Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

making jam yourself is stupidly expensive.

156 replies

ToniAlto · 03/11/2022 09:34

We've got a glut of apples so started investigating the internet and adding to basket all the bits and pieces I think I'd need.

I've come to the conclusion that each jar of applesauce would be roughly £12, obviously reducing if I store and reuse the jars and equipment for the next ten years.

AIBU to think that home made jam/sauce is stupidly expensive.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 03/11/2022 12:00

I do, if I want them all to match. If you want to be competitively holier-than-thou about it, you could consider that if you truly were reducing, reusing, recycling, and knitting all your own yoghurt, you'd have precious few old jars anyway, wouldn't you? What with making everything yourself.

i knit my own yoghurt and crochet my own müsli. My DH bakes all our bread and we make pretty much everything from scratch (what can i say? I'm an old hippy and he's a chef)

we haven't bought jam for years, people give us jars and often return the ones we gave them previously (in return for a load of jars usually). The only jars we reuse from bought are the honey jars, and those from dill pickles (which we give to the neighbour who makes her own)

The sneering is so unattractive

Ariela · 03/11/2022 11:56

Jam Pan: direct.asda.com/george/home/pots-pans/silver-stainless-steel-stock-pot-30cm/051073770,default,pd.html?cgid=D26M08G08C12
These are really good value.

Jam thermometer: www.dunelm.com/product/jam-thermometer-1000117935

If you have a food processor, then use that to chop stuff up.

You don't need tongs if you have oven gloves.

Ask locally on FB for old jars. Many come with perfectly reusable lids (ones that have not been used for curry or similar that stains the seal.
Or buy replacement lids - you can often find packs of assorted sizes online

UnaOfStormhold · 03/11/2022 11:54

In canning you need to achieve fully sterilised and sealed jar contents to avoid the risk of food poisoning. This is quite different from preserving with high quantities of sugar (also applies to preserving in salt, alcohol or vinegar) where the sugar (etc) is in sufficiently high concentration that it provides protection against bacterial growth and spoilage. As a result 50:50 sugar/fruit jams don't need all the canning equipment and reusing jars is fine (I still put my jars in boiling water to ensure they're properly clean and try to use the ones whose lids pop to show they've sealed properly). Freezing is also very effective if you don't want to use the high quantities of sugar.

senua · 03/11/2022 11:49

Where is the best place to buy sugar this year? I had trouble finding big/bulk bags but I got some from a Tesco Superstore in the end.

CaptainMyCaptain · 03/11/2022 11:46

You don't need all the gadgetry just a big pan and you would only need to buy sugar. I save all my glass jars so have never bought any. Have a look on Freecycle someone might be giving them away.

Caspianberg · 03/11/2022 11:45

We make jam every year as glut of berries in garden

I use a regular pan, like a pasta saucepan
I use jars from year before, ideally similar so they match.
just buy jam sugar which was 1kg for €1 this year.
I just wash jars in hot soapy water, then sterilise in the oven for 30 mins.

Mincemeat is also homemade, and cheap.

spiderlight · 03/11/2022 11:45

You don't need all the fancy bits. For apple butter, it's just apples, sugar, cinnamon and cloves. Chop, peel and soften the apples in water (with the cores to add pectin), remove cores, whizz up with a hand mixer, add sugar and spices and a pinch of salt, and then simmer for an hour. We reuse/scrounge jars so it costs us very little.

rainstorm101 · 03/11/2022 11:37

My French friends are very into jam making and I think just after making it (before it sets) they store the jars upside down (so that the whole of the inside of the jars, pre sterilised anyway, are covered in boiling hot jam which presumably kills off any remaining spores? I will enquire as to the science but their jam is insanely good.

yes I follow some of the same US sites. - a lot of Americans have big houses, tons of kitchen storage, very cheap kitchen goods and also can mad stuff like beef stew and mince, so they abide very strictly by proper canning rules for all that then extrapolate it through jam etc. They have ‘strong opinions’ on our more relaxed jam making on Reddit canning thread.

SarahAndQuack · 03/11/2022 11:29

SpinMeRightRoundBabyRightRound · 03/11/2022 11:26

@SarahAndQuack it’s just a deep dish baking pan, I don’t cover the jars, just fill it up to the lids. They still form a seal. It could have been ikea but I’m sure I’ve seen similar in supermarkets.

Thank you!

I think I am on the cautious end with canning things, but I'm realising I started doing it when DP was pregnant, so I was being very careful. Given DD is rising six I could probably relax now! Grin

Catgotyourbrain · 03/11/2022 11:28

Jam pan from ebay £15
get on local forum and ask for jars
Buy sugar in bulk.

The sugar is the most costly item, and the space to store the jars.

Its quite quick once you get set up.

Also: I have a white paint pen i write on the jars with. Looks really nice, shows up, and can be washed off for reuse.

The 'canning' thing is confusing I agree - took me ages to work out they are actually jars in the US.

falllakes · 03/11/2022 11:27

I make excellent apple butter in large quantities using the slow cooker.
You need no special equipment, I do use a hand held mixer or the food processor.
But I reuse jars and then tend to keep in fridge afterwards. It keeps for months.
Americans are very OTT about canning.

SpinMeRightRoundBabyRightRound · 03/11/2022 11:26

@SarahAndQuack it’s just a deep dish baking pan, I don’t cover the jars, just fill it up to the lids. They still form a seal. It could have been ikea but I’m sure I’ve seen similar in supermarkets.

AlisonDonut · 03/11/2022 11:21

The apple press and scrutter are for pressing for juice.

Peel, decore, slice and put in a pan and just cover with water and cook. Once cooked, add the same volume of jam sugar. Cook until a rolling boil. Then put a cold plate in the freezer and drop some onto the plate. About 10 seconds later if it crinkles when you run your finger through it, it is done. If not put plate back in freezer and try again a bit later.

Once done, ladle into sterilised jars. Pop some greaseproof paper over with an elastic band or a lid. At best, you need to buy the sugar. Maybe a funnel. If you want to be really sure some milton fluid.

Fleur405 · 03/11/2022 11:20

I made jam for the first time using damsons from a tree at our new house. All I bought was a jam thermometer and some sugar. You do not need all that crap! you just need a heavy bottomed pan.

personally with the apples I’d make a base for apple crumble and freeze in portions ready for crumble topping to be applied!

if you want to avoid all the peeling and chopping, just slice and roast them and the skin will peel off easily once cooked.

Mosik · 03/11/2022 11:16

I made rhubarb jam for the girst time this year. Just bought sugar and scrubbed and sterilised some used glass jars. No special sugar or pectin or pans.
I also have an apple glut but I just stewed and froze it. I used bags and didn't fill them so they could be frozen flat. Takes up very little freezer space that way. Use for puddings, apple sauce or just to eat with yoghurt.

AlviarinAesSedai · 03/11/2022 11:13

People will give you free jars!! You can make jam in microwave.

baffledcoconut · 03/11/2022 11:10

A heavy bottom saucepan and sugar and you’re good to go.

you don’t even need a thermometer.

RinklyRomaine · 03/11/2022 11:07

In the days before DS decimated my crops I would freeze gallons of raspberries and then jam later in the season. We eat lots of gherkins in this house; the jars are reused for bramble and apple jelly and apple jam. Our neighbours garden is blackberry jungle so we don't cut back over the fence until I've filched them, then DH clears a path for the old boy next door and I get the rest! Freeze apple compote for breakfasts, or chopped raw for crumbles. The bramble jelly is fabulous, everyone loves it, toast, cakes, a bit in gravy for roast pork... it's maybe 50P a big jar!

I use a stock pan, bit of sugar and old baby muslins. Sterilise jars in the dishwasher.

Mirabai · 03/11/2022 11:05

pumpkinscoop · 03/11/2022 10:51

Mirabai, DSis was on the hunt for Bonne Maman jars - that was when she discovered all her friends are doing the same! They are ridiculously expensive even on FB. There's Instagram pages devoted to preloved BM jars - they are very pretty.

Our preserves shelves are sadly all mismatched but the jar contents make up for it. We currently have plum sauce, Kashmir chutney, plum chutney, apple and date chutney, damson cheese, apple and chilli jelly, plum jam.

That’s a shame I recently gave away a box of Bonne Maman jars on Freecycle.

I don’t actually like jam, I’m not the jam eater in this household - however I love home-made chutney and yours sound lush.

JudgeJ · 03/11/2022 11:03

ToniAlto · 03/11/2022 09:34

We've got a glut of apples so started investigating the internet and adding to basket all the bits and pieces I think I'd need.

I've come to the conclusion that each jar of applesauce would be roughly £12, obviously reducing if I store and reuse the jars and equipment for the next ten years.

AIBU to think that home made jam/sauce is stupidly expensive.

Apple sauce? It's apples, sugar depending on the apples and water, where on earth do you get £12 from? It needs a knife to peel and core, a big pan, maybe a squirt of lemon juice, that's it, mine usually takes about 5-10 minutes. I then keep it in the freezer in bags or old tubs, eg yoghurt.
Not all cooking needs shares in Lakeland!

C8H10N4O2 · 03/11/2022 11:01

80sMum · 03/11/2022 10:40

A preserving pan is usually larger and shallower, has no lid and usually has 2 handles.

We have a proper big preserving pan, inherited from MiL. Its quite attractive and makes a lovely planter whilst we use a regular lidded pan and sometimes a pressure cooker for actual preserves.

We did use the preserving pan a couple of times but in reality its too big for the domestic quantities we want to cook - its designed for the days when an entire winter's blackberry jam was made in one batch.

We reuse old jam and pickle jars, I do a quick boil but nothing extensive - the stuff going in is extremely hot and the lead seals as it cools.

sueelleker · 03/11/2022 10:58

My late DH loved jam, and I used to make loads of it. A tip for preserving is to add a crushed Campden tablet to each batch. It's sodium metabisulphite, used in wine-making (which I also do) I've never had jam go mouldy when using it. And if you're sterilising a lot of jars, run a dishwasher cycle without detergent.

CraigDavid · 03/11/2022 10:56

I make apple jam and chutney every year because we have an apple tree. I re use all my old bonne maman jars and use my usual big saucepan - you don't need a jam pan. Costs me nothing apart from sugar and gas to cook.

starfishmummy · 03/11/2022 10:55

ToniAlto · 03/11/2022 09:55

I've not actually bought anything yet. I've done the online equivalent of filling a trolley and then running àway, leaving it by the check out.

I also don't want to store a load of specialised, one purpose stuff.

I managed to get it that high by watching YouTube videos by amazing USA canning experts. The next thing is DH spots an apple press £65, then there's the crusher, another £65.
a big jam pan is £60, can tongs £10, thermometer £10, magnetic lid lifter thing....
The matchy, matchy empty Kilner jars work out at over £2 each.

I'm going outside to refile through the recycling bin for the pasta sauce jars...... (Would be wrong to have a sneaky peek in my neighbours?)

Canning is a different thing and assuming you are in the UK, canning equipment is expensive because ynlike the states, it's a niche market.

Americans make jam and then can it for some reason. In the UK we make jam, stick a disc of waxed paper on top, seal the jar with cellophane and a rubber band and keep it for years. You just need to use the right recipe that has enough sugar to preserve it.

Apple sauce is different but there are things you can make like apple butter (a thick jam) that just need a heavy based pan and some jars.

Newusername21 · 03/11/2022 10:55

Apple Butter, Apple sauce and Jam are all very different things and there will be differences to how they are made and stored. Also if you're looking at USA recipes and tutorials be careful of language differences.
If you are making apple sauce that won't keep as long - due to the low sugar content.
Regardless - whatever you are making you will not need any fancy equipment. I've been making jams and chutneys for years and the only "special" thing I've bought is a metal funnel to help fill the jars.