying to manage a distressed child. It was his turn for childcare.

Rhythmisadancer · 04/11/2022 12:21

Poor thing, he's only 3. I'm sure nearly being left behind was enough of a consequence. Remember the last time you didn't get ready, you nearly got left behind! And he will remember how horrid that was.
I hope he's having a lovely time at the swimming pool :)

DuvetHugger · 04/11/2022 12:20

OP I'd have done the same. I couldn't have watched him be so upset. Just do your best, we are all just doing our best

InsertPunHere · 04/11/2022 12:20

I couldn't have left a little 3 year old out of swimming to prove a point

It’s not proving a point, it’s demonstrating what happens as a consequence. If you don’t get ready for swimming in time, you don’t go swimming. Those people who did get ready in time will go swimming without you.

OP, I think you and DH need a good long talk about handling expectations and managing DS1’s behaviour in a united way. Today was difficult, sure, but put it behind you and agree an approach you can both accept. You’re on the same side and it’s so much better when you know the other parent will back you up.

Justcallmebebes · 04/11/2022 12:17

My daughter has to do this with her DD who can be extremely challenging. It's heartbreaking to watch but such a valuable lesson if implemented after fair warning. DGD is 7 now and getting better and following instructions as she's learnt she has to bear the consequences if she doesn't.

Awful when they're tiny but it will pay off

user1471538283 · 04/11/2022 12:12

He is only 3. I think he had consequences enough.

Next swimming morning I would explain to him that he needs to be ready to go otherwise Daddy would have to go without him and he was so upset last time. Maybe start the process of getting ready the night before by packing his little bag, laying out his clothes with him so he knows the plan.

I couldn't have left a little 3 year old out of swimming to prove a point.

ItsaMetalBand · 04/11/2022 12:12

The idea behind the punishment was solid but what fucks it up is that your DH sounded rather disorganised and he did it out of anger/frustration rather than as a teaching moment. And that's not great. No judgement there - see my fail below.

He was right to threaten to leave DS at home and right to follow through.
However you were also right to call him back when you realised that the effect of the punishment caused that amount of distress. I'm sure it was a massive shock to him but lots of cuddles and no more telling off about it will go a long ways towards making you all feel better. As will planning better.

See what it's like next week - but also have swim stuff packed from the night before, have clothes laid out from the night before as well, and do LOTS of countdowns - "after breakfast we all need to get dressed and get our shoes on" LOTS of reminders, and give himself ample time. And then LOTS of praise when they are all in the car on time setting off.

I had an issue where 3yo DS would run off in public. I tried everything, right down to my worst parenting fail where I smacked the back of his leg. I always swore I'd never smack but I reflected that I did it because I was frustrated and it wasn't coming from a genuine place of teaching different behaviour. Spoke to a very wise colleague who's kids were reared for advice and on the back of that I did a dummy run to the supermarket a day I didn't need anything. On the way I explained expected behaviour - hold mummys hand, hold the basket, no running off. I explained that if we did all that and he didn't run off, he would be allowed a muffin as reward. If he ran off, we would get in the car and go home, no muffin.

Naturally, he shot off as soon as we got into Tesco. Caught him and gave warning 1. Did it again, so lifted him and got as far as the car with him protesting he would behave. So chance 2, got in and he was good for about 5 mins then shot off again, so it was back to the car, and back home, no muffin. He was balling his eyes out. After that it only took a stern "do we need to go back to the car?" for him to not run off.

However, I planned it out for a trip we didn't need to do - in the heat of the moment like your DH, needing to get somewhere by a certain time I don't know if I could have done any better than him.

Kanaloa · 04/11/2022 12:09

But when DS1 climbed into the car, and DH looked pissed off, and DS2 started to cry and DS1 was smiling from ear to ear - I did think, am I letting DS1 just dominate everything?? - that's not good for him. He already struggles with not doing what he's told at pre-school and thinking he can do what he wants.

I mean this is also not surprising - of course he thinks he can just do what he wants… because he can. He behaves however he likes, and as long as he screams and causes a fuss if he dislikes the consequence, they will immediately be called back for him. At which point he’ll be ‘smiling ear to ear’ because now he’s learned that there are no consequences to his behaviour.

Kanaloa · 04/11/2022 12:06

emptythelitterbox · 04/11/2022 10:34

He is right. Your DS needs consequences.

Amazing when his dad left, he knew exactly what he should have been doing and did it quickly.

Next time. See how fast he gets his things and gets ready. He won't be faffing about.

I was just going to say this. If the child had still just been running round playing I would have said it was cruel as clearly the child doesn’t have the comprehension to understand why they’ve been left.

But your child instantly ran to do as he’d been asked, which he’d been refusing to do, as soon as he wasn’t allowed to go for an activity he enjoyed. If I was you I’d have said ‘you didn’t want to get ready when asked, so you didn’t go swimming.’

sunshineandsuddenshowers · 04/11/2022 12:04

I would have done the same thing as you. He was distraught. He's too young/immature/maybe SEN to understand that what he was doing would have such dire consequences. I don't think that parents should rule their kids w pain!

I also don't think it would have been a disaster if DH HAD gone on and left DS1. I hear what another poster said about control - this is definitely a thing as kids get older, but it really doesn't sound like it here.

Not such a fan of consistency as some others here - I think you can be responsive and change things.

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 12:02

KidsArt · 04/11/2022 11:59

Yeah - I think the upset from DS1 was far more about DS2 and DH going somewhere without him, rather than missing swimming.

In between sobs, he was saying things like "DS2 and daddy gone. DS1 want to go to too" and "bye bye mummy, me go now with daddy and ds2" and trying to get out the front door - it was the feeling that they had left him. And that his brother was taken in a way of 'Fine, we will go have a nice time without you'

I do understand people saying these are natural consequences but to me - it seemed too harsh. Too raw. An 11 year old would be upset but know they were coming back, know they could probably go next week. DS1 seemed completely and utterly panicked.

But when DS1 climbed into the car, and DH looked pissed off, and DS2 started to cry and DS1 was smiling from ear to ear - I did think, am I letting DS1 just dominate everything?? - that's not good for him. He already struggles with not doing what he's told at pre-school and thinking he can do what he wants.

I am really conflicted. I wish I felt as sure about my parenting decisions as some of you guys.

Sometimes natural consequences are harsh

harsher than most traditional ‘punishments’ in fact.

but they work incredibly well, especially in ND children - hence why they’re recommended. Children from trauma backgrounds also benefit from them (so much so most local authorities require adoptive parents to be trained in therapeutic parenting which is very natural and logical consequences based)

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 04/11/2022 12:01

My ds who has asd was similar at that age , he was pretty demand avoident as well.

I wouldn't have left him to get in that state and wouldn't have learnt anything from it .

He's 9 now and understands natural consequences but at 3 he wouldn't have learnt anything from being left , it would possibly have caused more anxiety though . Transitioning can be tough at that age anyway without adding asd into the mix

ParsleySageRosemary · 04/11/2022 12:01

ofwarren · 04/11/2022 10:19

I'd have done the same as you with my ASD child.
They don't always understand the transitions, especially at 3 years old.
Can you create a little social story to show him what has to happen to go swimming?

Just emphasising this, as it’s a good idea. I work with ASC kids. They are a mixed bundle, but they often struggle with things like:
cause and effect
time sequences
one thing happening after another

Do make a social story, and make a list of what has to happen for him to go. In older years we make visual timetables of what is happening next. He is young but if you can put the effort in of making pictures to show the sequence of what has to happen and pull the pictures off one at a time as they are completed it may help.

I think the shock you describe of not going was consequence enough on this occasion.

Icecreamandapplepie · 04/11/2022 12:01

I think you were right.

He's 3 for crying out loud. The shock of nearly being left behind will be enough.

ProFannyTea · 04/11/2022 11:59

Oddly your son mysteriously developed the ability to listen and behave once he thought he was about to miss out on a treat he enjoys. I wonder if your DH returning may have an adverse effect though and he may play up even more now because he knows they will come back.

KidsArt · 04/11/2022 11:59

Yeah - I think the upset from DS1 was far more about DS2 and DH going somewhere without him, rather than missing swimming.

In between sobs, he was saying things like "DS2 and daddy gone. DS1 want to go to too" and "bye bye mummy, me go now with daddy and ds2" and trying to get out the front door - it was the feeling that they had left him. And that his brother was taken in a way of 'Fine, we will go have a nice time without you'

I do understand people saying these are natural consequences but to me - it seemed too harsh. Too raw. An 11 year old would be upset but know they were coming back, know they could probably go next week. DS1 seemed completely and utterly panicked.

But when DS1 climbed into the car, and DH looked pissed off, and DS2 started to cry and DS1 was smiling from ear to ear - I did think, am I letting DS1 just dominate everything?? - that's not good for him. He already struggles with not doing what he's told at pre-school and thinking he can do what he wants.

I am really conflicted. I wish I felt as sure about my parenting decisions as some of you guys.

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 04/11/2022 11:57

He’s three. I don’t think your decision was weak at all. Clearly the issue with him needing to get dressed needs to be addressed- but I don’t think his dad just walking out on him is the way to do it.

shinynewapple22 · 04/11/2022 11:53

I think the issue here that was so upsetting for him was that his dad went out with his younger brother and left him behind. If there was only one child involved the consequence would have been that nobody went anywhere - so there is learning from his actions but not so devastating .

It's much harder when two children are involved - especially if one child has additional needs .

Mamarsupial · 04/11/2022 11:51

I think what happened was perfect actually.

Your 3 year old learned that there is a very real risk that he will get left behind if he doesn’t get ready. He got a second chance though. Call this morning a ‘warning shot’. Tell him next time, daddy won’t come and get him so he’s better hurry up. And next time make sure he really DOES follow through.

I think 3 years olds need a chance to put things right, and you gave him that.

Snugglemonkey · 04/11/2022 11:51

I am a fan of natural consequences but would be raging about this for a few reasons.

Firstly, you were working from home and therefore unavailable for parenting. So leaving your son was not an option for DH any more than leaving him in an empty house would have been. He had no right to leave a hysterical child for you to deal with,or to involve you in any way without discussing it with you.

Secondly, I am not sure your son was able to grasp the impact of the potential consequence in this case, so don't think he was really making a choice. I will have conversations like: "what about your coat?" When DC is going out, followed by "I don't need one", so "well, it looks pretty cold. You will need to come in when you are freezing. Are you sure you don't want it now?". So when he choses to go out and freeze, it is a choice followed by a natural consequence he clearly understands. If your son didn't understand, then it feels unduly harsh to go as far as it went.

I would be more inclined to say he would have to go in his pyjamas. Or, at a push, say I would need to put ds2 and the stuff in the car, so he was understanding that I was getting ready to leave. If that didn't get him doing it, I would unpack the car and say it was a shame we couldn't go, but the time for going had passed now and there is no swimming this week.

I would not abandon him. Then they tend to concentrate more on the unfairness they perceive at the abandonment and less on their role in it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread