Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The state of the NHS right now is terrifying

493 replies

Faciadipasta · 04/11/2022 07:25

I am feeling genuinely scared for us as a country health care wise. I was reading today about a chap who died of internal bleeding while his family were kept on hold to 999 for 10 minutes as nobody even answered the phone.
Then there are all the people who die while waiting for an ambulance to arrive, because they are all lined up.outside the hospitals unable to offload their patients.
People can't see a GP at all, so there are bound to be loads who are dying of things that could have been prevented if they'd been seen. Waits at A and E are enormous and they don't even have enough chairs so people with serious injuries or illnesses are having to just sit on the floors in the corridors.
We're actually starting to feel like one of those warzone countries that you see on the news and it is scaring me shitless.
I mean even in the US you wouldn't just be left to die because there was nobody to answer the phone although admittedly you'd probably end up bankrupt for paying back the care, but at least you wouldn't be dead!
I personally feel like we have no care, no safety net. And it's scary.
Will it get better? What can be done?

OP posts:
Whizzi24 · 06/11/2022 10:44

The proportion of frequent attenders has increased over past five years. This might be expected during a pandemic with an ageing population but a sizeable number are children.

Is there evidence of this? I'm surprised that it would have increased during the pandemic when most people were trying to avoid healthcare settings!

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 10:40

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 16:12

Blair used PFI which cost a fortune and takes years to pay off. Are we still? If so that’s adding to the problem we face today.

Looking it up they have stopped using PFI contracts but

A total of 101 NHS trusts are still on the hook for just under £50bn in future unitary payments, despite severe upcoming budgetary challenges, according to a Guardian analysis of hospital trust accounts

We can’t just overinflate through PFI and get real spend that way it just kicks the can to us.

PFI rightly gets a bad name but what was the alternative? add 100s of billions to the national debt, PFI kept these costs of the national balance sheet, government borrowing costs shoot up, then comes GFC, followed by CV and Ukraine - bigger picture is PFI gave future Govt's the head room to borrow.

We would also have had no new hospitals without it and then where would we be now?

We had, in real terms 0 or 1% increases (whilst med inflation was running at 4% in the '10's) in NHS spending during austerity, transferred training costs to students and now wonder why the health service is a mess.

Kendodd · 06/11/2022 10:40

Thing is, a patient wouldn't necessarily know when to see a doctor or not.
I had pneumonia several years ago, when I eventually went to the doctor, I got told off for not coming sooner. The following year, I got sick with what felt like the exact same symptoms at the exact same level and went to a walkin centre. I got told off there for seeking medical attention for something that can be looked after at home.

CaronPoivre · 06/11/2022 09:15

Whizzi24 · 05/11/2022 18:32

It would be interesting to see if there were any statistics on the proportion of health service users who actually go in for thise things, because I'm sure it's a tiny minority and not the reason health services are struggling

In 2015 it was 13.2% of GP attendances for all ages that were more appropriate for treatment with over the counter remedies.

The proportion of frequent attenders has increased over past five years. This might be expected during a pandemic with an ageing population but a sizeable number are children. Frequent attenders tend to be from a certain socioeconomic demographic and is likely reflective of reduced public sector support particularly in poor areas. Loss of family centres, loss of sure start, parenting groups, reduced HV and social work support, greater social isolation result in higher attendance at GPs doors.

Wherediditallgo · 06/11/2022 09:01

Whizzi24 · 05/11/2022 18:32

It would be interesting to see if there were any statistics on the proportion of health service users who actually go in for thise things, because I'm sure it's a tiny minority and not the reason health services are struggling

It’s more common than you think- when my children were small I remember lots of parents going to the doctor with their children for coughs, colds, upset stomachs etc.Maybe now it’s physically impossible to see a doctor people will take a more sensible approach.
The trouble is that once you’ve given it the 3 days to see if things will settle and it hasn’t and you need an appointment but can’t get one, things can end up escalating like the poor person upthread who undoubtedly cost the NHS way more when a simple course of antibiotics early on would have sorted it.
It then becomes a self perpetuating downward spiral. There’s no easy answer, but clinging to the old model isn’t working.
The NHS has never balanced the books- not even at the beginning.

glitterwobbles · 05/11/2022 23:38

The system is broken. I was refered urgently to see a neurosurgeon as I have spinal cord compression. The referral was made in june 2021 and I have an appointment in Dec.
I have been ringing every month after waiting a year, and was removed from the list at one point. Apparently an admin error.
I live with daily headaches, am losing sensation in my arms and my balance has been affected.
I am a nurse and know how hard everyone on the frontline works there just aren't enough medical staff and nurses. I also object to people saying that staff go off sick to play the system. I have not taken time off and have swopped my shift for my appointment.
There are seven million on waiting lists, 10 hour waits in A&E and it's almost impossible to see my G.P.
I don't know what the answers are but we need to fix it before it completely falls apart.

Whizzi24 · 05/11/2022 18:32

CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 17:09

We definitely need to be a little less dependent and start treating coughs, colds, D&V, warts, verrucas, earwax, cracked feet, everyday headaches, bites and stings with over the counter or homely remedies. We also need to understand that GPs aren’t there to parent or sort bad behaviour and that sometimes short term sadness and worries are normal emotions, not mental health problems.

It would be interesting to see if there were any statistics on the proportion of health service users who actually go in for thise things, because I'm sure it's a tiny minority and not the reason health services are struggling

MissyB1 · 05/11/2022 17:13

TheNosehasit · 05/11/2022 12:12

The funny thing is that what that depicted in 2012 is happening in the reverse now. Whereas it starts out with the grim reaper and nurses as drones, it then progresses to happy times where all the children are getting better and the nurses are jumping for joy, the reverse is happening.

Yep we have literally gone back in time, how depressing 😕 Why oh why did the public allow this to happen?

Wallaw · 05/11/2022 17:11

MintyFreshOne · 04/11/2022 07:59

Not true

@MintyFreshOne
@sorrynotathome

This isn't true. Hospitals and A&E in the US must provide care regardless of insurance status.

For anyone interested, some statistics on Americans and health insurance since the introduction of the ACA

www.statista.com/topics/3272/obamacare/#dossierKeyfigures

CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 17:09

We definitely need to be a little less dependent and start treating coughs, colds, D&V, warts, verrucas, earwax, cracked feet, everyday headaches, bites and stings with over the counter or homely remedies. We also need to understand that GPs aren’t there to parent or sort bad behaviour and that sometimes short term sadness and worries are normal emotions, not mental health problems.

CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 17:05

The efficacy of the vaccines is well documented. You’re being deliberately provocative or are seriously challenged in the grey matter department and struggling to understand basic data.

woohoowoohoo · 05/11/2022 17:04

But I agree about social care. My relative was bed blocking for at least a week and in the end we discharged him without a care package (which luckily has been fine )

woohoowoohoo · 05/11/2022 17:02

In my family we've had two emergencies in the past few months and an ambulance came immediately and there was excellent care. One time it was called for us by 111 who correctly diagnosed it was an emergency . There's definitely a massive issue but it's not all bad , we've had a really good experience both times .

MakeMineALarge1 · 05/11/2022 17:00

Aishah231 · 05/11/2022 16:56

We could stop spending billions on covid vaccines that at best don't work very well!

Evidence please?
ICU are not overrun with Covid
Each one I've seen, covid is an incidental finding .

Aishah231 · 05/11/2022 16:56

We could stop spending billions on covid vaccines that at best don't work very well!

MakeMineALarge1 · 05/11/2022 16:55

I've worked a shift in ICU today
We have a patient in who doesn't need an ICU bed but has been in 3 weeks as we can't find a suitable place for them to go! One bed.
We cannot admit into that bed.
We have to provide a nurse.
Today we had capacity to accept the 3 admissions.
My unit is now full.
We cannot admit any more, but this PT will remain with us as there's no where for them.

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 16:45

MakeMineALarge1 · 05/11/2022 16:27

As a nation we don't help ourselves, we eat too much, don't take exercise, drink too much and take drugs. Yes I am generalising but a lot of issues wouldn't be there if we were all healthier.

Secondly we don't expect to be ill, we want instant gratification, we should expect coughs colds etc, but we don't we ring and demand appointment's with GP, when most illness will run themselves out, ringing and demanding an appmnt for a headache when you haven't even taken a paracetomol is ridiculous! Yes this does happen.

If we used GP/Pharmacist correctly, this may relieve pressure on a&E

But ultimately we need good social care, this is where the blockage is in hospital, lack of good social care for our elderly.

People are getting appointments regularly with their GP, but they are not always the ones who most need them!

Yes agree with all this too

MakeMineALarge1 · 05/11/2022 16:27

As a nation we don't help ourselves, we eat too much, don't take exercise, drink too much and take drugs. Yes I am generalising but a lot of issues wouldn't be there if we were all healthier.

Secondly we don't expect to be ill, we want instant gratification, we should expect coughs colds etc, but we don't we ring and demand appointment's with GP, when most illness will run themselves out, ringing and demanding an appmnt for a headache when you haven't even taken a paracetomol is ridiculous! Yes this does happen.

If we used GP/Pharmacist correctly, this may relieve pressure on a&E

But ultimately we need good social care, this is where the blockage is in hospital, lack of good social care for our elderly.

People are getting appointments regularly with their GP, but they are not always the ones who most need them!

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 16:20

And outside that issue if you want to increase health and social protection past half government total expenditure, where from?For the ageing population issue

Incoming ‘tax the rich’ - to a point as the top end have options, middle won’t take much more taxing

Plus net zero issue looming which costs

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 16:12

Blair used PFI which cost a fortune and takes years to pay off. Are we still? If so that’s adding to the problem we face today.

Looking it up they have stopped using PFI contracts but

A total of 101 NHS trusts are still on the hook for just under £50bn in future unitary payments, despite severe upcoming budgetary challenges, according to a Guardian analysis of hospital trust accounts

We can’t just overinflate through PFI and get real spend that way it just kicks the can to us.

walkinginsunshinekat · 05/11/2022 16:02

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 12:56

Having a look around the Google it seems real terms spending has increased over time. Orange line for health. the Covid years up sharply which makes sense.

Grey line up hugely too which is likely all the furlough etc

Social protection up steadily probably mostly due to ageing population.

Heath and social protection (welfare and pensions) is about half of total spend.

We are heading into an ageing population
‘The UK's population is undergoing a massive age shift. There are over 11 million people aged 65 and in ten years' time this will have increased to 13 million people, 22% of the population.’

This is hard to deal with especially when a political party finds it hard, or we do, to talk about what is facing us and how to do it with the NHS model. A model that was good but was conceived before these issues became more pronounced.

Yes and you can see from your graph, it pretty much flat lined between 2010 and 2015 and did not increase significantly after that until CV.

Blair almost doubled the amount spent - since 2010 it has gone nothing like as much (CV aside) & thats why we are in a mess.
What was the first thing the Tories did after 2015? removed the bursary & hasn't that worked out so well!

Remember too, medical inflation runs at approx double that of CPI and in real terms, a nurse earns around 20% less now. than he/she was on in the mid 90s.

On sickness rates in NHS, perhaps @PolaDeVeboise can struggle in with a heavy cold or a strapped up ankle in office/WFH and get by, a Porter/Paramedic/Nurse/Dr cannot.

CaronPoivre · 05/11/2022 15:47

And they'd understand waste disposal and air filtration systems how?
Doctors are employed to provide medical and surgical care not to run an SSD department or make soup.

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2022 12:56

Having a look around the Google it seems real terms spending has increased over time. Orange line for health. the Covid years up sharply which makes sense.

Grey line up hugely too which is likely all the furlough etc

Social protection up steadily probably mostly due to ageing population.

Heath and social protection (welfare and pensions) is about half of total spend.

We are heading into an ageing population
‘The UK's population is undergoing a massive age shift. There are over 11 million people aged 65 and in ten years' time this will have increased to 13 million people, 22% of the population.’

This is hard to deal with especially when a political party finds it hard, or we do, to talk about what is facing us and how to do it with the NHS model. A model that was good but was conceived before these issues became more pronounced.

The state of the NHS right now is terrifying
endofthelinefinally · 05/11/2022 12:39

Mobiledesktop · 04/11/2022 11:11

It would help if so many GP's didn't just work 2 or 3 days a week. They are simply on such good money that they can afford to do this.
Someone in government really needs to take on the GP's and the BMA. It has to be 5 days a week or nothing.
Otherwise we have to train endless amounts of people (or import them) to fill the rota.
If they are saying the working day is too long then let's look at that.
A country needs people that have to work. It's a fact of life. If you pay huge salaries and offer part time hours then you are incredibly foolish if you think that people won't take advantage and put their lifestyle first.

I worked in GP for years before I retired. The first GP arrived at 7.30 am and worked through till about 4, the next arrived about 10.00 and worked through to 7.30pm. Lunch times were meetings/clinical and budget, there were 3 partners and they did 2 late evening surgeries, 3 early bird surgeries, baby clinics, minor surgery, care home visits, and a Saturday morning surgery. They were also part of the the 111 GP on call service. Just because a GP is available in the surgery 3 days a week doesn't mean they are sat with their feet up doing nothing. Part time for a GP is usually more than average full time hours for a lot of employees. We need more GPs and there simply aren't enough.

LadyWithLapdog · 05/11/2022 12:38

@somethinsomethin sorry about your friend. It can be a tough call knowing what’s the right thing to do. OTOH someone was telling me she wants to sue the ambulance trust as she was told it’d be a 3h wait and to make her own way to the hospital. She did ask a neighbour but thought taxiing was part of the service.

Swipe left for the next trending thread