Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The state of the NHS right now is terrifying

493 replies

Faciadipasta · 04/11/2022 07:25

I am feeling genuinely scared for us as a country health care wise. I was reading today about a chap who died of internal bleeding while his family were kept on hold to 999 for 10 minutes as nobody even answered the phone.
Then there are all the people who die while waiting for an ambulance to arrive, because they are all lined up.outside the hospitals unable to offload their patients.
People can't see a GP at all, so there are bound to be loads who are dying of things that could have been prevented if they'd been seen. Waits at A and E are enormous and they don't even have enough chairs so people with serious injuries or illnesses are having to just sit on the floors in the corridors.
We're actually starting to feel like one of those warzone countries that you see on the news and it is scaring me shitless.
I mean even in the US you wouldn't just be left to die because there was nobody to answer the phone although admittedly you'd probably end up bankrupt for paying back the care, but at least you wouldn't be dead!
I personally feel like we have no care, no safety net. And it's scary.
Will it get better? What can be done?

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 04/11/2022 09:10

Testina · 04/11/2022 08:28

Why?

Why?

Because getting to see a GP for anything non urgent is so demanding it’s more or less a FT job and for most people it’s just not workable.

To take my situation as an example. At my GP practice in SE London (which I think is not atypical), there are no bookable appointments at all now. The only ways to get seen, short of going to A&E are:

a) (in theory) phone the surgery from 8am for a same day appointment. The switchboard is inundated from 8am until about 10am. Invariably by the time someone picks up, all appointments for the day are gone
b) (in theory) book appointments online the night before. See point a. It just isn’t ever possible.
c) Queue up outside the GP’s office, dole queue style, for a same day appointment. You can usually get an appointment this way but at massive inconvenience.

In cases a and c this realistically takes a half day off work minimum to get booked in and seen. In theory case b is designed to circumvent this but there are almost never appointments available.

So unless you have something that requires urgent attention it’s very difficult to justify taking a half day off work several times a year to get advice on something which quite likely will turn out to be trivial.

We are always been told about the importance of vigilance, early intervention and being proactive about one’s health. The problem is that if you have a job and/or childcare responsibilities this is virtually impossible to achieve within the NHS without jeopardising your livelihood.

No wonder so many people brush potential health issues under the carpet and put things off until it’s too late.

Davros · 04/11/2022 09:08

Much of what you’ve quoted is the extreme stuff - yes it’s happening but it’s not universal. Yes we should demand better but there’s no point getting hysterical.
I agree with notathome. I have extensive experience of using the NHS, As does much of my family. I don't find it "terrifying". E.G. I sent a message and photos to my GP last Friday morning, I got a phone call a few hours later, they wanted me to go in at 2pm which I couldn't manage so at 3.30pm i was there, got seen and a prescription, reviewed in person this Wednesday. This is typical. I've had knee physio recently, been to the lymphoedema clinic, multiple scans etc. this is recent experience but typical for me and many of my family

GoldIsMyBirthMetal · 04/11/2022 09:07

Tomatoeplantpants · 04/11/2022 07:37

To the poster who said we should have access to a G.P twenty four hours a day. That’s great in principle but we haven’t even got enough G.Ps to cover the current working day.

Exactly, there is already an out-of-hours GP service covering the whole UK, but in many places no or very limited GPs to staff it.

Lots of “timewasters” potentially could have something wrong, are concerned about something but not able to judge if significant or do not have access in hours to what they think they need. Of course there are some with no excuse.

crossstitchingnana · 04/11/2022 09:06

My local hospital has declared two critical incidents in recent weeks. All because they are struggling to cope with demand.

containsnuts · 04/11/2022 09:06

@memorial so we shouldn't complain until it sinks to the standard of "third world war zone"?

Carriemac · 04/11/2022 09:03

it's bad but not that bad . i can easily access GP care via phone or in person , online for prescriptions etc and it's all working welll.
i think you are being very insulting to NHSs staff who are overworked and underfunded and deliver a por under resourced service . i am one of this staff, i earn less than two of my recently graduated children after 30
years in healthcare ( i'm fairly senior and have a phd )
my only child that earns less than me is a junior doctor, working in ED at the moment for 29k a year after 6 years of university

Labraradabrador · 04/11/2022 09:02

sorrynotathome · 04/11/2022 07:30

In the US you wouldn’t receive care if you couldn’t provide proof of funds beforehand.

Much of what you’ve quoted is the extreme stuff - yes it’s happening but it’s not universal. Yes we should demand better but there’s no point getting hysterical.

Not true - hospitals are legally required to treat you in an emergency in the US regardless of insurance/ ability to pay. They will then seek payment afterwards, and it might well bankrupt you, but as op says you would still be alive.

CookPassBabtridge · 04/11/2022 09:01

I can't fault my recent hospital stay really, lots of staff, very attentive, clean, efficient.. but took 15 months to get my op. But yes the state of A&E, drs apps, wait times etc.. scary.

Topgub · 04/11/2022 09:01

minipie · 04/11/2022 08:56

I agree with the posters saying we are expecting too much for too little money. Everything is overstretched. It’s a vicious circle, staff leave because they are overwhelmed and so the remaining staff are even more stretched.

The NHS at conception was never intended to offer every treatment under the sun, including very expensive medications and surgeries. And it wasn’t set up to deal with an ageing, overweight population who take the NHS for granted and have high expectations.

We either need to pay more (be that in tax, insurance, or fees at the point of use) or we need to accept that the NHS cannot offer everything to everyone. If the latter then it would be better to pare back what the NHS offere and do that well, than have the current scenario where in theory the NHS does everything but in practice it’s struggling to do any of it well.

As a PP said we need to pick our poison.

👏👏

Topgub · 04/11/2022 09:00

@Kissingfrogs25

The idea that businesses run things better with no waste is laughable.

Or that other health care systems also don't cost billions

It makes no sense to me that people complain about the cost of health care and the think, I know what will help!

Profit!

Mrmoody · 04/11/2022 09:00

And I agree the nhs is struggling, but my mum had a cancer scare and got seen in an hour by the gp and had testing within a week, my 9 month old had a chest infection and was at the gp within 30 minutes with an appointment.. so yes it's a pain I had to wait 3 weeks to see the gp, but when you need it they are there

Mrmoody · 04/11/2022 08:58

@CaronPoivre of course crews don't choose to outside a hospital, you know they get told which one to go to right? My DH spent 4 hours queueing out of area at a hospital as that was the one he was told to go to, but the hospital back in area was quieter.. if they don't follow control they are the ones risking their job (and yes it has happened)

memorial · 04/11/2022 08:56

Your whole post is hysterical and over dramatic and over exaggerated. Of course there are huge issues in the NHS but go and live in the 3rd world/war zone for a few months or pay for services system and let's see what you think.
And I am going to object personally to this one
People can't see a GP at all, so there are bound to be loads who are dying of things that could have been prevented
Myself and every other GP I know must be imagining the thousands of patient contacts then, urgent care, mental health, possible cancer diagnoses, chronic disease medicine. Not only are we having more contacts and FTF appts than before COVID, we are having increasing pressures to "go back to normal". There is no normal. This is the only way to manage the massive demand currently with ever reducing staff and resources.

minipie · 04/11/2022 08:56

I agree with the posters saying we are expecting too much for too little money. Everything is overstretched. It’s a vicious circle, staff leave because they are overwhelmed and so the remaining staff are even more stretched.

The NHS at conception was never intended to offer every treatment under the sun, including very expensive medications and surgeries. And it wasn’t set up to deal with an ageing, overweight population who take the NHS for granted and have high expectations.

We either need to pay more (be that in tax, insurance, or fees at the point of use) or we need to accept that the NHS cannot offer everything to everyone. If the latter then it would be better to pare back what the NHS offere and do that well, than have the current scenario where in theory the NHS does everything but in practice it’s struggling to do any of it well.

As a PP said we need to pick our poison.

achangeisafoot · 04/11/2022 08:56

I'm an NHS worker, the problem isn't plenty of money and mismanagement- the problem is that no one applies for our jobs. And this isn't a brexit thing, this has been happening for years.

So while people sit around and criticise how we're trying to work this (yes my service has a 2 year waiting list, yes I desperately wish it didn't, yes I get up at 5am most days to try to clear the back log of work before I officially start being paid at 9am, yes my service has several vacancies it cannot fill) maybe sit back and ask why you're not applying for these posts? Why you didn't train in a caring professional and then maybe you'll see why those of us who did are so frazzled trying to do it.

I'm not saying the NHS is perfect, it isn't, but lots of us are trying really bloody hard.

drawstringbags · 04/11/2022 08:55

I live in a European country. Where I live GP is free as is paediatrician for all under 14s. You can see them on the same day, they also home visit if necessary. You don't pay for emergency a&e.
We do pay, proportionately to income, for some tests and some interventions. For example an ecg for someone on low/middle income costs around 18€ . It would have been more for those on higher income, and less for those on lower. 10 physiotherapy visits cost around 35€.
A full range of blood work, done and results back within the week costs us around 25€, again, there will be those that pay more, and those next to nothing.
I'm not saying this system is better, it's just not a frightening way of doing things and people don't stop getting treatment because of the costs.

DashboardConfessional · 04/11/2022 08:53

HavingABadHairDayToday · 04/11/2022 08:50

Well I’ll be dead if it becomes payable. I can’t get travel insurance for my condition and my mortgage broker was unable to extend my life insurance to cover the entirety of the cost of our house. My life insurance only covers about 2/3 of the house cost, that’s how bad my condition it. I take 7 prescriptions every two months. At NHS rates, that’s around £70 but I know for a fact that just one of my tablets costs the NHS £600 for a months supply which I couldn’t afford. If it all goes private then I’ll really be stuck, as will plenty of people like me.

Exactly. Anyone with autoimmune conditions which normally multiply (my own mum has rheumatoid arthritis requiring biologics) would be absolutely fucked.

And I suspect this shower of shit government's definition of "people who can't afford it" would be very narrow.

Kissingfrogs25 · 04/11/2022 08:52

We are ageing nation, this is only going to be a million times worse in a few years or less.

The quicker we can move over the Australian model the better. We simply can not continue with the illusion that we can keep pouring tens of billions into a system and see it evaporate. We need private companies to run the NHS as a business so that waste is reduced to the bare minimum, and we all need to start paying directly for the NHS services through a tax of some kind.
A brand new model and the biggest overhaul since its conception is what is required.
The NHS was simply not designed to cater for every single health need known to civilisation. It started as emergency help for those too poor to pay and since then has exploded into doing absolutely everything. It is failed business model and will never work, it does not matter how much you invest, it is a bottomless pit.

The NHS is not sustainable and hasn't been for years, decades.

Not a single party will touch it, but someone has to eventually grasp the nettle.

Those saying reduce waste, well that was what the hospital managers and very well paid consultants were there to do - and they have failed miserably for the best part of twenty years plus.

We need root and branch change, and quickly.

Pottedpalm · 04/11/2022 08:51

Family member is a surgeon. They frequently find that they attend for a shift expecting to perform maybe three procedures, which they have thoroughly prepped for. Anaesthetist and theatre staff all in place. Then they are told that the surgery cant go ahead as the patient(s) haven't had all the necessary tests. Sometimes they may do only one, or even no, surgery at all.
My own DB was scheduled, after much waiting, for brain surgery on a Monday. On theFriday afternoon he had a call from the hospital asking him why he hadn’t had a pre-op. Asking him! They said it was urgent. He had not been given an appt and ended up being sent to a hospital more than an hour away where it could be done.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 04/11/2022 08:51

malificent7 · 04/11/2022 07:33

I blame the government. If they funded it properly it would improve. I think they want a US system as it fits their capitalist ideology.

Which is what Sunak was gunning for all along.

HavingABadHairDayToday · 04/11/2022 08:50

Well I’ll be dead if it becomes payable. I can’t get travel insurance for my condition and my mortgage broker was unable to extend my life insurance to cover the entirety of the cost of our house. My life insurance only covers about 2/3 of the house cost, that’s how bad my condition it. I take 7 prescriptions every two months. At NHS rates, that’s around £70 but I know for a fact that just one of my tablets costs the NHS £600 for a months supply which I couldn’t afford. If it all goes private then I’ll really be stuck, as will plenty of people like me.

endofthelinefinally · 04/11/2022 08:50

In France you pay according to your income. It is a very efficient, safe system. You can get a GP appt within 24 hours, scans, Xrays, blood tests all available very quickly, women's health services including post natal physio all good.
I think paying for decent health care is worthwhile, as long as there is a safety net for those who can't afford it.

CaronPoivre · 04/11/2022 08:49

Daisymae55 · 04/11/2022 08:40

I’m sure. I’m not knowledgable enough on the subject, just know the reasons why my sibling left. I don’t know what the answers are all I know is the current situation isn’t working and it’s very sad 😞

I don’t doubt that is the reason they gave. I doubt the accuracy of their reasoning. Lots of nurses, junior doctors and even consultants have very little understanding of NHS funding. Why would they?

mumda · 04/11/2022 08:47

The NHS seems to be subsets of organisations within organisation after organisation. Deliberately complex and presumably some efficiencies would be found if you pulled it apart to look closely

Longwhiskers · 04/11/2022 08:47

I haven’t rung the doctors for years as could never get through (had to call at 8 and wait for up to an hr, the time I was meant to be commuting to work). But recently we moved from London to a less populated area and the difference has been stark. Last week I rang the doctors to make an appointment for something regarding my child. I got straight through to reception (no hold) and the receptionist said the doctor would call me that very afternoon! And they did. I did say it was non urgent. In London we’d have had a two week minimum wait for the doc to call back.

the other weekend my other child was ill, rang 111 who made an out of hrs appointment to see a GP 20 mins away. They then said to go to A&E where there was a paediatrics department. Triage there was 20 mins and then the child was seen (and it certainly wasn’t life or death, was a minor thing that did need treatment but not urgent).

so for me where we have moved to (less populated area) the NHS has worked well when we’ve needed it. Total difference to our overcrowded bit of London. That’s my limited experience anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread