Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No, cheating is not just "biology"

59 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 03/11/2022 16:52

I've just had to block somebody on another forum for continuously spamming me with comments about how cheating is simple biology, is acceptable and inevitable, and the real problem is "people like me" who want monogamy.

Its because of people like me and the majority in society (who don't agree with infidelity) that men feel "forced" to take vows that go against their basic biology.

Apparently all of our husbands are at it, will have been at some point, or will be in the future.

She isn't a troll, just an aggressive twit in a polyamorous relationship who thinks those of us who don't want to be - are fools.

What's your take?

(Disclaimer, I have nothing against polyamorous people - power to them if that's what makes them and their partner(s) happy. What I have an issue with is how people like this person believe that their way is the right way and the rest of us are fools)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fruktsoda · 19/11/2022 14:30

People who can't accept that others have a different view and instead pursue them and make pests of themselves are stupid. What aspect of biology explains that bizarre time-wasting habit, I wonder...

WiddlinDiddlin · 19/11/2022 14:27

Naunet · 18/11/2022 20:25

This is true, I can’t think of any species where the males all fuck around whilst the females are monogamous. How would it even be possible?! The men who think this are just sexist fuckwits.

Birds... lots and lots of birds actually.

Swans, mate for life... and cheat.

The birds that only pair up for a season and are supposedly monogamous throughout that season... mostly are not and its more often the female who has a male on the side!

Runningintolife · 19/11/2022 14:15

Group disapproval among mammals is a powerful force to drive out behaviour considered immoral by the group. So I would say both the urge to cheat and the decision not to are driven by our biology including neurobiology. We are complex and we exist in a world and a culture. Survival depends on social success. Their messages sound dull.

Untitledsquatboulder · 19/11/2022 14:08

@Speedweed no, that's nonsense. Cheating is one strategy for getting your genes into the next generation/accessing good genes for your offspring and is used by both male and females in many species, including humans.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2022 14:07

"replacing your deceased wife". Not widow.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2022 14:06

Another man, call him Fred, has sex in prehistoric times with one woman. Stays with her. Has 4 kids. Most survive as he knows they are his and gives them extra meat and fights off predators.

That's interesting and plausible. I suspect, though, given how few humans survived to adulthood in those days, the idea of a stable, nuclear family of four kids in the model model was vanishingly rare back then. A lot of women would have died in pregnancy/childbirth and a lot of their children would have died of disease or starvation long before they reached reproductive age. But that would have been "replacing your widow" as opposed to cheating.

The model of a monogamous marriage lasting 50+ years would have been freakishly rare in those days because few couples would have had the opportunity to remain in a stable partnership for long, so people just didn't have time to think much about the ethics of sex outside marriage.

At any rate, I agree with a PP that just because something is biologically determined doesn't mean it's totally justifiable.

Speedweed · 19/11/2022 13:57

Wasn't there some bit of research a few years ago which took this (victorian, sexist) assumption that men are biologically designed not to be monogamous, and actually ran the statistical numbers to see if they'd back up the theory, because it didn't make sense in a patriarchal society to have this institution which apparently 'didn't suit' men.

They calculated the amount of women back in Neanderthal times, and took into account that people lived in tribes and therefore a man would basically risk death if he tried to get access to females in other tribes, and they also threw women's limited fertile window eaxh month into the sums - and taking all that into account, they realised that a man would be better of having one woman that he had access to all the time and therefore he could have sex with her as frequently as he wanted, and would be more likely to get her pregnant and pass on his genes.

So actually, men for thousands of years have been programmed for frequent sex in a monogamous relationship.

Whereas for a woman, her interest is in getting the best genes for her offspring, which means she's actually motivated to have sex with as many different men as possible (frequency isn't such a big feature, because she's only fertile for a few days each month). So women aren't programmed to be monogamous - hence the invention of marriage by the patriarchy, to enable each man to control 'his' woman.

So yeah, this woman is wrong.

DonnaBanana · 19/11/2022 13:37

A lot of things are biological including a lot of things relating to libido, who you’re attracted to, etc. But that doesn’t matter. One of the main features of being human is to control our biological urges and overcome our biological limitations. In this way, cheating is both biological and a choice because you could just not do it in the same way I don’t just eat a whole tin of Pringles in one go even if my brain screams yes! Mature people deny their biological urges.

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 19/11/2022 13:36

But it is particular genes that survive that drive our biology. If Fred has more children who survive, because he is monogamous and his ‘drive’ to have sex was able to be monogamous, then those genes and behavior from those genes will survive more than Henry’s genes.

IcedPurple · 19/11/2022 13:26

She's not wrong in the sense that from a reproductive standpoint, which is all that nature cares about, it makes sense to shag multiple people. However, we as humans aren't dictated to by our biology. It also makes biological sense to start having babies at 14, but that would be illegal in most Western countries. If someone feels they are unable to resist their 'biology' then noone is forcing them to be in a monogamous relationship. Cheating is not inevitable.

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 19/11/2022 13:16

Men are designed to "cheat" in the sense that their reproductive destiny is to have sex with as many women as possible. You see I think this is a myth, or at best just a theory.

Our reproductive destiny as men and women are to have children who survive to reproduce. That is how the gene survives.

So if one man, call him Henry, has sex with loads of women, in prehistoric times say, probably those women are also having sex with loads of men, so Henry may only cause one pregnancy. He doesn’t know which child is his. He doesn’t look after it as his own, the child doesn’t survive.

Another man, call him Fred, has sex in prehistoric times with one woman. Stays with her. Has 4 kids. Most survive as he knows they are his and gives them extra meat and fights off predators.

So the gene for monogamy will survive for Fred more than Henry.

Well that’s my theory anyway!

angelofdeath21 · 18/11/2022 21:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

how interesting I'm glad someone has the brains to back up the bold statements finally. the students in your class are bloody lucky

Flirtyandthirty · 18/11/2022 21:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Jumpwaddlecollapse · 18/11/2022 21:09

Right I'm an idiot but there is so much about all of this I just don't get - For instance I have known men that do not want children, definitely use protection - but they also say they have biological urges to have sex with as many women as possible? Men can have thousands of children - but today they would pay for them or hold responsibility for them - so they wouldn't. Are they saying primal biological urges are stronger than common sense?

I get a primal urge (well that's what it feels like) to eat a whole chocolate cake when I'm hormonal - but society doesn't go "there, there - have a massive binge" - I would be judged for it if I did. Why is okay for some urges to be recognised and others ostracised - Especially when the cake hurts me, and infidelity hurts others.

Rinatinabina · 18/11/2022 20:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Could you possibly elaborate, I’d be interested to hear your take on it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 18/11/2022 20:52

Well you're both sort of right. Biologically speaking there's more than a grain of truth in what she says. Men are designed to "cheat" in the sense that their reproductive destiny is to have sex with as many women as possible. Historically women have cheated less, partly because their security and that of their children tended to depend upon their sexual fidelity and frowned upon cheating. But a lot of them have done it anyway.

But the whole point of a committed relationship is supposed to be that you renounce the primacy of your biological urges and many people do remain sexually faithful for life. Clearly if its something you want to do and commit to doing you can do and a lot of people, both women and men, are genuinely happier in a monogamous relationship.

The fact remains, though, that there is a lot more cheating in society than most people will allow themselves to admit. It might not be all of "our husbands" but statistically it is likely to be more than we might think.

Rinatinabina · 18/11/2022 20:45

Naunet · 18/11/2022 19:50

Works for bonobos.

Aren’t they all basically bi and mate constantly to smooth social interactions. I don’t know about you but I wouldn’t be standing up in a meeting during tense negotiations and go “we’re all a bit stressed, how about a bonobo peace fuck” .

Namenic · 18/11/2022 20:39

stealing And violence are biology too. So I guess she would be in favour of getting rid of our legal systems.

Naunet · 18/11/2022 20:25

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 18/11/2022 20:23

Also, in the animal kingdom, many animal species mate for life and are monogamous.

With monkeys, there are huge variations.

However in most animal examples, it is not that all the males get to have sex with any female if they are not monogamous. It is that ONE dominant male gets to only have sex with the other females. While the other males look on hopelessly or are outcast.

So if biology is the excuse, is it that ONE dominant male in our society can have as many women as they like and the others just have to put up with it?!

This is true, I can’t think of any species where the males all fuck around whilst the females are monogamous. How would it even be possible?! The men who think this are just sexist fuckwits.

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 18/11/2022 20:23

Also, in the animal kingdom, many animal species mate for life and are monogamous.

With monkeys, there are huge variations.

However in most animal examples, it is not that all the males get to have sex with any female if they are not monogamous. It is that ONE dominant male gets to only have sex with the other females. While the other males look on hopelessly or are outcast.

So if biology is the excuse, is it that ONE dominant male in our society can have as many women as they like and the others just have to put up with it?!

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 18/11/2022 20:19

We men… oops!

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 18/11/2022 20:18

I 100% agree OP. This is what my Ex tried to excuse himself from constantly cheating on me, whilst I was pregnant, with a young baby, with our disabled child. That is was somehow just ‘nature’ and him being a virile, sexy guy… 🙄

There is no proof that we men are biologically primed to cheat, lots of theories and lots of interesting views.

There is as much evidence that we are NOT primed to cheat, and worldwide the norm is that culturally we as societies do not seem to function well outside monogamy, and children do not get the best deal. In almost every religion and culture long term monogamy is the norm, and it was not normal that people married but then cheated (that was mainly the reserve of the very rich).

Cheating also is risky biologically, carrying the risk of sexual diseases. It is risky in other ways, cheating with another mans wife for example.

This is because the survival of the species goes not lie in the drive of an adult male. It is the survival of our children. Children have more of a chance biologically if they have a mother and father who are completely dedicated to them, and who are not ‘spreading themselves thinly with multiple women and babies that they cannot support’. If we are talking about survival of the fittest than this is it. And this is why wealthy people in cultures could afford to break that rule, they could afford to support more children.

Naunet · 18/11/2022 20:17

takealettermsjones · 18/11/2022 20:08

I don't really see the value in justifying human choices using the "biology/evolution/look at the rest of the animal kingdom" argument, personally. If you want to be polyamorous, go for it, but "it's ok because chimps do it" seems like the own goal of intelligent argument to me. Chimps throw shit at each other and all.

I personally find it incredibly interesting to consider how we were originally designed to live and there’s nothing stupid about looking to our closest cousins for a reference. However, that doesn’t mean lying to someone is justified and just as other species don’t respond well to certain (natural) behaviours within their own species, we don’t have to either.

takealettermsjones · 18/11/2022 20:08

I don't really see the value in justifying human choices using the "biology/evolution/look at the rest of the animal kingdom" argument, personally. If you want to be polyamorous, go for it, but "it's ok because chimps do it" seems like the own goal of intelligent argument to me. Chimps throw shit at each other and all.

ClareBlue · 18/11/2022 20:00

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/11/2022 19:41

Biology may lead some of us to want more than one partner.

Nothing in biology makes it inevitable that one person lies and deceives another in order to facilitate that desire!

This
Cheating is different to biological urges.
And it's not overwhelming. It's an urge the same as alot of urges that we control.
Even our goats can control their biological urges when they want to.