Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy heavy class

37 replies

Jennybeans401 · 03/11/2022 07:04

Dd was bullied at her previous school (Y5) and I removed her a few

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SuTissue · 03/11/2022 09:48

Most of the primary schools where I live are boys or girls only. The one closest by is mixed. My dd will be starting school next year and she always says she wants to go to school with boys and girls. I was all for it and it was top of my list for applications. However, I was since chatting with a neighbour whose dc just started and the class is 5 girls to 29 boys and it has put me right off.
For one thing, dd was very excited to start pre school but there’s been lots of problems with her getting picked on by two of the boys. She wants to play dinosaurs and cars with them and they are into superheroes which she loves, but they won’t let her play with them because she’s a girl. They shout at her and gang up on her. She is too small to even understand why they don’t want to be friends.
I don’t want her to be in a small minority of girls in primary school. She might get along with some of the boys but I think realistically she will not end up having a close friendship with them. I’ve seen the way the kids interact around here and they just don’t mix that way (probably in part because most of the schools are single sex).
As pp said, there’ll be a small pool of girls and if they don’t get on that could be a big problem. It’s also a different story when they’re six to when they’re twelve.
So yes I think it’s a legitimate concern but the low standards in the school is also very concerning.

ThatsBullshirt · 03/11/2022 09:21

All through primary there were 12 girls and 27 boys in my year group. Having more boys was never a problem although there was plenty of drama within the girls!

PeekAtYou · 03/11/2022 09:20

My children have been in classes where the ratio of boys and girls was massively skewed and it worked out fine but I would also be worried. 4 girls means a very small potential friendship pool and if they are paired up or one is a Queen Bee type who dominates then it will negatively affect your dd who needs her self esteem repaired. Ofc there's a chance that things could work out fine but it's a massive risk to take when your child needs her confidence restoring.

Do you plan to move before secondary school ?

thing47 · 03/11/2022 09:17

DD was in boy-heavy classes throughout her time at school, a trend which continued through secondary school. Just a freak year, I think. But our experience of that was wholly positive, @Jennybeans401 we actually found the boys to be very caring and quite protective of the few girls in the class. Of course her close friendship group from school is boy-heavy as a consequence (1 girl and 6 boys), but it has never been a problem.

And it's not as if it led to an issue over forming female friendships – at university she lived in an all-girls house in her second and fourth years.

Also agrees with @Notjusta that a new HT can make a massive difference. DD's secondary modern was in special measures shortly before she started there but a really strong HT and revamped SLT turned it around, clamped down hard on bullying and other issues, encouraged the more academic children, really ramped up the atmosphere of the school as a community working together etc etc. It is now over-subscribed.

isittheholidaysyet · 03/11/2022 09:17

My sons primary class had 26 boys and 9 girls. I think it worked out well for the boys. PPs have queried about behaviour and such like and I think having so many boys helped. The boys could be themselves. There was the usual disruptive few who generally were in with the football gang. But because there were so many of them, there were also groups of geeky boys, academic boys, kind gentle responsible boys, the we-play-any-weird-sport-except-football boys. Etc. It meant the boys could be masculine without being boisterous and disruptive. Which was so nice.

Obviously it was a little harder for the girls, but friendships were common across the genders. There was less of the catty girl problems, because boys don't work like that. But there was 9 of them. So just enough to find another friend if you fell out with someone.

So basically I wouldn't let a boy heavy class put you off.

(Though by year 6 the classroom stank of boy sweat and lynx, but some problems can't be helped!)

FlounderingFruitcake · 03/11/2022 09:15

My DD is in a boy heavy class too. The only issue is that there are less options for girl friendships, so we have had a slightly intense best friend relationship to deal with. Other than that it’s fine, she gets on well with the boys too and it’s a lovely class.
The special measures bit is what would concern me. However, if you’re home schooling now and it’s not really working out then I don’t know what harm would come from giving it a go. Worse case scenario is that DD doesn’t like it and you’re back where you are now.

MrsMoastyToasty · 03/11/2022 09:13

DS was in a class of 21 boys and 9 girls at reception age. Within a few months a couple of families had relocated out of the area and new families moved in, and the balance started to change (we live in an area with military and travellers). By the time he was in year 6 the girls outnumbered the boys.

ShepherdMoons · 03/11/2022 09:11

It's pot luck, you don't know the character/personality of any child until you get to know them. I don't remember such imbalanced classes in terms of gender though, ours was evenly balanced when I was young.

I would try the new school and see how it goes. If it's too rowdy or your dd hates it you haven't lost anything.

TeenDivided · 03/11/2022 09:02

MissWired · 03/11/2022 08:56

A better question would be to ask why the sex ratio is so unbalanced when in nature the ratio of males to females is almost exactly 50/50.

This imbalance was never seen when I was young, so what's changed?

Sometimes it just happens. DD was in a class of 21 girls and 6 boys from reception. However that then put off other boys from joining / staying as there were fewer similar children, so despite significant churn in the class, the in-balance stayed throughout primary.

(Just like you could toss a coin 30 times and get 25 heads and 5 tails or whatever, it doesn't mean that on average it comes out 50-50.)

MissWired · 03/11/2022 08:56

A better question would be to ask why the sex ratio is so unbalanced when in nature the ratio of males to females is almost exactly 50/50.

This imbalance was never seen when I was young, so what's changed?

jeaux90 · 03/11/2022 08:47

WhiteCatmas · 03/11/2022 08:33

Boys aren’t evil you know.

No they aren't but in the secondary school system they commit over 90% of the sexual assaults, and girls were the victim 80% of the time.

There were over 5000 cases in the uk over the recent 3 year period.

So OP is absolutely right. Primary is less of a problem but still a consideration.

Notjusta · 03/11/2022 08:40

WhiteCatmas · 03/11/2022 08:33

Boys aren’t evil you know.

On Mumsnet they are!! Nasty unruly little things 😉.

I'm sorry your DD has had such a horrible time.

I sent my DS to a school that has a poor Ofsted - it had just had a leadership change and was very clearly on the up. I think it can be (but not always) a good time to join a school as with the right leaders things improve rapidly and your child gets all the benefit of that. My DS Scholl recent ofsted saw them get outstanding in 3 of the 5 categories inspected and good overall.

I wouldn't worry about it being boy heavy (as you may guess from my first sentences) - boys are pretty cool (as are girls)!

CaptainMyCaptain · 03/11/2022 08:35

I had 19 boys and 5 girls in a January intake in my Reception class once. It was the best class I ever had. None of them were bullies.

WhiteCatmas · 03/11/2022 08:33

Boys aren’t evil you know.

ShepherdMoons · 03/11/2022 08:32

As for your original question about a boy heavy class it may be okay. If the teacher is good and has good discipline then it could work out great. It also depends what the small group of girls is like, it's very 'up in the air' I know but it's pot luck with the personalities in a class.

ShepherdMoons · 03/11/2022 08:31

I think it's good you've removed your dd, the other school doesn't sound ideal but you could give it a go. You could end up making yourself ill trying to do too much which will be very bad for your dc.

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/11/2022 08:12

Of course they are... God. Please tell me you have options other than 1 or two local high schools?

We didn't go to a local school so anyone my dd had a problem with , well they all went to a different school so it wasn't a worry.

Are you in as incestuous situation as it sounds? What are your options re high schools? If the school doesn't deal with anything and the parents are part of the inner circle then you are gonna be straight back here very soon. 😬

Is moving an option at all ( long shot I know)?

Jennybeans401 · 03/11/2022 08:05

@Whatwouldscullydo the head was dismissive , they said they'd tried lots of strategies but when I asked them about the strategies the head had been watching the children from inside the hall. The bullying was emotional/verbal and nasty but I doubt you'd be able to hear that from the hall.

Dd was so miserable and had been for so long that I took her out.

Local authority told me I now need to complain to the governors then to local authority about it. The bully's mum's best friends are governors at the school though.

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 03/11/2022 07:57

Jennybeans401 · 03/11/2022 07:50

@Whatwouldscullydo the school couldn't do anything more, they said I needed to speak to the bully's parents as the school didn't have the resources to sort the problem out. The school encouraged us to move schools.

Dd was depressed and anxious every day so I took her out of school a few weeks ago.

What resources are they talking about? There's no behaviour policy/ reward/sanction set up?

Have you contacted ousted re the disregard of controlling behaviour at the school?

I only asked because its not that long until you will be looking at high schools and unless there's loads of choice your likely to end up with exactly same kids you moved away from.

Jennybeans401 · 03/11/2022 07:52

I think their ofsted was in 2020, the new head seems good

OP posts:
Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 03/11/2022 07:50

Dd1 only had between 3 and 5 girls in her class the whole way through primary. It was ok and it taught her how to get along with people she wouldn’t be natural friends with.

id be more Concerned about the school being in special measures. How long ago was the last ofstead? Have they had time to improve the standard of teaching since the last inspection.

if it’s your only option then I’d try it. Hopefully it will all work out fine.

Jennybeans401 · 03/11/2022 07:50

@Whatwouldscullydo the school couldn't do anything more, they said I needed to speak to the bully's parents as the school didn't have the resources to sort the problem out. The school encouraged us to move schools.

Dd was depressed and anxious every day so I took her out of school a few weeks ago.

OP posts:
fishonabicycle · 03/11/2022 07:46

My son's primary class was very boy heavy 22 to 10 I think, and it was a lovely class - his teachers all commented on what a nice set of kids.

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/11/2022 07:43

Another thing to consider is where will she be going to secondary school.

Moving further down the school when there's still a few years left for the kids to grow up/out of bullying it would probably make more sense. But moving in year 5, putting her through all that upheaval to simply be back with the same kids in high school in a 2 years later seems a little pointless.

What have you done to work with the school on the bullying? Schools can be terrible for dealing with it but unless you want to play musical schools for the next few years at some point you May find yourself in the position of having to really work with the school and maybe get together with parents. Because actually you could find the bullying moves to your new school fir what ever reason and it starts all over again.

Can you speak to other parents find out of they are working on anything?

Jennybeans401 · 03/11/2022 07:34

Behaviour is good at the other school but the Ofsted report criticised the teaching standards.

A friend of mine also said there is a high turnover of staff.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread