Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WFH with children

632 replies

Annie232 · 04/11/2022 09:04

On many threads I hear women pop up and mention how they WFH x number of days and so don't need childcare on x number of days. Incidentally, within my NCT group on discussions on return to work a few of the women have said similar and that they plan to WFH 1/2 days a week and therefore save on childcare. Is this a thing now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ImAvingOops · 08/11/2022 08:01

Childminding is a very specific job and the parents who use your services will have chosen you knowing that you are caring for your own dc simultaneously. Some parents will be okay with this, but others will prefer their dc to get 100% of the caregivers time so will opt for a nanny instead. The point being that the 'employer' gets to make an informed decision.
Lots of people advocating wfh on this thread haven't formally agreed this with the people who pay them. They're on dodgy ground.
And some have confused the issue of working around their contracted hours so they can do childcare with actually working full time while simultaneously looking after their children.

eastegg · 07/11/2022 22:24

ZoChan · 07/11/2022 20:37

Oof! That one hit home a bit as I am a business owner but have my kids at home/school whilst I work.

I am a childminder (Montessori trained so quite niche) but originally set up in order to bring in some money whilst being at home with my own children. Ultimately I now work with my own children at home, so it IS possible OP. I am self employed so set my own hours to suit my family, and I don't have to pay for childcare. However: I have my own children at home whilst I am working!! They are at home- the place where they relax so they don't always want to help me out. Their behaviour reflects on my business and it is very stressful should they have a bad day- which they do because they're kids!

@Annie232 I work at home with my kids present, because I am experienced in child development, behaviours and they do contribute a lot to my customers: we provide a family environment. But I would not take on an admin job with expected meetings, with my children at home- a seven month old who just started with me barely naps for longer than 30 minutes at a time even for her own parents! You don't know who your baby is going to be, how tired you're going to be, how much the trust in your childcare provider relieves some of the pressure on parents. Childcare isn't just for work, it's knowing they're safe happy and stimulated whilst you do the supermarket shop, go the gym, go out for lunch with your partner! If paying me £5 an hour is too expensive to provide care for the most important person in your life, with all the qualifications and registrations I have, then to be honest, I don't know what to suggest.

I agree, it’s surprising isn’t it, that these hotshots in such senior roles who’ve been promoted multiple times don’t fork out a bit of that salary for some proper childcare.

Also, what if the child doesn’t sleep well? It’s particularly crazy advice to say it’s doable when the person asking is talking about babies (she mentions an NCT group). You don’t know what you’re going to get. 2 out of 3 of mine didn’t settle for hours in the evening until they were older, got up in the night and were early risers. And yet people like Wiluli glibly tell us they do their work while their kids sleep in til 10am.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 07/11/2022 22:03

the older ones learned to read while I worked and wanted to “ work “ with mum at times . The 6 year old could pretty much be at least a Sectetary by now the amount she knows lol

This doesn’t sound remotely data protection compliant.

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 20:47

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 20:19

As others have said, you are in completely the wrong discussion.

If you work in a legal setting as you say, then you of all people should know what a contract is. You shouldnt be advising women that they don't have to work all their hours stated in their employment contract if they consider themselves efficient.
Where on earth did you study law?
And can these women hire you to represent them if they get dismissed?

I haven’t seen their contracts so will depend on what they say . As I posted early my office never revoked wfh with children , because most people were able to work well even during covid . This will depend entirely on each persons contract . I’m by no means saying people should hide it , just stating some jobs can be done with a child at home and a few adaptations so some of those mums thinking about wfh may be able to do it

ZoChan · 07/11/2022 20:37

Summerfun54321 · 07/11/2022 00:05

More fool any woman working twice as hard for no extra pay. Either I’m a SAHM and my DH can earn the money, or I work and earn a wage. Anyone agreeing to do both childcare and work simultaneously is doing themselves a huge disservice. Any man agreeing to or expecting a woman to do this is a misogynist.

Oof! That one hit home a bit as I am a business owner but have my kids at home/school whilst I work.

I am a childminder (Montessori trained so quite niche) but originally set up in order to bring in some money whilst being at home with my own children. Ultimately I now work with my own children at home, so it IS possible OP. I am self employed so set my own hours to suit my family, and I don't have to pay for childcare. However: I have my own children at home whilst I am working!! They are at home- the place where they relax so they don't always want to help me out. Their behaviour reflects on my business and it is very stressful should they have a bad day- which they do because they're kids!

@Annie232 I work at home with my kids present, because I am experienced in child development, behaviours and they do contribute a lot to my customers: we provide a family environment. But I would not take on an admin job with expected meetings, with my children at home- a seven month old who just started with me barely naps for longer than 30 minutes at a time even for her own parents! You don't know who your baby is going to be, how tired you're going to be, how much the trust in your childcare provider relieves some of the pressure on parents. Childcare isn't just for work, it's knowing they're safe happy and stimulated whilst you do the supermarket shop, go the gym, go out for lunch with your partner! If paying me £5 an hour is too expensive to provide care for the most important person in your life, with all the qualifications and registrations I have, then to be honest, I don't know what to suggest.

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 20:21

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 20:19

As others have said, you are in completely the wrong discussion.

If you work in a legal setting as you say, then you of all people should know what a contract is. You shouldnt be advising women that they don't have to work all their hours stated in their employment contract if they consider themselves efficient.
Where on earth did you study law?
And can these women hire you to represent them if they get dismissed?

Sorry that was for wiluli, the main WFH with kids rep on this thread

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 20:19

As others have said, you are in completely the wrong discussion.

If you work in a legal setting as you say, then you of all people should know what a contract is. You shouldnt be advising women that they don't have to work all their hours stated in their employment contract if they consider themselves efficient.
Where on earth did you study law?
And can these women hire you to represent them if they get dismissed?

Jijithecat · 07/11/2022 20:03

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 17:48

I’m dyslexic and to be honest just came out of gallbladder surgery yesterday and a bit high on meds and very tired . But you of course believe what you wish . I have nothing to prove to you . I’m absolutely fine wfh with or without kids , and have done so the last 5 years . I agree not every job will be conducive with wfh but mine is .

Well the meds might explain why you're discussing a vastly different situation.
Had you prefaced with 'if you can work your day very flexibly to complete your work when your children are sleeping at night and you won't be called into the office at the last minute then it's doable but having sole parental responsibility for a two year whilst trying to do a 9 - 5 job isn't going to work' then it would be different. But you didn't.
People look to Mumsnet for advice.

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 19:55

Let's just hope a load of naive working new mums don't wrongly take away from this that they dont need to join any nursery/childcare waiting lists at all when their Mat leave is over

TheOrigRights · 07/11/2022 19:34

they all do at least 2 days of work at home a week , on those days they do their important calls when the partners are home and replies and email sending once kids are in bed and before they get up

So they're not doing childcare while working, thus not relevant to the discussion.

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 19:04

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 18:17

So you are agreeing that yours is far from a "normal" situation and so you shouldn't be speaking for the millions of women with bog standard normal jobs who can't necessarily get away with doing what you do.
It's irresponsible to advise the naive on here to do this when they could be putting their careers at risk when it could be against their legally agreed contracts.
It's especially dangerous to be offering ill career advice in the current (& forecast) financial climate.

But lots of jobs can be fine this way . 3 close friends work in the insurance industry and in a legal setting as myself , they all do at least 2 days of work at home a week , on those days they do their important calls when the partners are home and replies and email sending once kids are in bed and before they get up . Lots of wfh jobs do not require fixed office hours just for those hours to be done in a set period if time and off course for targets to be achieved .
Personally I do not care if Anna , Patel and Mia ( fictitious names ) have their kids at home with them or not or if they do the school pick up or go to baby yoga , all I care is they present their work as they should and meet team expectations .
Even during covid with 2 kids at home I still worked the whole time , it was harder but doable , yes none where babies and it involved me finishing a few meetings in the car to hide from noise but targets here meet , children where entertained and somehow my mental health is still intact .

Most people who do it won’t be doing it 5 days a week and probably with a target of the kids getting to free nursery age . It’s a sacrifice people do but it’s also rewarding in my case . All of my kids have amazing work ethics , the older ones learned to read while I worked and wanted to “ work “ with mum at times . The 6 year old could pretty much be at least a Sectetary by now the amount she knows lol

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 18:17

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 17:48

I’m dyslexic and to be honest just came out of gallbladder surgery yesterday and a bit high on meds and very tired . But you of course believe what you wish . I have nothing to prove to you . I’m absolutely fine wfh with or without kids , and have done so the last 5 years . I agree not every job will be conducive with wfh but mine is .

So you are agreeing that yours is far from a "normal" situation and so you shouldn't be speaking for the millions of women with bog standard normal jobs who can't necessarily get away with doing what you do.
It's irresponsible to advise the naive on here to do this when they could be putting their careers at risk when it could be against their legally agreed contracts.
It's especially dangerous to be offering ill career advice in the current (& forecast) financial climate.

reigatecastle · 07/11/2022 18:15

Sarahcoggles · 07/11/2022 08:02

I often wonder if this is one of the reasons for shit customer services since Covid - ringing companies, banks etc. People are "working" from home to save on childcare.

I think if that were the case the employers would have cottoned on by now, they have quite sophisticated software to monitor call length, how long people are waiting before the call is picked up etc. I just don't think they care - they are happy to take the money from customers and then ignore them when things go wrong/block access by using chatbots etc.

I don't think you can work from home with a small child, but you can probably save on the wraparound care with school-age children depending on the job or whether you work part-time. My son is older now but I could easily fit my current job around school hours if I needed to.

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 17:51

eastegg · 07/11/2022 14:23

I can’t help noticing a lot of what you’re posting is unintelligible. Do you have your kids with you?😂

No as I put above , I admit I’m a bit high on meds I just had gallbladder surgery yesterday . And I’m also dyslexic and had my keyboard on another language, which I would normally workout fast but 🤦🏻‍♀️ I’m brain dead the general anaesthetic really was tough on me for some reason

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 17:48

Jijithecat · 07/11/2022 12:08

And yet your attention to detail is so poor.

I don't buy a word you say.

I’m dyslexic and to be honest just came out of gallbladder surgery yesterday and a bit high on meds and very tired . But you of course believe what you wish . I have nothing to prove to you . I’m absolutely fine wfh with or without kids , and have done so the last 5 years . I agree not every job will be conducive with wfh but mine is .

Chiccaletta · 07/11/2022 16:55

A work contract is a legally binding agreement.
If you are not working your contracted hours while looking after children (regardless how fast/slow worker you are in your child-free moments) then you have broken your contract and can be dismissed / downgraded to a part time or flexible hours contract for your actual working hours and (for some) sued for the hours you have effectively stolen from your employer to date.

This is happening more now people are forgetting to set up official flexible working contracts with agreed new working times post lockdown (to maintain their new lifestyle and reflect their actual output hours). Some employers hadn't been prepared to deal with it as not enough precedents/case law yet.

You at least need to check any WFH policies, make sure you employer is aware of your situation being baby-adjacent and get agreement in writing to protect yourself should anyone from HR start an investigation. And if you dont, figure out how quickly you can get a new job should you be dismissed. All you need is one disgruntled colleague to tip them off if they feel there is inequality going on.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 07/11/2022 16:19

Usernamen · 07/11/2022 15:12

I should add that not all senior managers manage really junior people who need hand-holding and on-the-job training. Some have very skilled professionals reporting into them who themselves are senior and experienced (and often have more up to date technical skills, as these move quickly in some industries). A strong team below you can massively reduce your workload, particularly if your staff are motivated and want to get promoted etc - they often want to take work off your hands. When you consider all that, 10 hours of actual work for a full time senior role doesn’t seem so fanciful.

Where I work, senior leaders are expected to do things like corporate initiatives, mentoring, speaking at team meetings, slots at training sessions, stuff to raise awareness of the organisation.

Oversight of your own team is only maybe half your time - but you are expected to be available to them in working hours. E.g. a member of my team has a young son who fainted, she dashed off to hospital and he may have cancer. I needed to be around to emotionally support her and to reallocate her work. I think I would be failing her if I was off at playgroup. She is usually someone very independent work wise and in no need of micro management

Usernamen · 07/11/2022 15:12

sheepdogdelight · 07/11/2022 14:58

In some workplaces it’s really not so easy to take work off junior people so they have a smaller workload. Where I work you’d be accused of not letting them develop and for hogging client work

I'm not suggesting that senior people do junior people's work.

I'm suggesting that they look at what their teams are doing and if there is anything that can be improved. And then look to make a plan to action it.
Which should be within the remit of a senior person anyway ...

I should add that not all senior managers manage really junior people who need hand-holding and on-the-job training. Some have very skilled professionals reporting into them who themselves are senior and experienced (and often have more up to date technical skills, as these move quickly in some industries). A strong team below you can massively reduce your workload, particularly if your staff are motivated and want to get promoted etc - they often want to take work off your hands. When you consider all that, 10 hours of actual work for a full time senior role doesn’t seem so fanciful.

Usernamen · 07/11/2022 15:04

sheepdogdelight · 07/11/2022 14:58

In some workplaces it’s really not so easy to take work off junior people so they have a smaller workload. Where I work you’d be accused of not letting them develop and for hogging client work

I'm not suggesting that senior people do junior people's work.

I'm suggesting that they look at what their teams are doing and if there is anything that can be improved. And then look to make a plan to action it.
Which should be within the remit of a senior person anyway ...

Absolutely agree that that would typically be in the remit of a senior manager, but reviewing a report and providing feedback takes a fraction of the time it takes to actually produce the report, for example. This is what I mean about these roles being largely ‘oversight’.

sheepdogdelight · 07/11/2022 14:58

In some workplaces it’s really not so easy to take work off junior people so they have a smaller workload. Where I work you’d be accused of not letting them develop and for hogging client work

I'm not suggesting that senior people do junior people's work.

I'm suggesting that they look at what their teams are doing and if there is anything that can be improved. And then look to make a plan to action it.
Which should be within the remit of a senior person anyway ...

Usernamen · 07/11/2022 14:57

TheOrigRights · 07/11/2022 13:45

I can't think how that sort of working pattern would work if you needed childcare when work was hectic, unless you have extremely flexible childcare - like grandparents who are able to be flexible.

nb I realise your post isn't discussing your own childcare situation.

I was just giving an example of where you can do literally no work for weeks and still be paid in full for your ‘contracted hours’. Plenty of jobs aren’t about being online/contactable for the exact number of hours it says in the contract. I find it strange how much of a hard time people on this thread got for describing a work pattern that is really not all that unusual (especially professional/skilled work at senior levels).

Jijithecat · 07/11/2022 14:33

Sorry @Dinoteeth, I just reread my last post and it sounds unnecessarily curt towards you. I just meant for my post to support what you are saying.

eastegg · 07/11/2022 14:23

Wiluli · 07/11/2022 10:48

i Work considerably faster than some of those on my team ( I have a extremely good memory so what take sitters often 30 m to find I will remember ) , I’m also a team leader , meaning I need to know what my team members strong points are and their weaknesses . If I conta you work 50% more than what others are able Im being unfair to them and I do nit expect this from them because I know most people could not cope with it . Giving it your all often doesn’t mean work non stop .

I can’t help noticing a lot of what you’re posting is unintelligible. Do you have your kids with you?😂

Jijithecat · 07/11/2022 13:57

Dinoteeth · 07/11/2022 12:14

Yip and look at the increased numbers of 5 and 6 year olds needing speech therapy.
Those 5 /6 year olds were 2/3 when covid kicked off.

I heard about the BBC report about child speech delays on the radio this morning.

'The number of five and six year olds who need speech and language support at school has risen by 10% in England over the past year, BBC analysis shows.

The increase, which is substantially greater than previous years, is partly due to lockdown limiting social interactions, experts say.'

Parents had very little choice during lockdown, but they do have a choice now.

TheOrigRights · 07/11/2022 13:45

Usernamen · 07/11/2022 12:31

Some people are getting a really hard time for essentially having a flexible employer. So what if your contract says 40 hours and you can get the work done in 10? As long as this is a case of a senior person being on top of task/having enough autonomy to manage down working hours, and other staff are not picking up the slack, I see nothing wrong with it.
I am in a slightly different position in that, rather than doing my job any time I like, my work is so ‘up and down’ that I can be flat out busy for weeks (working very late hours in some cases) and then have absolutely nothing to do for weeks on end. I don’t mean I can get away with just bits of admin, I mean literally no work to do - so I don’t bother logging on and I can go to a pilates class mid-morning and get a pedicure mid-afternoon etc. I don’t feel guilty / like I am taking the piss, because I know as soon as work picks up again I’ll be burning the light at both ends and barely having enough time to eat let alone take myself to pilates/the nail salon.

I can't think how that sort of working pattern would work if you needed childcare when work was hectic, unless you have extremely flexible childcare - like grandparents who are able to be flexible.

nb I realise your post isn't discussing your own childcare situation.