Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The state of the NHS right now is terrifying

493 replies

Faciadipasta · 04/11/2022 07:25

I am feeling genuinely scared for us as a country health care wise. I was reading today about a chap who died of internal bleeding while his family were kept on hold to 999 for 10 minutes as nobody even answered the phone.
Then there are all the people who die while waiting for an ambulance to arrive, because they are all lined up.outside the hospitals unable to offload their patients.
People can't see a GP at all, so there are bound to be loads who are dying of things that could have been prevented if they'd been seen. Waits at A and E are enormous and they don't even have enough chairs so people with serious injuries or illnesses are having to just sit on the floors in the corridors.
We're actually starting to feel like one of those warzone countries that you see on the news and it is scaring me shitless.
I mean even in the US you wouldn't just be left to die because there was nobody to answer the phone although admittedly you'd probably end up bankrupt for paying back the care, but at least you wouldn't be dead!
I personally feel like we have no care, no safety net. And it's scary.
Will it get better? What can be done?

OP posts:
LadyWithLapdog · 07/11/2022 07:56

Private health insurance does not cover emergency care. In many cases it doesn’t even cover investigations. Not to mention pre-existing conditions.

Bramblejoos · 07/11/2022 07:56

Yes you do - seems you have to fill in a form , might have to pay if you make several requests -
www.nhslothian.scot/YourRights/DataProtection/Pages/Subject-Access-Requests.aspx

CaronPoivre · 07/11/2022 07:55

You can access and get copies of your medical records but it is expensive and time consuming for healthcare providers. It’s not about being sued, it’s about not wasting money when they’re resources are so stretched.

CaronPoivre · 07/11/2022 07:53

Bramblejoos · 07/11/2022 05:22

You can see your own GP medical records online
www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/about-the-nhs/how-to-get-your-medical-records/
You can ask the hospital to see your records.

People would lose their paper health records so not reliable.

There is legislation that requires all healthcare providers to maintain comprehensive records of care and treatment provided. The red book scheme quickly showed lots of people lose personal records. What would happen for records of people with dementia or learning disabilities where there was no LPA?

Records have become more complex with more NHS services being handed to independent sector. There isn’t a single record system and patients need to consent to information sharing between providers.

Completely open records aren’t workable either - would you want your local pharmacist, an ambulance technician or a podiatrist knowing about your incontinence, an assault or an STD, for example?

Wherediditallgo · 07/11/2022 07:02

I’m in Scotland and we have no access to medical records as far as I know.

Bramblejoos · 07/11/2022 05:22

Wherediditallgo · 06/11/2022 17:32

A really simple solution to the poor communication would be to have our own copy of records/ reports etc from each of the departments to take wherever we are going next in case we have to move across heath regions for treatment.
I would have thought the expense of this would be saved by helping to streamline time between appointments ie they can’t say they haven’t seen test results or a report from the previous consultant.

You can see your own GP medical records online
www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/about-the-nhs/how-to-get-your-medical-records/
You can ask the hospital to see your records.

People would lose their paper health records so not reliable.

TroopOfFlyingMonkeys · 07/11/2022 03:15

Faciadipasta · 06/11/2022 16:11

Sorry @LordNelsonsPigStatues but in my area at least, your wrong. The NHS as a concept is brilliant, certainly, but if you can't access help when you really need it then that is a serious problem. And you can piss off calling me 'privileged' for wanting to be able to get healthcare for my family.
Honestly I could real off at least 6 times when we as a family (and im talking nuclear family of me, DH and 2 dc here not wider family) have been seriously let down, that would have led to VERY serious consequences. I also know 2 young people (30s) who died of very treatable cancers because they were not able to.see GPs for a long time, and then were repeatedly fobbed off when they did manange to get seen, which meant their cancer was diagnosed too late.
I was absolutely not suggesting we adopt a US style system though if that's what got your back up?

Same thing happened to my lovely, very physically fit friend. She died aged 33. NHS entirely culpable, completely preventable. She should still be here.

TroopOfFlyingMonkeys · 07/11/2022 03:13

Lucy7890 · 06/11/2022 17:55

I'm job hunting now and started to value private health insurance above public pension which I may or may not be able to use in 25 years' time. I already pay private for dental and MH treatment for my child, and would not go back.

Agreed. I'd never switch jobs now without private health care and dental care (that covers my children also) matching what I have now. Still have to pay for it through tax obviously! But it us now essential because every treatment they or I have needed for the past two years has had to be done privately or it would still not have happened. And yet a huge chunk of my salary is still deducted for the NHS which has effectively ceased to exist. My father would also he dead by now (twice!!) if not for private healthcare. It's sick how many people are suffering. This system has collapsed.

ViolinPin · 06/11/2022 18:13

Wherediditallgo · 06/11/2022 17:32

A really simple solution to the poor communication would be to have our own copy of records/ reports etc from each of the departments to take wherever we are going next in case we have to move across heath regions for treatment.
I would have thought the expense of this would be saved by helping to streamline time between appointments ie they can’t say they haven’t seen test results or a report from the previous consultant.

This is what happens in America is it not ?

For some resaon the NHS are not too keen on you having access to your own private mediacal records.

I wonder why that is ?
Less law suits ?

Lucy7890 · 06/11/2022 17:55

I'm job hunting now and started to value private health insurance above public pension which I may or may not be able to use in 25 years' time. I already pay private for dental and MH treatment for my child, and would not go back.

Wherediditallgo · 06/11/2022 17:32

A really simple solution to the poor communication would be to have our own copy of records/ reports etc from each of the departments to take wherever we are going next in case we have to move across heath regions for treatment.
I would have thought the expense of this would be saved by helping to streamline time between appointments ie they can’t say they haven’t seen test results or a report from the previous consultant.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 06/11/2022 17:31

Having used Bupa this year, I can assure you that isn't a very good option either. I actually got NHS physio appointment before an appointment was made privately. And I literally had to justify every small bit of treatment and tests. At a time of serious illness it was very frustrating. And my Bupa insurance doesn't allow for a second opinion so I'm waiting on NHS now anyway because the BUPA doctor was shit.

SnitterBug · 06/11/2022 16:14

Noticed a lot of adverts for Bupa . I'm scared this is where we're heading if we want any decent health care .

Faciadipasta · 06/11/2022 16:11

Sorry @LordNelsonsPigStatues but in my area at least, your wrong. The NHS as a concept is brilliant, certainly, but if you can't access help when you really need it then that is a serious problem. And you can piss off calling me 'privileged' for wanting to be able to get healthcare for my family.
Honestly I could real off at least 6 times when we as a family (and im talking nuclear family of me, DH and 2 dc here not wider family) have been seriously let down, that would have led to VERY serious consequences. I also know 2 young people (30s) who died of very treatable cancers because they were not able to.see GPs for a long time, and then were repeatedly fobbed off when they did manange to get seen, which meant their cancer was diagnosed too late.
I was absolutely not suggesting we adopt a US style system though if that's what got your back up?

OP posts:
LordNelsonsPigStatues · 06/11/2022 15:58

sorrynotathome has it. It’s not perfect no. But over a decade of a shitty govt who are ideologically opposed to the nhs and subsequently underfunding it will do that for a health service.

I mean even in the US you wouldn't just be left to die because there was nobody to answer the phone although admittedly you'd probably end up bankrupt for paying back the care, but at least you wouldn't be dead!

Do you know how many people avoid using healthcare in the US because of how much it costs? How many won’t even call an ambulance because the price tag runs into the thousands? Do you have any clue how many Americans die purely because they can’t afford to be seen by a dr, or have life saving treatment precisely because they will go bankrupt? Yes, actually, many Americans die because of the way the health system is run. Are you aware that the single biggest cause of bankruptcy in the US is healthcare bills?

The nhs is not perfect, but it’s fucking brilliant. Us brits don’t have a clue how good we have it here. Your criticisms of the nhs are so privileged it’s unreal. Yours sincerely, dual citizen of the U.K. and the states.

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2022 15:50

fiftiesmum · 06/11/2022 15:18

We have a system which was set up in the days when if you were diagnosed with some conditions eg cancer, heart attack, kidney failure, diabetes it was basically curtains for the vast majority. Scientists have developed treatments for these conditions where many people have nearly normal life expectancy which is a wonderful thing but require treatment and monitoring which is both labour intensive and expensive - we have not increased taxes to cover this or trained staff in time.

It’s difficult to match the burden with this model though. So the strain will increase unless it changes. But politically it’s not easy, understandably in many ways.

NoSkiing · 06/11/2022 15:47

That’s a good assessment @fiftiesmum
The answer is more doctor, nurses and staff.
But berating the doctors (GPs) who are still here and not quite won’t help train them. For those saying Gps should work 100 hours a week, if police or teachers or Tesco staff were made to do that, then of course most would refuse quit or make mistakes. The reason you can’t see a GP is they are already working 12 hour days and more than most people full time and need more funding to have more staff. Same with hospitals where are minimal staff on weekends and nights. You can’t just make all staff work 100 weeks to cover, in its current state you would lose staff 9-5 Monday to Friday to cover nights and weekends. The answer is just more funding and more staff and better management. NHS management is top heavy and totally shit.
But don’t blame the staff working hard still here, there the ones here!

fiftiesmum · 06/11/2022 15:18

We have a system which was set up in the days when if you were diagnosed with some conditions eg cancer, heart attack, kidney failure, diabetes it was basically curtains for the vast majority. Scientists have developed treatments for these conditions where many people have nearly normal life expectancy which is a wonderful thing but require treatment and monitoring which is both labour intensive and expensive - we have not increased taxes to cover this or trained staff in time.

Whizzi24 · 06/11/2022 14:22

Yes, I guess best case is inefficient, worst case serious issues must be missed.

Perhaps smaller, local diagnostic hubs where you could have x-rays, blood tests, ultrasounds etc could help the system so people didn't always have to go to hospitals. Of course, many smaller hospitals where these sorts if things used to be done have been closed down over the years.

MakeMineALarge1 · 06/11/2022 14:16

@Whizzi24 you're right
The system is so bloody fragmented and no one talks to each other and the lack of documentation between department is truly frightening

Whizzi24 · 06/11/2022 13:37

I guess I am just surprised that there are people who wish to spend hours hanging on the phone at 8am in the hope they might get an appointment for their verruca!

What I have noticed as my DC is suffering from an ongoing medical issue that nobody seems to diagnose, is the lack of joining the dots which I think also wastes time. We have had to have several appointments over the last three or four months, all a huge hassle to arrange. Managed to get a face to face appointment back in the summer holidays (great for me as a teacher) with an issue. However, the GP did not examine my DC at the time and prescribed cream by listening to me describe symptoms. Might as well have been a phone appointment. Then could only get phone appointments for the next 6 weeks. After nearly 2 months, managed to get the first face-to-face appointment where someone actually examined her. They suspected possible hernia so did an ultrasound referral but was worried it would take too long so sent us to A&E (of course, if we had a speedy referral system, A&E visit would not have been necessary). Also, if the first GP had just done an examination, we could have ruled out the things they kept prescribing antibiotics for which turned out to be for a misdiagnosis.

Seen by surgical team at A&E - ruled out hernia but thought it might be another condition which needed diagnosing via ultrasound. Roll on ultrasound scan 4 weeks later and the radiologist is only looking for hernia symptoms even though that had already been ruled out. He only checked for the other issue because I, the parent, raised it as a possibility. Now DC might have to have an MRI scan, but I can't find out more until the report is read by a doctor at my surgery, which will take a week even though it is sent automatically to them electronically and added to DC's file. Then I will have to make another appointment to talk through next steps as I feel like I am the only one actually in possession of all the information. It is such a ludicrous and time consuming system.

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 13:07

Topgub · 06/11/2022 10:46

@Whizzi24

People avoiding health care settings only really lasted for the first long down

And since then there has been a massive increase.

That lock down caused a huge number of problems

While the numbers of people contacting NHS 111 and phoning for an ambulance were above pre-pandemic levels – and at historic highs – other measures of activity, such as elective care and emergency admissions, remained at or below those seen in 2019

Health.org.uk March 2022.

A poor health service has costs.

The Health Foundation’s analysis finds that by the second quarter of 2022, 200,000 older workers (age 50–69) had left employment due to ill-health since the start of the pandemic: the biggest contributor to the recent rise in economic inactivity for that group. Ill-health is defined as 'people reporting they are temporarily sick or injured or long-term sick and disabled'

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 11:08

It effectively ceased to exist a while ago. None of the treatment people in my family need is being done at all.

CaronPoivre · 06/11/2022 11:01

Whizzi24 · 06/11/2022 10:44

The proportion of frequent attenders has increased over past five years. This might be expected during a pandemic with an ageing population but a sizeable number are children.

Is there evidence of this? I'm surprised that it would have increased during the pandemic when most people were trying to avoid healthcare settings!

There is. Note it isn't all attendances (although they've increased hugely) but frequent attenders I am talking about. Those for whom other sources of support have vanished with the first philosophical stance of austerity.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 10:46

@Whizzi24

People avoiding health care settings only really lasted for the first long down

And since then there has been a massive increase.

That lock down caused a huge number of problems