Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bus driver wouldn't let my dad on bus aibu to think he is a jobsworth?

310 replies

oohopo · 03/11/2022 12:01

My dad is 85.
He has a bus pass.
He was coming to my house last night for tea.
He got on bus and his pass wouldn't work (it has a tiny rip in)
It was valid for two years still.
Normally you tap your pass and they let you on.
Obviously when he was tapping it wasn't registering.
So he had to get off and go home to get his wallet.
He was coming to mine so didn't think he needed anything but his pass.

It made zero difference to that bus driver
Aibu to think it's a shitty thing to do to a elderly man.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 03/11/2022 16:30

Maybe he was an annoying jobsworthy, plain and simple. But maybe he was new or maybe the jobsworthy is 'one step above him' and has recently come down on him for letting someone on the bus when a pass didn't work. Maybe that jobsworthy or someone else is truly 'after his job' and he's being extra careful so as not to give them reason to sack him. Maybe an edict has 'come down from on high' and he doesn't want to take a chance. You just don't know.

I'm a senior. There have been times I've been given a 'senior privilege' simply based on my appearance or because the 'entity' involved has a 'don't ask, don't tell' policy. But I never assume and there have been times I've been asked for ID so I always carry it. Better safe than sorry. If the issue was that Dad had no cash, he needs to remember to carry a bit of cash, if only because passes can also get lost or stolen. Plus, it's always good to carry some spare cash. DH and I always have what we call our 'hidden $20' in our wallets for emergencies.

Kat70 · 03/11/2022 16:29

SpinningFloppa · 03/11/2022 13:08

No it’s not different as the school kid would be in uniform!

Well in my area a child in school uniform can't be refused travel by bus drivers on school days even if they've forgotten their pass! This is an agreement made by the bus companies to ensure children are never left in a vulnerable position.

JOFFCV · 03/11/2022 16:28

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 16:20

@Canthave2manycats get a grip if you bothered to read all of my comments I said things like this happen in London weekly. Maybe I’m just desensitised.

It would have been nice to let the old man on yes but he didn’t HAVE too. That’s my point

Would you have let him on?

oopsfellover · 03/11/2022 16:25

Not keen on the word jobsworth as it’s often applied sneeringly to people who haven’t actually got much flexibility about how to do their job. However this does seem unnecessary from the driver.

BellePeppa · 03/11/2022 16:22

I would complain and tell them exactly which bus it was. Bloody hate jobsworth prats.

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 16:20

@Canthave2manycats get a grip if you bothered to read all of my comments I said things like this happen in London weekly. Maybe I’m just desensitised.

It would have been nice to let the old man on yes but he didn’t HAVE too. That’s my point

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 16:19

ancientgran · 03/11/2022 15:41

So for those of us not in London, can you check visually that the oyster card is valid/n date/paid for or whatever, is there a photo so you can see it is there. If you can visually see the card is OK but the reader isn't reading it then yes I think they should be allowed on.

Yeah on zip oysters for those under 15 (I think it’s from 11-15) you can see the date it expires and it has a picture of their face on it. So many kids come on the bus with a cracked oyster or a picture with a scratch in it, all the things that’s now allowed stated in the terms & conditions. Some bus drivers still let them on but many don’t. I agree with you, it should be allowed in these circumstances but I don’t think the ones who don’t allow it are bad for following their job

Canthave2manycats · 03/11/2022 16:10

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 15:28

You’re right but the driver didn’t do anything wrong by not letting him on, it’s really as simple as that

It's shocking that any bus driver would treat an elderly passenger clearly entitled to concessionary travel, just because 'computer says no'!!!

It's even more shocking that some posters don't think this twat of a driver did anything wrong!!! So much for "Be Kind"!!

One day, if you are lucky @DoubleBuggyDriver , you may find yourself in a similar situation.... bet you will change your tune then. An incident like this is quite liable to rob an elderly person of their confidence and thus independence (as I think someone posted upthread) - but what would the likes of you care about that! Maybe you could start a campaign to remove concessionary travel for older people, seeing as you are completely devoid of empathy?

Seriously, what kind of person would put an elderly man off a bus that he was clearly entitled to travel on? Takes jobsworth to a whole new level!

Prettypenny123 · 03/11/2022 16:01

This is awful. Funnily enough my very pretty young adult daughter often gets waved on to the bus for free, have seen this happen when I’ve waited with her at night to see her in the bus safely so I don’t buy that “more than my jobs worth” crap. Complain.

HaveANiceFuckingDay · 03/11/2022 16:01

My 14 year daughter in full school uniform gets free travel with an oyster card . The children under 16 all get free travel we are in a oyster card area. She forgot her pass. The driver let her on and the conductor got on and fined her £40 for not having her pass. Even tho he knows she is entitled to free travel as she is under 16 . Yes it was a shitty thing to do I agree but maybe if he'd let him on a conductor might have got on and fined him £40 because it was damaged. Not agreeing with the bus driver at all in your dad's situation at all but the driver would have got the blame

SuperCamp · 03/11/2022 15:53

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:39

The amount of passengers on the bus and the amount who paid or used a pass if a revenue inspector gets on.

And how would this revenue inspector know how many people had got off the bus?

I have never seen them count people.

They get on, check tickets and passes. The OP's Dad could have shown his pass - albeit damaged.

Do you have insider knowledge of revenue protection inspections?

maddiemookins16mum · 03/11/2022 15:51

These kinds of incidents really upset me, I get so cross on behalf of an elderly chap I’ve never meant. It’s just so unkind. I so wish someone on the bus had offered to pay.

Onlyforcake · 03/11/2022 15:49

It sounds ridiculous. Drivers have waved me to sit down when the card won't scan due to the tech being a bit precious at times. If someone comes to inspect then obviously the driver and the passenger would explain and stick to the decision when they can visually check its a valid card?! There's no point in it being photo I'd if it doesn't work as a manual back up.

Regularsizedrudy · 03/11/2022 15:48

Thelnebriati · 03/11/2022 12:14

There was a case in Nottingham where a young woman was raped at the bus stop after being refused entry on to the bus, and they changed the rules and gave the bus drivers more leeway.

So its worth raising it as an issue with the bus company.

Yes I remember this case, it was truly chilling. She was 20p short or something in the middle of the night. I’m amazed at the lack of human decency often displayed by bus drivers.

ancientgran · 03/11/2022 15:45

SleepingStandingUp · 03/11/2022 14:34

But if my pass didn't scan despite being in date, no one would think I, able bodied middle aged women, should travel regardless. It would be "well you should have made sure your pass worked first!"

And tbf, I've said upthread they should be able to punch it in manually, and I've def seen drivers use their descretion on a balance of probability of being inspected. Which is good and it would have been the kind thing to let him travel. But I don't think it's "sack the bstrd" event either like some people are making out.

How do you check your pass is working without getting on a bus and trying it?

FernlovingNodosaur · 03/11/2022 15:43

JOFFCV Yes I have, in the past given up my seat or moved seats for people more vulnerable than me on quite a few occasions. On a couple of occasions to people with double buggies too. There are even signs on the buses I travel on requesting I do this for elderly people. Bad bus companies giving favours to the elderly like that. I think there is a bit of the green eyed monster about what she/he considers freebies/favours to the elderly in DoubleBuggyDriver posts.

ancientgran · 03/11/2022 15:41

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 15:03

You didn’t answer the question? If you get special treatment because you’re old then surely school kids who’s zip oyster have a crack in it should still be allowed on the bus?

If old people get allowances for being old then why can’t younger people get allowances for being young? I’d genuinely like an answer

So for those of us not in London, can you check visually that the oyster card is valid/n date/paid for or whatever, is there a photo so you can see it is there. If you can visually see the card is OK but the reader isn't reading it then yes I think they should be allowed on.

ancientgran · 03/11/2022 15:38

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 13:43

Perhaps you could take your dad's dignified response rather than name calling the key workers who continued getting you all to work during a pandemic with no protection while their colleagues were all dropping like flies 😉

Perhaps you could read the post from a bus driver who explained how you deal with this.

ancientgran · 03/11/2022 15:35

AutumnLea · 03/11/2022 13:31

Bus driver here.

At our company management would want to be informed of an incident like this as we would consider it poor customer service and would have a word with the driver. It could have been a new driver not familiar with handling those situations just yet.

In this case we would issue a manual ticket, encourage them to order a replacement and allow travel. If an inspector boarded they would be happy with that.

We don't leave vulnerable people at the roadside.

Thank you for the information and it is nice to know that there is still commonsense being used.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 03/11/2022 15:33

Total arsehole.

My card hasn't work for whatever reason in the past and the driver would let me on.

Some of them are jobsworths.

I always brought a spare euro on the school run because I have seen drivers refuse school children if they'd no credit for the fare or their card acts up.

I've only had to use it twice for a school going child.

I'd like someone to do the same for DD.

I'm sorry someone didn't offer to pay your DF fare.

DoYouKenMrsM · 03/11/2022 15:32

YANBU.

JOFFCV · 03/11/2022 15:31

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 15:28

You’re right but the driver didn’t do anything wrong by not letting him on, it’s really as simple as that

People can still think he's a twat for not letting him on.

Will have to agree to disagree.

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 15:28

JOFFCV · 03/11/2022 15:26

People give up seats on buses for old people, pregnant ladies & disabled people because they are being kind. Most people probably wouldn't give up a seat for a young healthy person. So yes most people do tend to treat old people differently.

You’re right but the driver didn’t do anything wrong by not letting him on, it’s really as simple as that

JOFFCV · 03/11/2022 15:26

DoubleBuggyDriver · 03/11/2022 15:16

How do I sound like I hate old people? I don’t think you understand, no one is obliged to do any favours for anyone. You just said his pass didn’t work. If the bus driver let him on then that would have been a nice thing to do. He asked him to get off meaning he didn’t want to do OPs dad a favour.

I don’t think you should get certain allowances just because you’re old. So many of these comments are saying the driver’s a prick or a jobsworth etc but if the OP said her daughter’s zip oyster had a crack in it and a driver didn’t let her on, people would be saying she needs a replacement and the driver didn’t do anything wrong. Double standards tbh

People give up seats on buses for old people, pregnant ladies & disabled people because they are being kind. Most people probably wouldn't give up a seat for a young healthy person. So yes most people do tend to treat old people differently.

MyOnlyDays · 03/11/2022 15:21

It must have been more than a small rip for the pass not to have worked. 🫤

I think it's a shame the bus driver couldn't have let him on but I think it's unfair for posters to be so rude about the driver when they don't know what the rules are. Maybe some companies give bus driver some discretion but maybe this bus drivers company doesn't or, if it does, then it only covers people travelling at night or something.

My brother works as an engineers for a big national company and has ZERO discretion about how he does certain parts of his job that customers can not seem to understand. My brother thinks the rules are too rigid but ultimately won't risk his job.

Maybe that bus driver had been to generous in the past and is on a warning. You just don't know the rules.

I suspect though that he gets so much abuse from passengers that he has decided to just follow the rules. If he let on one person then he risks other passengers whinging about when they weren't let on free. Anyone who doesn't fancy paying would just claim they forgot their pass and that they were disabled. It's harder to stop if there aren't fixed rules.

There is plenty of fraud around and plenty of people who try it on all the time.