Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling so guilty over not being able to afford Christmas

58 replies

elm26 · 02/11/2022 11:30

My DH and I have prioritised paying off our debt for the past 11 months.

We have about another 6 months of paying it off to go and we are due our first baby in May.

We also need to move to a 2 bedroom as we have no room for any additional stuff such as a cot or a pram.

My family go all out at Christmas, even for the adults and I have done this too since I started working at 16.

We simply cannot justify buying everyone presents this year and will just be buying for the children (18 and under) in the family.

We are volunteering for the vulnerable and elderly with some friends this year so won't be with any family for Christmas Day but I still feel so guilty and sad not getting everyone a gift. I know next year will be the same with a 7 month told.

Does anyone have any ideas of what I could do? I was thinking of making festive shortbread in batches for the adults and putting it in a nice gift wrap etc.

OP posts:
Winter2020 · 02/11/2022 13:50

I would suggest when you asked to downsize Xmas- perhaps to less than a fiver per person/homemade or card - you don't say "this year" but set the expectation that this is what you would like to do things going forward.

In my family we agreed to only buy for adults when we all had kids and it was such a relief. Hugely reduced the cost but also the stress of thinking of things to buy.

Even buying for the kids I sometimes think I am putting a lot of energy and money into what to buy when it would be so much easier to buy for our own kids and other people do the same for their own. I guess the more I know the kids the more I enjoy buying for them and choosing things they would like. Kids I see less often have been simplified to money in a card.

Bite the bullet and go for it.

Dixiechickonhols · 02/11/2022 13:49

Just be clear and open. I bet lots in your family feel same. It’s ideal time to stop. Don’t say no presents then do shortbread. You haven’t got money or space for presents.

Thedungeondragon · 02/11/2022 13:44

I thought you were going to say you had young DC and couldn't afford Christmas for them. You have nothing to feel guilty about. You sound like you have your priorities right, and surely anyone who cares about you will understand that?

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 02/11/2022 13:40

Definitely set expectation now.

On my family side we do a secret Santa for adults, and only buy for godchildren. They get Santa, godparents, parents and often grandparents. Nuts.
DH's side is tricker but a lot fewer people and no kids bar ours so while still a faff to buy things for people who probably don't want them it's a lot less.

I'd way prefer shortbread or marmalade or something consumable. The guilt of taking stuff to the charity shop after Christmas. It's such a waste.

PauliesWalnuts · 02/11/2022 13:35

Our secret santa works really well - I only have to buy one at £30 instead of nine at £20. We've been doing it about five years now and it's going to be permanent.

And I'd snap the giver's hand off if someone gave me home made tablet or fudge instead of something bought!

Ericaequites · 02/11/2022 13:33

Talk with your family about new expectations. Everyone is feeling pinched due to inflation, but are not ready to open the conservation. Other family members may be relieved to cut back as well.

Daddydog · 02/11/2022 13:31

Please don't feel guilty - by volunteering you are bringing so much happiness to people. That's the true spirit. Volunteers Xmas week for 10 years before I had a young family as I got sick of the commercialisation. Best Xmas I ever had.

We always do DIY Xmas gifts. Why not make a festive tipple? This year I'm making Pinapple Tepache (beer/cider) - I made 2 test batches and it was soooo good! Super cheap and quick to make - you can find a recipe online. www.liveeatlearn.com/pineapple-tepache/ It's just:

2-3 ripe pinapples (you just need the skin and core so you can use the fruit to maybe make a festive chutney) - pinapple skins contain natural yeast.
Brown Sugar
Cinnamon sticks
Cloves
Ginger
Water

That's all! You just chuck it into a big mason jar and leave it somewhere warm for 1-2 days to ferment. Then bottle it and leave the bottles for 24hrs somewhere warm. Then as if by magic you get a delicious sweet, spicy, fizzy beer which is about 2-3%. Make a DIY lable and you have a wonderful Xmas tipple that costs pennies!! You can make at least 3 batches from the old skins - just add more water and sugar. So with just the stuff you throw away from the pinapple and sugar and spice you can make 18lt of Beer!

Shinyandnew1 · 02/11/2022 13:31

Have a chat with them now about your financial circumstances. Make sure they know you don’t want presents from them either.

whatthejuice · 02/11/2022 13:30

You are doing the best thing! What a present to yourselves and new baby to be in a better financial position!
Someone once made me homemade fudge. It was so delicious and one of my fave presents that year (and the cheapest I'm sure!)

Sittingonabench · 02/11/2022 13:26

I would love to receive Christmas cookies/shortbread as a gift at Christmas! The fact is people buy things they need at the time and everyone is feeling the pinch from bills. But the thought and effort to give some lovely biscuits are a lovely caring present and more meaningful than some soaps or candles IMO.

tiredandstripey · 02/11/2022 13:16

Agree there’s nothing to feel guilty about however some people do start their shopping incredibly early and I know several people who have already declared their Xmas shopping all done. This is probably even more so for people who buy for loads of friends and family. So it’s possible that people will have already bought you gifts. Rather than saying you’re not doing Xmas for adults could you maybe suggest secret santa? And/or suggest a spending limit or that you would only do homemade gifts.

personally I’m not sure homemade gifts are always worth it, hours of slaving away and spending on ingredients etc and then not everyone will even eat them. But it’s a nice gesture and shows you have thought about people. If you were my family i would just say honestly please don’t worry, you don’t need to make biscuits, just come round and bring a bottle to share.

Fundays12 · 02/11/2022 13:14

Don't feel guilty but please explain to your family now. You might find it takes some of the pressure of others to. Many people are struggling this year so less costs might be a relief.

londongals · 02/11/2022 13:04

you are doing a great job no need to feel bad give yourself a pat on the back

HungryandIknowit · 02/11/2022 13:03

I second the secret santa. I'm not a huge fan of the materialism at Christmas, but am aware that for some families gift giving etc. is a huge part of it. If they won't agree to secret santa shortbread sounds amazing! I'd personally prefer something home made most of the time anyway.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 02/11/2022 13:03

And don’t worry about the baby next Christmas. We will have a 6 mo old snd trying to keep costs down. Our plan is to do a small tree with some hand me down decs/ make some decs (hand prints with glitter glue anyone?!) and get a home bargains stocking with some little bits for dd - bibs, bath toys, bubble bath - and a small roast with a bottle of wine and some LIDL treats. Lots of walks wrapped up with flasks of coffee or homemade mulled wine to see Christmas lights around and about. Our local primary has a school fair that’s about £2 to get in and they have a grotto to take baby to see Santa and get a little wrapped gift. It will be magical because we are together not because of how much we are spending. You’re prioritizing the right things and doing a great job for your baby already. ❤️

PruSarne · 02/11/2022 12:58

I suppose families have their own traditions, it’s up to 18 in mine and same for birthdays.

I am glad as I hate shopping, it’s not the cost it’s the faff. I did used to buy a panettone for my sisters family as her DH was Italian. Sadly now widowed my sister said no panettone anymore , she hates it apparently and he was the only one who loved it.

Mummyongin · 02/11/2022 12:43

About 10 years ago we had so little money that I had to totally rethink Christmas gifts. I made chutneys and biscotti for everyone in glass ikea containers. They went down a treat.

Fgsvirgin · 02/11/2022 12:35

I love shortbread. It would be well received here.

But do tell everyone now.

Rainallnight · 02/11/2022 12:23

No shame to that at all. Just say it early to set expectations.

My DB rang up last year when all my Christmas shopping had been done and said ‘let’s not do presents this year’, meaning between his family and mine and I was a bit 🤨

Beachbabe1 · 02/11/2022 12:21

Be honest! You are paying off debts, saving for a house and saving for a baby!! Everyone will understand!! We were saving for a house and told everyone we were only buying for children! Zero issues!!

IAmAlreadyRegrettingMyGreyColourScheme · 02/11/2022 12:15

I'd be made up with the shortbread as a gift. Thoughtful idea and you can put your own thought/design into it.
Perhaps you could suggest to friends family you all do homemade stuff this year or just cards if they're not feeling inventive? Could become a nice tradition if everyone's on-board.

Cats23 · 02/11/2022 12:09

I only get my parents and IL gifts , my siblings and their children dont get anything- We've always done tjis and with the children we tend to meet up at a local xmas party or soft play.
My Dp and children get gifts ofcourse but not extended family- There is too many to buy for otherwise and who needs extra gifts really!
Shortbread sounds perfect though!
Just explain to family your plan to cut back from now on and save but a small home made gift will be given.
Dont feel guilty.
Xmas isnt about gifts

beachcitygirl · 02/11/2022 12:00

Fantastic, I'd much prefer a hand made shortbread than some of
The stuff I get.
Such a thoughtful gift xx

BananaSpanner · 02/11/2022 11:58

Nothing to feel guilty about but I agree with the PP saying have the conversation about it with your family. Knowing that your not going to be spending very much whilst simultaneously letting everyone spend on you as normal is a bit off. They might wish to still go ‘all out’ on you but give them the choice. They might also be delighted to have a cheaper Christmas.

Maray1967 · 02/11/2022 11:58

That sounds great - I do something similar for my brother - something that we always ate at Christmas as kids.
You have a baby on the way and money is tight - anyone who doesn’t appreciate that is being self-centred, quite frankly.
Stick to your budget and give your gifts with love.

Swipe left for the next trending thread