Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD be herself

239 replies

Pinpot · 01/11/2022 21:02

DD age 6 is very honest and speaking frankly, can be overly direct and tactless.

If she doesn't want to walk with a friend en route to school or if she doesn't want to play with a friend or see a relative she just blurts it out.

I can see she hurts peoples feelings although she's not malicious at all.

She will also chat on about new toys or holidays, even though she knows some of her friends don't have as much (we live in an area with some deprivation and her friendship group is diverse).

I am now and always have been very careful of peoples feelings. She doesn't seem to care.

I try to gently correct her or to provide strategies to end play dates gently or even at times to accept that she just needs to suck it up and put up with someone she's not sure about.

But part of me absolutely rejoices that she's not a people pleaser and just tells the truth.

What to do? Will life just force her to contort herself into 'be kind' or will she just go through life losing friends and alienating people? And does that matter if she's authentically herself? AIBU to just let her be who she is?

OP posts:
Topsyturvy78 · 01/11/2022 23:51

Do some role play with her you pretend to be her and she pretends she's a friend. Might help her understand that sometimes what she says can hurt they're feelings.

Fraaahnces · 01/11/2022 23:45

Could she be on the spectrum? Is she completely unable to read the room? Might be worth discussing with her teacher if she is otherwise (academically) bright but socially clunky. She will end up ostracized by the other kids if this continues without guidance.

Coyoacan · 01/11/2022 23:45

You are supposed to educate your chi. She is only six and you think her authentic self is a six year old without empathy or the ability to put herself in other people's shoes?

chaosmaker · 01/11/2022 23:44

I did/do the same and am either loved or loathed by people. Some love my honesty and others can't cope with it. I prefer people to know where they are with me anyway. Also prefer others to be the same with me. Life's too short for all the tiptoeing and shilly shallying around others.

SoupDragon · 01/11/2022 23:44

or will she just go through life losing friends and alienating people?

this is what will happen.

DD age 6 is very honest and speaking frankly, can be overly direct and tactless.

you mean she is rude.

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2022 23:44

I think your job as a parent is to help her pick up on social clues and help her read the room. If she’s blunt then gentle guidance may well pass her by. There’s a mid way between rude and doormat. How would you feel if x said that to you. Does she do any groups eg rainbows (girl guides) that would help her.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 01/11/2022 23:43

@wackamole - I had not seen the full “Be Kind” quote, until you posted it - thank you.

RachelGreeneGreep · 01/11/2022 23:40

KatieBell12 · 01/11/2022 22:12

It's your job to teach her how to interact appropriately. She will have no friends if you allow her to continue without intervention.

I agree.
Have a sibling who, among other things, didn't believe in saying no to their child. Also allowed them to speak as they pleased without filter to adults and children.

Poor kid struggled massively when it came to interacting with others, as a result. Saw them at an occasion where the whole class was present, and not one of the other children gave them as much as a glance, still less a hello. It was heartbreaking but the parents had set the child up tbh.

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 01/11/2022 23:39

Being yourself and having good manners are not incompatible.

Maybe your people pleasing history is understandably preventing you from seeing that.

Both are important. It's about finding a balance. After all, if being herself means lacking empathy she would become a one dimensional person. We develop through connection and that does require thinking about who the other person is, too.

I don't know that she'll necessarily end up lonely but she could end up quite mean if you encourage her to stick at this stage of her development.

She will properly learn through trial and error that having no filter has consequences. No man is an island.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/11/2022 23:35

As if people are calling a six year old girl an arsehole and preaching about kindness. Oh sweet irony!

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 01/11/2022 23:32

Aquamarine1029 · 01/11/2022 21:06

There's a vast difference between being a people-pleasing doormat and someone who is unconcerned about needlessly hurting people's feelings. If being "authentically herself" means she's an arsehole, I fail to see how that's something to celebrate.

@Aquamarine1029 is right. Your dd needs to learn that there are ways of saying things, and being honest, without being horrible/hurting people’s feelings.

There is plenty of middle ground between being a doormat/people pleaser and being mean and unkind, and if you don’t want your dd to have no friends, she needs to learn to modify her behaviour. Of course she can still be assertive and stand up for herself, but it is perfectly possible to do that without hurting other people.

All too often, on here and on other social media, I see stories of people who have adults in their life who claim to be assertive or blunt, and to ‘say it as it is’, when what they actually are is insensitive, cruel and have no care for anyone’s feelings. They don’t have friends - just people who are scared of them, and they alienate everyone. You don’t want your dd to end up like this, and now is the perfect time for her to learn to be a bit kinder, gentler and more tactful - and I don’t think it will mean she isn’t ‘herself’ any more.

WhereYouLeftIt · 01/11/2022 23:29

"I try to gently correct her or to provide strategies to end play dates gently or even at times to accept that she just needs to suck it up and put up with someone she's not sure about."
I suspect you are being far too gentle! Take a leaf out of your daughter's book and be blunt - 'DD, you're being rude again. Stop it.'

She's six, and from your OP it sounds as if you expect her to divine social expectations from the aether. Now, some children do, the observant ones who are interested in how things work; but I would say most have to be explicitly taught them. Most parents don't realise they are teaching this to their children, but nonetheless they are. You (and your husband, obviously) are not teaching her the social skills necessary to daily life, and frankly, as her parent, it is your JOB to teach her those skills. So get on with it.

Creameggs223 · 01/11/2022 23:24

Teach your child!! If she doesn't want to play/walk with someone say no thanks I'd rather walk/play alone their Is absolutely no reason for her to be rude.

Onceuponawhileago · 01/11/2022 23:18

Massively focussed on self identity, getting her needs met, being her authentic self, individualism as coached by a parent blah blah... In my experience in my daughters circle these kind of girls hold sway till about age 11-12 then people usually tell them to hitch a ride and they become unpleasant and insecure which I assume follows them through life. You are doing her no favours by teaching her to be as she is.

Fancypants1983 · 01/11/2022 23:17

The way I see it , you have a choice . You can teach your child politeness , manners and compassion for other’s feelings .

or life is going to.

and life teaches hard. Life is the big sister of the weeping girl you offended coming to give you a hiding in the park.
life will not pick you for the team.
life will leave you without a partner for the trip.
life will lose you the chance to compete for your dream job.

I’d have a word to be honest , she’ll thank you for it later .

Xmasbaby11 · 01/11/2022 23:14

My asd dd 10 is a bit like this - her social skills are lacking and she needs to be taught explicitly when/why she can't be so direct. She doesn't pick up social rules and cues like a NT child. Your dd is only 6 so has time to learn this. Believe me it's less cute as they get older amd became problematic around 8-9 when girls communicate in a more mature way. There is a difference between direct and rude.

Alexandernevermind · 01/11/2022 23:13

Posters are being very harsh. The child is only 6 for goodness sake. I do wonder if the responses would be the same if you were asking about a boy. Just teach tact but don't discourage boundaries, once she is more mature then it'll fall into place. Also, make sure she is not using walls to mask insecurity.

wackamole · 01/11/2022 23:13

It's normal for a young child to be focused on her own needs and wants and only partially aware of how others might be impacted. Also normal that they may not distinguish between a feeling of the moment (I don't want to play with Sophie right now because I'm reading my book) and an ongoing opinion/preference (I hate playing with Sophie because she only ever wants to play dolls and it's boring).

If the whole family is going to grandma's for the day and the 6yo pipes up that she doesn't want to go, very likely you end up taking her anyway and it would be rude of her to tell grandma "I didn't want to come but mum made me". (At six she might get away with it, at 10 or 15 or 20 it'll almost certainly be considered rude). But if she hates going to grandma's because she gets carsick or she's afraid of the dog or the neighbour's children bully her, you need to know that - just accepting "I don't want to" does your daughter a disservice.

At this age, something like "manners" will be learned mainly by rote; she can probably understand not doing something to someone else that she'd be hurt to have done to her, but she's not going to understand the full context of a situation. All you can do is help her be in touch with her own feelings but also to put them in perspective. You can teach her what's "expected" (basic manners) without teaching her to hide or ignore her feelings, opinions, and preferences from herself or you/her parents. She doesn't have to say "oh, Grandma, I've been looking forward to this trip all week!" but what's the point of saying "mum forced me to come"? If she genuinely does want to express her true feelings and opinions all the time in social interactions, they'll still be there when she's old enough to understand the impact and choose bluntness anyway.

As for the "be kind" stuff, I think the best thing you can do is remember that the original quote was "be kind, [when] it costs you nothing". If it DOES cost something, if it comes at the expense of being safe or happy or well or honest or solvent or whatever else is also important, then it requires further situation-specific thought. A 6yo is just at the beginning of figuring all of that out and definitely needs guidance!

SheepDance · 01/11/2022 23:12

NuffSaidSam · 01/11/2022 21:13

I think this is something that will probably work itself out tbh. As she gets older and a bit more self-aware, develops some empathy etc. she'll curtail her behaviour. Let her feel the natural consequences of her behaviour, set a good example and then leave her to figure it out.

Agree with this.
It may be no bad thing in certain situations to be blunt, though. As she gets older she will probably be more sensitive with it.

User15432 · 01/11/2022 23:08

Bottom line is, it’s your job to help your child be accepted and liked in society.

If you can see your child is rude and bragging then others see this 10 times more.

You are doing her no favours. We all have innate flaws, if we never worked on them then we’d all be arseholes. It is your job to minimise the flaws not nurture them.

Labraradabrador · 01/11/2022 23:07

People seem to pile on about insensitivity about haves / have nots, but I think most 6yos are oblivious. My two 5yos get excited about the most pointless nonsense- they have recently regaled their friends about a special eraser, a random coin token of no monetary value, and a dead moth that ‘lives’ in her bedroom. They have also been insanely jealous of friends who went camping for holiday rather than our holiday abroad. It is important to have sensitivity as she ages and social status becomes more linked to the adult commercial world, but it isn’t surprising she is oblivious.

I always respect my child’s desires for playmates, etc in part because one of mine is maybe sen and doesn’t always want to participate, butI do have lots of conversations about kindness, the importance of taking care of others, etc. when they say something rudely I will acknowledge their stated desire (I don’t want to play with that kid) to something more polite (I know you want to do something else, but it would be kinder to say’ not right now, maybe later’). One of mine is extremely blunt, and really doesn’t give a toss about what anyone else thinks, but she also isn’t seeking to hurt anyone. She just needs a bit of guidance in how to express herself without hurting others.

FirstandLastBorn · 01/11/2022 23:06

@Strawblue I hadn't seen your post when I wrote mine. 😊

FirstandLastBorn · 01/11/2022 23:05

Empathy goes a long way, OP. It's one thing to be assertive and have boundaries but quite another thing to be callous.

User15432 · 01/11/2022 23:05

My daughter was like this. I have spent years trying to guide her into being a kind and considerate person, sometimes I had to be tough. I always explained the other persons position and point of view.

Etinoxaurus · 01/11/2022 23:01

Cherrysherbet · 01/11/2022 22:23

You need to guide her.

Exactly this. Model turn taking and tact. You’re doing her no favours.