Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Starbucks don't take cash

541 replies

CoastalWave · 02/11/2022 09:48

AIBU to think this is ridiculous?

Took DS yesterday for a treat after school with his birthday money. We only spent £8 but as he handed over his £10 we were told, sorry we don't take cash anymore, card payments only.

Is this just the start of the slippery slope down to a cashless society ?

Really annoyed me!

OP posts:
bruffin · 08/11/2022 21:16

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 21:07

So charities have to buy card machines because people will not carry cash?

As i have said previously, it is expensive to deposit cash in the bank. FWIW the charity i worked for very rarely had cash donations and that was over 15 years ago.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 21:07

Tomikka · 08/11/2022 18:35

Charities such as Shelter sponsor the homeless to enable them to open a bank account

www.hsbc.co.uk/help/money-worries/no-fixed-address/

and may get card machines via a charity or by themselves

amp.theguardian.com/cities/2018/feb/27/card-cashless-society-homeless-contactless-payments-britain

www.theargus.co.uk/news/17890425.amp/

Card machines that run via a smartphone app retail at approx £30, but can be bought for less or for free (I have one that I got for free by leaving it in an online shopping basket for a little while)
The provider takes less than 2% in transaction fees

As long as they have a data connection then it will take payment, a basis PAYG will give plenty of data for a month.

But there are others which run via their own embedded 3g connection which normally cost more, but there’s one for £9.99 at the moment - the catch with this one is 1% plus 7p

So charities have to buy card machines because people will not carry cash?

bruffin · 08/11/2022 20:59

thehorsehasnowbolted · 08/11/2022 20:34

a coffee shop in Picadilly had a touch machine on their window that you could donate to a Homeless charity

Good idea. Feed the ballooning charity industry with their inflated management salaries and expenses. I wonder how much of your donation actually reaches the homeless

I worked for a charity for 11 years as an assistant accountant, i am more than aware how money is spent and where it comes from.
The company i work for now also works with homeless charities and pay for people on the street to work with the homeless.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 08/11/2022 20:34

a coffee shop in Picadilly had a touch machine on their window that you could donate to a Homeless charity

Good idea. Feed the ballooning charity industry with their inflated management salaries and expenses. I wonder how much of your donation actually reaches the homeless

bruffin · 08/11/2022 19:35

Places in the west end, I know Macdonald's in Victoria did it and a coffee shop in Picadilly had a touch machine on their window that you could donate to a Homeless charity

palygold · 08/11/2022 18:40

Oh Big Issue sellers! That makes sense they might be given card machines.

I was going to say given that we're usually discouraged from donating to homeless people directly.

Allverywellwiththebenefitofhindsight · 08/11/2022 18:38

I'm with you, OP. I use cash for different reasons (mostly because I hate the idea of anyone being able to see what I'm up to - not that it's interesting, but still). I wouldn't go to a place which only accepted cards. The other thing that seriously pisses me off is 'pay by phone only' (e.g. car parks). I haven't got a phone either, and don't want one. So I can't park in some places. Very annoying.

Tomikka · 08/11/2022 18:35

palygold · 08/11/2022 18:16

Except for the homeless people who have a basic card account, and may be using a card machine to take payment when begging.

Homeless people with card machines? I can't say I've ever seen such a thing.

Charities such as Shelter sponsor the homeless to enable them to open a bank account

www.hsbc.co.uk/help/money-worries/no-fixed-address/

and may get card machines via a charity or by themselves

amp.theguardian.com/cities/2018/feb/27/card-cashless-society-homeless-contactless-payments-britain

www.theargus.co.uk/news/17890425.amp/

Card machines that run via a smartphone app retail at approx £30, but can be bought for less or for free (I have one that I got for free by leaving it in an online shopping basket for a little while)
The provider takes less than 2% in transaction fees

As long as they have a data connection then it will take payment, a basis PAYG will give plenty of data for a month.

But there are others which run via their own embedded 3g connection which normally cost more, but there’s one for £9.99 at the moment - the catch with this one is 1% plus 7p

bruffin · 08/11/2022 18:33

palygold · 08/11/2022 18:16

Except for the homeless people who have a basic card account, and may be using a card machine to take payment when begging.

Homeless people with card machines? I can't say I've ever seen such a thing.

I used to give the big issue lady a pret card at Xmas. She used to stand outside there every day.

palygold · 08/11/2022 18:16

Except for the homeless people who have a basic card account, and may be using a card machine to take payment when begging.

Homeless people with card machines? I can't say I've ever seen such a thing.

Tomikka · 08/11/2022 18:10

tillytown · 08/11/2022 17:44

Hi OP, the reason they have gone cashless is so homeless people can't use their stores anymore. They can talk about how it's better for business to be card only all they like (it isn't, it puts normal people off going there and the bank fees are still the same), but it's all about making lives harder for the very poor

Except for the homeless people who have a basic card account, and may be using a card machine to take payment when begging.

They can simply refuse to serve anyone unless doing so discriminates against a protected characteristic. (They still can but at risk of being sued)

Individual Starbucks franchisees choose which methods of payment that they will accept

bruffin · 08/11/2022 17:59

tillytown · 08/11/2022 17:44

Hi OP, the reason they have gone cashless is so homeless people can't use their stores anymore. They can talk about how it's better for business to be card only all they like (it isn't, it puts normal people off going there and the bank fees are still the same), but it's all about making lives harder for the very poor

Bank fees are not the same. It's costs twice as much to pay in cash than to pay for credit,/ debit card transactions. As well as that insurance companies put in restrictions on how much money can be held in the safe and how many people need to take it to the bank.

tillytown · 08/11/2022 17:44

Hi OP, the reason they have gone cashless is so homeless people can't use their stores anymore. They can talk about how it's better for business to be card only all they like (it isn't, it puts normal people off going there and the bank fees are still the same), but it's all about making lives harder for the very poor

Tomikka · 08/11/2022 17:26

reigatecastle · 08/11/2022 14:56

PayPals fine/charge/account freeze applies to business accounts and those that raise funds promoting misinformation This does not affect ordinary users

That isn't my understanding. Financial institutions already do it for no apparent reason - sometimes simply because someone isn't profitable enough - there doesn't have to be anything malicious going on.

Those would be financial insitutuons freezing an account / refusing service and sending you elsewhere which is not the $2500 PayPal ‘fine’

sethsgoat · 08/11/2022 16:06

And we don't have any chain coffee shops in our village! It's all independent.

sethsgoat · 08/11/2022 16:02

I've copied and pasted for you @Fattoushi

"Good luck trying to buy a coffee in a blackout!
How do you think they're going to light/heat the cafe, or operate the coffee machine.
How you pay is irrelevant as the shops/cafes will mostly be shut!"

Rural location here. Well our business is in one. Blackouts not common but not unexpected in harsh weather conditions either.

A few people here have backup generators. We have one in our pub. In the last blackout we gave away hot drinks to locals. Some shops open here regardless. Cash is here to stay.

Fattoushi · 08/11/2022 15:55

sethsgoat · 08/11/2022 15:20

But back to the point of this thread i.e. Starbucks, I think it's highly unlikely that a chain like Starbucks would open in a blackout due to the insurance, power, heating, security and staffing problems.

You're the person who 'deviated from topic' by mentioning cafes and shops generally.

In rural locations particularly, where blackouts are not unexpected in harsh weather conditions, there is prep and backup, and cash is extremely useful.

I'm pretty sure rural coffee shops, like Starbucks, won't be open in blackouts. Not least because you can't make coffee without power.

Where would cash be useful in a blackout, exactly?

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 15:22

Honestly problems, problems.
Chains close because staff rightly have no interest in solving the issues.
But the local pub stayed open.

I also see in the City I lived in until the summer there are events planned of an orchestra by candlelight. Somehow they are managing to do that.

Nobody is saying everything will be as norma;l. But independent pubs will I am sure be open during blackouts. Especially if they are planned. It is easy to have alternative low lighting and not expensive to buy, and to record purchases manually. They can even have a calculator if staff need it.

sethsgoat · 08/11/2022 15:20

But back to the point of this thread i.e. Starbucks, I think it's highly unlikely that a chain like Starbucks would open in a blackout due to the insurance, power, heating, security and staffing problems.

You're the person who 'deviated from topic' by mentioning cafes and shops generally.

In rural locations particularly, where blackouts are not unexpected in harsh weather conditions, there is prep and backup, and cash is extremely useful.

user1497207191 · 08/11/2022 15:17

@antelopevalley

The corner shop had queues out the door during the local blackout as the chains all shut.

Well there you have it - ALL the chains were shut as you say yourself! Small owner-managed businesses are completely different, and of course, there are fewer of them, so their remaining stocks wouldn't last long if all the chains are shut! A couple of years ago, our village suffered an outage when our substation blew up - our village pie ship/bakery stayed open, but ran out of stock within a couple of hours as all the customers who'd normally get their bread/milk etc from the Spar shop (which closed immediately) went to the bakery instead and bought all it's stock! For the afternoon of day 1 and the second day, the pie/bakery shop couldn't open as they didn't have enough to sell to make it worthwile opening.

We had a family newsagents back in the 70s and I remember serving customers by torchlight and candle light. Times were different then. I particularly remember that we sold fireworks, not just boxes but also individual ones which we kept loose in boxes. Looking back, it was pretty dangerous and stupid, but during the power cuts, we'd sell fireworks by candle-light! Luckily, the almost inevitable didn't happen, and I presume we thought it was safe at the time! But I also remember we had several customers who tripped over things and walked into things due to poor lighting. If that happened today, I'm pretty sure we'd have "no win no fee" injury lawyers suing us!

Kazzyhoward · 08/11/2022 15:08

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 14:42

The corner shop had queues out the door during the local blackout as the chains all shut.
It is funny how some people do not realise it is possible to do things without electricity.

Depends on the business doesn't it?

Some won't be allowed to open as they won't be insured if no power for heating, lighting and security systems. Workplaces aren't safe for staff if there's no power for lighting potentially dark/gloomy storerooms, back rooms, toilets/kitchens, etc. Likewise if no heating, the workplace may be too cold for staff to legally be required to work.

Of course, some smaller businesses can open based on natural light if they have lots of windows.

Likewise if they have their own generators they can open.

We did indeed have a local shop which opened during Storm Desmond, but soon had to close as they sold out of the stock they could sell (they couldn't sell fresh/frozen stock as the fridges/freezers were down so the stock melted or warmed too much, hence unsafe to sell).

Owner-managed small shops will be better placed to stay open temporarily as they're more likely to be able to rely on memory for prices and able to work out sums of shopping and change without need of a till system - staff are less likely to be able to work without electronic POS tills etc. Workplace H&S legislation is less of a problem if it's the business owner working in the shop without power, rather than employees where it may be against employment law for them to be expected to work in what are almost certainly unsafe conditions.

But back to the point of this thread i.e. Starbucks, I think it's highly unlikely that a chain like Starbucks would open in a blackout due to the insurance, power, heating, security and staffing problems.

reigatecastle · 08/11/2022 14:56

PayPals fine/charge/account freeze applies to business accounts and those that raise funds promoting misinformation This does not affect ordinary users

That isn't my understanding. Financial institutions already do it for no apparent reason - sometimes simply because someone isn't profitable enough - there doesn't have to be anything malicious going on.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 14:42

The corner shop had queues out the door during the local blackout as the chains all shut.
It is funny how some people do not realise it is possible to do things without electricity.

sethsgoat · 08/11/2022 14:40

"Good luck trying to buy a coffee in a blackout!
How do you think they're going to light/heat the cafe, or operate the coffee machine.
How you pay is irrelevant as the shops/cafes will mostly be shut!"

Rural location here. Well our business is in one. Blackouts not common but not unexpected in harsh weather conditions either.

A few people here have backup generators. We have one in our pub. In the last blackout we gave away hot drinks to locals. Some shops open here regardless. Cash is here to stay.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 14:22

I have said before. In a local blackout in my area the corner shop and pub remained open. It is very easy to use manual systems for cash.
Restaurants will close although I wonder if our local Thai that mainly uses large gas cookers will remain open? But pubs are one of the easiest to keep open.