Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Energy Company Reluctant to Refund - please

36 replies

JemimaPyjamas · 02/11/2022 16:25

My brain today is mush due to a million other things, but I want to get this 100% clear before I fire off yet another email. Apologies in advance for this being a) boring and b) possibly garbled...

I am in credit over £450 for my gas and electric. I clearly overpay, and hence want some back. The Energy company say that it 'best to be reviewed in a few months time' and are reluctant to refund more than £50. I am now also getting the £66 a month via the government and when my DD goes out, will be in credit by another £125. My bill for last month was £128 with the extra government input but, as it's winter, that's normal.

What my fuddled brain needs someone to explain, in simple terms is, am I paying in advance for what I allegedly using? If so, their energy forecasts are wrong, and also the money in the account is my money and not theirs?
Am I being paranoid in assuming that it benefits them to have people build up a lot of credit as they can accumulate interest on it, but they have no actual right to keep hold of it, or at least that much?

I am admittedly knackered and hence possibly not thinking it through logically, but their insistence on keeping hold of the cash already there doesn't seem to make sense. It's like I owe them rather the the other way round (this is 100% NOT the case.)

I have never been in debt with them and I am also happy to have a slight buffer of, say, £100 for the time being but AIBU to insist for a lot of the current balance back - particularly as it seems to be constantly increasing, AND we have the £66 a month going in as well until April...?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wtfisgoingonhere21 · 02/11/2022 22:00

This is why I can't understand the posters saying they're happy being hundreds of pounds in credit to the companies because the money is surely better in a separate account of yours to use as a bugger than theirs??

There was another poster who's having trouble getting the direct debit lowered as she's paying over £300 a month on current usage of around £150 and she still has a credit in the high hundreds.

People are starting to be refused lowering of direct debits even though they're based on a forecast not actual usage and are now being refused refunds.

It's not going to go well.

Soon there will be people on their asses and struggling to buy fuel and food but still be paying out loads of extra and no refunds.

travellinglighter · 02/11/2022 21:50

Norriscolesbag · 02/11/2022 17:00

I think the best thing to do is to close your account and move to another provider. The money will soon come then.

Absolutely don’t do this if you’re on a fixed tariff.

Getoff · 02/11/2022 21:44

Why are people having arguments with their companies? I change companies fairly often, and for as long as I can remember, they all allow me to login to their web site and set my direct debit to whatever I think it should be.

Twotwotwotwo · 02/11/2022 21:43

If it is Octopus then just put your DD right down in the online account. Click the ‘change my payments’ link on the main account page. The scroll down to ‘edit amount’. It is super easy to do.

Their balance forecast is based on typical usage so high for heating in winter. I also have a house where our energy usage is abnormally constant through the year. So the DD looks really high. I just adjusted the DD down for it to make sense.

It is just a function of them being unable to predict usage well in slightly unusual circumstances (like a wood burner).

arewe · 02/11/2022 21:38

I have had similar with my energy provider 2 weeks ago, where they tried to tell me about my bills going up and to keep £740 I have built up since April, but I have demanded this money returned to me, as I prefer it to be in my bank account, not theirs. They finally agreed, but tried their luck again and raised my DD quite significantly the very next day. Again, I had to call them and only after I have threatened to cancel my DD altogether, they have reinstated my old DD amount.
You have to be very firm and not let them get away in keeping your money or raising your DD just because they have access to your bank information.

Getoff · 02/11/2022 21:35

I can predict my usage very well, and I find Shell's predictions very accurate and reasonable. I don't know if having a smart meter is contributing to the accuracy of their predictions. I have £365 credit at the moment, my direct debit is set to £220, but they take £66 less than that due to the govenment scheme. I was paying about £100 last winter.

Svalberg · 02/11/2022 21:23

If it's Octopus, you can change your DD amount online without even talking to them. Just change it to £50pcm until its at a figure you're happy with. If you go into the red one month, you can make an extra payment online to cover the deficit.

JemimaPyjamas · 02/11/2022 21:21

I’m making it a bit of a mission to use as little as possible now too (hence the logs) and generally using eco settings rather than before I used quicker cycles for the washing machine etc. I will top up the £125 if needs be, but as it’ll be over £600 credit soon I don’t think a refund seems that strange a request!

OP posts:
Ladybug10 · 02/11/2022 21:12

Shell also think I’ll use more kWh in the next 12 months than in the previous 12 months.
🤷🏻‍♀️ Heating only went on today for a few hours. First time since March.
We’re in a 3 bed semi and the direct debit they want is £280 !

JemimaPyjamas · 02/11/2022 21:08

@BlueWalnut thats really handy, thank you.

@Athenen0ctua My credit is increasing far more than what I am using. I have said in previous post (which I don't blame you for not ploughing through, it's hardly gripping) that our usage doesn't change hugely throughout the year as most of it is electric (we currently have three tonnes of wood in the shed!)

@FormerlySpeckledyHen I am wondering about this, while also keeping a bit of a buffer in case we do use more than expected.

Thanks everyone for their help.

OP posts:
FlowerArranger · 02/11/2022 21:02

@Halloweenyesterday - if you are paying actual usage rather than monthly direct debits, you'll be charged at a higher rate.

Athenen0ctua · 02/11/2022 21:01

Can't you just reduce your dd instead? I've revised mine downwards as needed looking at their prediction tool.

Athenen0ctua · 02/11/2022 20:58

I've read you should have double your dd (average monthly bill) at the beginning of winter. Mine is £90 (£23 with government help) and Octopus let me have a refund dropping my balance to £200 last month. So letting you have £50 of £450 dropping it to £400 sounds right.

£128 plus £66 is high for October, it's not really winter and was also mild this year.

Halloweenyesterday · 02/11/2022 20:57

I was £500 in Credit with my council tax but they refused to refund me. They took it off next year’s bill so my payment will be lower overall. Bit annoying.

I don’t understand how people end up in credit with their energy bills or what the point is tbh. I pay for what I use and I’ll continue doing so when bills increase. I’d rather not continuously pay £200 for £100 usage and have the energy company just hold £100s of my money unnecessarily.

FlowerArranger · 02/11/2022 20:54

How much are you actually hoping they'll refund you? Realistically - i.e. leaving enough for the bill that is due in January?

Given how much you have on your plate, might it perhaps make more sense to leave it for now and review after the next bill?

NB: there should be a form to request a refund on the company's website.

Sirpatrickdelaneypodmore · 02/11/2022 20:52

We’d built up a huge credit with SSE (around £900) then when the rates went up last month I got an email saying they were upping the DD to account for the rides. I flipped, what was the point of building up such a massive credit if they’re going to increase the DD anyway?! So I asked for a refund and got around £500 back. We’re currently using around half the current DD so once the heating goes on a bit more, we’ll probably use up the remaining credit and if I then need to up the DD , I will.
Continue to pursue the refund OP as long as if you do get a high bill in say January you’d be able to pay it. Our money is better in our own accounts right!

BlueWalnut · 02/11/2022 20:48

Some good advice from Citizens Advice about this

FormerlySpeckledyHen · 02/11/2022 20:45

Can’t you convert to variable DD thereby only paying for what you use each month?
This is what I do. My money is better off in my bank rather than British Gas’

JemimaPyjamas · 02/11/2022 20:32

@luxxlisbon as I said in earlier posts, it doesn't vary enormously as most of usage is electric rather than gas.

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing someone else said similar to me but I wasn't sure if it was true or not. Like I've said, I don't mind some credit but I don't want or need to have £100's worth. I can always pay extra if I need to but isn't it more sensible to pay as and when if I can do this?

OP posts:
JamMakingWannaBe · 02/11/2022 20:23

Ladybug10 · 02/11/2022 19:32

I’m with shell and over £500 in credit, and that’s before the government £66 a month goes in .
They have put my direct debit up by £50 !
Online account won’t let me change it back and they won’t refund me the credit amount as the computer system has calculated that by April I will have used all the credit as well as the monthly direct debit.

EXACTLY the same here.

Shell reckon our annual costs are over £4k. We're living frugally in a 3-bed house so I think we're closer to the £2.5k average. Annoyingly I can access my old PurePlanet account to compare our usage to last year.

I've just changed to pay a variable DD so we pay for what we use each month.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/11/2022 20:15

They’re always desperate to have you in credit so they take money off you that you don’t actually need to pay yet.

Id keep pressing to get it back and, if you’re worried, putting it in a savings account til winter is over. Even if you do then need to pay it to them you’ll make a little bit of interest and, importantly, they won’t. Overall they’re making a lot out of having as many people in credit as possible.

Hesma · 02/11/2022 20:13

Similar situation here, I’ve just lowered my DD amount and will increase when needed

luxxlisbon · 02/11/2022 20:11

The point of a DD is to over pay for the 6 months of summer so there is extra for the colder 6 months.
£450 credit from the summer months doesn’t sound crazy, prices only went up again recently and it has been mild so heating hasn’t been in too much for most people.
It means £75 a month can go towards your much higher winter usage.

Being in credit by £450 suggests your energy supplier hasn’t miscalculated your DD regularly.

VickerishAllsort · 02/11/2022 20:06

When my supplier wanted to increase my d/d by 250% I told them what I thought would be a reasonable price to pay, so they adjusted it.
I'm pretty sure that you don't have to accept the payment they want so it should be worth contacting them and telling them what you are prepared to pay.

JemimaPyjamas · 02/11/2022 19:37

This sounds similar to me - I can pay if it goes up but none of the calculations make sense.

OP posts: