Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

English regional/country speaking accents

213 replies

Alondra · 02/11/2022 11:38

A couple of days ago I saw a video from Snoop Dog commenting a Planet Earth segment of an iguana v snakes. Apparently is an old one but I never saw it before and thoroughly enjoyed it. Not many videos can make me laugh out loud, and he did..... .....except I could only understand 80% of what he was saying, thank goodness for the subtitles.

I had a coffee with an Aussie friend yesterday and while commenting the video and the fact that after 9 years living in Australia, I still have problems understanding English she breezily said "don't worry, I still get problems understanding some accents as well"

Which led to a lively conversation. I learned English in public schools in Spain where the emphasis is English Oxford grammar....and prepares us shit at all to understand different accents. When I arrived in Australia I couldn't understand a word anyone was saying and was ecstatic when I saw Queen Elizabeth Christmas speech - I understood everything.

I've progressed a bit since then ....but I still have problems with American accents, Scottish accents (much as I love Scots) and other English accents as well (my niece in law is Cornish and boy, I keep saying"What, what?'" when we talk.

So, if you are a born English speaker, do you have some problems understanding other regional/country accents? And if you do, which ones?

OP posts:
ClaudiaWankleman · 03/11/2022 11:07

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2022 23:32

Spoken English in Shakespeare's time was primarily rhotic as are most American accents. So there is that.

Well a lot of people in England are still rhotic speakers too.

That doesn't mean any of us sound like Shakespeare. None of us are pronouncing 'Measure for Measure' the way Shakespeare did for example.

Brummies who distinctly pronounce the 'g's in 'sing' or 'tongue' are probably pronouncing it as Shakespeare did.

Sistanotcista · 03/11/2022 09:40

Interesting piece in the Guardian about accents - www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/nov/03/can-you-lose-accent-england-southern

ClaryFairchild · 03/11/2022 02:14

I can even understand most foreigners speaking English - used to transcribe interviews and then edit them into something more grammatically correct.

ClaryFairchild · 03/11/2022 02:12

Native Aussie who lived in the UK for 20 years.

OP, you made me laugh remembering sitting in a lecture with a Japanese friend listening to a Scottish Lecturer (in London) for about 10 minutes before she turned to me and asked "Is he speaking English?" She was totally baffled, and gave her a copy of all of my lecture notes for that subject from then on.

I'm pretty good with most accents, but a Glaswegian or strong Yorkshire accent will still be problematic for me.

What I find most annoying is when you ask someone to repeat themselves because you didn't catch what they were saying and instead of slowing down they just talk louder, and sometimes pair that with actually speaking faster. Sooooo helpful, not.

caoraich · 03/11/2022 00:56

I'm scottish, have a fairly strong accent apparently but I have only rarely come across an English speaking accent I've struggled with. I have family in the US, Canada, Australia and Ireland (including Cork!) and they're all fine. A non native speaker's English normally has to be very poor for me to be confused by it. I wonder if I just have an ear for it though as I can mimic most accents if I've heard them a handful of times.

It helps at work - I work in healthcare in a big city and can understand most people.

I once had to give up on a bloke from East London but I think that was more to do with dialect than accent.

Bécassine · 03/11/2022 00:21

Meant to say - I have a very weak West Lancs accent, but I go broader when I'm in my home town and weaker most other places. Weirdly enough I also unconsciously go broader when I'm around people with a different strong regional accent, especially if they all have the same one. I'd go broader with my peers than at home as a survival/ fitting in mechanism, so I wasn't singled out as "posh" as much for having non-local parents, so I guess it's that. Had to significantly attenuate it when I went to uni down south to be understood.

Bécassine · 03/11/2022 00:16

This is really interesting. I tune into most accents fairly quickly as long as I'm expecting them. So if someone code switched from RP to a regional accent I'd struggle, but if I knew that was how they always spoke I wouldn't. Same with english as a second language accents - I've actually had people comment on how easily I understand their strong non-English accents.

Interesting about Spain though, I always thought there were 5 co-official languages (castellano, catalán, euskera/vasco, gallego, and aranés). Maybe I'm mistaken. I speak a rather mixed Spanish accent due to having teachers from all over, although it's mostly solidified into a north Navarrean-Basque accent now I've spent a good amount of time there and made friends with native Basque speakers. They have a different accent to the non basque speakers in the same area, and the younger ones at least use different spellings in castellano (what we learn as Spanish), and some different vocabulary thrown in, based on the Basque language. For example using "k" in place of "qu" in a lot of words. That seems to be a conscious political choice as well as inherited accent, teens and early twenties who've benefitted from the renewed Basque language education.
Argentinian was the hardest accent to get the hang of out of the ones I've heard, it's very different phonetically, but again not so bad once I'd tuned in. Peruvian quite easy, although the different uses of ustedes vs vosotros got me a bit. I haven't really spent any time with people from Southern Spain though, so Andalusian accents might be another thing.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 03/11/2022 00:05

London burn and bred. Have lived around the uk, including S Wales, Newcastle upon Tyne and S Yorks. I've spent a lot of time in various parts of Scotland too. I've only once come across a regional accent so strong I couldn't understand the speaker, and that was a particular area of E Yorks with a strong historical connection to the Netherlands.

SequoiaTree · 02/11/2022 23:34

TerrifyingGhostTrain · 02/11/2022 11:49

Is it?

No

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2022 23:32

ClaudiaWankleman · 02/11/2022 17:53

I see what you mean. Unfortunately I’m part of a Facebook group where ‘Americans speak the language as Shakespeare did’ is parroted as fact. It’s bloody painful.

Spoken English in Shakespeare's time was primarily rhotic as are most American accents. So there is that.

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2022 23:26

mathanxiety · 02/11/2022 17:19

@ClaudiaWankleman

No, that's not what anyone is suggesting.

But there are features of American English that have been there from the time of the colonies, which have fallen into disuse in Britain. They are routinely used here as examples of (1) American backwardness and (2) how Americans have mangled the English language.

For example, usage such as 'gotten'.

Another example is "fall" for autumn.

Flossiemoss · 02/11/2022 22:52

Avrenim · 02/11/2022 22:36

I've lived all round England and a couple of other places that weren't England and speak a couple of other languages (or rather, used to - I can still understand them but the speaking is very rusty these days) so I always used to think I had a reasonably good "ear" for accents, plus I'm originally from one of the parts of the country people often have problems with.

However....can I understand a really broad Glaswegian accent or a really broad Liverpool twang?! Can I 'eck as like...I had to get the bus recently in Liverpool, and I presume every word the driver said was English but I couldn't for the life of me have told you what he said!

Are you sure it was English??
im born and bred in the city. There’s areas of Liverpool I can’t understand!
also broad kent. I need an interpreter. Scottish accents on the other hand I understand perfectly.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 02/11/2022 22:42

I’m in the SE and have only ever had a bit of trouble with extremely broad Glaswegian or Geordie (Newcastle) accents. A dd who was at Newcastle uni also found the broader accents hard to understand at first, but soon got used to them.

A Swedish friend’s son who came to work in London spoke virtually perfect English but was still having a lot of trouble with accents. His mother, who was living here, advised him to watch EastEnders and Coronation Street!

Avrenim · 02/11/2022 22:36

I've lived all round England and a couple of other places that weren't England and speak a couple of other languages (or rather, used to - I can still understand them but the speaking is very rusty these days) so I always used to think I had a reasonably good "ear" for accents, plus I'm originally from one of the parts of the country people often have problems with.

However....can I understand a really broad Glaswegian accent or a really broad Liverpool twang?! Can I 'eck as like...I had to get the bus recently in Liverpool, and I presume every word the driver said was English but I couldn't for the life of me have told you what he said!

Pearfacebanana · 02/11/2022 22:34

Midlander here. I often do a lot of work with clients in Liverpool. On a one to one basis I can understand them but when they all start talking together I get completely lost!

ParsnipsAndPies · 02/11/2022 22:33

The only two people I've struggled to understand are my daughter's martial arts instructor who was Glaswegian and, weirdly, my husband who's a brummie. When he's worked up about something and speaking really quickly I can't grasp what he's saying. I do love accents though, particularly Welsh and Irish - and Scottish, and Black Country, and Geordie!

TroysMammy · 02/11/2022 22:08

@derxa colleague? Polish? Did you actually read what I typed? I never typed those words and there are other countries that are classed as Eastern European and yes I have spoken to people from places other than Poland.

Why on earth have you decided my post was worth pouncing on when there were plenty before mine saying they couldn't understand accents? For the record, not that it's any of your business but I have significant hearing loss and I also have a Welsh accent which you'd probably sneer at that too.

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2022 22:06

Americans could drive for 3 days and the accent changes but not to the same extent (I don't think?? Or am I just not hearing it.)

You are probably just not hearing it, although to be fair, the differences are not as great as they are in the UK. I'm from the state of Georgia and even within the state, there are several different regional accents: coastal (mine), mountain, South Georgia, and a few other variations. But my guess is that most people from outside the southern US would not hear the differences.

ADialgaAteMyDog · 02/11/2022 21:54

I do find threads like this very interesting.
I'm from Bristol and although a lot of people would consider it a 'farmer' accent, it's really not and when actors fail to do it right it's usually because they're over doing it.
Interestingly, although I am Bristolian I have a "posh" accent but compared to actual Southern RP-adjacent accents I actually have quite a strong burr.

Agree on the cadences on other regional accents being difficult to tune in to. The most I've struggled was meeting two lovely Geordies in Newcastle, I felt awful for asking them to repeat themselves so much!
I also struggle a bit with North Walians speaking English.

xPeaceX · 02/11/2022 21:52

''There’s a meme I saw that says (about driving in the UK) ‘It’s been 4 hours, the accent has changed 5 times and breadbuns have a new name’. It’s so true!''

ha ha, I'm not even English but his makes me laugh. Americans could drive for 3 days and the accent changes but not to the same extent (I don't think?? Or am I just not hearing it.)

xPeaceX · 02/11/2022 21:43

Haven't read the whole thread but I bought ''Courtiers'' on audible, written and narrated by Valentine Lowe who has a very upper class English accent and he's hard to understand. Really slurs over the first half of every sentence. It was difficult to listen to because I was consciously listening with EFFORT to the first half of every sentence! If I relaxed and just listened, I missed a lot. I gave up on it.

I can find foreigners hard to understand. Not spanish people as I speak spanish so I know where they're coming from, which helps. But sometimes I feel like I must come off like Alf Garnett. You can only say ''what sorry?'' twice and after that, you just have to wing it.

derxa · 02/11/2022 21:42

TrashyPanda · 02/11/2022 21:39

Aye, but we’re a’ Jock Tamson’s bairns, right hen?

We ur 😉

TrashyPanda · 02/11/2022 21:39

derxa · 02/11/2022 21:32

Scottish accents are very varied You can say that again

Aye, but we’re a’ Jock Tamson’s bairns, right hen?

TrashyPanda · 02/11/2022 21:37

TroysMammy · 02/11/2022 19:52

I used to speak to a carer on the phone in work and thought he was Eastern European. He was called Kevin and he was from Glasgow.

So you don’t know the difference between a Scottish accented person, whose mother tongue is English and Eastern European person, for whom English is their second/third/fourth etc) language?

how peculiar.

im a first generation Eastern European, born and lived in Scotland all my life and cannot see any similarity at all.