Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

CMS diverted income. child maintenance dodgers, CMS not fit for purpose, leaving children in poverty, facilitating abuse and coercive control

33 replies

Toastandavocado · 03/11/2022 23:28

Am I being unreasonable to think this is a crock of shit?

www.gov.uk/government/consultations/child-maintenance-modernising-and-improving-our-service/child-maintenance-modernising-and-improving-our-service

Here’s my advice from someone with years of experience of the woefully inadequate CMS system. Ltd Company Director wilfully paying a pittance to the welfare of his children and a system that has never ever led on the Welfare of the Child principle (if you’re at the start of this journey this advice is for you 💐)…

submit a variation as soon as you know there is diverted and unearned income. Be sure to mention both diverted and unearned income in your variation form to catch all hidden income sources- At this very early stage know you are going through the process, you are ticking the boxes that allow you to move to tribunal. Less than 20% of variations/Mandatory considerations are upheld and this is because CMS are an administrative money making government body and not one bit about your welfare, or the welfare of your child/children. Be very aware of this going forward, it will save you the years of heartache and stress I have had. And it will hopefully get you to a place more quickly where you can actually have your child/children’s welfare supported. I’ve spent years with ‘bits’ of information, misinformation and full ridiculous wild goose chases from CMS. DO NOT FALL INTO THIS TRAP. If you have a self employed/Ltd Company Director child maintenance dodging ex this is what you need to do… you need to follow the steps to get to tribunal. It is the ONLY way you and your child/children stand a chance. By all means involve your MP/MSP in fact I’d urge you to do that but they are not going to get your children the maintenance they deserve… by all means report them to HMRC (which CMS tell you to do, then HMRC direct you to online because they’re so overwhelmed with RP’s they don’t deal with them) however this will still not get your child/children the maintenance they deserve. They live in real time? You live in real time? You and your child/children need the support now. The way I have stated below should have a much better chance at success…

www.voiceofthechild.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Variations-Overview.pdf

www.gingerbread.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Challenging-your-Child-Maintenance-Service-calculation.pdf

Submit a variation instantly, once your variation is submitted (you can submit a variation at any time in your CMS case) chase up every week, as soul destroying as it will be as otherwise you’ll place your faith in a system that is broken and shit and doesn’t care about your child/children… you will be on hold for over an hour every time you phone, possibly cut off after an hour and have to start again, that happens often too. Keep going until they reject it, they will.
Don’t fall for their lies that their online portal is a wonderful way of keeping in touch, they’ll ignore that too. Push to get a response, that allows you onto the next ‘administrative’ step.


Do not bother playing detective, contacting HMRC or doing any of the the other nonsense that should be their job, just provide what you can.

As soon as you receive your rejection (because you will) complete and send in the mandatory reconsideration form (within a month)

wait for that to come back rejected because it will! Now download the tribunal form and fill that in and send it off (within a month)

www.gov.uk/government/publications/appeal-a-child-maintenance-group-decision-by-the-dwp-form-sscs2

And now you’ve got a fighting chance of getting some justice and maintenance for your children.

The system is set up to make us fail… it’s nearly killed me. I’m at tribunal stage. Come along and join me and let’s get a fair outcome for our children and improve their life chances. They deserve to be supported by both parents and they deserve a system that protects and supports them, we don’t have this in the UK and it’s an utter disgrace for a country that should genuinely protect the welfare of the child, and uphold the legislation around this. I’m rooting for you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 21:41

Elsie sorry you’ve had this struggle too, I can only imagine the grandparent status would have made it all the more difficult for you as parent status is confusing enough for CMS. Glad to hear you got some outcome but it’s still utterly frustrating it’s not the ‘fair’ outcome or putting the children at the centre by the organisation that reports to lead on the welfare of the child… as I said in my op… crock of shit.

OP posts:
ElsieMc · 22/11/2022 21:28

I should mention that when I say I "settled" this was because there were substantial arrears on my case that the Liability Order made a legal debt. I settled within £750 of the amount due and agreed to write that off. Just to clarify.

ElsieMc · 22/11/2022 21:17

FIU involved in my case and my God the fuss I had to make it to get to this stage. CMS already had a Liability order against him (I am a grandparent carer) and they always win this because there is no defence in law to non payment of child support. This is quite funny when you discover how bad CMS are at actually applying this.

They also tried to take out a charge over his property but a simple search at the Land Registry by me revealed he had transferred it into his elderly parents' names. I had to tell the CMS this as they forged ahead.

I got one of the decent FIU workers but even then I had to bite my tongue over a 2 week period when he sent me paperwork showing a nil contribution as my gs's deadbeat dad stated he earned less than £200 pw and provided accountancy "proof".

I then got a phone call. FIU man told me he told deadbeat dad he was not happy with the paperwork supplied by his accountant and that he wanted five years of his books straightaway. He told him I wanted to settle for x amount and he point blank refused. Strangely the next morning FIU man was contacted and deadbeat dad paid me directly the same day. I had to sign a disclaimer but I was just relieved to walk away. I believed it better to get a lump sum rather than continue with the stress of non payment over the years.

I don't think they tell people at FIU stage that you can put a figure forward to settle. I was asked the lowest I would accept and I said a whole lot more. It depends how much they have to hide and I have no doubt I was still significantly short changed but I felt at peace with my decision for my gs.

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 21:02

Thanks cooda

OP posts:
Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 21:01

Thanks Dahlia, it’s these bits of info that I really hope help the women coming behind us. The stress is horrendous and none of us would want it for our daughters or friends. Nearly 2023 pfft

OP posts:
Dahliadawn · 22/11/2022 20:54

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:37

Dahlia, it’s soul destroying isn’t it. It impacts every bit of your life and well being. I know exactly how that made you feel. You and your children deserved better. We all deserve better.

Thank you, and yes we do all deserve better! I can’t believe this CMS system is so crap but it’s all we have. Although, it’s deadbeat dads in the first place that ar3 the cause of us having to go down that route,

Dahliadawn · 22/11/2022 20:52

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:40

I should have said FIU was before I raised an appeal so still within the shitty CMS system. I suspect they ‘up their game’ when they’re being directed by a Judge.

Oh most definitely! The investigator provided a complete breakdown of what he found in bank statements, so if anyone goes to Tribunal, they’re best to ask the Judge to involve the FIU as it will likely prove your case that the ex has more money than they’re letting on!

coodawoodashooda · 22/11/2022 20:51

Agreed op.

Stressfordays · 22/11/2022 20:50

He will 100% be earning cash in hand however I currently lack any info of where. I don't have the energy to CSI it anymore. I've reported him several times for benefit fraud, nothing has ever come of it. I don't even want his money however I feel I am doing my children a disservice by cancelling it. At least I can show them I tried and he did whatever he could to weasel out of it.

Dahliadawn · 22/11/2022 20:49

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:36

Dahlia I’m glad that worked for you. Did you get back payments and appropriate payments in place going forward? Are the payments still being made? Unfortunately I had FIU involved too and they were awful. I’ve heard this from others too. Tiny team and hit or miss if you get the right person to investigate. As with all areas of CMS there’s no decent communication or accountability. It leaves vulnerable RP’s and children just as vulnerable. It should never be a lottery when the stakes are so high.

Yes they stuck on 20,000 to exh’s annual income, on top of his income from work. It was calculated down into that ridiculous formula they use, but it was worth me going to Tribunal.
He’s still paying back pay,

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:45

That’s exactly what they do! Administrative body, we’re just pests on the system. Took me a long time to figure that out as it’s sold as an organisation that’s about putting children at the centre… utter bullshit and the MPs that support it should be held to account. Your tricky situation is the fact your ex is on benefits. Is he playing the system? Should he be getting benefits? If you really think not, report him for benefit fraud and fill in the form I have provided in my post for diversion of income and unearned income and raise an appeal. Don’t even bother wasting any more time with CMS you’ll get nowhere.

OP posts:
Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:40

I should have said FIU was before I raised an appeal so still within the shitty CMS system. I suspect they ‘up their game’ when they’re being directed by a Judge.

OP posts:
Stressfordays · 22/11/2022 20:39

I got a letter today stating my ex needs to pay £6.72 a week for 3 dc. No payment schedule or anything which is completely unlike any of the other letters I have received. I feel it is a constant battle with CMS. I have never received a willing payment from my ex, I had a period of 3 months where they took £7 out of his benefits, to which he quit and got a cash in hand job. I sent them the evidence of where he was working and everything. Nothing. I think they make it such a chore so you give in and close the case.

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:39

Please contact Womens Aid. And if there’s any justice in this world (starting to lose hope) you’ll be back in that house.

OP posts:
Glumbums · 22/11/2022 20:37

Glumbums go to Womens Aid for advice. Don’t delay, phone them tomorrow. I’m so so sick of hearing about these bullies and women feeling like they just have to take it. Best of luck

I will. He still lives in the family home which he bullied me out of. He says if I press the cms button he will sell the house. Its ridiculous but I am very emotionally attracted to the house and as we're tennets in common I hope that I will get to live in it again someday.

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:37

Dahlia, it’s soul destroying isn’t it. It impacts every bit of your life and well being. I know exactly how that made you feel. You and your children deserved better. We all deserve better.

OP posts:
Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:36

Dahlia I’m glad that worked for you. Did you get back payments and appropriate payments in place going forward? Are the payments still being made? Unfortunately I had FIU involved too and they were awful. I’ve heard this from others too. Tiny team and hit or miss if you get the right person to investigate. As with all areas of CMS there’s no decent communication or accountability. It leaves vulnerable RP’s and children just as vulnerable. It should never be a lottery when the stakes are so high.

OP posts:
Dahliadawn · 22/11/2022 20:31

Dahliadawn · 22/11/2022 20:29

I totally agree about the CMS being not fit for purpose. However, I’ve ploughed on through to a Tribunal and the Judge ordered the Financial investigation Unit to become involved.
They were able to access my ExH’s bank accounts and found so much unexplained money, and so my claim that ex was earning a side income was believed.

Oh and I was given copies of the bank statements too, which pissed me off to see how ex was spending on hotels, holidays, fancy restaurants, designer clothes, cars, yet he was happy for our kids to go without.

Dahliadawn · 22/11/2022 20:29

I totally agree about the CMS being not fit for purpose. However, I’ve ploughed on through to a Tribunal and the Judge ordered the Financial investigation Unit to become involved.
They were able to access my ExH’s bank accounts and found so much unexplained money, and so my claim that ex was earning a side income was believed.

Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:24

Women’s Aid and police don’t let him away with it. I was always scared to do anything because we are so conditioned to just put up with things. I do understand why you’re worried though as the system sucks and it’s just lies from CMS when they say they have measures in place to protect us. However, Women’s Aid will really help you.

OP posts:
Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:20

Glumbums go to Womens Aid for advice. Don’t delay, phone them tomorrow. I’m so so sick of hearing about these bullies and women feeling like they just have to take it. Best of luck.

OP posts:
Toastandavocado · 22/11/2022 20:14

JustLyra I’ve had my MP involved at the beginning, they told of their own story of the horrendous system when it was CSA and they too had suffered the same treatment and not received the appropriate maintenance. I have read numerous MP and MSP discussions spanning years around all of the major issues, loopholes, avoidance, lack of/non enforcement, poor training, wrong advice. Nothing has changed. You are right though, we need political power and we need it to be high on the agenda. Unfortunately as over 90% of resident parents are female we are disadvantaged instantly… I think we can all draw our own conclusions about a system set up predominantly by male politicians that’s supposed to protect the welfare of children.

JustLyra another fantastic point. I openly talk about the pittance the ex is paying towards his children and getting away with and I can see people squirm as if I am the one with the problem. In no other walk of life is it socially acceptable to shirk your financial responsibilities but many in society still actively support fathers to not support their children, it’s mind boggling. I’ll continue to make people squirm.

hettie, that’s the sad thing, a friend said to me, “he can’t love them” and I actually thought, he can’t love them like I do because no matter what hatred I had towards another human I’d always put my children first- (he cheated and left me by the way) still should not have any bearing on financially supporting your own children.

OP posts:
Neanov · 22/11/2022 20:06

@Glumbums do you have any evidence? If so you need to report him. You need to claim cms don't let him bully you.

Glumbums · 22/11/2022 20:01

Well I put in an application and ex basically bullied me out of going to the pay and collect stage. He shouted at me and basically threatened me. Not sure whether to go ahead and feel unsafe or go on and live my life.

hettie · 22/11/2022 19:57

I'm curious as to why men do this? Do they separate off from their children? How do they do that? What would your ex's think say about the welfare of their children? Presumably they were at once time enthusiastic about having them? Did they ever love them? I would walk over hit coals for my DC....I just can't think how I would ever get to the stage where I could see them so without. How in a break up does that happen?