Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I got a sick note to go on holiday

421 replies

Marleymerm · 01/11/2022 22:58

Last month I worked at least 40hrs of overtime when my boss kept asking me to "stay late" or "just come in a few hours at the weekend" as we had a deadline approaching. I worked it and wrote it all in my time sheet, I work in an office so we don't have clock ins or anything.

Anyway, I got paid last week and got nothing for my OT, I asked my boss who said he only asked me to stay to help, he never actually agreed to pay me for it and he was asking me to "help the company" like we all should be doing.

I thought about fighting it but people in my office are petty and those above me would probably make things difficult for me. So instead I got a sick note from my doctor for 6 weeks for stress and booked a holiday. I've been honest with my work that I've booked the holiday and said it's to help with my stress, now my boss is saying this is clearly out of spite and he'll be giving me a written warning. However if he does that he'd have to formally admit to not paying me OT. I do feel nervous after realising I actually get full pay when I thought I'd only get SSP and now I'm worried my boss is going to take it further.

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 02/11/2022 09:21

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2022 08:58

Well you must work in a strange place if they consider getting more days off for cancer to be a discretion. And where they consider they can disregard a doctors note and think they know better than someone with 7 years training.

It’s not about whether it’s a genuine sickness so managers are not saying they know better. That’s just the sickness policy, if you have a serious illness it’s considered discretionary, just the way it is. No-one would get a warning for being off for cancer treatment but the policy isn’t about whether sickness is genuine or not, but how much it can afford to pay out in sicknesses. People do take less sick days if there’s a policy of x number of days if you’re sick in a certain period. That’s quite normal for many big companies / departments. People should be grateful if their place is more generous with sick as many aren’t. It’s very costly to companies

Darbs76 · 02/11/2022 09:18

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2022 08:58

Well you must work in a strange place if they consider getting more days off for cancer to be a discretion. And where they consider they can disregard a doctors note and think they know better than someone with 7 years training.

It’s a Government department. That’s the sickness policy

ReneBumsWombats · 02/11/2022 09:10

Darbs76 · 02/11/2022 08:35

If you’ve got cancer you’d get more days and it would be a discretion, but otherwise that’s just how it works. You get paid 6 months for sickness so has to be some limitations. It was much more generous in the past but people take the P and it got changed from 12 days and 6 occasions to half of that. As I say there is discretion, set criteria and extra days for illness but it’s not based on whether it’s a genuine illness or you have a note or not

Where do you work where time off for having cancer is a discretion??

hopalongnowplease · 02/11/2022 09:03

The OT didn't make you sick with stress.

Not getting paid was the issue!

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2022 09:01

Movinghouseatlast · 02/11/2022 08:42

There is not a universal sickness policy in the UK. Some places have draconian sickness policies.

Your sickness policy doesn't help the OP whose company probably has a very different policy.

I know it's not a universal sickness policy, that's why I said it may be different in different workplaces in line 1.

I was responding to another person commenting who acted like what is the case in her workplace is universal.

Testina · 02/11/2022 08:59

Maybe spend some of your 6 weeks off looking for ways to improve your resilience?
I would feel very angry at being cheated out of the money, and I’d look for another job. But it wouldn’t make me stressed to the point of being signed off.
It sounds quite spiteful and childish - 6 weeks?!
I’d have told HR that I want 1 week (as it was 40 hours) TOIL and taken the holiday then.
If you need 6 weeks to calm yourself, you’re doing yourself no favours not working on your reactions.

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2022 08:58

Darbs76 · 02/11/2022 08:35

If you’ve got cancer you’d get more days and it would be a discretion, but otherwise that’s just how it works. You get paid 6 months for sickness so has to be some limitations. It was much more generous in the past but people take the P and it got changed from 12 days and 6 occasions to half of that. As I say there is discretion, set criteria and extra days for illness but it’s not based on whether it’s a genuine illness or you have a note or not

Well you must work in a strange place if they consider getting more days off for cancer to be a discretion. And where they consider they can disregard a doctors note and think they know better than someone with 7 years training.

TippermostToppermostHigh · 02/11/2022 08:54

I think the best thing you can do is look for another job. Your boss sounds like an arsehole who treats his staff like dirt.

If you work in an office environment, and get paid lots and lots of money, then meeting deadlines via staying late for a short time, is the norm. If you are paid hourly for your work, then you should be paid for EVERY hour you work. You have been paid OT in the past, and no notice had been made to you that this has changed. They are in the wrong.

I don't particularly agree with the way you have gone about it, but it is your own company's fault. If they treated people a bit better, they wouldn't have stressed out staff.

I'd look for another job.

I get it. I used to work in an office and get paid a lot of money. It was expected to stay late and get the job done. Now I get paid hourly. I am very particular and even a jobsworth over the hours because they are like that with me. I was made to pay back time for a serious medical appointment I had to attend, so when they asked me to work an extra hour, I made sure they paid it back to me in TOIL.

Moving forward you need to be very clear up front that you are only doing overtime if you are paid, or you get the time back, and you want that in writing. Unfortunately your boss has taken advantage of your handwork. Legally he cannot do anything, but he can make your life difficult. Keep all correspondence over this and make sure any conversations are via email. If there is an issue later, you have proof.

yellowtwo · 02/11/2022 08:53

oldbrownjug
Op has been signed off before with stress, the Gp clearly thought she needed this time off.
'Give and take' isn't working 40 extra hours unpaid.

Gwenhwyfar · 02/11/2022 08:52

"The minimum wage applies to hourly paid work."

It seems to apply to salaried work as well
www.gov.uk/minimum-wage-different-types-work/paid-an-annual-salary

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/11/2022 08:50

I don’t think they can give you a written warning without accusing the doctor of fraud. Which they’ve got no grounds to do. I probably wouldn’t have mentioned the holiday, but in fact there’s no reason why not, as it’s allowed when you’re off with stress.

The not paying you for overtime is scandalous. It’s ok when people are on good salaries to expect a bit extra (within reason) but not if you’re on an hourly rate, and especially not either that much or when the clear precedent has been to pay you.

Sparklfairy · 02/11/2022 08:48

40 hours free overtime in a month is the equivalent to the OP taking a 25% ish pay cut if she's FT. I don't think anyone here berating her would accept that.

Formerpupil · 02/11/2022 08:48

Are you part time OP? 40 hours overtime in a month for a full time Monday to Friday role would be roughly 2 hours a day. I’m not following the missing evenings with family and days off unless it was 40 hours in a shorter space of time?

However, I’d have thought HR would have to do something to make your pay up to NMW. With my employer we have a clause in our our contracts where we agree to work whatever hours are required based on business need with no entitlement to overtime pay or TOIL but our apprentices/ graduates still receive extra pay where they’d otherwise be paid less than NMW in a month.

icbatoday · 02/11/2022 08:48

notanothertakeaway · 02/11/2022 07:47

You were willing to do the overtime when you thought you'd be paid for it

I get that it's frustrating not to be paid. However, I fail to see how not being paid results in a previously acceptable situation changing to "I'm so stressed I need time off to recover"

You're taking the pXXX

This is a silly comment... take overtime out of the equation and imagine it was just your usual hours of work and your company just stopped paying you.. 'you were willing to do the work until you realised you wouldn't be paid and then suddenly you don't want to do the work anymore.. I know it's frustrating to not be paid but just accept it.. and keep working' .... hmmm

oldbrownjug · 02/11/2022 08:44

Mis use of GP time, lying, dishonesty, undermining the struggle to take mental health issues seriously, incompetence of dealing with employment matters in an adult professional way, exploitation of employment laws...
Just what we all need in our society.
And 40 hours sounds such a lot - of course OP is "owed" six whole weeks back, (225 hours - cos that's fair innit!)
40 hours is roughly two hours a day - so she maybe started at 8 instead of 9 and finished at 6 instead of 5.30 and cut lunch to 30 mins instead of an hour to cover a busy period.

If she is on the clock then she should of course be paid for this - as long as it was agreed. (You can't just work a bit late and expect payment - it has to be authorised. Clearly this wasn't.) The boss clearly thought it was give and take - OP didn't. The conversation needs to be had and maybe the boss will look again at all the times OP is a bit late back from lunch or spends twenty minutes on a tricky personal phone call...without making up the time).
Thing is we all pay for this. (See current thread about UK being poor man of Europe) Whether OP works for the NHS or local govt or M&S or EON - it affects
costs. And GPs have nothing else they could be doing of course.

ocadodeliveroo · 02/11/2022 08:43

Well done OP.

CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP.

Now it's all even.

Don't you dare do another minute of overtime ever!

Movinghouseatlast · 02/11/2022 08:42

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2022 07:37

Not necessarily true (maybe it is different in different workplaces I don't know). Where I work in a school, if you have more than 3 occastions of sick leave in 12 months, you are interviewed by your line manager about it but the length of time you are off is immaterial. So people who want to play the system would know it's counted the same whether you are self certifying for a day or a week.

However, even if you are off more than 3 times it doesn't necessarily end in a sickness warning and wouldn't if you had a doctors note for example. People with known health conditions in my department have multiple episodes of sick leave in a year without a "sickness warning". A doctor's note will protect OP no matter how many periods of sick leave she has already built up.

There is not a universal sickness policy in the UK. Some places have draconian sickness policies.

Your sickness policy doesn't help the OP whose company probably has a very different policy.

whumpthereitis · 02/11/2022 08:39

TheMoops · 02/11/2022 08:31

40 hrs over a month is just over an hour extra each day. It's hardly a lot. Good grief!

Maths isn't your strong point is it? It's 10 hours a week, so two hours a day - unpaid and without the offer of TOIL. It's wrong.

My DH did that for 30 years! Plus international travel cutting into weekends and arriving home at midnight.

I do extra hours and international travel and I ALWAYS get my hours back.

It comes down to whether you enjoy work or not, and are a coper or not.

No it's about companies taking advantage and employees knowing their worth. Nobody should be expected to work an extra week in a month without either being paid or getting that time back.

I’m astounded that someone is bragging about her family members being foolish enough to allow themselves to be taken advantage of, as if it’s something to be proud of or aspire to.

Currently in the UK on an international posting for my husband’s job and it’s something his company absolute financially compensate for over and above what he is already paid to do. He certainly wouldn’t do it for free, or for the same wage he would get back home, and nor would his company expect him to. They expect him to value his time and expertise.

clippyclops · 02/11/2022 08:39

Those saying raise a grievance like it's that simple. The grievance process is hugely stressful in itself, with employers' tendencies to breach timescales, conveniently lose information, conveniently get confused and often tell downright lies to defend their corner.

OP, your boss would be on shaky grounds giving you a warning about this when you have a sick note. If he has an HR department to take advice from, they would not back him doing this IMO. If anything is going to be taken further it sounds like it would be your sickness record as a whole and there is a legitimate process for this, or should be.

Per se there is not a problem going on holiday whilst signed off especially if it's stress. You'll find a number of articles online from employment lawyers confirming this.

If you are not in a union I suggest you join one immediately although they might not be prepared to help you retrospectively.

Vecna · 02/11/2022 08:37

I approve. Good for you OP. "Help the company" the cheeky get! Enjoy your holiday.

yellowtwo · 02/11/2022 08:36

LucilleLovelace · 02/11/2022 08:12

I've done months like that (unpaid, but I get a good salary) and it's exhausting and demoralising and unsustainable.

Oh FGS!

My DH did that for 30 years! Plus international travel cutting into weekends and arriving home at midnight.

My DCs do it regularly in their companies.

It comes down to whether you enjoy work or not, and are a coper or not.

Op gets paid hourly, presumably if your DHs work included international travel he was paid a salary, a quite a good one.
Op, your Gp gave you the sick note after you told them about what is happening and how you are feeling. Why would a Gp give a 6 week sick note if they didn't think you needed it.
Enjoy your holiday and look for another job, that workplace sounds awful.

Darbs76 · 02/11/2022 08:35

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2022 08:31

That seems ridiculous. Of course it matters if the sickness is genuine or if you have a doctors note. What if someone has cancer? What if they have been sectioned in a hospital as a member of my team at work has been? The employer can't just disregard genuine illnesses - physical or mental - just because it's government money!

If you’ve got cancer you’d get more days and it would be a discretion, but otherwise that’s just how it works. You get paid 6 months for sickness so has to be some limitations. It was much more generous in the past but people take the P and it got changed from 12 days and 6 occasions to half of that. As I say there is discretion, set criteria and extra days for illness but it’s not based on whether it’s a genuine illness or you have a note or not

LucilleLovelace · 02/11/2022 08:34

whumpthereitis · 02/11/2022 08:25

And? My husband and I have done/do the same, but we sure as shit get compensated for it.

Would we do it in a minimum wage job with little opportunity for career progression and no thanks? When the boss is taking the utter piss? Absolutely fucking not.

Well you may get compensated for it, (with a good annual salary) but unless you are paid overtime which most managerial jobs don't pay, then you are working unpaid hours.

The OP was an idiot not to raise it.

If she is hourly paid - and has a time sheet- then that's the route she needed to go down.

Not the passive aggressive approach of being signed off 'sick' .

Yes, fine, take holiday but also pursue the company for payment for extra hours worked.

Going off with 'stress' won't make her a good employee in the future if she changes jobs as it will be on her records.

Movinghouseatlast · 02/11/2022 08:34

Marleymerm · 01/11/2022 23:14

I am stressed, yes, I should have been clearer. I just worked 40hrs OT in a month, missed on time with my family, overworked myself and then got told I wouldn't even be getting paid. I've been on sick with stress before.

I was completely honest with my GP and I feel so crushed that all the hard work and late nights I did were for nothing on my part. I just wondered if anyone has advice on where I would stand if I was to get a written warning. I don't know if my boss can try and get me with the accusation this is all just to get back at them.

It depends what your contract says. If it says you get paid for overtime then you should be paid for it. If it doesn't then you don't.

Most 'professional' environments don't pay for overtime- people just work.late for their salary. It is ridiculous- eg in banking people can do 80 hour weeks and don't bat an eyelid. Those who don't do it probably won't progress. It is horrible and very hard to stop as it's engraved.

Back to you. The holiday and the overtime are two different issues, you are confusing the two. Most organisations I have worked for would take a dim view of you taking a holiday whilst off for stress unless you agreed it with HR beforehand. Yes, again it's ridiculous because are you really going to get better stuck at home? But it is the way it is.

GreyGoose1980 · 02/11/2022 08:32

What is the ‘custom and practice’ in your company OP? What does it say in your employment contract? Are there any OT policies? Have you been paid OT in the past? Is your contract clear? If so it’s reasonable for you to assume you’d be paid. If not then you should have clarified.

Regardless of the above a Dr has signed you off so legally whilst your company can penalise you for the number of sickness days, as per their sickness policy, they can not easily legally challenge the validity of your stress.

If they meet formally with you, you definitely need to stop associating the fact you took time off with the fact you weren’t being paid for the overtime (as in your OP you are making this seem like you took time of as you felt it was owed to you and depending on your employment contract and custom and practice within your company this is likely to be unjustified) and just focus on the fact you are genuinely stressed and legally signed off.