Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Starbucks don't take cash

541 replies

CoastalWave · 02/11/2022 09:48

AIBU to think this is ridiculous?

Took DS yesterday for a treat after school with his birthday money. We only spent £8 but as he handed over his £10 we were told, sorry we don't take cash anymore, card payments only.

Is this just the start of the slippery slope down to a cashless society ?

Really annoyed me!

OP posts:
Washyourfaceinmysink · 03/11/2022 10:12

A restaurant near me is card only and has been for about 4-5 years, well before Covid. They went cashless after their staff were held up at knifepoint one night. I don’t think I’m ready for a totally cashless society, but can understand why shops/ restaurants do it - less hassle and much safer for their staff.

PeekAtYou · 03/11/2022 10:03

Considering that financial organizations like HSBC have been caught laundering money for Mexican drug cartels and are too powerful to prosecute, it's very concerning how much power they wield.

palygold · 03/11/2022 10:02

amp.theguardian.com/money/2020/jun/24/you-cant-pay-cash-here-how-cashless-society-harms-most-vulnerable

This is an old article, but useful still.

PeekAtYou · 03/11/2022 09:57

Apologies if someone brought this up but PayPal tried to have a clause allowing a $2500 fine for wrong think.

www.hitc.com/en-gb/2022/10/28/paypals-2500-fine-for-misinformation-has-not-been-reinstated/

They retracted this but in a cashless society, you can see how this could be abused.

antelopevalley · 03/11/2022 09:54

And both did a roaring trade because everywhere else was closed locally.

antelopevalley · 03/11/2022 09:53

Except they do not close. When there was a power cut in our area the chain all closed. The corner shop and independent pub stayed open. There was sun to provide light, no heating but people understood, they wrote down purchases in cash, pumps would not work in pub but they sold other drinks.
Long term they would have had to close, but no they did not have to close for a 4 hour power cut.

Kazzyhoward · 03/11/2022 09:28

Tomikka · 03/11/2022 04:23

That’s up to the retailer.
If they have any sense then they will consider various options, which could include not taking cash normally but taking cash if there is a total failure (eg if their issue is the cost of handling cash)

Card payments can still continue during a power failure when their mains goes down if their card machines are charged and have mobile connectivity
eg if the wifi is off but the machine has mobile access, but if their POS is wifi only then it won’t

A business with a high enough turnover will use a ‘full’ POS system with lower transaction fees but a monthly subscription etc, which might be more intergrated into the till etc - if that combined system requires mains & wifi then it won’t work

But they could be holding a non subscription handheld card machine as spare which runs on an app it has its own direct mobile connection - in which case it just needs to be charged and to find a connection
That will work in a power cut unless the mobile phone masts are also cut off and don’t have a backup power source

If there's a power cut, the retailer will almost certainly have to close unless it has it's own generator. There'd be no lighting, no heating/ventilation systems, no security cameras, electronic tills won't be able to read bar codes, etc. During Storm Desmond, our town had no electric for 3 days, there were no (or very, very few), shops open, nor were cafes, pubs, petrol stations, etc. It's not safe to open without lighting, and everything in fridges/freezers had to be disposed of. The power cut meant no mobile phone either for the first day, so no mobile internet for mobile phone linked card readers etc.

Conkersareback · 03/11/2022 07:32

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2022 06:35

Everyone seems to have forgotten when the banks, credit cards etc shut down the accounts owned by russians, when they invaded the Ukraine. Many ordinary russian people were stranded on holiday. They had to declare themselves homeless in the countries that they were in, to get food.

Another example are protesters. The police hand information over to the DWP when they break up protests and things like hunt sabotages. Many people on disability or attendance allowance benefits were sanctioned and had benefits removed. Even if the protest only involved them getting driven in a car and sitting on a chair all day. I know a lot of protesting pensioners, they made up the numbers on the picket lines and outside other places.

So imagine your ability to buy food was totally reliant on our government not pissing off whoever owns the businesses and all rights to protest was removed. Or your ability to get benefits had your behaviour overseen by the police and again if you do something against big business/government, then you get no income.

Another scenario, fraud takes place, it happened to my DD on her Argos card. The Argos card that she was relying on for Christmas toys for her children. Her account was shut down while they investigate. Luckily we could help, but many people won't have any other means of shopping. She also had ongoing issues for weeks with Amazon because they wasn't understanding that although she could change her password, they had to sign out all devices first. This was because of not being able to talk to an actual person and then a lack of understanding/language barrier.

We aren't just being forced into no cash, we will be forced into paying on our phones, because cards take so long to replace.

Yeah I won't be having a stash of cash lying around just in case those scenarios happen!

What's wrong with paying by phone?

Aishah231 · 03/11/2022 07:24

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2022 06:35

Everyone seems to have forgotten when the banks, credit cards etc shut down the accounts owned by russians, when they invaded the Ukraine. Many ordinary russian people were stranded on holiday. They had to declare themselves homeless in the countries that they were in, to get food.

Another example are protesters. The police hand information over to the DWP when they break up protests and things like hunt sabotages. Many people on disability or attendance allowance benefits were sanctioned and had benefits removed. Even if the protest only involved them getting driven in a car and sitting on a chair all day. I know a lot of protesting pensioners, they made up the numbers on the picket lines and outside other places.

So imagine your ability to buy food was totally reliant on our government not pissing off whoever owns the businesses and all rights to protest was removed. Or your ability to get benefits had your behaviour overseen by the police and again if you do something against big business/government, then you get no income.

Another scenario, fraud takes place, it happened to my DD on her Argos card. The Argos card that she was relying on for Christmas toys for her children. Her account was shut down while they investigate. Luckily we could help, but many people won't have any other means of shopping. She also had ongoing issues for weeks with Amazon because they wasn't understanding that although she could change her password, they had to sign out all devices first. This was because of not being able to talk to an actual person and then a lack of understanding/language barrier.

We aren't just being forced into no cash, we will be forced into paying on our phones, because cards take so long to replace.

We'll said. I'm going to boycott all businesses which go card only. It discriminates against the very poor and gives the banks and governments too much power. Imagine the lockdown craziness again with the government able to freeze your bank account if you don't comply!

SocksAndTheCity · 03/11/2022 07:04

I use cash too for day to day stuff as it's easier for me to budget. I've also read/seen The Handmaid's Tale and always have enough in the house to buy food a month or so.

I lost my card holder with all my cards a few weeks ago and it would have been a nightmare without it as even the quickest replacement took a week. If others don't want to that's up to them, but I can't see why anybody would think that people having fewer choices is a positive thing.

megletthesecond · 03/11/2022 06:53

I still use cash. I'll even pay for a big shop and petrol in cash.
Starbucks make awful tea anyway, I went once and never again.

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2022 06:35

Everyone seems to have forgotten when the banks, credit cards etc shut down the accounts owned by russians, when they invaded the Ukraine. Many ordinary russian people were stranded on holiday. They had to declare themselves homeless in the countries that they were in, to get food.

Another example are protesters. The police hand information over to the DWP when they break up protests and things like hunt sabotages. Many people on disability or attendance allowance benefits were sanctioned and had benefits removed. Even if the protest only involved them getting driven in a car and sitting on a chair all day. I know a lot of protesting pensioners, they made up the numbers on the picket lines and outside other places.

So imagine your ability to buy food was totally reliant on our government not pissing off whoever owns the businesses and all rights to protest was removed. Or your ability to get benefits had your behaviour overseen by the police and again if you do something against big business/government, then you get no income.

Another scenario, fraud takes place, it happened to my DD on her Argos card. The Argos card that she was relying on for Christmas toys for her children. Her account was shut down while they investigate. Luckily we could help, but many people won't have any other means of shopping. She also had ongoing issues for weeks with Amazon because they wasn't understanding that although she could change her password, they had to sign out all devices first. This was because of not being able to talk to an actual person and then a lack of understanding/language barrier.

We aren't just being forced into no cash, we will be forced into paying on our phones, because cards take so long to replace.

Conkersareback · 03/11/2022 06:20

msbevvy · 03/11/2022 04:16

I have just been stuck for 30 with my DH in A&E and the hospital restaurant was card only. Luckily I had one with me but some will be stuck there with no food.

You have to be desperate to use the place, they charge £5 for a sandwich and I paid £8 for a portion of chips and a burger with no bun.

But surely this is the same if the machine took cash? Some people wouldn't have cash?

I'd argue that more people would have sufficient cards or access to phone with a card loaded on it than cash.

Tomikka · 03/11/2022 04:23

PeekAtYou · 02/11/2022 10:30

I am interested what happens if there's a power cut and the card machines don't work. Do they shut the shop to new customers? Until card machines don't need internet /electricity, I can't see a fully cashless society being possible.

That’s up to the retailer.
If they have any sense then they will consider various options, which could include not taking cash normally but taking cash if there is a total failure (eg if their issue is the cost of handling cash)

Card payments can still continue during a power failure when their mains goes down if their card machines are charged and have mobile connectivity
eg if the wifi is off but the machine has mobile access, but if their POS is wifi only then it won’t

A business with a high enough turnover will use a ‘full’ POS system with lower transaction fees but a monthly subscription etc, which might be more intergrated into the till etc - if that combined system requires mains & wifi then it won’t work

But they could be holding a non subscription handheld card machine as spare which runs on an app it has its own direct mobile connection - in which case it just needs to be charged and to find a connection
That will work in a power cut unless the mobile phone masts are also cut off and don’t have a backup power source

msbevvy · 03/11/2022 04:16

I have just been stuck for 30 with my DH in A&E and the hospital restaurant was card only. Luckily I had one with me but some will be stuck there with no food.

You have to be desperate to use the place, they charge £5 for a sandwich and I paid £8 for a portion of chips and a burger with no bun.

Tomikka · 03/11/2022 04:12

Kazzyhoward · 02/11/2022 10:26

A couple of shops/pubs in our rural village are "cash only" but that's because of the crap internet (both landline and mobile) which makes the card machines slow and unreliable, and they couldn't do with the hassle and wasted time of people trying to pay by card only to hold up the entire queue whilst waiting for the hamsters to power the internet on their treadmill (well it feels like that some days). It'll be very different in places with reliable broadband/mobile.

At a show recently a friend ended up with free drinks due to card machine failure.

The barman came back to her after the first attempt telling her the payment had failed and charged her again - but she was concerned over double payment as the machine didn’t show the failed message when he got back to her

So she spent a while afterwards trying to check her online banking in case the same amount came up twice …. Which it didn’t at all

Tomikka · 03/11/2022 04:05

Precipice · 02/11/2022 10:12

Unfortunately, that's not what legal tender means. Legal tender refers only to what should be accepted for the payment of a debt. If you're paying for something upfront, there's no debt. (I'm not sure how it can work for things you pay for afterwards, like in restaurants. It ought to qualify to my mind.)

However, I agree that it should work like that. The principle of adopting cash has been accepted elsewhere - in Poland merchants now can't refuse to accept cash payments from retail customers.

I pay almost exclusively in cash, because I feel strongly that cash should be maintained as a method of payment.

For a restaurant after eating a meal the legal tender element means they cannot subsequently take you to court for the debt if you have offered to pay with cash under the terms of legal tender.

So if you had offered to pay cash, they refuse it then a court will not enforce the debt.
But legal tender covers how much of each denomination is valid - such as if you only offered to pay in 1p & 2p coins as they are legal tender up to 20p
But pound coins are not limited

kateandme · 03/11/2022 02:37

JKGalbraith · 03/11/2022 01:51

it’s not ‘sneering’ to point out that OP’s lack of willpower isn’t the problem of Starbucks 🙄

It’s not lack of willpower. It’s being human and how human brains work,react,process things.it is widely accepted and researched that contously or subconsciously people do this.

JKGalbraith · 03/11/2022 01:51

antelopevalley · 03/11/2022 01:49

Loads of research shows that people on very little money find it easier to budget with cash. You can sneer at individuals all you want, but it is a well recognised fact.

it’s not ‘sneering’ to point out that OP’s lack of willpower isn’t the problem of Starbucks 🙄

antelopevalley · 03/11/2022 01:49

JKGalbraith · 03/11/2022 01:42

your lack of ability to refrain from spending money because you’re using a plastic card rather than handing over cash is not Starbucks (or any company’s) problem. it makes no sense saying ‘it’s easy to think oh it’s only £4 when paying by card’, why would you not also think the same when paying by cash? Confused

Loads of research shows that people on very little money find it easier to budget with cash. You can sneer at individuals all you want, but it is a well recognised fact.

Allthestarsabovemyhead · 03/11/2022 01:47

It’s annoying me a lot now. It’s rare to find a shop that will take cash. I went shopping in the summer and none of the shops would take cash. Fat face wouldn’t open their till. They just said I don’t think we have the change for that.

JKGalbraith · 03/11/2022 01:42

your lack of ability to refrain from spending money because you’re using a plastic card rather than handing over cash is not Starbucks (or any company’s) problem. it makes no sense saying ‘it’s easy to think oh it’s only £4 when paying by card’, why would you not also think the same when paying by cash? Confused

kateandme · 03/11/2022 01:35

Genevieva · 02/11/2022 23:08

I became aware of this issue some t time ago when volunteering for a charity that helps disadvantaged people. They are the most likely to rely on cash - either as a means of escape from domestic violence, or as a means of managing their finances. They are more likely to be paid in cash and are the least likely to have a bank account or bank cards. Take cash away and we push them even more into the fringes of society. Ever since then I have made an effort to get cash out every week and pay for as much as I can with it - groceries, petrol... anything I buy in person pretty much.

Exactly my problem with it.and would you look at that,once again the most vulnerable and disadvantaged will suffer because of it. So many of the people we see have to pay via cash.they can’t afford to do it any other way. They are often embarrassed and ashamed enough when they go to the supermarkets with their envelopes of cash.they don’t need this to contend with now too.

MugginsOverEre · 02/11/2022 23:22

MavisChunch29 · 02/11/2022 10:14

Good. I don't want people fannying about with small change when I'm trying to buy a cup of coffee. The queues are long enough as it is.

Get DC a Nimbl card and come into the 2020s.

So we can pay £2.50 a month so my children can spend their own little bit of money? Why should I pay a middleman? Same goes for a GoHenry card. There are few completely few fee free cards out there for children.

SheepDance · 02/11/2022 23:11

I was in Asda earlier and queuing for the self service. There are 4 tills that are cash and card and 6 that are card only.
They had to go about 6 people down the queue to find someone who wasn't paying cash and could use one of the 6, so I don't think we'll be going cashless any time soon.

Cash is also crucial to people escaping domestic violence, by the way:
cashessentials.org/cash-lends-a-helping-hand-in-case-of-domestic-abuse/

Swipe left for the next trending thread