Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So pissed off with child's swimming lessons

104 replies

Mammytothreelo · 02/11/2022 19:28

My dc2 age 9 has been in group swimming lessons 18 months & has been on level 2 over a year. He has been at 88% progress only needing to pass one more stage to move up. He's been at tbis percentage for the oast 3 montgs! I went today to watch & ususl teacher missing. The group lessons are 12 pounds for 30 mins, the instructor started 5 minutes late. The area my son needs to pass wasn't covered. I am blue in the face from asking them to asses him to go to level 3. I said to the receptionist before class & she said oh can't be assessed today as usual teacher will only do assessments... New teacher had no interest just stood on side watching. I sent a very pissed off email demanding to know why we are paying 120 quid for a 10 week term & my child hasn't been assessed since sept 1st! Aibu to be ripping?!!! Today's lesson was a complete waste of time & money, teacher was hopeless.. Other teacher is misding more than is there. Dc1 age 10 progressing nicely in level 4 in same pool... The manager is going to call me tomorrow, any advice appreciated!

OP posts:
Hmmmm2018 · 03/11/2022 08:51

I didn't believe in lessons, never had them myself and learnt to swim and tried teaching my own children, as could see that swimming lessons seemed like money making con. However after a number of years of them refusing to listen to me and me realising I am not a swim teacher I have been forced to go to swimming lessons. They definitely do seem to be somewhat of a con, they move children up randomly it seems (whenever they need space to move someone else) and having to pay for lots of holiday lessons that nobody can make rather than giving everyone a summer break is annoying. We have tried a couple of different options and the latest one seems quite good. It doesn't have such narrow windows of levels, so you are being taught to your level within a wider band of skill but don't have to wait around to go up to next level. We are lucky to have several pools to choose from within driving distance so have been able to shop around. Hope things improve Op

cinnabongene · 03/11/2022 08:49

We found swimming lessons absolutely useless. Definitely agree with a PP that they try and keep the ‘stick’ on a level for as long as possible due to payment.
Eventually we removed them from lessons and joined a leisure club, where DH and I taught them ourselves. They’re now very competent swimmers and love the water

Mammytothreelo · 03/11/2022 08:45

What should I say on the call today? I want dd moved up immediately regardless of the skill passed, should i demand money back from the lessons too?

OP posts:
Sunshineandflipflops · 03/11/2022 08:45

Going back a bit here but my youngest also struggled with group classes - instructor never watched him and was too busy talking to her colleagues most of the time. In the end, he repeated to her what his dad had said to me about her being "a rubbish instructor" - oops - and we felt we had to leave anyway!

We took him somewhere else for 1:1 lessons as he got it much quicker. I think we saved money as he was done much sooner than he would have been. We stopped lessons for both of them as soon as they could confidently swim well enough to get themselves out of trouble (didn't bother with all the extras) and they gained confidence further by us taking them/going on holiday, etc.

Delatron · 03/11/2022 08:36

Completely agree @savehannah - how parents are being duped. So much wasted time and money!

savehannah · 03/11/2022 08:35

Wow swimming classes are really doing a good job in persuading parents they have to shell out for weekly lessons for years and years because it's "a life skill". My kids never had lessons except the school ones but we just took them swimming a lot when they were little and they just gradually learned. The most they ever gained in confidence and strength was on holiday messing around in the pool every day.
Aged 12 my daughter had about 8 private half hour lessons to get some better technique. She could already swim a length. She came out with a bunch of certificates because she had completed all the "stages" in no time.
While water confidence, being able to float, tread water and swim enough to enjoy the water safely are useful life skills, your child only needs to learn butterfly and all the other higher level stuff f they want to compete, or work in swimming!
Stop being conned by swimming lesson providers! Get off the bandwagon!

Delatron · 03/11/2022 08:35

Long term - you save money with private lessons, they progress much quicker and it’s a better experience all round.

I clocked very early on in group lessons they really aren’t getting much swimming time whilst they wait their turn.

Darbs76 · 03/11/2022 08:32

We also complained about the classes starting late. 5 mins late for a 30 min sessions really eats into the lesson. It did make a difference

Darbs76 · 03/11/2022 08:31

billy1966 · 02/11/2022 19:35

Group lessons are a complete waste of time IMO.

One on one lessons are far better value as you move through the levels far quicker.

I did the math and it was cheaper when on the first lesson a woman told me this was her 4th year doing lessons.🤯

I knew that I would absolutely lose my mind so booked one on one and after about 12 we had completed them and said child was flying up and down the pool.

I could see the progress onna weekly basis, it was that pronounced.

I wish I’d paid privately much earlier than I did for 1-1 sessions. My DD progressed so much faster so saved money overall and my time!

Mammytothreelo · 03/11/2022 08:29

Push and pull the water to complete one vertical rotation, face fully submerged.

This is the skill she's stuck at, wasn't a assessed until Sept 26th & hasn't been covered since!! She's just been doing the sruff shes passed already.. So pissed off as an op said tgis isn't a fun activity it's a skill we're paying for her to be taught.
The stand in teacher yesterday, 5 mins late didn't bother asking names, just next, you next etc... No instruction, she just stood at the side watching... So angry. As I said above this is the only one for miles, we're rural & lessons completely oversuscribed...

OP posts:
KweenieBeanz · 03/11/2022 08:28

Sunnyqueen · 02/11/2022 20:06

I dont understand the point of formal swimming lessons tbh. I have taught all mine myself. They all learnt fast (about 3 hours from no clue to half a length) and are all extremely strong swimmers and super confident in the water. Then you hear all these stories like op just seems like a bit of a con to squeeze money out of parents, makes 0 sense why it takes so long.

I know several parents who claimed to have taught their child to swim themselves, on holiday, or at weekends, around age 5-6. Then school swimming lessons started mid-juniors and those kids were the ones put in the bottom group because although yes they could swim a few m they didn't have the technique/stamina/breathing technique to do full lengths of the pool, plus they didn't know the different strokes. Few kids learn to swim properly with good technique across all 4 strokes without proper lessons.

Mammytothreelo · 03/11/2022 08:21

OperaStation · 03/11/2022 07:01

£15 is unheard of. It’s £36 where I live.

OP your son is very old to be in stage 2. Do you take him swimming aside from the weekly lessons?

Also, I don’t agree with other people who say they don’t get moved up mid term. They get moved up all the time to make space in the lower stages. There’s always a waiting list.

I can't swim myself, petrified of water. I had a near drowning experience so avoid at all costs which is why I'm obsessive with dc becoming very competent.
This isn't a council pool, it's a pool in a private gym.
Dh takes the dc to a council pool 20 miles away about once a month.

OP posts:
Delatron · 03/11/2022 08:19

I didn’t buy in to the whole group swimming lesson thing. Standing on the side for years whilst they waited their turn to swim half a length.
We did no ‘levels’.

We did a few intensive courses over holidays. Quite a few 1-2-1s. Joined a local triathlon club. Both are very strong swimmers now and have been since about age 9/10. (They could swim much earlier). They can swim a mile across a lake. Maybe their butterfly isn’t great but that’s not my priority.

BogRollBOGOF · 03/11/2022 08:15

My two tend to average out as a swimming level corresponding with their school year. I've got a y5 recently in stage 5 and a (dyspraxic) y7 in the upper end of stage 6. Both tend to fly through the first 50% slow down until 90% then get hung up on something specific for a few months. Both lost 6 months of swimming time then were blocked from moving up for 3m post-Covid even though they'd been passed. It took 11 months to actually move DS1 up into a space from being passed in 2020 as he was already waiting for a space by March 2020.

They often do get stuck on refining a skill to standard. I have gently asked the teachers what they need to do to move on if they've been stuck a while and get a sensible answer about their technique. If it's a more random skill that's checked less frequently it's usually coming up shortly. (The same also happens to my two for grading in martial arts) In the early years, DS1 benefited from occasional booster lessons in the holidays (DS2 didn't need them)

We're in group lessons of 12 at about £24pm each. If I took them weekly myself for practice, there would be little difference in cost and when they are stuck I remind myself that they are also benefiting from regular swimming practice. Their progress hasn't been spectacular, but their peers who were pushed through quicker in smaller, more expensive private providers largely stopped lessons around y4 when school swimming started, and tend not to keep the practice of technique and stamina up so don't necessarily maintain the advantage of the head start. The benefit we have is establishing swimming as a regular habit (and appropriate casual slots are scarce)

In a market where demand outstrips supply, there's no advantage in to strategically eeking out the stages trying to keep people in and risking losing them due to poor progress at points like stage 2 when there's an abundant demand for Foundation/ Stage 1.

33goingon64 · 03/11/2022 08:14

This is exactly what happened with my DS I asked around for recommendations and moved to another swim school. He's made vast improvements and skips up a level each term. Look for a more nurturing model where they really watch and record each child's progress. The indicator for me on lesson 1 was that the teacher knew DS's name straight away. Not sure the previous teacher knew it after 2 years!

Glittertwins · 03/11/2022 08:02

You have the same issue @Dreikanter as we do. It doesn't benefit the children at all either.

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 03/11/2022 07:54

I found that the most pushy parent was the one that had the child fly through the levels. That’s not me unfortunately.

HopelesslyOptimistic · 03/11/2022 07:32

I agree with another poster, group lessons are dreadful. If you can afford 1/1 watch how your ds improves. Or do a batch of daily lessons in holidays if your area provide that option. Good luck!

ShovellyJoe · 03/11/2022 07:29

Our nearest leisure centre is quite a drive and swimming lessons are ££ so we never had the money for lessons.

Earlier this year, we went on holiday to somewhere with a pool for the first time ever and 10yr old ds absolutely loved it. We looked into lessons but still couldn't find the money for the petrol, parking and fees. Randomly, I met a woman who has a private pool at her house and hires it out for £20 an hour for a private family swim. One swim a week, 6 months later and DS can confidently do front crawl, back crawl, breaststroke, a length and a half under water and is getting there with butterfly. Definitely worth asking around locally as the place we use doesn't advertise.

Dreikanter · 03/11/2022 07:13

Not all swimming clubs can run a learn to swim programme. I used to run one for our club but the Council decided to take it over - together with all our staff and clients. No choice as we were stuck using Council pools for both club training sessions and lesson teaching time.

It is a juggling act to move kids up, especially when you’re trying to accommodate siblings in different levels at the same time. 7 in a class isn’t too bad (I’ve seen much bigger classes in group lessons).

What skill has your DC not been assessed on?

bakebeans · 03/11/2022 07:02

Join a swimming club. There will be some as they are all over the country. You get a lot better for your money and the kids make lots of friends.

OperaStation · 03/11/2022 07:01

TwiggletLover · 02/11/2022 19:40

In our area it is £30 for a 1-2-1 lesson so not sustainable for us on an ongoing basis. £15 is a real bargain

£15 is unheard of. It’s £36 where I live.

OP your son is very old to be in stage 2. Do you take him swimming aside from the weekly lessons?

Also, I don’t agree with other people who say they don’t get moved up mid term. They get moved up all the time to make space in the lower stages. There’s always a waiting list.

autienotnaughty · 03/11/2022 06:26

I understand we have had similar. They didn't assess my son for ages and then passed two stages in same day! I do believe it's more about managing the groups and money than the child progressing. If there is another group close by perhaps put his name on wait list and continue to push for assessment at this group.

Paq · 03/11/2022 05:49

If you're not happy, you should look to move.

OP has said there are no other options. I live rurally, the council has shut out only local swimming pool. Kids have a 20-30 minute drive to the next nearest council pool and unsurprisingly lessons are over subscribed.

OP is paying for a service (coaching) not an activity for her DC and should be treated as such.

Fuuuuuckit · 03/11/2022 05:37

Hmmmm. I had swimming lessons as a kid. Never went further than 100m badge and I can't front crawl or butterfly for toffee. But I love to swim, and go twice a week for exercise and social contact.

My kids only had a term of lessons at school because they were already beyond the curriculum as I took them to the pool every week since they were tiny - water confidence initially to widths to lengths.

We swim for pleasure now, either locally or when we go on holiday. I've never needed to front crawl or butterfly, I'm very happy to plod along with breast stroke or back crawl.

My cousins were competitive swimmers as kids, and now they're up before 5am 6 days a week to take their kids training. Which is great for them but neither I nor my kids have time or the inclination for that.

If I'd spent let's say £12 a week for a year on my kid's swimming lessons - over £600 - and was seeing no progress, I'd be kicking up quite a stink, never mind for lessons reduced by 5 minutes!

Swipe left for the next trending thread