Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bus driver wouldn't let my dad on bus aibu to think he is a jobsworth?

310 replies

oohopo · 03/11/2022 12:01

My dad is 85.
He has a bus pass.
He was coming to my house last night for tea.
He got on bus and his pass wouldn't work (it has a tiny rip in)
It was valid for two years still.
Normally you tap your pass and they let you on.
Obviously when he was tapping it wasn't registering.
So he had to get off and go home to get his wallet.
He was coming to mine so didn't think he needed anything but his pass.

It made zero difference to that bus driver
Aibu to think it's a shitty thing to do to a elderly man.

OP posts:
HistrionicNeurotic · 03/11/2022 12:50

Your poor dad. Making a hex for that awful bus driver. Blady jobs worth indeed

Drodeadledbedfedheadredsaid · 03/11/2022 12:50

You 100 percent need to complain with time number of bus bus stop etc if that is their blanket policy that driver has no control over they need to change it. If it is not the driver needs to be told. Totally unacceptable to treat an elderly person like that same goes for anyone to be honest but vulnerable disabled and young should not be left at bus stops. As long as dad isn't making up an excuse of why he was late of course. If no joy from bus company expose them in the paper.

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:50

oakleaffy · 03/11/2022 12:46

Exactly.
Just the other day I got on the bus and didn’t have exactly the right change.
Driver waved me through - ( only a few stops til bus station)
Drivers can use their discretion.
It’s obvious that an 80 yr old is going to have free travel ( The rest of us probably will have to be 100 before getting free travel as things stand currently)

Rubbish. Drivers can not use their discretion. There are conditions of carriage. Phone a bus garage and ask them. They'll laugh at you.

SirenSays · 03/11/2022 12:49

It's cruel to leave people stranded, I'd definitely complain. I remember reading about a girl who was brutally attacked because the bus driver wouldn't let her on as she was 20p short

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2022 12:49

Mariposista · 03/11/2022 12:37

Your poor, poor dad. If I had been on the bus I would have paid for his fare and made sure he had the means to get himself home.
Why are some people so mean to elderly people? I was in a small seaside cafe the other day and they had a cash free policy. This sweet old gentleman on his own was ahead of me and doesn't use a credit card, he only had a 5 note. The girl at the till said sorry, can't serve you then. Fortunately the nice family ahead of him paid for his 1,20 cup of coffee and gave the girl what for.

They had no business giving the girl what for. Is she supposed to risk her job by giving free stuff away? Social media complain on the business page, but don't verbally abuse staff.

I'm surprised that someone didn't pay him on, that's the norm were I live.

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:48

Whiteminnowfish · 03/11/2022 12:46

Aaaahhh...your poor dad, bless him.

That bus driver was a total jobsworth, yes. He could have turned a blind eye and let your dad on the bus. He would've been able to clearly see that he is elderly.

If his manager got on the bus to do a check, the bus driver could have just explained his decision.

I rarely use buses, but on the occasions I have had to use a bus, some of the drivers are abit grumpy.

Drivers don't get to explain their decision. They don't get to use their own discretion. It doesn't work like that. They are disciplined if they get caught letting people on without paying or a working pass.

oakleaffy · 03/11/2022 12:46

Dreamwhisper · 03/11/2022 12:22

That's bloody awful and completely unreasonable. I'm very cynical about this as I (as a youngish woman) have been let on the bus loads of times if card didn't go through, wrong change etc. So there obviously isn't a huge pressure on them to never use their discretion.

I'd be really upset and actually would right to them. If he has a pass in date, he should have let him on the bus and advised he get a replacement. I'd speak to their customer services and let them know if happened and express your concern. It's bloody cold as well.

Exactly.
Just the other day I got on the bus and didn’t have exactly the right change.
Driver waved me through - ( only a few stops til bus station)
Drivers can use their discretion.
It’s obvious that an 80 yr old is going to have free travel ( The rest of us probably will have to be 100 before getting free travel as things stand currently)

Whiteminnowfish · 03/11/2022 12:46

Aaaahhh...your poor dad, bless him.

That bus driver was a total jobsworth, yes. He could have turned a blind eye and let your dad on the bus. He would've been able to clearly see that he is elderly.

If his manager got on the bus to do a check, the bus driver could have just explained his decision.

I rarely use buses, but on the occasions I have had to use a bus, some of the drivers are abit grumpy.

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:46

Besides. A damaged pass is not valid.

Maverickess · 03/11/2022 12:45

FictionalCharacter · 03/11/2022 12:21

Surely if there was a spot check, it would be revealed that the discrepancy was due to a passenger who had a valid pass that couldn’t be counted? The company didn’t lose money from this journey- it’s not like someone being on the bus who didn’t have a pass and didn’t pay a fare.
The welfare of elderly and vulnerable passengers should trump protocol, and drivers and inspectors should be given discretion.

Exactly, drivers should be given the discretion to make these decisions, the ones I know personally are not and they are the ones liable for punishment if they do. And get called jobsworths and arses if they don't, like the way everyone is jumping to calling the bus driver names here and complaining about him personally, without knowing if this was his decision solely or if it's a company policy that means punishment for deviating from.

Of course if the drivers do have discretion then yes, he made the wrong call imo and needs to be spoken to.

I don't agree personally with all the policies or even laws I have to work under and enforce, but that means diddly squat if I'm caught not doing it.

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:45

Bookworm20 · 03/11/2022 12:42

The amount of passengers on the bus and the amount who paid or used a pass if a revenue inspector gets on.

Understand that. But I think if I was a bus driver I'd rather feel the need to explain to the inspector on the off chance one actually got on, than leave an elderly person with a valid pass behind on their own.

The revenue inspector reports you to your garage. Drivers can get in trouble if they do this in front of a revenue inspector. It isn't a black and white matter.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 03/11/2022 12:45

Mariposista · 03/11/2022 12:37

Your poor, poor dad. If I had been on the bus I would have paid for his fare and made sure he had the means to get himself home.
Why are some people so mean to elderly people? I was in a small seaside cafe the other day and they had a cash free policy. This sweet old gentleman on his own was ahead of me and doesn't use a credit card, he only had a 5 note. The girl at the till said sorry, can't serve you then. Fortunately the nice family ahead of him paid for his 1,20 cup of coffee and gave the girl what for.

Thing is that's not the girl's decision. It was made by whoever owns the business, we're rural and a few places have gone cash free to reduce banking costs. She can't give away free stuff. I suppose she could perhaps pay for it herself and take the cash but it's a complete PITA and is probably against company policy.

£1.20 for a coffee though, where is this cafe located? In the 90's?

ReformedWaywardTeen · 03/11/2022 12:42

It's nasty but I'm not surprised
DD and their mate went to the cinema in half term, and their friend had their usual weekly bus pass they use for school.
The bus driver refused to let her use it, saying she was clearly using someone else's pass because it was daytime and she "looked too old" for a school bus pass. She's 15! And it was half term. It hadn't been an issue on the way there. It was pouring with rain and getting dark. Luckily DD had enough money for a single fare for her friend and wouldn't have left her behind.

Their mum did complain and was refunded for the single ticket.

Some of them are just jobsworths. If they can see it's valid then obviously it's at their discretion but seeing an elderly gent have to get off is terrible. I so hope you raise it for him.

DarkMatternix · 03/11/2022 12:42

There's a special name round here for the old people trying to use the bus passes before 9:30, it's that common. Twirlies, as in "Am i too early?"

Bookworm20 · 03/11/2022 12:42

The amount of passengers on the bus and the amount who paid or used a pass if a revenue inspector gets on.

Understand that. But I think if I was a bus driver I'd rather feel the need to explain to the inspector on the off chance one actually got on, than leave an elderly person with a valid pass behind on their own.

purplewashbag · 03/11/2022 12:41

I'd report it and let the company deal with. Probably be tempted for a sad face local paper as well because what on Earth are we coming to when we treat people this way. It's cruel.

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:41

Bookworm20 · 03/11/2022 12:37

I too would contact the company and raise a complaint. He had a valid bus pass, was was obviously elderly at 85 and wasn't let on purely because the machine thingy didn't register his pass. All the driver had to do was inspect it and allow him to travel. If a spot check happened, its not like he let someone on for free is it.

Plenty of elderly people would be left inconvenienced or worse vulnerable for such a rule. Luckily your dad was able to walk home and get his wallet. What if he'd been travelling back to his home though and unable to get there, just because the machine didn't register his pass?

It definitely needs raising. Rules may be rules, but common sense needs to kick in sometimes.

No. He was not let on because his pass was damaged and no longer worked. The machine did its job and rejected a faulty pass. It isn't a free service. If your pass is damaged it is your responsibility to get a replacement.

Limosella · 03/11/2022 12:41

Dotjones · 03/11/2022 12:09

On the face of it, YANBU, but the bus driver doesn't necessarily have the power to allow people on without a valid pass or ticket. Bus drivers can get into trouble if they are caught allowing this to happen.

There's also the aspect that elderly passengers tend to be the most difficult because bus drivers regularly have to deal with ones who haven't got their pass or are trying to use it on a service that won't accept them. (What I mean is, not all are difficult, but proportionally they make up a large part of the "troublesome" customers drivers have to deal with each day. I get the bus regularly and I see this at least weekly. The occasions where I've been on a bus and a driver has needed to call the police out to remove a disruptive passenger were all due to elderly passengers refusing to get off, despite not having their pass on them.)

Really? Have you never travelled by bus when the kids are let out from school. Many have 'forgotten or lost' their passes and give the driver lip if they are questioned about it. I travel a lot by bus and it certainly isn't the older passengers who are difficult. These kids incidentally are often travelling all of two or three stops which they could possibly walk although maybe not last night when it was pissing with rain

ProFannyTea · 03/11/2022 12:39

RoseslnTheHospital · 03/11/2022 12:05

@PuttingDownRoots which numbers need to tally?

The amount of passengers on the bus and the amount who paid or used a pass if a revenue inspector gets on.

Mariposista · 03/11/2022 12:37

Your poor, poor dad. If I had been on the bus I would have paid for his fare and made sure he had the means to get himself home.
Why are some people so mean to elderly people? I was in a small seaside cafe the other day and they had a cash free policy. This sweet old gentleman on his own was ahead of me and doesn't use a credit card, he only had a 5 note. The girl at the till said sorry, can't serve you then. Fortunately the nice family ahead of him paid for his 1,20 cup of coffee and gave the girl what for.

Bookworm20 · 03/11/2022 12:37

I too would contact the company and raise a complaint. He had a valid bus pass, was was obviously elderly at 85 and wasn't let on purely because the machine thingy didn't register his pass. All the driver had to do was inspect it and allow him to travel. If a spot check happened, its not like he let someone on for free is it.

Plenty of elderly people would be left inconvenienced or worse vulnerable for such a rule. Luckily your dad was able to walk home and get his wallet. What if he'd been travelling back to his home though and unable to get there, just because the machine didn't register his pass?

It definitely needs raising. Rules may be rules, but common sense needs to kick in sometimes.

Caroffee · 03/11/2022 12:34

Complain to the bus company and/or the local press.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 03/11/2022 12:33

It may very well be that company policy forbids letting them on without paying the fare or a valid pass. The pass doesn't let OAP's on "for free" it gives details to the bus company who then charge the cost of the fare to whoever is paying for the scheme. Scottish government up here.

If a driver was to let a passenger on without valid pass/ payment then they could be considered as acting ultra vires and be personally liable for any compensation claims in the event of an accident.

nothingevergoesright · 03/11/2022 12:32

Thing is, without the card registering by tapping, there is no way the company get paid (the council reimburse the bus companies an absolute pittance for OAP and disabled cards). The company would get nothing for letting your father on without the card being tapped (there is no over-ride available, if there was it would be open to fraud).

It also has the knock on effect on reducing bus services if they let people on without their cards working.

That said, my husband would have let your father on, he does with children and elderly. Drivers have some discretion, but it does lose the company money as they cannot recoup their costs for just 'looking at a card'.

InFiveMins · 03/11/2022 12:30

Disgusting. Get complaining to the company. Your poor dad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread