Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask neighbour not to use their 'tiny house'

93 replies

Notnowjo · 01/11/2022 22:55

My neighbour has a huge house and a small additional dwelling in her back garden, we think it's used when family and friends come to stay. It's pretty small like a studio so couldn't really be lived in long term. It's not attached to the main house. She has 5 bedrooms, multiple bathrooms, 1 teenage boy so space isn't an issue

We discovered yesterday that all the dirty sewage & water from this studio has been draining across our property for the last 3-4 months.
It filters through a large garden (hers then ours) and our retaining wall then across our garden (gravity!)

It has taken her over 2 months to get a draining guy to look at it, it took him about 15 minutes to find the issue (yes we have been continually reminding her)

This morning I'm disappointed to see another stream of water across our patio, I think they shouldn't use the water in the studio until the problem is fixed.

Am I being unreasonable to ask her not to use the studio?

OP posts:
Namechangehereandnow · 02/11/2022 08:12

Report to Environmental Health 🤷‍♀️

Morestrangethings · 02/11/2022 08:03

Whoops, unless it’s a water pipe burst. (In which case your neighbours water bill will be eye watering) But your plumber said dirty water, I believe?

Morestrangethings · 02/11/2022 08:01

If you are in where I am in Australia (and probably everywhere on Aus), all water - sink, shower, toilet etc go into a main line which is the sewer.

So if you are in Australia, your neighbour is behaving badly. Ring your local council and tell them. And let them know how long it’s been happening etc.

same thing happened to me at the last place I lived. Sewer water was running down the hill from 4 houses on the hill above me. The council told me they’d send someone out the next day but they turned up within hours.

After repairs were made at the source (that day) they came to my house, removed all the effluent and the effected lawn and topsoil, and laid down some chemical stuff to sanitize it.

we’ve had a heap of rain these past 2 years in Aus (climate crisis) and places that have never flooded before are flooding repeatedly.

Best of wishes OP and hope your problem is fixed very soon.

1WomanWonder · 02/11/2022 07:37

Ah. Didn't see you are overseas. Fingers crossed for an Environmental Health equivalent.

EarringsandLipstick · 02/11/2022 07:32

We discovered yesterday that all the dirty sewage & water from this studio has been draining across our property for the last 3-4 months.

If you had sewage flowing onto your property for 3 - 4 months you'd know all about it! You wouldn't be just assuming it was water.

It's clearly not sewage but is a leak or malfunction in her plumbing. For example, my down-pipe at the side of my house is where water from the downstairs bathroom comes out, washing machine runoff etc. occasionally the drain gets clogged with leaves; the water will start to run down the side passage until I sort it out.

You need to clearly define the problem & then write to her asking her to resolve it.

Sausagenbacon · 02/11/2022 07:31

We're overseas & the last few months have been very, very, very wet."
This could be literally anywhere

Southwig22 · 02/11/2022 07:31

I'd be reporting her quicker than you could say "cholera"

Sausagenbacon · 02/11/2022 07:30

I ask because it's pointless asking people to give advice when they don't know where you are.

BMW6 · 02/11/2022 07:28

What country are you in? Do you have an Environmental Health equivalent?

Laffinalltheway · 02/11/2022 07:26

@Sausagenbacon

"We're overseas & the last few months have been very, very, very wet."

1WomanWonder · 02/11/2022 07:22

Loads of people have advised correctly. Environmental Health will serve a notice that requires works, within a stated timescale. If the person responsible fails to resolve it the council can do the works and charge the owner. If there is an ongoing issue with sewage in the meantime that is causing you a nuisance they can require the person responsible to stop, particularly given that they have alternative provisions.

Personally I would be doing this before contacting my insurer. However the integrity of the retaining wall should be checked.

One other observation. It would be unusual to get a steady stream of water in the way you have described from a small summer house. Is the sewer possibly shared with other properties eg over the back?

ChateauMargaux · 02/11/2022 07:22

Grey water and sewage are not usually treated in the same way. You could do a dye test with the loo to check...

But she still needs to fix it and the council / environmental health / party wall solicitor would all be options for moving this forward.

Letter before action might also be required... send it registered post and make it clear that she needs to stop, assess the damage and fix it.

Sausagenbacon · 02/11/2022 07:11

Where are you OP? In the UK?

TheSandgroper · 02/11/2022 07:01

Bugger paying for a cease and desist letter from a lawyer. This is what Council’s Health department is for and it comes with powers of enforcement.

MavisChunch29 · 02/11/2022 07:00

Shopaholic123Go · 02/11/2022 01:25

I hate these sheds "summer houses" they're almost always used for people to live in full or part time. Unless you live on a country estate with acres of land you don't need a "summer house". All these people with one in an ordinary tiny garden, it's so unnecessary. I hope your neighbour gets in trouble for this OP, her behaviour is dispicable.

Nonsense, what snobbery. We have two sheds and a summer house and two other storage units in our garden, and all are needed and utilised for garden furniture and storing tools and bikes to doing yoga in. We are five people in a very full 4 bed semi detached house and need the garden storage/extra space too. You can do all that without creating a tiny house or an enviromental health hazard.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 02/11/2022 06:59

Whatever your country's equivalent of Environmental Health - raw sewage not going into a proper drainage system is a public health issue.

A "cease and desist" letter (can pay a lawyer to make it more carefully worded, or can do it yourself. Needs to state very clearly that all sewage and waste water from their Tinyhouse dwelling is coming on to your property and is leading to you having their poo on your kitchen floor. Be that blunt, as this will make it clear how unacceptable their behaviour is.

ivykaty44 · 02/11/2022 06:53

if they have people staying in it, they need to be careful as if council tax get wind that this is being used - they’ll be out wanting to see if they can charge council tax 😂😂

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/11/2022 06:37

ozymandiusking · 01/11/2022 23:03

Have you been in touch with The Enviromental Health departent. When you say drainage, do you mean a plumber I would have thought what they are doing is illegal.

This.

I had a very similar problem with a neighbour who backed on to me, who first agreed to fix the problem, then prevaricated, then just refused to do anything about it.

Env. Health got it sorted within days.

GreenCereal · 02/11/2022 05:28

I’m guessing Wellington - extremely wet weather and a retaining wall?!
Definitely get onto the council asap. Have a look to see if you can find the planning permission for the studio online as well.

ThingsIhavelearnt · 02/11/2022 05:18

StripeyDeckchair · 01/11/2022 23:02

Tell her that it needs fixing immediately and the space cannot be used until its fixed.
You are also looking for her to make good your garden - do you know if the watrt is foul or clean? If foul the your garden needs clearing and cleaning.

If you don't see any action in the next 7 days then contact environmental health as this is a health issue.

This - solicitor letter now explaining your frustration and the environmental health implications for you and the lack of a prompt response from them - send a strongly worded letter if not a solicitor letter - and send it recorded delivery then contact environmental health urgently and the council again by email or recorded delivery. Stress your attempts to resolve it and the lack of response and include any reports you have. She needs to cover the costs of all your surveys and don’t forget you may have legal cover via your insurance

WiddlinDiddlin · 02/11/2022 05:17

Mm.. in a house, then eventually, yes, the grey water (sinks, bath, shower) would be directed to the foul drain (toilets) and out into the sewer.

So in my house the foul drain from our toilet runs down the back of the house (and up as the pipe vents higher up) and then into the foul drain a few feet into the yard.
The grey water drain from upstairs joins the foul drain down pipe on the back of the house, but the greywater from the kitchen downstairs joins the pipe in the yard at a manhole cover.

Then that drain runs to the sewer which has a manhole cover at the end of my yard (but not every house in my row has one of those, so if there was something wrong in there, im the access point to the sewer).

If you were building a small studio with both grey water and foul, theres a few ways to do it.

One would be to put in a macerating toilet if the sewer access point or foul drain access point is uphill from the toilet - these grind up solid waste and then a pump pushes them uphill to the outlet point.

Or you'd put in a toilet with normal plumbing to drain into a suitable outlet.

Outlets could be the foul drain, direct to the sewer or to a septic tank (but chances are if they have a septic tank, so would you so you'd know that).

It is highly unlikely they have intentionally plumbed the toilet into a greywater soakaway, because whilst water would still drain, the solids would not and it would back up under their garden/property and absolutely STINK.

I suspect they've plumbed the toilet in properly, but the greywater to the soakaway and it isn't done properly or its not really up to the capacity needed when the place is in use... or they have a leak they are unaware of.

TheSandgroper · 02/11/2022 03:38

Are you in Victoria? Then get onto your council now. Right now. It might be that the septic tank has never been emptied but it might be something else. Whatever it is, it needs sorting out today. Then get onto planning and talk about planning permission with a failed septic system. But council health first.

Doingmybest12 · 02/11/2022 03:18

Sewage is the excrement in the toilet , is this draining into your land? If so call planning and environmental health ASAP.
Grey water - dirty washing up water hand washing water - I would have a chat, send a formal letter ,contact planning if no improvement but try and manage it in a more friendly way.
Not sure you can ban her from using her posh shed, can only ask her not to use the loo or sink and threaten letter from solicitor about sewage if this is what is bring discharged.

superram · 02/11/2022 02:49

Grey water and sewage are very different things. You need to politely have it out with her as you are concerned your property is being damaged but intimately I think you may to ask your house insurance cover to address it.

Notnowjo · 02/11/2022 02:31

Thanks guys sorry to post and run.

We've lived here a few years, studio was there before we moved in. We're overseas & the last few months have been very, very, very wet.

We have a huge retaining wall, a short while ago something changed in the way the water was draining from the retaining wall, once we were sure we spoke to neighbour and said do you have a leak in your pipes? Her house is next door but a lot higher (wall is maybe 10 feet)

We've been chasing her for a couple of months, we were told she had to go through a number of plumbers eventually one came round chucked some dye down the drains and it came hosing out at the bottom of our wall within a few minutes.
He told us it was 'dirty' water. Doesn't all 'dirty' water drain off your property through the same drain ie shower water, toilet flush, washing machine, dishwasher and water that drains away when you rinse out a mug or wash your hands or whatever? Eventually it all drains out through 1 drain?

She has a hole in her pipes, as a result water has filtered down through her property and into our garden and is now coming out of the bottom of this wall.

I assumed once she realised what was going on they would not use water in the studio, from the speed the dye came out I'm guessing there is now a pile of poo and toilet paper with effectively a pathway through the middle that the water drains straight out through.

I also assumed they would stop using water in the studio?

Thanks for all the comments, I'm on to our insurance company in a couple of hours. I'm totally grossed out we have cats and kids so this has been traipsed all over my flooring for the last couple of months. I was disappointed to see a stream of water crossing my garden this morning (it's raining but the water is now so obvious it's like we have a stream)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread