Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WFH with children

632 replies

Annie232 · 04/11/2022 09:04

On many threads I hear women pop up and mention how they WFH x number of days and so don't need childcare on x number of days. Incidentally, within my NCT group on discussions on return to work a few of the women have said similar and that they plan to WFH 1/2 days a week and therefore save on childcare. Is this a thing now?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:22

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 14:17

considering he is SVP for an entire business unit yes no one cared or came down on him for it.

The company is making record profits (especially during COVID too) shareholders are happy, management are happy - what’s not to like.

Maybe broaden your outlook and stop viewing the world through a very small lens

They made record profits despite losing 8 figures??

Ive worked in many roles and any SVP or CEO would get the almightiest of bollockings and probably the sack for taking a month off and not using AL. Sounds like you work for one of those companies where people on the ground work like dogs and shit rolls downhill from people at the top who say “Well I am a SVP so you can’t tell me what to do”.

Honestly, I’m not buying any of it - a company where no one does a day’s work but they make a squillion pounds in profit?

samstownsunset · 04/11/2022 14:21

@Yerroblemom1923

Agree, depends entirely on what you do.
My DH has a good city based job and now WFH 3 days a week. He couldn't do his job and look after the kids.

I left my toddler at home with him to do the school run last week as it was chucking it down. Was gone all of 25 mins and it was mayhem when I returned!

I'm lucky to be flexible but I orchestrated this situation myself. Wanted to be at home with my children and make a living so I made it happen.

It has its downsides of course but mostly positive.

Rainbowpurple · 04/11/2022 14:20

Clearly some people who own their autonomy at work / high in the management role / have their own company and flexibility can WFH with their kids. I did on my maternity because I had to / wanted to do some hours as the business is mine.

The question here is... How many people ( women) are in these super fortunate, niche sector or higher up in management role that absence from work doesn't reflect poorly upon them?
Interestingly enough I haven't seen many male colleagues / employees of mine who wanted to WFH and also look after their kids?

Brieeeeeeeee · 04/11/2022 14:20

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 09:21

I don’t think it’s common for people to actually do this. Many people plan to do it and realise that it’s stupid.

If DD is sick sometimes we will both wfh and alternate our day so we don’t have to take unpaid leave. It’s hell though and means you’re basically working from 5am to 11pm and it’s exhausting.

This, basically. You can’t work properly and look after a baby or young child. Many of us muddled through in lockdown or when someone’s ill, but it’s rubbish and tiring and can’t be done long term.

strugglebug22 · 04/11/2022 14:20

Personally I don't give a shit about my job. It isn't highly skilled, there isn't a lot of responsibility, I don't have people under me. The pay reflects all this. If I were in a more demanding role I wouldn't dream of trying to juggle my dd at home while I worked. As it is I can probably manage to coast by doing very little for one day providing I get the rest of my work done earlier in the week while she's at nursery. I know for a fact that other colleagues do things in work time - gardening, school runs, shopping, one even decorated her living room! So I don't feel bad about it to be honest.

elephantmarchingin · 04/11/2022 14:19

@Teder we both do 35 hours per week ish so I do 8:30-4:30 with an unpaid lunch break. DH does 7-3.
We don't often log back in later as no need to. In busy spells we may but not often much of a need.

DS has never known any different so he is very used to it. Also before anyone says he's met all his milestones, is happy and healthy and able to cope in social situations

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/11/2022 14:17

I think with rising costs everywhere people may choose to try to save eg nursery/childminder fees.

DB and his DW have a 4 year old, she works a demanding role. DB works in film but on and off, so minds his son and does school drop/pickup etc. when he’s picked up his son no way can he leave him in a flat to do his own thing. Screen time or too much is bad for him!

SIL’s DB and her SIL have 2 DC’s one is 5 and other is 2, he’s in nursery. The husband is at work but can wfh a lot and the wife I think wfh 1-2 days a week but still has the 2 year old in nursery. I think the husband does school pick up and drop off.

it is hard combining work and childcare but unless you’re very well off or on benefits most parents have to work these days!

wordler · 04/11/2022 14:17

I'm self-employed and wfh with my DD from 2 days before I went into labour until she was school age. Took 3 weeks off after the birth and had to go straight back to the computer.

It's very doable - in fact very easy when they are babies because they sleep so much. Toddlers much harder - I baby proofed the room I worked in and created a 'safe zone around my desk with baby gates so that she could see me while she was playing and I could easily interact with her.

But it's exhausting - you have to be able to stop and start constantly - and find ways to be ready to work like a crazy person as soon as they nap. Catch up on things as soon as DH gets home etc.

If you have to be on Zoom or a phone call at specific times then it's probably not going to work because you will get background noise or even a crying baby just when you don't need it.

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 14:17

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:10

So a manger took 4 weeks off but didn’t use annual leave and the company are ok with that??

It seems your workplace only attract piss takers.

I seriously struggle to see a company that could make money like this. I’ve worked in the LA and civil service and have seen that level of piss taking though.

considering he is SVP for an entire business unit yes no one cared or came down on him for it.

The company is making record profits (especially during COVID too) shareholders are happy, management are happy - what’s not to like.

Maybe broaden your outlook and stop viewing the world through a very small lens

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 14:17

So all you need to make this work is a DH to be available whenever you actually need to work, therefore not really looking after your child while working, or work such a little amount of time that you aren’t actually working while looking after your child either.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:16

It is working out great for them

Someone stealing from is working out well for them?

They took over a year to fill my role, in which time they lost tens of millions in terms of net revenue.

then they’re a shit business.

You personally generate tens of millions of £ by working 10 hours a week?

They want someone who understands how rondo the job and do it well, they don’t care how I do it, how much I work, as long as my goals are achieved - which they are. I’m regularly awarded performance bonuses - so clearly it is working out for them.

So they HAVE told you “You can work as little as you want despite being contracted to full time hours”?

Also, all companies want and expect this someone to know how to do the job. That doesn’t mean the employer can breach their contract literally every day.

And sure they’d love to pay me less, any employer would, but they wouldn’t as I’d leave and they’d be stuck losing money again.

They should pay you less if you’re only doing 2 hours a day.

I do find it incredibly hard to believe that there is an organisation out there who so desperately needs, to the point they lose 8 figures sums one specific person who is such a genius that they allow them to work 10 hours a week and pay them for 37. Usually those losses come as a result of much, much more than just not being able to fill a job role.

Teder · 04/11/2022 14:15

elephantmarchingin · 04/11/2022 14:13

Not miserable at all. Typical day looks like this

8am - breakfast (DH logs on at 7 and I log on at 8:30)
9:30am - DS does craft activity
10/10:15am - DS has snack and TV time
11am - tends to play with his toys/lego/read books
12:15 ish - we stagger our lunch breaks so I do DS lunch then he is taken and the dog for an hours walk or to the library etc in that hour.
1:30/whatever time we get back - DS can pick an activity from his box (bakerrosss stuff, little pound shop toys etc) which keeps him occupied for about an hour to be honest
2:30 - Naps for 45mins to 2 hours
When he wakes up - DH has finished so either goes out to shops/park/whatever evening activities

We have the sort of job where colleagues don't collaborate or need to work together so no waiting on other people. We also exclusively use emails to communicate with any customers etc so can be much much more flexible.

just out of interest, how many hours do you work? Are you logging back on when your son is in bed? I did this during covid and it nearly broke me but my work situation was different to yours.

Teder · 04/11/2022 14:14

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 14:08

It is working out great for them

They took over a year to fill my role, in which time they lost tens of millions in terms of net revenue.

They want someone who understands how rondo the job and do it well, they don’t care how I do it, how much I work, as long as my goals are achieved - which they are. I’m regularly awarded performance bonuses - so clearly it is working out for them.

And sure they’d love to pay me less, any employer would, but they wouldn’t as I’d leave and they’d be stuck losing money again.

You’re in an extremely unique niche role. Yet, you struggle to understand even seniors and managers have deadlines and get “told” what to do. Not all jobs are the same!

elephantmarchingin · 04/11/2022 14:13

Not miserable at all. Typical day looks like this

8am - breakfast (DH logs on at 7 and I log on at 8:30)
9:30am - DS does craft activity
10/10:15am - DS has snack and TV time
11am - tends to play with his toys/lego/read books
12:15 ish - we stagger our lunch breaks so I do DS lunch then he is taken and the dog for an hours walk or to the library etc in that hour.
1:30/whatever time we get back - DS can pick an activity from his box (bakerrosss stuff, little pound shop toys etc) which keeps him occupied for about an hour to be honest
2:30 - Naps for 45mins to 2 hours
When he wakes up - DH has finished so either goes out to shops/park/whatever evening activities

We have the sort of job where colleagues don't collaborate or need to work together so no waiting on other people. We also exclusively use emails to communicate with any customers etc so can be much much more flexible.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:11

One of my recent new starters came from Coke and they had a very similar set up in her team (she doesn’t have kids yet but others would WFH with their kids and manage the workload around a small but highly productive set of hours)

So at Coke they work the hours they’re contracted to? That’s not the same as what you’re doing

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:10

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 14:05

But it is the same, when you get to a certain level it’s really not uncommon to set your own deliverables, targets, goals and schedule.

I am a manager, and no I don’t think something is amiss, a fair few under me do the same with their kids (and did so before I got this role). Others don’t as their roles can’t be done in short bursts and they have more external meetings. My own line manager took 4 weeks off (not as holiday just in general) as his kids had extended their visit to him and his wife and he wanted to spend more time with them, he was available for an hour a day for urgent calls and that was it.

It’s not unusual or uncommon, I’d actually struggle to think of one company in our peer set that also doesn’t operate similarly. One of my recent new starters came from Coke and they had a very similar set up in her team (she doesn’t have kids yet but others would WFH with their kids and manage the workload around a small but highly productive set of hours)

So a manger took 4 weeks off but didn’t use annual leave and the company are ok with that??

It seems your workplace only attract piss takers.

I seriously struggle to see a company that could make money like this. I’ve worked in the LA and civil service and have seen that level of piss taking though.

user159 · 04/11/2022 14:09

We operate a very successful hybrid working policy at my work place but it's built on trust. Everyone knows childcare should still be used in your working hours so for me I still use nursery, but they are flexible elsewhere like doing the school run, exceptions for sick children etc.

There is absolutely no way I could do my job with a three year old in the house on a normal, regular basis. The stress of it would be something else!

They are paying me so I don't think this is massively unreasonable!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/11/2022 14:09

I hope these people that are flexible and work later to make up are not delaying colleagues because they haven’t replied or been in a call. I also hope they don’t expect others to dial into calls after core office hours because that’s the only time they are free. Fine if you are flexible and work totally on your own but if you do have dependencies on others or them with you then there is definitely an impact

Hope is a wonderful thing, but realistically it happens and that's when you get "My child comes first" annd variations on "We need the next generation - they'll be paying your penssion"

Both of which are natural and right, but if a point comes where commitments and the job don't match it's perhaps best to look for something else

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 14:08

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:02

But it’s not great for your employer when you’re taking the piss the way you are.

Youre really telling me that given the option they rather pay you for 27 hours you’re not working rather than have you working in that time?

It is working out great for them

They took over a year to fill my role, in which time they lost tens of millions in terms of net revenue.

They want someone who understands how rondo the job and do it well, they don’t care how I do it, how much I work, as long as my goals are achieved - which they are. I’m regularly awarded performance bonuses - so clearly it is working out for them.

And sure they’d love to pay me less, any employer would, but they wouldn’t as I’d leave and they’d be stuck losing money again.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 04/11/2022 14:08

But it is the same, when you get to a certain level it’s really not uncommon to set your own deliverables, targets, goals and schedule

I agree and had been at that certain level for a long time until I went SE. Never once did I think though that meant I could set my own hours outside of my contracted hours and work as and when I pleased, for a fraction of the time I was contracted for. Who told you otherwise??

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/11/2022 14:08

elephantmarchingin · 04/11/2022 14:02

We have a really good employer and DS!

We have not yet paid for any childcare and both WFH full time (DS is 3).

As he has got towards 3 1/2 it's become a bit more difficult so we are putting him in preschool for a couple of days a week from January.

It's possible to do but we don't have to do meetings or any calls so maybe that's why it's easier

But you do the work and make up time don’t you?

the perks for me for WFH is if i’m having a lazy day I can get up at work time, have breakfast and check emails at the same time - so working too. I can then grab a shower and get dressed in say 10 minutes which would cover a tea/toilet break etc. or I make up time before or after work.

my commute time is approx 1 hour so WFH definitely allows me to save on that hour which is wasted time to me.

Grumpybutfunny · 04/11/2022 14:06

Nope I can just about do it with a 9 year old but even then meetings get interrupted by telling him to turn the volume down or go raid the fridge. Our employer knows about it as it's usually days I've agreed to swap an off day to be in a meeting, if it's roted day you wouldn't get away with it.

CherylCrows · 04/11/2022 14:05

TheOrigRights · 04/11/2022 13:59

I haven’t worked in a job where my time was so closely managed since I was a teenager: must be so demeaning as an adult being told you need to do this by x date.

There is a HUGE difference between being having your time managed closely and only working 2 hours a day on a full time contract.

different workplaces and different jobs have different set ups.

Surely you accept it is unusual to hire someone on a full time contract and for that person to work 2 hours a day. If you were a manager would you not think something was amiss, either with the employee or with the contract?

But it is the same, when you get to a certain level it’s really not uncommon to set your own deliverables, targets, goals and schedule.

I am a manager, and no I don’t think something is amiss, a fair few under me do the same with their kids (and did so before I got this role). Others don’t as their roles can’t be done in short bursts and they have more external meetings. My own line manager took 4 weeks off (not as holiday just in general) as his kids had extended their visit to him and his wife and he wanted to spend more time with them, he was available for an hour a day for urgent calls and that was it.

It’s not unusual or uncommon, I’d actually struggle to think of one company in our peer set that also doesn’t operate similarly. One of my recent new starters came from Coke and they had a very similar set up in her team (she doesn’t have kids yet but others would WFH with their kids and manage the workload around a small but highly productive set of hours)

Yerroblemom1923 · 04/11/2022 14:04

@samstownsunset absolutely! I think the posters arguing against are jealous that their scenarios mean it's not possible. And they can't save money on childcare.
It's interesting how every summer (towards September school start dates etc) there are similar threads asking how the OP can work from home due to cost of childcare. Much depends on how much is expected of you from your boss and whether you're expected to keep jiggling a mouse as "proof" of activity etc.
Much of WFH seems to involve "team meetings" where people say nothing much to move things forward albeit the odd "Roger that. I'll email that over ASAP" and other such pointless nonsense.
Bosses are wising up and cracking down now so everyone will be back in the real world soon. Think of the electricity/gas you'll save from being in a lovely warm office.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/11/2022 14:03

TheOrigRights · 04/11/2022 13:59

I haven’t worked in a job where my time was so closely managed since I was a teenager: must be so demeaning as an adult being told you need to do this by x date.

There is a HUGE difference between being having your time managed closely and only working 2 hours a day on a full time contract.

different workplaces and different jobs have different set ups.

Surely you accept it is unusual to hire someone on a full time contract and for that person to work 2 hours a day. If you were a manager would you not think something was amiss, either with the employee or with the contract?

Well her manager obviously isn’t keeping a close enough eye on her as they should be then!

In my large global organisation, if this was noted (and it would be!) they’d be disciplined pretty sharpish and rightly so!

it’s a few bad apples who take the piss out of WFH structures that mean a few companies will review this perk for people who don’t abuse it!