Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The state of the NHS right now is terrifying

493 replies

Faciadipasta · 04/11/2022 07:25

I am feeling genuinely scared for us as a country health care wise. I was reading today about a chap who died of internal bleeding while his family were kept on hold to 999 for 10 minutes as nobody even answered the phone.
Then there are all the people who die while waiting for an ambulance to arrive, because they are all lined up.outside the hospitals unable to offload their patients.
People can't see a GP at all, so there are bound to be loads who are dying of things that could have been prevented if they'd been seen. Waits at A and E are enormous and they don't even have enough chairs so people with serious injuries or illnesses are having to just sit on the floors in the corridors.
We're actually starting to feel like one of those warzone countries that you see on the news and it is scaring me shitless.
I mean even in the US you wouldn't just be left to die because there was nobody to answer the phone although admittedly you'd probably end up bankrupt for paying back the care, but at least you wouldn't be dead!
I personally feel like we have no care, no safety net. And it's scary.
Will it get better? What can be done?

OP posts:
CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 09:05

People misunderstand the NHS. They think it’s one organisation. They think it’s one funding stream. They think trusts have responsibility for training doctors and nurses.
They have no concept of deaneries, and the fact that anyone below consultant level has limited choice about where they work; nor that some specialities have so few training places there are never going to be enough consultants in that field and that creates backlogs. For vascular neurosurgery, there were two speciality training posts in U.K. last year. Others wanting to train needed to go to John Hopkins or another US centre.

One of the biggest inefficiencies or reducing risk of successful litigation. There’s a huge organisation set up to manage and ‘insure’ against this. The NHS paid £2.4b in clinical negligence claims in 2018-19. This equates to about 2% of the entire budget for the NHS in England (roughly £115bn). NHS Resolution also has to account for claims likely to be received in the future. Now standing at £83.4bn, the amount “set aside” for such claims is among the most substantial public sector financial liabilities faced by the UK government, second only to nuclear decommissioning. That is not entirely because of failings and negligence- only a third of claims actually go to litigation but managing them has become hugely expensive. There used to be Crown immunity but one only needs to read MN to see that people think they can claim for ridiculous things.

Much of the bureaucracy and ‘form filling’ is to appease the authority and reduce risk of successful claims through the CNST programme) clinical negligence scheme for trusts) where the better you can evidence risk reduction the lower the premium to trust. This needs people to manage the process, lots of evidence and takes up much time. Trusts need to have evidence to defend the many claims for compensation brought. That takes more paperwork and more staff and doesn’t necessarily improve care or outcomes. There is no way around this except reinstating crown immunity or a similar scheme.

Social media is another unavoidable nowadays. Both the trust using social media (which takes time and money) but enables messages to be seen by many and improves communication and people running social media campaigns that end up costing the trust millions. There have been two or three fairly recent cases where parental disagreement with a trust over the care and treatment (or withdrawal of treatment) of their child has created massive public campaigns that the trust can’t respond to but which results in a need to spend large amounts on additional security, on staffing, on legal fees, on support services for staff and other parents and on comms. Situations like these, though truly tragic, happen in many trusts on a slightly more local profile weekly. Going to the Court of Protection costs money.

it’s not all about turning lights off and changing sheets less frequently.

memorial · 05/11/2022 09:05

georgarina · 05/11/2022 08:55

I follow a Youtuber in her 20s with cancer. It's terrifying to see surgeries and investigations delayed and cancelled, being rushed to hospital bleeding and vomiting and having to drive to three different hospitals before finding a bed. Due to mismanagement she wasn't diagnosed until she was already stage 3. The service is too stretched and it's unacceptable.

And this is tragic. However IME this far less the norm that you would be led to believe.
On the whole cancer and significant illness care is very well run and prioritised.
But of course that doesn't make such good social media does it.

memorial · 05/11/2022 09:03

Wherediditallgo · 05/11/2022 08:59

How is it to be solved? We all know people who have received poor treatment but what’s the answer? The money has to come from somewhere so it’s either got to be as increased tax or as some form of copayment.

This exactly. But the spoilt British public and corrupt inept government have no will to do this so will just continue to bash those on the forefront for not working hard enough until the whole thing falls apart. And they can blame the workers

memorial · 05/11/2022 09:02

CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 08:00

I’m really curious to understand where people think there are savings to be made and too many managers?

Would you get rid of matrons? Directorate lead nurses? Director of Nursing? Specialist nurses such as the infection prevention and control lead or the site managers? All are doing vital jobs.
What about the Medical Director? The clinical lead for orthopaedic surgery? The Guardian of safe working hours (who also tends to be clinical)?
The complaint manager?
Head of Estates and Facilities? Head of Governance? Safeguarding lead? Theatre manager? Caldecott guardian (usually also has another role and statutory requirement), mortuary manager? Catering manager?

There are lots of managers but these trusts are hugely complex, very large organisations. Some employ over 20,000 staff. That needs managers.

100000% this!
People with absolutely no idea how these huge services run. Who will do all that then? The already massively understaffed clinicians??
As if private businesses have any less management structure!
People who have never worked in the NHS or certainly not at any service lead level pontificating.
It needs more resources the NHS I funded less per capita than almost any other 1sr world health service and relies heavily on staff good will (including the managers spoken of). They are now reaping the years of underfunding and treating staff like shit.

Wherediditallgo · 05/11/2022 08:59

How is it to be solved? We all know people who have received poor treatment but what’s the answer? The money has to come from somewhere so it’s either got to be as increased tax or as some form of copayment.

georgarina · 05/11/2022 08:55

I follow a Youtuber in her 20s with cancer. It's terrifying to see surgeries and investigations delayed and cancelled, being rushed to hospital bleeding and vomiting and having to drive to three different hospitals before finding a bed. Due to mismanagement she wasn't diagnosed until she was already stage 3. The service is too stretched and it's unacceptable.

Wherediditallgo · 05/11/2022 08:48

Medicine has come such a long way since the NHS was started. Looked at all the advanced treatments which are now offered but are considered routine- heart surgery, joint replacements, chemotherapy etc. None of this was available years ago yet we all think it can be covered by paying in the same low level of NI. It’s just not sustainable.

Notthetoothfairy · 05/11/2022 08:21

SpookyMcGhoul · 04/11/2022 07:31

I think the NHS wasn't built to be the service provider it's morphed into today and it's simply not fit for purpose for our large / ageing / ill population. I'm not quite sure what the solution is, but it's just an endless money pit right now!

Same. I’m no economist but honestly don’t understand why there is not enough money for the NHS, schools, decent social services etc when the U.K. charges such huge amounts of tax.

There has to be a massive amount of wastage somewhere but I guess it’s impossible to know where without going through all the accounts with a fine toothcomb. The U.K. should also not have got into any debt.

achangeisafoot · 05/11/2022 08:07

I've always wondered about the getting rid of managers thing too. They did that in our Trust years ago- just culled all the senior leadership roles. It's been a disaster, we're all scrambling on the ground to do the best we can day to day but with no vision, innovation or positive change. We haemorrhaged junior staff because the management job still actually needs doing but now on top of their own job with no support from above. We're just bringing senior managers back it, it's making such a difference already.

CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 08:00

I’m really curious to understand where people think there are savings to be made and too many managers?

Would you get rid of matrons? Directorate lead nurses? Director of Nursing? Specialist nurses such as the infection prevention and control lead or the site managers? All are doing vital jobs.
What about the Medical Director? The clinical lead for orthopaedic surgery? The Guardian of safe working hours (who also tends to be clinical)?
The complaint manager?
Head of Estates and Facilities? Head of Governance? Safeguarding lead? Theatre manager? Caldecott guardian (usually also has another role and statutory requirement), mortuary manager? Catering manager?

There are lots of managers but these trusts are hugely complex, very large organisations. Some employ over 20,000 staff. That needs managers.

HRTQueen · 05/11/2022 07:36

It is very worrying

of course it’s underfunded but it’s terribly mismanaged (the wasted money is eye watering) and has been for a long time you can be critical of both because both are the reason iits in such a dire state

The NHS simply was not set up for the services that are now needed. It has to change we have to look at France or Germany and many of us will need to be paying a lot more towards our healthcare

ask people how they would find it many come back with well add 1p on to tax that won’t touch it we all need to pay for considerably more towards our healthcare and take more personal responsibility (I include myself)

as for the even in America statement. Having been to the states over the summer I can assure you it’s far worse there I was stepping around homeless people in the streets who were shockingly unwell in California a state that is so wealthy it has more money than that vast majority of countries

memorial · 05/11/2022 06:29

containsnuts · 04/11/2022 09:06

@memorial so we shouldn't complain until it sinks to the standard of "third world war zone"?

No but we do those places a disservice acting like our privileged position is in anyvway similar.
I have worked as a HCP in a 3rd world country and I can absolutely assure you it is in no way shape or form in any way similar.

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 22:17

and this one time.... at band camp.....

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 04/11/2022 15:19

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 11:33

Another thing which the NHS won't even look at is alternative medicine. Massage, yoga, acupuncture etc.

I had acupuncture on the NHS at a hospital pain management clinic.

IdealToilet · 04/11/2022 15:04

I do believe there is is trickle down of blame.

Any fully funded service by the tax payer has corruption, the savings required are always put on the actual workforce, labour and public.
The Government will only privatise part of the NHS that requires people to pay for actual labour, labour is costly and harder to steal from, huge contracts of buying will still be in their hands.

So many people in power taking their cut from the huge amounts of money the NHS takes from the tax payer. There is no way a Government would allow or want it to be totally private, although people think that is what the conservatives want, they don't.

The NHS is a huge money cow for those in power, as is the BBC, and other public services.
Until the corruption at higher levels are revealed then the continuation of blaming, the workforce and the public will continue. A never ending cycle of blame that diverts people away from true corruption.

Prestissimo · 04/11/2022 14:58

That's great to hear @BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted - just as it should be. Shame it's not the same for everyone at the moment.

All the best with your tests and getting a diagnosis.

BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted · 04/11/2022 14:53

As a current service-user, still to be diagnosed, my experience of the heath-service has been rather different to what has been discussed on this thread.

Experienced distressing symptoms, phoned the GP surgery asking for an urgent appointment. Received a phone call back from the GP on duty within an hour. Discussed symptoms and was in the surgery for consult less than two hours later, having jumped the queue of patients in the waiting-room.

Had a couple of tests undertaken within days. To date I have had two out-patient appointments, with another this Sunday and a scheduled out-patient diagnostic procedure in a fortnight. All different departments. The hospital I am attending are holding out-patient procedures on the weekends, presumably to catch up on their backlog. I have been impressed by the friendly efficiency of all the practitioners I have so far encountered

Worriedddd · 04/11/2022 14:46

Even the rotas are messed up in the NHS , many private hospitals offer fixed rotas so you can have a life outside of your job and plan accordingly. Many NHS rotas are crap

amicissimma · 04/11/2022 14:31

Within a few posts you have your answer: there are still people who think that the reason the NHS is in such a mess is that 'we' (or the nasty Tories) don't spend enough money on it. While that argument prevails the real issues of dreadful management/organisation/philosophy/insufficient accountability are never going to be addressed.

At last, even the Labour party (Wes Streeting) are beginning to get the message.

I have been involved with the NHS as a user, supplier, volunteer worker and supporter of users since the 1960s. Year on year there are more managers and admin staff drifting about, the requirements to be entered on this system and that system multiply, there's more slightly broken expensive equipment lying in the corridors, more user-unfriendly systems introduced and the waits get longer, the mistakes continue, some of the staff get brusquer and many of the staff get more stressed out. And yet still there are cries for more money.

As a volunteer at Covid injection clinics I have been impressed by how efficiently the pharmacy and off-NHS-premises ones were run. Returning to NHS premises I've been exasperated by the number of managers drifting by, re-organising a perfectly well-running system and making unnecessary demands on both the volunteers and even the vaccinees. Then they bustle off and the volunteers put all the systems back so it runs properly again, but what a waste of resources.

TomTraubertsBlues · 04/11/2022 14:30

Some of the nonsense people post about the NHS on here is crazy.

On another recent thread someone posted that ICU doctors had told her that all ICU medical and nursing staff worked a pattern of 2 weeks on and 6-7 weeks off. And she stated this as fact, despite the fact it is obviously utterly bullshit.

To be charitable, she may have misunderstood and they were actually talking about their on-call rota, but it's more likely that these posters are just making stuff up to spread misinformation to make the NHS seem hugely wasteful.

A bit like the poster on this thread whose brother the 'neurosurgeon' thinks the only problem with the NHS is 'young nurses' taking the piss. Yeah, right.

I don't work for the NHS any more (I'm non clinical and my profession can work jn many industries), and I am very glad I got out. Sympathies to those who are still having to deal with this.

SizzlestheSausageDog · 04/11/2022 14:27

As someone who works in a hospital it is soul destroying when you suggest an improvement or cost saving and get ignored. Then they bring in a management consultant who says the same thing and somehow it means more from Joe Bloggs health consultancy and they actually act on it.

Hudsonriver · 04/11/2022 14:25

TheNosehasit · 04/11/2022 11:43

If woo saves me from back pain, stress, heart strain, obesity, fatigue, mental illness............. then yeah.........

I'll go for 6000 year old proven therapies over pharma.

Or you could exercise, eat properly, cut down on UPF, booze and fags and do a yoga session at home via YouTube.
Lavender bath, hobbies etc

Sorted!

TomTraubertsBlues · 04/11/2022 14:23

TheFeistyFeminist · 04/11/2022 09:31

Some say the NHS is mis-managed. Do those people work in the NHS? Are they seeing it from the inside and saying that, or saying it from the outside?

I work in the system and see it from the inside.

While the higher echelons such as commissioning arrangements, NHS England etc, keep having to re-organise every few years, the frontline services press on with trying to deliver the best care possible, in innovative and money-saving ways.

We try to keep people out of hospital, discharge inpatients at the earliest safe opportunity, increase day surgery provision to tackle waiting lists and so on, but it's never enough.

People who can't get a GP appointment end up at A&E.
People who need ongoing support at home can't get social care support so they remain as an inpatient longer than necessary.
Your local acute hospital trust is squeezed in between those two failings and as a result, is falling short.

But which one ends up on the ten o'clock news? The one with all the ambulances queued up outside.

Before you ask, I've worked in the NHS under Labour and under Conservative, so I have seen a broad range of funding and policy played out.

I agree with this. I have worked both in Trusts and in NHSE. The amount of waste and incompetence I saw in NHSE was off the scale, whereas the Trusts I worked at were generally working hard to be as efficient as they could despite not having enough people. It was depressing to compare the two.

Prestissimo · 04/11/2022 14:21

Ah yes, that makes more sense.

Probably we could get some trained-up sixth formers to give flu jabs, now I think of it Wink

SizzlestheSausageDog · 04/11/2022 14:20

By community I meant chemist *