Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No, cheating is not just "biology"

59 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 03/11/2022 16:52

I've just had to block somebody on another forum for continuously spamming me with comments about how cheating is simple biology, is acceptable and inevitable, and the real problem is "people like me" who want monogamy.

Its because of people like me and the majority in society (who don't agree with infidelity) that men feel "forced" to take vows that go against their basic biology.

Apparently all of our husbands are at it, will have been at some point, or will be in the future.

She isn't a troll, just an aggressive twit in a polyamorous relationship who thinks those of us who don't want to be - are fools.

What's your take?

(Disclaimer, I have nothing against polyamorous people - power to them if that's what makes them and their partner(s) happy. What I have an issue with is how people like this person believe that their way is the right way and the rest of us are fools)

OP posts:
Naunet · 18/11/2022 19:50

Rinatinabina · 18/11/2022 19:46

I struggle to believe this. I imagine males were more invested in children if they were certain of parentage. Yeah a tribe would share tasks like child rearing etc etc but lineage and bonds of “marriage” through tribe would only work if you knew who everyones dad is. No point in creating an alliance with another tribe thinking you are getting the chiefs daughter if no-one knows who the chiefs daughter’s dad actually is. Things like jealousy, rivalry, possession would also exist and monogamy would keep relationships within a tribe stable wouldn’t they?

Works for bonobos.

Rinatinabina · 18/11/2022 19:46

Lili132 · 18/11/2022 19:28

But women didn't depend on specific man for survival. Nuclear family is a fairly new concept. For majority of human history people lived in tribes. Both men and women hunted /gathered food and everyone depended on a whole group. Nobody could easily survive on their own.
If a father of a child died there would be others to support the mother plus she co could still gather food while carrying a baby. And often women did not even know who the father was. Child rearing was responsibility of the whole tribe. Not just a mother and father.
Also contrary to popular belief hunter gatherers knew how to avoid pregnancy and that with extended breastfeeding ensured there was space of few years between having children.
So many assumptions about human pair bonding and evolution is based on short period of patriarchy.

Now there is lots of benefits to monogamy and sex for human beings is about much more then passing gens. We have sex for intimacy, bonding, stress relief etc etc. Humans are very complex and there is no simplistic answers when it comes to our behaviours.

I struggle to believe this. I imagine males were more invested in children if they were certain of parentage. Yeah a tribe would share tasks like child rearing etc etc but lineage and bonds of “marriage” through tribe would only work if you knew who everyones dad is. No point in creating an alliance with another tribe thinking you are getting the chiefs daughter if no-one knows who the chiefs daughter’s dad actually is. Things like jealousy, rivalry, possession would also exist and monogamy would keep relationships within a tribe stable wouldn’t they?

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/11/2022 19:41

Biology may lead some of us to want more than one partner.

Nothing in biology makes it inevitable that one person lies and deceives another in order to facilitate that desire!

Rinatinabina · 18/11/2022 19:39

DH asked me to get married, I went, “ok then”. I’m going to complain that he forced me into a social construct of serial monogamy.

Also I have a lot of instincts, I instinctively feel like kicking Peter every time I see the bastard but I manage to not do it. EVERY.SINGLE .TIME. And I promise you the urge is overwhelming plus I have impulse control issues. So if I can manage I think most people could actually not cheat if they applied themselves.

Personally I think the poly doth protest too much. She probably doesn’t actually like it and is externalising her anxiety about it, if enough people agree it’s a good idea it’ll probably make her feel better,

Flirtyandthirty · 18/11/2022 19:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lili132 · 18/11/2022 19:28

BMW6 · 03/11/2022 19:49

Well men are biologically designed to impregnate as many women as they can as quickly as they can, over around 60+
years, whereas women can only have one birth every 9 months or so over a much more limited reproductive span.
That much is true BUT the bonding of Love was designed by nature to get the man to stick around his mate, to provide and protect mate and offspring.

If males had just fucked then fucked off the women and children could not have survived, so a bonded family unit was imperative for the survival of the species.

Now of course males can indeed fuck and fuck off, by and large society will help provide for mother and children if the father is unwilling or unable or unfindable.

Is he right? Well if the survival of the species depended on men like him then he wouldn't gave come to exist as we'd have died out.

So really all she's advocating is men not having any responsibility. More fool her.

But women didn't depend on specific man for survival. Nuclear family is a fairly new concept. For majority of human history people lived in tribes. Both men and women hunted /gathered food and everyone depended on a whole group. Nobody could easily survive on their own.
If a father of a child died there would be others to support the mother plus she co could still gather food while carrying a baby. And often women did not even know who the father was. Child rearing was responsibility of the whole tribe. Not just a mother and father.
Also contrary to popular belief hunter gatherers knew how to avoid pregnancy and that with extended breastfeeding ensured there was space of few years between having children.
So many assumptions about human pair bonding and evolution is based on short period of patriarchy.

Now there is lots of benefits to monogamy and sex for human beings is about much more then passing gens. We have sex for intimacy, bonding, stress relief etc etc. Humans are very complex and there is no simplistic answers when it comes to our behaviours.

thenewduchessoflapland · 03/11/2022 20:14

replied to say that instead of looking for excuses to cheat just don't bother getting married in the first place.

It's not just married people that cheat;people in any kind of relationship can cheat.

My friend is in a poly relationship;she doesn't shout it from the treetops;close friends and family know;it works for her situation;I respect that and she doesn't try to convince anyone else they need to be in a poly relationship;she thinks it's shit when monogamous people cheat on their partners;she doesn't justify their behaviour.

It's not biology to cheat;it's just people behaving badly and doing stuff they should they shouldn't be.

BMW6 · 03/11/2022 19:49

Well men are biologically designed to impregnate as many women as they can as quickly as they can, over around 60+
years, whereas women can only have one birth every 9 months or so over a much more limited reproductive span.
That much is true BUT the bonding of Love was designed by nature to get the man to stick around his mate, to provide and protect mate and offspring.

If males had just fucked then fucked off the women and children could not have survived, so a bonded family unit was imperative for the survival of the species.

Now of course males can indeed fuck and fuck off, by and large society will help provide for mother and children if the father is unwilling or unable or unfindable.

Is he right? Well if the survival of the species depended on men like him then he wouldn't gave come to exist as we'd have died out.

So really all she's advocating is men not having any responsibility. More fool her.

Onlyforcake · 03/11/2022 19:35

Biology isn't so relevant though. Cheating DOES exist because of a 'contract' if they can't stick to very simple terms (that aren't hard this isn't some HUGE overwhelming instinct it is AN urge, that people CHOOSE to act on or not). I just feel bad for her if sex is just something she feels compelled to engage in out of instinct, I like to involve more of my brain than that.

It doesn't matter if its biliogy or not. I don't think heaps of men are off weeping in corners because they've got a stable supportive relationship

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 03/11/2022 19:29

You're both right, and both wrong.

Biologically we're designed to have multiple partners. Monogamy is a social construct, but an important one because its become our norm.

UrslaB · 03/11/2022 19:26

Biologically speaking there is a hint of truth in what they said but humans as a species have evolved to try and supersede their biological and biochemical instincts. Its why we have civilization, technology, philosophy etc. We have social pressures, social conditioning and even emotional conditioning which has for millennium pushed humanity to form monogamous partnerships (patriarchy). Economic and societal norms are probably the largest pressures today which push towards it.

Being a rampant arse about 'biology' necessitating all men to an inclination to cheat and want casual sex however is abdicating all ideas of self control, consciousness and will-power to make informed choices. If you argue 'cheating' is all biology then you are admitting to having no self control and being no more evolved, emotional or intelligent than Bonobos or dogs.

Polyamory is fine for those who choose it when all parties are all on board, but its not for everyone. Some people, men and women, really do prefer monogamy and that is cool too.

Having lived happily in both types of relationships I see the positives and negatives. Currently in Monogomous relationship and have no desire to change that...would I be open to discussing changing it to an open relationship if my partner wanted to? Maybe...but that would depend on a conversation and agreement between us.

The idea that all men will cheat and have absolutely no self control because of some biological throw back is ridiculous and naive.

5128gap · 03/11/2022 19:26

Isitsixoclockalready · 03/11/2022 18:52

So women would prefer not to be monogamous but are forced to do so by patriarchy? Creative.

Certainly women's monogamy is very important to the patriarchal society. Not least, so that men can feel more confident they are investing in and raising their own children. But also because a model that encourages a woman's relationship with just one man gives that man greater power over her. It also reinforces ideas of women as the possession of a man and for his use only.
I'm not suggesting women are forced into it against their will, but it would be naive not to acknowledge there are strong incentives to steer us towards it and that societal messaging does just that.

Macaroni46 · 03/11/2022 19:09

Slightly missing the point, but if all these men are cheating, who are the women they're cheating with?
Surely approximately the same number of women must be cheating too? 🤔🤷‍♀️

Theunamedcat · 03/11/2022 19:04

The thing is everyone seems OK with men doing it awwww it's biology awww his dad did it he had a mistress so his son thinks it's all normal "sister wives" etc etc, try doing it as a woman see how fast you get slut shamed

Parkingmoan1 · 03/11/2022 18:58

I also don't think her argument stands up to scrutiny because loads of the people who cheat would certainly not be happy for their significant other to do the same. They don't want a truly polyamorous relationship, they just want carte blanche to have sex with whoever they like whilst the SO remains faithful.

OP posts:
LisaJool · 03/11/2022 18:55

I knew a guy who had Jamaican heritage and he said cheating was in his DNA because of his ethnicity 🤔

Isitsixoclockalready · 03/11/2022 18:52

Wreckit · 03/11/2022 18:37

I believe monogamy is unnatural and only so prevalent because of patriarchal societal conditioning.

So women would prefer not to be monogamous but are forced to do so by patriarchy? Creative.

JoonT · 03/11/2022 18:52

Well, I suppose it kind of IS biology, in that it's natural to lust after other people. But lots of horrible things are 'natural'. It's natural to lie and cheat and steal and think only of number one. The point is we're better than that. We can rise above our animal selves.

Parkingmoan1 · 03/11/2022 18:47

Wreckit · 03/11/2022 18:37

I believe monogamy is unnatural and only so prevalent because of patriarchal societal conditioning.

That's fair enough, but do you aggressively go after people who don't have the same beliefs / way of living? I'm betting not.

OP posts:
KitchenSupper · 03/11/2022 18:38

She is trying to convince herself. If she were content she wouldn’t care what you think

Wreckit · 03/11/2022 18:37

I believe monogamy is unnatural and only so prevalent because of patriarchal societal conditioning.

MrsCarson · 03/11/2022 18:32

The amount she harps on about it, maybe she's not so happy or comfortable in this polyamorous relationship as she want everyone to think and she's trying to convince herself by having everyone agree with her that it's a good idea, Biology.

Parkingmoan1 · 03/11/2022 18:27

5128gap · 03/11/2022 17:39

Why has she targeted you? Have you been equally vocal about monogamy? If so, the way I see it, if you don't want to hear dissenting voices don't air your opinions and let everyone just get on with their own thing. Or accept you'll get disagreement and respond with a rebuttal.
I don't disagree with your views, but people who do have the right to say so.

There was a post about the excuses men make for cheating (although it applies to women too)

I replied to say that instead of looking for excuses to cheat just don't bother getting married in the first place. Cue the barrage that followed where I was called a Karen, religious (?!) and part of "the problem"

OP posts:
Cheminaufaules · 03/11/2022 18:27

Technically, it's correct. Greed is part of biology. Self-entitlement is part of biology.
But that's not what she means, I know. She means that it's not 'natural' to have sex with one partner for your entire life. OK, tell her it's not 'natural' to shit on a toilet - she should get herself down to the woods and shit amongst the trees.
Plus, she forgets all the other wonderful human traits which balance the desire to procreate and temper our carnal lust! Traits like compassion, respect, duty, faith, faithfulness, kindness. But maybe she doesn't have those.

SomePosters · 03/11/2022 18:26

I mean if I look at my life experience the greater majority of relationships that have supposedly been monogamous have not in truth been so.

I’ve never cheated on a partner when I have been supposed to be monogamously committed to someone and according to most people I’ve asked and every study I’ve ever seen this is a minority position!

yanbu to feel annoyed with her though

Polyamory prophets are at best boring and at worst predatory.

Neither way is right or wrong

There are good and bad ways to do either.

live and let live

Swipe left for the next trending thread