Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should be able to pre book a doctors appointment?

105 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 04/11/2022 08:35

I rarely go, in fact the last time I went was 3 years ago. I've had a few ongoing health concerns which are now starting to effect me and my job, so I called to try and pre book an appointment to fit in with my work hours happy to wait a few weeks even (can't just have time off) and they have told me I now have to ring up at 8am everyday. Today was the first time I was successful ringing, number 2 in the queue first thing and yet even then they seemed to struggle to get me in. She also asked if it was urgent which it isn't so names me feel bad taking the appointment, but it's ongoing and affecting my quality of life. I now have to wait for a doctors call, and he may the treat me over the phone or bring me in. The thing is luckily I have a day off mid week, but when I worked in a school this system would be impossible due to no phones allowed. Its not a fair system for people who work.

OP posts:
Muchtoomuchtodo · 04/11/2022 09:27

My day off work is Mondays.
I can guarantee they every time I contact the surgery on a Monday the appts are for emergencies only.

my issue isn’t an emergency yet. I’d prefer it not to become one but I’m a bit lost at how to avoid that.
any ideas?

BeanieTeen · 04/11/2022 09:26

I just don’t understand the logic or logistics behind this system that’s being used. Maybe someone who works at a surgery or medical centre could explain?

Why can’t people ring up in the morning if they feel they need to be seen that day, but make advanced appointments - ringing up in the day or the evening for something that isn’t immediately urgent? This idea that people don’t have jobs and can sit on the phone in the morning at 8 is really silly (pretty much everyone is busy at that time with commuting to work, being at work, or doing a school run/ getting children ready for school - it’s just bonkers) I have no doubt people put off important yet non immediately urgent things because of this - think mole checks, breast lump checks, certainly testicle lumps or prostate checks! You know men won’t get that checked out at the best of times, never mind when it involves telling your boss you need half an hour off this morning to sit in a telephone queue for an appointment you might not even get…

I’m guessing there must be a reason for this daft and I think damaging system but I really can’t guess what it is, there seems to be little common sense involved - I’d like to be proven wrong. Someone please explain.

Glitteratitar · 04/11/2022 09:16

My GP practice is the same - they don’t offer appointments in advance. You have to call at 8am for morning appointments and 2pm for afternoon appointments. It takes me around two weeks to get an appointment, but I’m lucky that I have a flexible job so can easily carve out time for an appointment. I often wonder what people who don’t have that privilege do.

Once DS was unwell and needed an urgent appointment. I was told they don’t do emergency appointments and I should call 111. 111 sends us to the hospital and we are left waiting several hours in a packed A&E for something the GP should have helped with.

LaGioconda · 04/11/2022 09:13

I wonder why they bother to ask if it's urgent? It's not as if they're going to offer an appointment another day if it isn't, so it seems like a total waste of time asking.

StrataZon · 04/11/2022 09:13

I think its worrying that the GP system is so run down - why would anyone want the pressure & hassle of being a GP?
We need hundreds of GPs across the country, the main reason A&E depts are overrun is people going to them when they should be booking in to see their GP.

This^
A large amount of GPs work is managing chronic conditions. If people with these conditions can't access GP care then they deteriorate and end up at the hospital

StripeyDeckchair · 04/11/2022 09:08

This is exactly what happens at my GP.
Phone at 8am for an appointment on the day, no appointments available for future booking.

I recently discovered (because I politely but firmly pushed the issue) that GPs can book you in themselves for a future appointment but not the receptionist which seems a huge waste of their time.

I think its worrying that the GP system is so run down - why would anyone want the pressure & hassle of being a GP?
We need hundreds of GPs across the country, the main reason A&E depts are overrun is people going to them when they should be booking in to see their GP.

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 09:07

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 04/11/2022 09:00

I have no idea how anyone who works gets an appt, I rock up at the surgery at 8am to ask for an appt otherwise I never get through on the phone line. Thank God I'm flexible and can go pretty much when they offer an appt.

I piss my boss off, that’s how!
I sit unavailable from 8am to about 8:30 waiting in the queue, I sit with my personal phone out in meetings waiting for it to ring, try to avoid client visits as no doubt the call would come while I was on the tube and you obviously can’t call back you’ve just missed your chance, then I dash off to answer the second it rings and then have to leave work with no notice to get the train back home and bring my DD to the surgery.

LizzieSiddal · 04/11/2022 09:04

There is a system for the logic that was already in place before covid though, it was called booked an appointment in advance for non urgent things and phone up on the day for an emergency appointment! How does that not work for everyone?

Our GPs practice have recently changed from this system, I was very worried as you now have to phone, or book online, for that day, however you are guaranteed to see or speak to a GP or nurse that day.
It has actually worked extremely well. (Nurse appointments such as bloods, smears etc, can be booked ahead, plus if the GP thinks you need a follow up appointment, they book it in for you.

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 09:04

@C8H10N4O2 see my water analogy. It is really very straightforward, and nothing to do with poor management of services. I've been a GP for nearly 30 years, seen 3 different practice managers in that time, had literally hundreds of hours of meetings trying to figure out what appointment system to use .

We have tried every possible system - at least 10 different regimes in the time I've been there. We've done pre bookable, book on day, urgent on day, telephone triage, email, different ratios and combinations.

Our list size has got bigger and bigger and we have worked harder and harder, and it is still not enough.
Too many patients, not enough doctors. That's all there is to it.

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 09:03

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:58

"There is a system for the logic that was already in place before covid though, it was called booked an appointment in advance for non urgent things and phone up on the day for an emergency appointment! How does that not work for everyone"

@luxxlisbon but what happens when all the pre-bootable appointments have gone? They get put on the system in 6 week blocks, and are all gone within hours.

And what happens when all the emergency on-the-day slots have gone too?

And pre Covid MN was full of gripes about GP access, so this is nothing new.

Too many patients, not enough doctors. That's it.

It’s shit practice management.
If they are so busy and over run why does my GP block out a doctors time to call me, just to say every time without fail ‘oh for a 1 year old we would really need to see her in person’. Which obviously the receptionist already knew in the first place.
Its operating on a ‘computer says no’ system and employing no logic. It means, through no fault of my own, I’ve used 2 doctor’s slots instead of one.

It’s directly linked to covid, my practice and many others started this system of only being able to do on the day appointment during lockdown and they have stuck with it.

And I’m saying this as someone who agrees with telephone appointments in principle! There are so many things that helps with and suits, but it’s applied across the board with zero thought process.

Lcb123 · 04/11/2022 09:03

Can you message the surgery online? That's our surgery's first step, then they will reply, or book a phone appointment.

hairyunicorn · 04/11/2022 09:03

My GP is online (Babylon), i book appt's online and they are done via video or telephone call. Never have to wait too long for an appt. and can arrange to suit my schedule. have you thought of joining an online GP?

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 04/11/2022 09:00

I have no idea how anyone who works gets an appt, I rock up at the surgery at 8am to ask for an appt otherwise I never get through on the phone line. Thank God I'm flexible and can go pretty much when they offer an appt.

Hoppinggreen · 04/11/2022 08:58

Maze76 · 04/11/2022 08:43

My GP has the same set up for on the day appointments but I can also pre book using an app. It works really well.

That’s the theory at our GPs but I have never been able to book an appointment through the app. There are either none available or if I go on at 8am Precisely I might get one for next month if I’m lucky.
And those are telephone appointments, not seen a GP or nurse in the flesh for a couple of years now

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:58

"There is a system for the logic that was already in place before covid though, it was called booked an appointment in advance for non urgent things and phone up on the day for an emergency appointment! How does that not work for everyone"

@luxxlisbon but what happens when all the pre-bootable appointments have gone? They get put on the system in 6 week blocks, and are all gone within hours.

And what happens when all the emergency on-the-day slots have gone too?

And pre Covid MN was full of gripes about GP access, so this is nothing new.

Too many patients, not enough doctors. That's it.

Mindymomo · 04/11/2022 08:55

When we ring surgery we just ask for a telephone appointment as that’s what you get anyway. Receptionist asks what’s the condition and then GP rings back and if they want to see you will make an appointment. This takes quite a bit of time, I’d say 2/3 minutes to find appointment and sometimes it’s not at surgery but at a local community hospital and I can imagine what happens when the elderly are being told they’ve got to go there. So telephone call has lasted around 8 minutes with GP doing what receptionist should be doing in the first place. DH had appointment with a nurse last week 8.40 am. I asked him how many were in waiting room pre covid there would be at least 20 people, he said 3 people.

C8H10N4O2 · 04/11/2022 08:55

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:45

There is no system that works for everyone.
Some like to pre book, some prefer to ring on the day they feel unwell.
Bottom line - too many patients, not enough doctors.
The country is overpopulated.

No its bad patient management based on assumptions that patient time has no value. It also discriminates heavily against the most disadvantaged. None of this is forced on healthcare by "funding cuts" - its about basic business operations and a presumption that patients time is valueless.

If the costs of patient and employer time were included in NHS operating costs I dread to think what overall costs would be.

cavily1806 · 04/11/2022 08:55

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:52

I'm a GP.
We do prebookable appointments in the afternoon, book-on-day in the morning.
The afternoon slots are booked up within a few hours of the surgery going on the screen.
The on-the-day slots are gone by 10am every day.
We keep a few afternoon slots back for genuine on-the-day emergencies and they all get used too.
We are a nice practice in a nice area and we can't recruit any more doctors. No one applies to job adverts. Our area has seen a lot of building, patient numbers have increased massively, and we're not allowed to turn people away if they live in our area.

I'm baffled at these endless posts wondering why people can get GP or hospital appointments. It's really very basic.

Take a half pint glass and a 1 pint jug. Fill the one pint jug with water, and now try and get all that water in the half pint glass. That is literally the challenge facing the NHS.

Sounds dreadful for you all. I'm so sorry. I think we all appreciate GPs so much. It's the system that's broken after years of Tory rule, not the people on the front line

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:52

I'm a GP.
We do prebookable appointments in the afternoon, book-on-day in the morning.
The afternoon slots are booked up within a few hours of the surgery going on the screen.
The on-the-day slots are gone by 10am every day.
We keep a few afternoon slots back for genuine on-the-day emergencies and they all get used too.
We are a nice practice in a nice area and we can't recruit any more doctors. No one applies to job adverts. Our area has seen a lot of building, patient numbers have increased massively, and we're not allowed to turn people away if they live in our area.

I'm baffled at these endless posts wondering why people can get GP or hospital appointments. It's really very basic.

Take a half pint glass and a 1 pint jug. Fill the one pint jug with water, and now try and get all that water in the half pint glass. That is literally the challenge facing the NHS.

StrataZon · 04/11/2022 08:52

It is truly dreadful now. We are storing up masses of problems down the line as people can't access routine healthcare. I don't know how elderly people are managing.

We are lucky in our GP practice as they have returned to a relatively normal way of working post lockdown. Everything is still triaged but it is possible to book an appointment in advance. But my student DD1s Practice is the same as yours.

Please complain to the practice and your MP. There is a national shortage of GPs and authorities have been warned about this coming for years. It takes years to train a fully qualified GP and Gov has failed to plan for this despite repeated warnings from GP leaders.

luxxlisbon · 04/11/2022 08:49

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:45

There is no system that works for everyone.
Some like to pre book, some prefer to ring on the day they feel unwell.
Bottom line - too many patients, not enough doctors.
The country is overpopulated.

There is a system for the logic that was already in place before covid though, it was called booked an appointment in advance for non urgent things and phone up on the day for an emergency appointment! How does that not work for everyone?

GPs capacity for appointments is a totally different issue to no triaging which ultimately just pisses away resources.

Beees · 04/11/2022 08:49

Ours is the same. No options to book anything the only way you can get an appointment is to ring on the day and see if they can fit you in, physically go to the surgery and wait all morning or by having a gp/nurse book you an appointment at the end of your last appointment (providing you got one in the first place).

It's maddening because sometimes it's not an emergency but you do still need to see someone and yet the only way you can get to see anyone is by being lucky enough to be 1 of the first 20 or so people to get through that morning. This then means that people who actually do need a same day appointment miss out because the appointments are all gone.

Meltinthemiddle · 04/11/2022 08:48

I just don't see how this is fair for people who actually need urgent appointments on the day or people with ongoing issues especially those who work and need to pre book to fit around their job. I'm now limited to what I can do now due to having to wait for a call back and not wanting to miss their call, its rediculous.

OP posts:
cavily1806 · 04/11/2022 08:45

We have a great online triage system. You submit a request online before 11 and they'll always get you in on the day if it's urgent or book you in a few weeks if it needs an appointment but isn't today urgent eg back pain but send you some advice to keep you going til then. Plenty of people complain about the system because you don't get seen/ prescribed antibiotics for a cold etc but I find the system brilliant personally. I understand some elderly may struggle though

Sarahcoggles · 04/11/2022 08:45

There is no system that works for everyone.
Some like to pre book, some prefer to ring on the day they feel unwell.
Bottom line - too many patients, not enough doctors.
The country is overpopulated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread