Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there must be a cheaper way of teaching Home Ec

111 replies

Ceramicpumpkin281 · 03/11/2022 18:43

On today's list:

A clove of garlic
Pinch of paprika
Table spoon of olive oil
1 chicken breast

This is an area where lots of families are struggling, Couldn't the school have store cupboard basics for the class to share that we all pay an annual amount towards. I know people will say these are the types of things families will already have at home but a lot won't!

The food also comes back inedible after kicking around all day so it's not proving a meal for the family either.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 04/11/2022 09:57

Our school asks £20 for year per pupil they then bulk buy ingredients so its cheaper

funtycucker · 04/11/2022 09:54

hesbeingabitofadick · 04/11/2022 09:13

I've still got mine. Grin
One of the cats tries to sleep in it given half a chance

Everything I ever made in Home Ec was either thrown in the bin (sandwich cake with melted butter cream because we ran out of time) or flushed down the loo (chilli con carne).

My mum often missed out things like spices because she didn't like spicy food. Nothing was ever left in the fridge after lessons (morning) just cling-filmed and left on a counter. By the time it got home about 5 hrs later was inedible or down right dangerous.

How much fridge space do you think the average food tech room has? If there are a minimum of 20 pupils per class and 5 period a day how do you expect to store all of those in a fridge?

Knittingnanny2 · 04/11/2022 09:48

My 1970’s basket is now my knitting basket. It used to have a plastic cover if I remember correctly.
Im so old it used to be called cookery, then in the mid 70’s Domestic Science. By the time my children went to secondary in the 90’s it had moved from Home Ec to Food technology. I remember my dad laughing at the new name like resistant materials!

hesbeingabitofadick · 04/11/2022 09:13

EVHead · 04/11/2022 07:54

Memories of all of the girls wandering about with one of these. I moved to a school where they provided most of the ingredients and when I came to school carrying my basket the other kids looked at me like. 😧

Wicker basket.

I've still got mine. Grin
One of the cats tries to sleep in it given half a chance

Everything I ever made in Home Ec was either thrown in the bin (sandwich cake with melted butter cream because we ran out of time) or flushed down the loo (chilli con carne).

My mum often missed out things like spices because she didn't like spicy food. Nothing was ever left in the fridge after lessons (morning) just cling-filmed and left on a counter. By the time it got home about 5 hrs later was inedible or down right dangerous.

RampantIvy · 04/11/2022 08:38

EVHead · 04/11/2022 07:54

Memories of all of the girls wandering about with one of these. I moved to a school where they provided most of the ingredients and when I came to school carrying my basket the other kids looked at me like. 😧

Wicker basket.

I had one of those. I did O level and A level home economincs, and by 6th form we were doing practical assignments where we had to make up to 7 dishes. Balancing everything home on the bus was difficult. Fortunately my friend's mum used to pick us up after school when we had 7 dish assignments.

funtycucker · 04/11/2022 08:34

BarbaraofSeville · 04/11/2022 07:45

Surely just about every parent would rather pay towards collective garlic, spices etc rather than have to buy whole packs of things they don't I use?

Obviously it will be an issue for those who can't pay, but if they don't have the money to pay towards school supplies, they're not going to have the money to buy full packs in the supermarket anyway.

Completely ludicrous for it to work like this and for it not to be changed. The school could just get a supermarket delivery of what's needed.

And who pays for it if parents don't cover the costs? Will parents also cover the delivery costs? You're also not considering the fact that not all schools will have storage space to store a large stock of ingredients as not all classes will be making the same thing each lesson

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/11/2022 08:34

EVHead · 04/11/2022 07:54

Memories of all of the girls wandering about with one of these. I moved to a school where they provided most of the ingredients and when I came to school carrying my basket the other kids looked at me like. 😧

Wicker basket.

I had one of those too. I wish I still had it. I did Home Economics at A Level (1973) so my parents had to provide a lot and it was only later I realised that they were quite hard up and struggled to provide ingredients sometimes. None of it was wasted though we could use the Home Ec room fridge and take it home.

EVHead · 04/11/2022 07:54

Memories of all of the girls wandering about with one of these. I moved to a school where they provided most of the ingredients and when I came to school carrying my basket the other kids looked at me like. 😧

Wicker basket.

BarbaraofSeville · 04/11/2022 07:45

Ceramicpumpkin281 · 03/11/2022 19:19

Yeh I think I will email the department and suggest the ideas on here. Maybe they've tried them before and it just doesn't work (as a PP said it requires parents to actually pay) but there's no harm in asking.

Surely just about every parent would rather pay towards collective garlic, spices etc rather than have to buy whole packs of things they don't I use?

Obviously it will be an issue for those who can't pay, but if they don't have the money to pay towards school supplies, they're not going to have the money to buy full packs in the supermarket anyway.

Completely ludicrous for it to work like this and for it not to be changed. The school could just get a supermarket delivery of what's needed.

Allsnotwell · 04/11/2022 07:43

Yeh I think I will email the department and suggest the ideas on here

Good idea- perhaps you could also offer to do the admin to collect the money and chase those who refuse to pay - and then you could also chip in for the short fall as some kids will be left out.

caringcarer · 04/11/2022 07:39

When you eat at cafe with those salt and pepper in little sachets of paper. Pick up a couple for when you have to send salt and pepper to school. They are useful for picnics too.

caringcarer · 04/11/2022 07:30

My son did Food at GCSE last year. Any children getting pee or free school meals got their ingredients provided other children could choose to pay £5 per lesson 1 week in advance and teacher ordered ingredients in for them or could bring own ingredients. Most paid the £5 each week and teacher got Tesco delivery. All food was kept in fridge in own containers with names on and collected after school. He made some nice meals we had for dinner. Certainly made him realise about cleaning up after cooking too. It worked very well. Any child not bringing in ingredients or paying the £5 had to do written work instead.

tigerbear · 04/11/2022 07:21

@BooksAndHooks same here.
DD has just begun secondary at what is supposed to be an outstanding school, and there’s been zero mention of doing any food tech.
She does an independent cookery class every so often, but it’s so expensive - £35 for 2 hours!

funtycucker · 04/11/2022 07:20

IreneJones · 03/11/2022 20:34

@GracieLouFreeebush That's terrible. You absolutely should not be spending your own money on ingredients. Can you claim back what you've spent? If you can't then you need to discuss a way forward with HoF.

Claim it back from what? There is no money left in budgets. Not even a few pounds to pay for some paprika

Comtesse · 04/11/2022 07:20

We used to have to bring in all the ingredients in some big stupid wicker basket as well as “presentation materials” like a nice tablecloth and a little bunch of flowers - seems insane now that I think about it! This was in a random comprehensive in 1990 Shock

RampantIvy · 04/11/2022 07:18

MarmiteCoriander · 03/11/2022 18:51

OP- are you saying that the children have to bring the ingredients to school with them from home? And remember to do so???😧

I have never heard of this! Admittedly I don't have children, but when I went to school- all the ingredients were there- at the school already! We never bought anything in at all!

When I did HE at school in the 1970s everyone brought ingredients in. The school didn't provide any.

Whycanineverever · 04/11/2022 07:17

Another one here where we Buy the main ingredients but the smaller ones are covered under a £10 annual payment.

BooksAndHooks · 04/11/2022 07:14

Be grateful yours still teach it. My eldest did a couple of lessons and only made a pasta sauce. Middle DS never got to do it at all and it has been removed from GCSE syllabus altogether at their school now.

Passenger17 · 04/11/2022 07:10

My dd had to bring in 150g of cheese for a pasta " bake" which in turned out they cooked on the hob and just needed a sprinkle of cheese...dh threw the cheese out when it got home because it has been kicking about the school all day in clingfilm. In fact the whole "bake" had so that was inedible.

Ceramicpumpkin281 · 04/11/2022 07:03

MarmiteCoriander · 03/11/2022 23:24

Out of interest, if your child does woodwork- do they need to bring in their own wood and nails for their lesson too??? What about metal work? Do they also source their own metal, solder etc???

As said up thread, I have no children and when I went to school- all the above, along with food in cooking lessons was there already and provided. I don't recall having to pay extra per term. Seems so odd that you'd carry raw meat and ingredients to school, to sit in your bag, unrefrigerated for hours and hours before cooking and eating! 😬

No but at the end of last year the art department ran out of money for paint! Kids were told to bring in their own if they wanted to use it. No joke.

OP posts:
SnooozyTree · 04/11/2022 00:35

They are paired up to cook in dds school, and split the ingredient list between them. Had to point out to dd that the way they divided the list (you bring the first 4, I'll bring the second 4) meant the other family had to spend more and find more unusual ingredients every time. For example, making beef chili and dd would have an onion, a pepper, a garlic clove and chili flakes.

Now dd pays more attention, and I make sure we cover more of the costs to make up for it.

Total pita, but it has been effective in helping dd with thinking ahead and planning for class.

America12 · 03/11/2022 23:52

pavillion1 · 03/11/2022 19:04

We took in what we needed to make what we was being asked .
Surely you knew these things would come up when deciding to have children ?

Do you honestly think people would think about things like this when thinking about having a baby ????

Changingmynameyetagain · 03/11/2022 23:39

Ds1 has just finished his term of food tech. One week he made a lasagna, they made it from scratch, white sauce, meat sauce and fresh pasta. Unfortunately they didn’t have time to actually bake the thing, my daft teenage dick of a son put the entire uncooked thing in his school bag ShockAngry About £8 of ingredients all over his bag/school books/pencil case. I was not best pleased!

Toddlerteaplease · 03/11/2022 23:39

We had to Bring ours in from home. My teacher insisted we should not bring in boil in the bag rice as it was expensive. My mum always used book in the bag and no way was she going out to buy normal stuff!

tunnocksreturns2019 · 03/11/2022 23:28

MarmiteCoriander · 03/11/2022 23:24

Out of interest, if your child does woodwork- do they need to bring in their own wood and nails for their lesson too??? What about metal work? Do they also source their own metal, solder etc???

As said up thread, I have no children and when I went to school- all the above, along with food in cooking lessons was there already and provided. I don't recall having to pay extra per term. Seems so odd that you'd carry raw meat and ingredients to school, to sit in your bag, unrefrigerated for hours and hours before cooking and eating! 😬

Yes, most of the stuff for Resistant Materials has to be provided too. That’s next term of Y9. How I wish DS had chosen a different option…! (But this is the stuff he is good at, so I don’t really mean it. Amazing stuffed peppers this week, did me two dinners as he doesn’t like peppers!).

They can - if they remember - take ingredients straight to DT fridge on arrival. However my DC have a 15 min walk to school, others are on a bus for an hour first, some will totally forget…