Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WFH with children

632 replies

Annie232 · 04/11/2022 09:04

On many threads I hear women pop up and mention how they WFH x number of days and so don't need childcare on x number of days. Incidentally, within my NCT group on discussions on return to work a few of the women have said similar and that they plan to WFH 1/2 days a week and therefore save on childcare. Is this a thing now?

OP posts:
Jules912 · 04/11/2022 13:17

I nearly had a breakdown trying to do this with a then 4 and 7 year old during lockdown!
Now things are back to normal my employer officially doesn't allow it, though will turn a blind eye for the odd occasion if they're ill etc. the now 10 year old they probably wouldn't even know was there but my 7 year old still won't leave me alone unless she's too ill to move from the sofa.

gwenneh · 04/11/2022 13:17

milveycrohn · 04/11/2022 12:35

I have not read the entire thread, but several different pages, and it seems to me that it depends, on a) the number and age of children, and b) the nature of the job

It does. I've had a few WFH roles since my DC were small so I've been through a fair amount of ages/stages with it, from infant through primary. Now DH is the WFH parent & I'm in the office on flexed hours.

I think I may actually be the only parent of young children in our company at the moment who does work from the office!

LanaDooleyx3 · 04/11/2022 13:14

Don't get me wrong, my children are not here every day, only 2 out of 5 but those 2 are my most quiet days and when i mostly do admin stuff, so writing up notes and paperwork.

But yes, not everyone works the typical 9-5 office hours or needs to be accessible on the phone or deals with customers.

Jijithecat · 04/11/2022 13:10

@CherylCrows is there a particular reason why you don't use childcare?

winterbabyrose · 04/11/2022 13:06

@Annie232 Yes its a thing, but it does depend on how flexible you can be in your role and what your employer is like, and how motivated you are.

For instance, I personally WFH with my 9 month old. My mum has her 1 day a week when I physically go into the office, but the other 4 days I work full time at home while looking after her. My employer are happy with the arrangement, and my job is flexible in the sense of I just work from a laptop so I can work around DD any hours I choose as long as the work is done. I also am managing to study for two courses at the same time as well. Plus, I get to spend an incredible length of time playing and looking after DD, as I tend to do most of my work in mornings/evenings and nap times.

Time management and motivation is key (& a great employer). But yes, it can definitely be done.

MinnieMountain · 04/11/2022 13:05

When I asked HR if I could change my 1/2 day to a full day, her first question was “What are you doing for childcare?”.

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 13:00

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 12:54

@CherylCrows but if there’s such a skills shortage in your industry, you are so super duper at your job and they pay you a lot of money … why would they be happy with you working 1.5/2hrs a day? Here’s a crazy idea, why wouldn’t they just want to to work more?

I really refuse to believe your employer is happy with you only working 2 hrs a day when you could just work more for them?

Any employer is concerned about making money at the end of the day, you could work 3 or 4 times more hours and still not be working close to a heavy week.
Seems stupid on behalf of your company to not just ask more if you. Unless you are pretending to be busy for large chunks of time every day while on play dates and at the park in order to not be given more work.

Because they would have no one otherwise? Better to have me for 2/3 hours a day than a hole (which is what they had for over a year before I was hired and they lost a shit load of money due to it)

I deliver on my goals, I have overdelivered on my strategic KPIs and for my role in particular there are other dependencies that means it’s not as simple as ‘doing more’

There are budgets in play, limitations as to our data sources, limitations as to the technology we have access to across markets. I even had a 6 month delay in a project the year before last due to a legal hiccup, I couldn’t fix it as it’s outside of my scope but it also meant nothing could move on the project in that time. There was nothing else during that time that needed active involvement from me either. So I did some internal training, coaching, went to a lot of events (any excuse to get work to pay for travel) but still not full time hours.

For someone convinced I’m lying you sure seem to be asking a lot of questions, maybe you can just accept you don’t get it and move on.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 04/11/2022 12:57

I define my role, my deliverables and my output. Which is actually common for even those working under me.

This is actually fairly true for me too in a non tech sector role and I totally could get away with working fewer hours than I am contacted to do. But I view it as that I am being trusted to use my contracted time effectively and so I work out what I can achieve in my working hours and do that. Anything else would feel dishonest to me.

Now it's not a transactional exactly 37 hours type thing, there is give and take but what you're doing seems like a total pisstake

StripyHorse · 04/11/2022 12:56

Tigofigo · 04/11/2022 12:48

But even picking up a primary aged child means being out of work for a while - takes me 10-15 mins to get there, 10 mins waiting around / cajoling them out / chatting to teacher and then another 10-15 mins home, sorting them a snack and activity if they need it etc. That's the best part of an hour away from my desk.

Exactly this.

I was WFH when DD2 was in Y6. Perfectly capable of entertaining herself when I wasn't working but I couldn't do the school run in the allocated time so I put her in wrap around care. We had set hours so I couldn't just log off for an hour and log back on later. If work allowed that flexibility I would have done it.

Theoretically I could have taken my laptop and kept my hotspot on (I know someone who did this) but I can't bring myself to take the piss like that!

The more people try and play the system, the more employers are going to turn away from allowing people to do this which is a shame. I loved not having to commute, being able to put a wash in before work (won't leave it while we are away from the house), being in for parcels etc.

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 12:54

@CherylCrows but if there’s such a skills shortage in your industry, you are so super duper at your job and they pay you a lot of money … why would they be happy with you working 1.5/2hrs a day? Here’s a crazy idea, why wouldn’t they just want to to work more?

I really refuse to believe your employer is happy with you only working 2 hrs a day when you could just work more for them?

Any employer is concerned about making money at the end of the day, you could work 3 or 4 times more hours and still not be working close to a heavy week.
Seems stupid on behalf of your company to not just ask more if you. Unless you are pretending to be busy for large chunks of time every day while on play dates and at the park in order to not be given more work.

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 12:53

LanaDooleyx3 · 04/11/2022 12:32

I really think it depends on what job you do and how much flexibility you have.

I'm very lucky that my manager doesn't really care when people are online as long as they get their work done that day. I've been on at 5am and 11pm and everything in between.

Don’t worry @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet will be in soon to tell you this is BS

apparently flexible employers don’t exist and everyone is lying about it

maddiemookins16mum · 04/11/2022 12:52

It’s causing issues fir many employers mainly because people are not being truthful. A parent at my office WFH - has three under 8 including a toddler. Has said they uses a CM, they don’t. The toddler runs riot around the house, disrupts calls to customers and to a Government body that they need to speak with as part if their job role. Then there’s the ‘oh I can’t call for this customer can someone else do it, the kids are all here because of’
a) they’re all ill
b) the (non existent) CM is ill
c) they got let out from school early (the two oldest boys are 4 and 7)
d) inset day (8 since September 😂😂😂)

The reality is the parent cannot afford any child care at all.

Yet the rest of us pick up the slack.
Funny how BC (before Covid) she was in the office every day and the 2 boys went to Nursery.

SheWoreYellow · 04/11/2022 12:51

Tigofigo · 04/11/2022 12:48

But even picking up a primary aged child means being out of work for a while - takes me 10-15 mins to get there, 10 mins waiting around / cajoling them out / chatting to teacher and then another 10-15 mins home, sorting them a snack and activity if they need it etc. That's the best part of an hour away from my desk.

I’m about 20 minutes and just work later. Ours are allowed to walk out on their own from age 8-9 so I meet them half way.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 12:49

HOTHotPeppers · 04/11/2022 12:35

I'm very lucky in that I'm one of the closes houses to school. I log out of work at 3.29 for a 3.30 school pick up. I'm back logged in by 3.35 but I do log out for that time. We are monitored to the minute but can log in and out as much as we like. So if DC needs me I log out of work and work later. It's not ideal and I'm glad school will now accept him in breakfast and after school club.

That’s good but I think you’re probably the exception! Most people walk a while or drive to their kids school and if it’s anything like my kids’ school they take fucking ages to boot them out.

Tigofigo · 04/11/2022 12:48

But even picking up a primary aged child means being out of work for a while - takes me 10-15 mins to get there, 10 mins waiting around / cajoling them out / chatting to teacher and then another 10-15 mins home, sorting them a snack and activity if they need it etc. That's the best part of an hour away from my desk.

TheOrigRights · 04/11/2022 12:48

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 11:33

Explain what?

Im baffled so many on here seem to struggle with this concept, I don’t know many at work who actually work their contracted hours.

And I am management, I report into our SVP, he doesn’t give a flying fuck when I’m online as long as he is getting the benefit from having me in role (which they are) I was promoted on mat leave and regularly get my bonus so clearly no issues there.

It took them over a year to recruit for my role as it’s in an area of skills shortages (especially at Snr levels)

This is very common in many sectors and industries (definitely common in tech and marketing based roles)

We must move in very different worlds.

I don't know anyone who doesn't work their contracted hours, and your work pattern doesn't seem to be something many on this thread are familiar with.

Good for you that it's worked out so well.

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 12:48

sheepdogdelight · 04/11/2022 12:32

The entire tech marketing space is being impacted by skills shortages, across multiple sectors and countries.

You see, that's the bit I find odd about your situation. I also work in a skills shortage role. That means that if I can finish something more quickly than planned, my employer is ecstatic and gives me something else to do (because we have more work than people on account of the skills shortage).

What never happens is that I get given a piece of work and told I have 10 hours to do it, so if I actually finish it in 3, I just put my feet up for 7 hours. So I'm assuming that you are telling your employer that things take longer than they do, so they don't give you more stuff. Or you take on specific pieces of work and charge to do the work regardless of time taken - though you've said that's not the case?

I don’t tell anyone things have taken longer than they have

as no one asks.

I don’t work on ‘tasks’ either and I’m never given a piece of work. I define my role, my deliverables and my output. Which is actually common for even those working under me.

Really not sure why some are finding this hard to understand, but then again I’ve not worked in a role where I’m ‘given a task and told when to complete it by’ since I was 19

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 12:47

sheepdogdelight · 04/11/2022 12:32

The entire tech marketing space is being impacted by skills shortages, across multiple sectors and countries.

You see, that's the bit I find odd about your situation. I also work in a skills shortage role. That means that if I can finish something more quickly than planned, my employer is ecstatic and gives me something else to do (because we have more work than people on account of the skills shortage).

What never happens is that I get given a piece of work and told I have 10 hours to do it, so if I actually finish it in 3, I just put my feet up for 7 hours. So I'm assuming that you are telling your employer that things take longer than they do, so they don't give you more stuff. Or you take on specific pieces of work and charge to do the work regardless of time taken - though you've said that's not the case?

Yes I can’t understand how being contracted for 37 hours, and presumably paid for those hours, and then only working say 15 hours isn’t skiving. You’re contracted to do hours, not sets if work. Unless you’re SE and charge per hours for the work you’re doing and however long it takes, your a great big skiver and I can’t imagine your employer is OK with that.

Although I do laugh that is mere mortals just don’t understand This modern way of working 😂

BackOnTheBandWagon · 04/11/2022 12:44

Fucking hell I can't believe so many people do this / are thinking of doing this. Maybe possible for a bit if you have a young potato baby, but mine was a live wire and would not tolerate not having attention and input, and / or would amuse himself by getting into all sorts of trouble. Crazy thinking - you'll be a crap parent and crap at work.

milveycrohn · 04/11/2022 12:35

I have not read the entire thread, but several different pages, and it seems to me that it depends, on a) the number and age of children, and b) the nature of the job

HOTHotPeppers · 04/11/2022 12:35

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 12:14

I read on a thread recently that apparently it’s a ‘thing’ now to work less if you’re super efficient even though you are contracted to 40 hours a week because people are so super dooper good at their job and the only person on the planet that can do it that working 2 hours a day on a FT contract is fine.

I mean I call total BS but whatever.

Also it’s easy peasy to work FT and still do the school run and have full family life because they WFH. Which makes me think “but either you make up the 30 minutes you’ve taken to do the school run later or you just skive every day”. But neither is true apparently 😂

I think this train of thought only happens in MN world and in reality kids are forever in after school clubs

I'm very lucky in that I'm one of the closes houses to school. I log out of work at 3.29 for a 3.30 school pick up. I'm back logged in by 3.35 but I do log out for that time. We are monitored to the minute but can log in and out as much as we like. So if DC needs me I log out of work and work later. It's not ideal and I'm glad school will now accept him in breakfast and after school club.

Miserablehag · 04/11/2022 12:34

This would not be acceptable in my work - babies and toddlers have to either be looked after by another adult in the home or out of it.

Younger school aged children would be considered acceptable for an hour or two after school but no more.

kids that would stay at home alone normally if working elsewhere would be fine.

how on earth can anyone do any work or attend Teams meetings properly whilst caring for a toddler???

Tomorrowisalatterday · 04/11/2022 12:33

I don't know anyone doing this full time with preschool children but I do know people doing it a bit:

One person I know had a toddler with a very secure and lengthy afternoon nap - she put him in nursery in the mornings, he napped in the afternoon and she would put him in front of the TV for an hour at the end of the day. She stopped when he dropped his nap but it worked well for her for about 18 months and halved her childcare costs.

A couple I knew both WFH on Fridays around their toddler - they would juggle their diaries and make up a bit of time in the evening. Nursery was flexible so if they needed the extra day they could book it.

We will see more and more of this with cost of living issues

saltofcelery · 04/11/2022 12:33

@MolliciousIntent "I can guarantee you that the women looking after babies or small children while working are spending most of the time failing their employer, failing their children, or both.

You need childcare if you're going to work. End of."

Exactly this. You can't possibly look after your child whilst working and you can't work whilst looking after your old. You're effectively stealing from your company by doing this.

sheepdogdelight · 04/11/2022 12:32

The entire tech marketing space is being impacted by skills shortages, across multiple sectors and countries.

You see, that's the bit I find odd about your situation. I also work in a skills shortage role. That means that if I can finish something more quickly than planned, my employer is ecstatic and gives me something else to do (because we have more work than people on account of the skills shortage).

What never happens is that I get given a piece of work and told I have 10 hours to do it, so if I actually finish it in 3, I just put my feet up for 7 hours. So I'm assuming that you are telling your employer that things take longer than they do, so they don't give you more stuff. Or you take on specific pieces of work and charge to do the work regardless of time taken - though you've said that's not the case?