Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish people would stop saying “just put a jumper on”?

245 replies

Notcontent · 02/11/2022 20:35

There have been sooo many thread over the years with people saying how no one really needs heating - how e.g. 16 degrees is positively sweltering - and if you feel the cold you should just put a jumper on and a bit of cold never hurt anyone…

This is complete rubbish and I think this myth needs to be debunked. It’s not helpful. Of course many people are being forced to have their heating off but that does not mean this is good for their physical or mental health.

I was prompted to start this thread as I was listening to a radio 4 science programme that tackled this topic head on. In summary:

  • when we get really cold (e.g. a room at 10 degrees) our body has to work really hard to keep our core warm and this places great strain on our body - increased heart rate, blood pressure, decreased congnitive ability, etc;
  • surprisingly, for a lot of people 23 degrees is the right temperature if you are just sitting around - this does not surprise me as if I am working from home, if I have my thermostat set to 19.5 degrees, I still have to wear ugg slippers and a big jumper;
  • getting chilled does make you likely to get sick - this is because we are constantly being exposed to viruses, which we do fight off (the cold virus in particular) but when we get chilled our body’s immune response is severely impaired.
OP posts:
Bestcatmum · 02/11/2022 22:13

I think that's a bit over the top OP. I grew up on a farm with no central heating whatsoever in a very cold area. The fire only went on in the evening. We just wore more clothing and were more active. We didn't sit around all day like people do now. People have managed without central heating for thousands of years and we haven't died out yet.
I haven't got my heating on. I have an active full time job and keep busy at home. Even hoovering makes me too hot. I'm 60 not a youngster. It's much more dangerous people sitting about all day not moving. We weren't designed to sit at a desk all day or in front of a TV for hours.

SillySausage81 · 02/11/2022 22:12

MyPurpleHeart · 02/11/2022 21:56

And my 99 year old grandmother still refuses to live in a house with heating. It's not as unsurvivable as people think

No heating whatsoever? Not even a fire or wood stove? What is the insulation in her house like? (No heating in a very well insulated house can be quite comfortable. No heating in a very poorly insulated house is a very different matter).

SillySausage81 · 02/11/2022 22:09

Topgub · 02/11/2022 21:22

@Notcontent

We never have the heating on at night.

Even in - temps.

We're fine.

I'm not suggesting it's OK for people to be without heat if they need it and obviously some people really are vulnerable to the cold.

Young, healthy adults? Not so much

Have you considered that your house might be better insulated than some other people's houses? Do any rooms in your house ever reach 9 degrees C in winter? Why are you only talking about having heating on at night? Obviously if you are able to heat your house to a decent temperature during the day and your house is decently insulated then you can turn the heating off at bedtime and the residual heat will keep everyone reasonably toasty until morning. But if you can't heat your house to a decent temp before bedtime in the first place, either because you can't afford the heating or your house is too poorly insulated (or both) then you are in for a bloody miserable night. I remember laying in bed at night as a child and young teen, before we got central heating, breathing under the covers to try and warm myself up, convinced I had early onset arthritis because my joints ached so much from the cold and damp (it happened again when I was a student living in a miserably cold and damp house share and I got tested at the GP - no arthritis, just miserable living conditions). It sounds like you are lucky enough to have never experienced such cold and damp.

APurpleSquirrel · 02/11/2022 22:06

Everyone's different!
My boss, when we shared an office, was a hot person. In the middle of winter she'd be in a T-shirt, skirt, no tights & thin shoes & was fine. She grew up in Scotland.
I, on the other hand am a cold person, & would be on the other side of the office in three layers (including jumpers!), fleece blankets, boots, heater & occasionally gloves. Then my boss would ask if we could open the window Angry
My SIL is even more extreme than me - she is usually in at least 3 layers at all times. House temp is on average 24 degrees (too hot for me!) & during the heatwave she managed to get down to just one layer. She's Australian but had lived over here for nearly 20 years.

Stripedbag101 · 02/11/2022 22:05

Puffykins · 02/11/2022 20:46

I lived through a renovation with no heating last winter. I had to wear a dryrobe, a sheepskin hat and Uggs for the days I was working at my desk, and I was still cold. My fingers used to get so cold I couldn't type. We had no radiators and several of the windows were broken. It was miserable (we also had no kitchen.) But we survived. Just.

I have no heating at the moment and some walls down! It is freezing. A jumper won’t help.

a heated throw has been my saviour - and an oddie!

But, I find I don’t move around the house as much. I get home from work - layer up, wrap myself in a heated throw and sit on the sofa all night. It’s a miserable way to live - I haven’t cleaned the kitchen in weeks😂. It’s too cold to spend any time in there. Just microwave a meal and run back to the sofa.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 02/11/2022 22:03

YANBU. Saying "put a jumper on" is stupid. My old manager used to say this to me.. Usually whilst I was already wearing a jumper 🙄

That horrible feeling of being cold to your bones is awful. It's much easier to cool down than it is to warm up.

GingerScallop · 02/11/2022 22:00

OP, studies have also shown that a comfortable room temperature is higher for women than men. Meanwhile office settings take the men's comfortable temperature range as the standard for comfort leaving women cold.
And if course there is a cultural/geographic element. If you are from a hot country/region your cold is different from someone from cold climes

offyoufuckcuntychops · 02/11/2022 21:58

I grew up in a cold house, and now live in one (by choice).

Each to their own.

I put the heating on for an hour or so when it's properly cold, so the house doesn't get damp (it's prone to it).

If I start to feel cold, I put another cardy on and make a hot water bottle for my feet.

MyPurpleHeart · 02/11/2022 21:56

And my 99 year old grandmother still refuses to live in a house with heating. It's not as unsurvivable as people think

Unseelie · 02/11/2022 21:55

Ifailed · 02/11/2022 20:42

Can't help wondering how humans evolved over 1000s of years without central heating.

Humans are tropical creatures native to Africa. Of those who moved to colder regions like Europe, the vast majority of them died before age five, and those that survived spent a lot of winter huddled around fires. Even my Gran’s generation still had a coal fire in the house and ‘banked’ the fire overnight so it wasn’t completely out then revived it in the morning.

It’s a dangerous myth that humans ever lived without heating.

MyPurpleHeart · 02/11/2022 21:55

I grew up in a house with no central heating and only a fire that heated the hot water. Radiators in the bathroom and front room only.

Many a night did my room go below 10 degrees and I survived, no adverse effects or health problems. You'll be amazed what a hot water bottle and blankets can do!

Delilahonabike · 02/11/2022 21:54

Some of us don't actually have any jumpers, and not really any spare money to buy any! I have a winter coat for when I go out but tend to wear long sleeved T-shirts round the house, new clothes never seem top of the priority list for me so I genuinely don't have many clothes at all. I wouldn't say we overuse our heating during the winter, tend to keep it on a fairly low constant temperature and our house holds the heat well so it's always been ok. Not sure what I'm going to do this year though if I can't afford heating or new jumpers Confused

DiddlyDoris · 02/11/2022 21:53

My room temp is currently reading 16 degrees and I'm sat here in a T-shirt 😅

WaddleAway · 02/11/2022 21:52

I fully agree that constantly breathing in cold air can't be healthy

why would breathing cold air be unhealthy? Damp and mouldy, yes, but why would cold air itself be an issue?

beAsensible1 · 02/11/2022 21:51

i think having to wear more than one jumper and blanket means your ARE cold and should probably warm up your place.

Or a heated blanket central heating is too pricey. But sitting in the cold and damp consistently isn't great for you.

SillySausage81 · 02/11/2022 21:51

I 100% agree. "Just put a jumper on" is patronising nonsense that implies we aren't already wearing a jumper, and that true cold can be defeated with just one layer of synthetic wool.

I work from home at my desk all day and in my last (rented) house the heating and insulation were both extremely sub-par (very old night storage heaters that weren't big enough for the size of the rooms, very large single glazed sash windows with rotting wooden frames), which meant that even with the heating on full, the house was bloody freezing constantly.

I used to wear fingerless gloves at my desk from October through to April, and on really cold days I would wear a woolly hat indoors too. I regularly used to wear a thermal vest and longjohns under my clothes at home, and even though we had an electric blanket on the bed there were still nights where I struggled to get warm at night even WITH the electric blanket on. I regularly used to put off showering and even going to the loo because the bathroom was so unbearably cold I couldn't bear to expose skin. (The bathroom was regularly at around 9-10 degrees C from December to February).

I get the feeling the "just put on a jumper" brigade have never known true cold.

HangOnToYourself · 02/11/2022 21:49

Comedycook · 02/11/2022 21:18

Do you live somewhere very cold? We never have heating on at night unless it's literally freezing weather.

I am up north so yes gets very cold here. I'm not talking about current temps but last year when I stayed at my boyfriends apartment, he only has electric heaters which cost a fortune to run so never puts them on. The apartments are really inefficient, apparently the efficiency rating they currently ha e wont be legal soon and they need to do some work to bring it up to standard. It honestly feels like you are sleeping outside it gets that cold

OhSunnyMorning · 02/11/2022 21:49

I think 16 is plenty warm enough.

Rather than putting a jumper on a hat will make more difference. We all have a responsibility to use less energy if we want to avoid blackouts. Wearing only a T shirt and having the heating on to counter this is really selfish given the current situation.

QS90 · 02/11/2022 21:49

A related issue will be dampness in houses (especially older houses, which is a lot of them). Colder air causes damp, as does insulating a house, so the amount of damp / mould / mildew will rocket a lot of places. This is of course bad for the lungs as well as being unpleasant in itself. No amount of jumper wearing will solve this one!

GetOffTheRoof · 02/11/2022 21:48

I'm sat in 17c in the living room. Jeans, uggs and a tshirt.

I wore the same clothes today for WFH, however needed my Oodie this afternoon. I try to avoid putting the heating on in the day unless I'm freezing as it has always seemed so wasteful. I didn't live in a house with central heating until 2002 at university!

witchesbubblebath · 02/11/2022 21:48

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2022 20:44

Well, they died a lot younger.

Also, it depends on how much and the type, but you can definitely die of exposure.
someone was saying on another thread months ago that no babies died due living in a cold environment. Yes they can and have! Idiot comments!!! Seriously though.

maddiemookins16mum · 02/11/2022 21:47

It’s 20 degrees in our lounge, I’m in my pyjamas (t shirt top, long bottoms). Heating has not been on. I’m warm as toast! In fact I’m too hot.

SoupDragon · 02/11/2022 21:47

RocOn · 02/11/2022 21:46

A lot of them died.

from cold?

WitchyOsmansXraySpectre · 02/11/2022 21:46

I find it odd that British people live in such cold houses

It's cos we're 'ard innit 😆

RocOn · 02/11/2022 21:46

Ifailed · 02/11/2022 20:42

Can't help wondering how humans evolved over 1000s of years without central heating.

A lot of them died.

Swipe left for the next trending thread