Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So pissed off with child's swimming lessons

104 replies

Mammytothreelo · 02/11/2022 19:28

My dc2 age 9 has been in group swimming lessons 18 months & has been on level 2 over a year. He has been at 88% progress only needing to pass one more stage to move up. He's been at tbis percentage for the oast 3 montgs! I went today to watch & ususl teacher missing. The group lessons are 12 pounds for 30 mins, the instructor started 5 minutes late. The area my son needs to pass wasn't covered. I am blue in the face from asking them to asses him to go to level 3. I said to the receptionist before class & she said oh can't be assessed today as usual teacher will only do assessments... New teacher had no interest just stood on side watching. I sent a very pissed off email demanding to know why we are paying 120 quid for a 10 week term & my child hasn't been assessed since sept 1st! Aibu to be ripping?!!! Today's lesson was a complete waste of time & money, teacher was hopeless.. Other teacher is misding more than is there. Dc1 age 10 progressing nicely in level 4 in same pool... The manager is going to call me tomorrow, any advice appreciated!

OP posts:
PlanningTowns · 02/11/2022 20:06

Our public pool was really recommended for lessons, so we enrolled immediately after lockdown. Teachers changed weekly, progress wasn’t recorded, limited times when moving up to the next stage and then 12 in a lesson - they couldn’t actually all get in as the lane too narrow.

pulled her out and going to a private pool with half the kids - done half a term and she is doing so much better and enjoys it.

try and find a private pool, they are out there but you have to look (private schools often have them!)

GabrielAgreste · 02/11/2022 20:04

I was annoyed with the swimming lessons at our leisure centre - my oldest son is very tall and they had him in a stage where he was swimming a distance that was only about 3 times his body length. He wasn’t able to progress or build stamina.

My youngest was totally dependent on floats & was absolutely hysterical at the idea of not having them.

Both kids have had lessons since then were tiny minus the pandemic & minimal progress.

In the end DH and I committed to a minimum of once weekly family swimming with more in the hols and basically taught them ourselves.

DS2 went from clutching onto me, to swimming underwater in the deep end with no aids in about a month of summer holidays twice weekly swims with a week of being on holiday and daily swimming in the middle of that.

FlounderingFruitcake · 02/11/2022 20:02

Are you sure there’s nowhere near you offering 1:1 or small group? Often these are in people’s private houses or schools at the weekend so you wouldn’t necessarily know that they exist if you’re just thinking in terms of where you know there’s a swimming pool locally.

PuttingDownRoots · 02/11/2022 19:58

The post Covid backlog is still causing problems.

My problem was I Stage 5. They never did butterfly. It was all DD needed. I complained weekly. She was swimming width after width in the other strokes while other children couldn't swim a width. Meanwhile her sister was having a similar problem in Level 4. A new teacher immediately moved DD2 up a group... she completed stage 5 in 7 weeks. Meanwhile DD1 had finished stage 5, and was waiting for Stage 6 lessons. At which point I withdrew both as it was all so pointless. The manager said they had asked for more stage 5-7 groups to be created instead of starting more in Stage 1, but they had been refused....

Mammytothreelo · 02/11/2022 19:57

billy1966 · 02/11/2022 19:41

How many in the class?
If 6 for example, each child is getting 5 minute tuition max for £12.

Very poor.
The teacher being late is VERY.

Check the cost of the one one one.
Mine was £25 for 30 minutes, but were getting 3 times the one on one and they just flew through the levels.

Worth every penny to get it over and done with.

7 in the group class!

OP posts:
notmyrealmoniker · 02/11/2022 19:56

Thats very slow progress. DS is also 9 and swimming weekly for 2 years and is on level 7. Maybe an alternative pool?

Mammytothreelo · 02/11/2022 19:56

Reluctantadult · 02/11/2022 19:37

I've had similar frustrations, so share your annoyance! My 2 dc have also been at their levels 1 year. Ds 5 in stage 1 then had new little ones join his class which set the whole class back. He was doing no swimming, having previously been up to swimming a width with no floats. Dd 8 in stage 3 was also seemingly going backwards, different teacher every other week, always told she needed to work on one last thing and ' to be more consistent'. But how could she with a diff teacher every other week. In the end I didn't exactly complain but I did set out my concerns and referred to the swim England skills they needed to demonstrate to go up. They've both been moved up as of next week.

@Reluctantadult dc2 has been on 88% for the past 3 months, it's crazy isn't it! Noone taking responsibility or covering the 12% needed, one tiny area to get him to level 3. I think when the manager calls tomo I'll be demanding they just move him up..

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 02/11/2022 19:54

See if they can change class - often a different teacher will see things differently.

I would definitely complain about a significantly late starting class though and ask for assessment next week. You'll probably find they will move up and be 'found a space if the swim manager is any good...

Mammytothreelo · 02/11/2022 19:53

AloysiusBear · 02/11/2022 19:35

Also at our pool they never move kids mid term because spaces rarely come up in the classes then and they are always full with waiting lists.

Whatever you do though, don't be tempted to pull him out entirely & refuse to pay until there's a space at level 3. Once out of the system they'll never find you one as he's not even blocking a space in a Level 2 group.

That's my other issue exactly! My friend has 2 dc at the pool & paid for 4 weeks during the summer term that they were on hols for as their spaces would be gone & there's nowhere else locally for lessons it's crazy!

OP posts:
Mammytothreelo · 02/11/2022 19:50

Thatiswild · 02/11/2022 19:34

Look elsewhere, I pay £15 for 1:1 lessons of 30 mins and the kids fly through the levels as it’s so much more personalised, the cost isn’t very much more and also takes a lot less years to get through the levels. Worth a look around anyway.

Where you are sounds like the first place I took my eldest, took forever to move through the levels, I got sick of it by level 2. It’s appalling.

Unfortunately there's nowhere else around for lessons, dh takes them to the public pool 20 miles away about once a month. They started after the lockdown regulations lifted & there is huge waiting lists in the pool..

OP posts:
Reluctantadult · 02/11/2022 19:49

Mine are learn to swim group lessons. Same issues, see my pp. But yeah they have the reputation here for being 'harder' in terms of their gradings, so presumably more exacting standards. Also they're good value £50 for a block of ten. Although some of the groups are large.

Bunnycat101 · 02/11/2022 19:48

We’re in the ‘been in a stage for a year’ club too. It’s driving me nuts but the worst thing about it is the slightly rubbish teacher taught my daughter a bad habit that the new teacher is trying to correct so she won’t be going anywhere until she’s unlearnt the past year of lessons. That was not welcome news!

Selkiesarereal · 02/11/2022 19:47

Our stages were recategorised so no idea what level of ability your dc has but we put ours into swimming club as the council lessons were just hopeless.

The speed that they have progressed in club swimming compared to council lessons is staggering. I would definitely recommend as whilst it is slightly more expensive, they get far more swimming time and less hanging around.

CourtAppointedHairdresser · 02/11/2022 19:46

itsgettingweird · 02/11/2022 19:43

Do you have a swimming club locally who do learn to swim?

They are generally better value. They teach to a higher technical standard usually because they are wanting children to get good enough to continue into the club and squads (business model!) and due to said business model they also want to keep parents on side to remain at the club so assess well and often.

They also tend to have much more in pool support (swim assistants) because many older swimmers do it to gain experience as they'll do on to teaching or volunteer as part of their D of E.

Great tip for all of us in this boat, thanks!

FancyFelix · 02/11/2022 19:43

Ditched swimming lessons because of this.

That Becky adlington swim stars are absolutely bloody awful. Can't think of a company I've had worse customer service from.

itsgettingweird · 02/11/2022 19:43

Do you have a swimming club locally who do learn to swim?

They are generally better value. They teach to a higher technical standard usually because they are wanting children to get good enough to continue into the club and squads (business model!) and due to said business model they also want to keep parents on side to remain at the club so assess well and often.

They also tend to have much more in pool support (swim assistants) because many older swimmers do it to gain experience as they'll do on to teaching or volunteer as part of their D of E.

CourtAppointedHairdresser · 02/11/2022 19:42

YANBU. When you get a call back, try to stay focused on the outcome you want (son has no opportunity currently to make progress and you want him to learn this area then get assessed) rather than the unreliable teacher.

shivermetimbers77 · 02/11/2022 19:41

Yes, my son has been in stage 4 for over a year.

billy1966 · 02/11/2022 19:41

How many in the class?
If 6 for example, each child is getting 5 minute tuition max for £12.

Very poor.
The teacher being late is VERY.

Check the cost of the one one one.
Mine was £25 for 30 minutes, but were getting 3 times the one on one and they just flew through the levels.

Worth every penny to get it over and done with.

TwiggletLover · 02/11/2022 19:40

In our area it is £30 for a 1-2-1 lesson so not sustainable for us on an ongoing basis. £15 is a real bargain

Reluctantadult · 02/11/2022 19:39

@billy1966 ,how old was your dc when you did that, just out of interest?

Coraline353 · 02/11/2022 19:39

We had similar awful lessons and a carousel of useless teachers. I stuck it out because I knew it was temporary (post COVID and we were moving house soon) but I did read them the riot act over teachers being very late for class.

Small group sessions if you can't find 1-2-1 are so much better

TwiggletLover · 02/11/2022 19:38

My DC was in stage 2 for over a year. It was so frustrating. Over the summer they had a week of 1-2-1 lessons and are now at stage 3. Apparently there is a big leap between stage 2 and 3. I didn't see it before but now DC is swimming much more proficiently I understand although still feel that the teaching was pretty poor in the group lessons for it to take so long with no progression

Reluctantadult · 02/11/2022 19:37

I've had similar frustrations, so share your annoyance! My 2 dc have also been at their levels 1 year. Ds 5 in stage 1 then had new little ones join his class which set the whole class back. He was doing no swimming, having previously been up to swimming a width with no floats. Dd 8 in stage 3 was also seemingly going backwards, different teacher every other week, always told she needed to work on one last thing and ' to be more consistent'. But how could she with a diff teacher every other week. In the end I didn't exactly complain but I did set out my concerns and referred to the swim England skills they needed to demonstrate to go up. They've both been moved up as of next week.

billy1966 · 02/11/2022 19:35

Group lessons are a complete waste of time IMO.

One on one lessons are far better value as you move through the levels far quicker.

I did the math and it was cheaper when on the first lesson a woman told me this was her 4th year doing lessons.🤯

I knew that I would absolutely lose my mind so booked one on one and after about 12 we had completed them and said child was flying up and down the pool.

I could see the progress onna weekly basis, it was that pronounced.

Swipe left for the next trending thread