Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a Solicitor might be able to help with this or am I wasting my time?

113 replies

girlfriend44 · 03/11/2022 16:37

I have been housing a BT openreach signal box on my house wall for many years. (wayleave agreements for anyone who dosent know)
BT are supposed to have an agreement with you if you have their property on your land as our people who supply electricity pylons etc.

It turns out through investigation that there was never an agreement in place for a box to be on my property all these years.

Openreach have offered me about £200 for all those years ive had the box plus agreeing to keep it on the house going forward?

You are not allowed to remove the box yourself otherwise you can be charged with malicious damage in order to get the £200 you have to agree to keep the box up there forever.
Everything is on their side and the payment is crazy, not to mention if i hadnt investigated it would never have come to light.

They agree the payments are low but say thats the most they will offer. I can fill in a form and get the payment and be done with ti.
OR
Would it be worth me contacting a solicitor to see if they can negotiate a higher payment or am I wasting my time.

Anyone had similar or know?

OP posts:
PlutoCritter · 04/11/2022 15:58

personally?

i'd ask them to remove it.

openreach are a bunch of incompetent idiots and there's no way i'd want any of their infrastructure near my house if i had any sway in it.

absolute shambles of an organisation -the idea that they could even pay you the £200 properly or arrange to not damage something when insisting they need "access" for maintenance is a joke. if they parked on your driveway and reversed into your flower bed you'd probably get off lightly.

TheWurst · 04/11/2022 15:51

girlfriend44 · 04/11/2022 13:45

That's not 200 pound a year that 200 pounds for all the years it's been there and ongoing from now on. It's peanuts. I don't benefit from the job either.

Say it’s been there 10 years, that’s £20 a year to rent a small square on your house.

I think you are coming across as wanting your cake and eat it, either accept the £200 or have it removed and you won’t have to think about it anymore. Or spend thousands of pounds trying to sue BT for trespass (would it be trespass?)

Jedsnewstar · 04/11/2022 15:13

girlfriend44 · 03/11/2022 18:09

Depends. No win no fee.

They don’t generally do no win no fee for things they are not clear cut wins.

This isn’t the pay day you are hoping for. Give it up.

midgetastic · 04/11/2022 14:21

So it could be a box that was installed a lifetime ago and been there ever since with no worries ?

And you wonder there is no record of any wayleave aggrement?

Coffeetree · 04/11/2022 14:10

Don't understand the cranky responses. You're right to expect a better explanation of why this thing is on your property and what your rights are.

Apart from the money, I'd be more concerned about access and repair over the years.

Did you use a conveyancing solicitor when you purchased the property? Maybe they can help.

A one-off consultation with a sol would be £100-200 so perhaps not worth it.

Dragonskin · 04/11/2022 14:10

ratsrats · 04/11/2022 14:01

so what?! It literally doesn’t affect your life at all, doesn’t cause you any inconvenience. £200 in return for nothing is a great offer! If it DOES affect your life and inconvenience you, get it removed and move on ffs! you’re not going to be getting more money you greedy git

This is exactly what I came on to say. If you don't want to take the £200 then get it taken off, but talk of getting solicitors involved is ridiculous

ratsrats · 04/11/2022 14:01

so what?! It literally doesn’t affect your life at all, doesn’t cause you any inconvenience. £200 in return for nothing is a great offer! If it DOES affect your life and inconvenience you, get it removed and move on ffs! you’re not going to be getting more money you greedy git

girlfriend44 · 04/11/2022 13:45

Ilovecheesetoasties · 04/11/2022 08:55

We are farmers and have 4 or 5 poles and cables on the land and get about £40 a year. £200 is pretty generous. I’d take it if I were you.

That's not 200 pound a year that 200 pounds for all the years it's been there and ongoing from now on. It's peanuts. I don't benefit from the job either.

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 04/11/2022 13:31

Dougieowner · 04/11/2022 08:30

dottypotter.
Fully agree.
Would be interesting if the OP would post the requested photo so we could see it.
Also does it serve her own property?

No it dosent serve my property.

There's nothing really to see its just a box on a wall with wires.

OP posts:
anniegun · 04/11/2022 09:50

If you don't want it just get them to take it away

PootLevato · 04/11/2022 09:48

Worked with Openreach daily in my last role, I’d take the £200, they would only
negotiate a Wayleaves agreement in extremely rare circumstances.

In 6 years I think I saw an increased payment maybe twice in probably over 500 cases I dealt with. Both were for infrastructure placed in areas of the countryside where it would cost a fortune to reroute and even then it wasn’t a significant increase in the payment.

Heartbreaktuna · 04/11/2022 09:20

I regularly see wayleave payments coming through various farmers accounts. They average around £3 a year 😅 I'd definitely just take the £200

TheWurst · 04/11/2022 09:12

BMW6 · 03/11/2022 16:45

All I can offer is that I recall years ago seeing a Wayleave payment in an account (I worked for HMRC) and it was £30 pa to a farmer for having a bloody enormous electricity pylon in one of his fields.

I suspect you will get no more that their offer - all this will have been established legally way back in the day. Would cost a lot in Solicitors fees too.

i agree with this, you’d be surprised how little wayleave payments are. I know someone who gets £13 a year for massive pylon cables to go over their house. Why they bought it is beyond me, the humming drives me nuts.

Ilovecheesetoasties · 04/11/2022 08:55

We are farmers and have 4 or 5 poles and cables on the land and get about £40 a year. £200 is pretty generous. I’d take it if I were you.

Letsnotargue · 04/11/2022 08:41

We had a small BT manhole cover in our front lawn, one day they knocked and asked if they could replace it with a bigger one to accommodate fibre broadband. No problem, told them to carry on.

The guy (who was surprised we were so accommodating - apparently he’d had some difficult ones that day) casually asked if we had a wayleave in place and suggested we look into it.

I filled out the form and they wrote to us offering £400 one off payment, the letter was v clear that there was no negotiation and take it or leave it. It did say that the signed agreement should be kept with the deeds as it was ongoing regardless of us selling the house. Nothing had been in place until that point - the house is 40 years old and doesn’t have telegraph poles in the street so I guess the manhole was put in when it was built.

Utility companies have an obligation to supply people and if they had to go and renegotiate with everyone they’d never be able to get any work done. We and our neighbours use broadband so I figure it’s only fair that we facilitate that.

Dougieowner · 04/11/2022 08:30

dottypotter.
Fully agree.
Would be interesting if the OP would post the requested photo so we could see it.
Also does it serve her own property?

Testina · 04/11/2022 08:20

@dottypotter “Maybe, but what about the fact they put it up and trespassed without permission at some point?
It's the fact they didn't follow the right channels in the first place that needs to be addressed.”

You really think BT just waltzed onto the property after OP bought it, and placed it?
At some point, it was placed there.
The owner at that point was in agreement.
That owner or a chain of owners sold to OP.
OP bought knowing there was no payment - or the seller would have informed her.

I expect the original agreement was either done years ago and somewhere along the way the agreement has been lost (e.g. a paper record of a one off payment) or a mistake made - not setting up the wayleave.

But even if thar original “mistake” was actually BT deliberately conning the original homeowner and lying that there was no choice and no payment, that wasn’t done to the OP.

Now if OP was somehow suing the original owner for not declaring that BT had access, and it was the original owner posting saying, “can I get a solicitor to make BT pay, cos they lied to me in the first place” I might say go for it.

But this is entirely the OP on a money grab for something she bought fully aware of. So £200 is a nice wee bit of money for nothing, and enough.

It’s in the public interest to allow items like this on private land - our infrastructure for electricity, telecommunications etc fuels our economy. If a court was involved in deciding the correct recompense, they would take that public interest into account. Additional cost on wayleaves would increase prices for all.

OP is chancing here arm, but she’s taking the piss.

Clymene · 04/11/2022 06:29

Dougieowner · 04/11/2022 00:11

I think this has been done to death now.

The DP (as I presume it to be?) exists, you would be willing for it to remain if you were offered more money for the wayleave agreement but you don't want to accept the (standard) sum that has already been offered. Answer, you ask for them to make arrangements to have it removed.

Simple and everyone is happy. 😁

She won't be happy because then she won't get the £200 Grin

Dougieowner · 04/11/2022 00:11

I think this has been done to death now.

The DP (as I presume it to be?) exists, you would be willing for it to remain if you were offered more money for the wayleave agreement but you don't want to accept the (standard) sum that has already been offered. Answer, you ask for them to make arrangements to have it removed.

Simple and everyone is happy. 😁

JKGalbraith · 03/11/2022 23:26

‘no win no fee’ 🤣 good luck with that.

If you don’t want it on your property, tell them to remove it. If it doesn’t bother you, take the money. Otherwise stop being so grabby

BMW6 · 03/11/2022 23:18

But you haven't answered my questions 🙄 I didn't ask you if you knew about Wayleaves did I.

I thought though you may have said "WTF is that and what's it doing attached to this property that I am looking to buy"? No?

WelshNerd · 03/11/2022 22:52

@Testina I did read my link and I am aware the issue is not identical to the OPs. However, as the issue relates to wayleave agreements with utilities I felt it was similar enough that signposting towards the company may be useful.

NoSquirrels · 03/11/2022 22:38

Honestly, take the £200 and let them have access to the box.

Or tell them to remove it if you’re dead set against anyone on your property ever.

We have a way leave for a cable under our garden - it’s about £2.50 or something every few years. And the water board need access to a manhole regularly to inspect. It makes no difference to your life, honestly. Let them do what they need.

dottypotter · 03/11/2022 22:35

Clymene · 03/11/2022 22:29

Some of us are 'up on these things' and can tell you that there's no way in hell you're getting any more than the £200 they've offered.

So you either take that or get them to remove the box.

Those are your options.

Maybe, but what about the fact they put it up and trespassed without permission at some point?
It's the fact they didn't follow the right channels in the first place that needs to be addressed.
Interesting Post. How many folks had heard of Wayleave I hadn't.

Hedgesfullofbirds · 03/11/2022 22:31

Sorry, posted too soon!

...a step down transformer in my garden, paying me £2000 for each 14 year period.
The irony is that I live very rurally and the transformer only supplies my property and that of my only immediate neighbour!

Swipe left for the next trending thread