Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD be herself

239 replies

Pinpot · 01/11/2022 21:02

DD age 6 is very honest and speaking frankly, can be overly direct and tactless.

If she doesn't want to walk with a friend en route to school or if she doesn't want to play with a friend or see a relative she just blurts it out.

I can see she hurts peoples feelings although she's not malicious at all.

She will also chat on about new toys or holidays, even though she knows some of her friends don't have as much (we live in an area with some deprivation and her friendship group is diverse).

I am now and always have been very careful of peoples feelings. She doesn't seem to care.

I try to gently correct her or to provide strategies to end play dates gently or even at times to accept that she just needs to suck it up and put up with someone she's not sure about.

But part of me absolutely rejoices that she's not a people pleaser and just tells the truth.

What to do? Will life just force her to contort herself into 'be kind' or will she just go through life losing friends and alienating people? And does that matter if she's authentically herself? AIBU to just let her be who she is?

OP posts:
AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:09

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:05

You might be very blunt (which is glaringly obvious from your posts) but presumably, given your personal situation, you also understand the need to be kind and to not necessarily say every "honest" thought you have?

I won't insult someone for no reason but if I'm asked for my honest opinion I'll give it. Very weird to think people like this don't marry? Granted I'm married to a neurodivergent man who appreciates directness himself, I'm just saying there's plenty of both men and women who appreciate that style of communication and therefore its incorrect saying they'll never marry or have kids or make friends.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:05

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 06:28

What a bizarre comment. I'm a very blunt person - I married in my very early 20s and have 3 kids. Whether you prefer direct people or ones who beat around the bush it has nothing to do with whether someone gets married or not.

You might be very blunt (which is glaringly obvious from your posts) but presumably, given your personal situation, you also understand the need to be kind and to not necessarily say every "honest" thought you have?

Endlesssummer2022 · 02/11/2022 06:47

What’s all of this ‘gently’ telling her to be more tactful stuff? Just tell her straight, like she apparently does to others. You’re not doing her any favours letting her think her behaviour is ok.

I met a girl at uni who ‘told it like it is’. People used to avoid her. Nobody wants to be around rude people.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 06:28

Charlize43 · 02/11/2022 03:04

She'll probably end up as a 45 year old childless singleton. When you meet these women it normally doesn't take long to find out why they are in this situation. It does sound like she's destined for a lonely life.

However, people can change. Maybe as she gets older she'll become more of a people person.

What a bizarre comment. I'm a very blunt person - I married in my very early 20s and have 3 kids. Whether you prefer direct people or ones who beat around the bush it has nothing to do with whether someone gets married or not.

Charlize43 · 02/11/2022 03:04

She'll probably end up as a 45 year old childless singleton. When you meet these women it normally doesn't take long to find out why they are in this situation. It does sound like she's destined for a lonely life.

However, people can change. Maybe as she gets older she'll become more of a people person.

Kamia · 02/11/2022 02:59

I don't think she's being intentionally rude she's 6 and still young. She is possibly so excited about her new toy but she hasn't thought about how others are feeling. Most 6 year olds would find being tactful difficult because that's a skill they have to develop. Piaget a child development theorist had said until age 7 children can be egocentric as in they don't understand how others are feeling. I think over time with a little help from you and pshe lessons at school she will understand a lot more and develop empathy.

mathanxiety · 02/11/2022 01:26

Agree with @Musti here.

mathanxiety · 02/11/2022 01:23

Sometimes you have to choose between being right and being kind.

Kids of 6 don't always see the need to choose kindness, but you can work on it.

Cheeeeislifenow · 02/11/2022 01:17

Op has already stated how she IS teaching empathy posters are reading way too much into it. And saying you don't want to go somewhere, or you don't want to walk with someone isn't rude.
Just got to teach how to phrase it. Instead of I don't want to walk with you, she could say something like, I would like to walk on my own today.
I think its good she is assertive and can express herself, a good trait to have.

DaughterofDawn · 02/11/2022 00:56

She can be taught how to uphold healthy boundaries without intruding upon the emotional boundaries of others.

Murdoch1949 · 02/11/2022 00:53

It would be helpful to your daughter to gently discuss with her, after an incident, what happened and how it could be changed. Maybe role play with her, to help her understand how she could be hurting others. She will learn how to adapt, without her spirit being quashed.

Discovereads · 02/11/2022 00:47

I’d get her assessed for autism.
Its not rudeness when the child is oblivious to how they’ve hurt feelings (only you see it and she seems to not care) and despite parental guidance and explanations simply do not get what they said or did that was wrong- so they keep doing it.

The “She will also chat on about new toys or holidays,” is common masking…trying to be social but not understanding the nuances.

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 02/11/2022 00:42

IWishICouldDance · 02/11/2022 00:36

She's 6, I have a 6 year old too. Sounds pretty normal to be honest. We remind our children that not all children can have everything they want and how lucky they are (we aren't rich but don't often need to say no to stuff they ask for). I'd imagine if they went to school with poorer children they'd say things about where they went or stuff they got, it wouldn't be said with mean intent though (my children are 6 and 4). My children are kind but assertive generally, fine by me, I wouldn't want them to be a pushover.

The difference is you said your children are kind and you remind them of differences between people who have and have not. That is you teaching them. The OP is concerned that her child will morph into being kind. The OP can see that she hurts other people's feelings and quietly rejoices that she is the way she is.

IWishICouldDance · 02/11/2022 00:36

She's 6, I have a 6 year old too. Sounds pretty normal to be honest. We remind our children that not all children can have everything they want and how lucky they are (we aren't rich but don't often need to say no to stuff they ask for). I'd imagine if they went to school with poorer children they'd say things about where they went or stuff they got, it wouldn't be said with mean intent though (my children are 6 and 4). My children are kind but assertive generally, fine by me, I wouldn't want them to be a pushover.

OldFan · 02/11/2022 00:28

Your job is to help her learn social skills etc. She doesn't have to be a people pleaser but learn more skills as we all do throughout life.

I'm not 100% NT and that meant I needed more guidance which I didn't get. I needed how to interact with others verbally spelled out or I didn't pick it up easily. This could've transformed my life and future outcomes. As it is I've never really been able to work and have few friends.

I know a leftie couple who let their kids act any which way and think it's hilarious. Recipe for a car crash of numerous kinds and not fulfilling their potential.

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 02/11/2022 00:24

There is a boy who sounds similar to your daughter in my DC's class. He is a talkative and smart boy but he lacks empathy. My DC describes him as tactless and says he says what he thinks without thinking how other people may feel.

His family are well off and he has expensive toys and travels a lot. He doesn't hesitate to ask other kids why they haven't been to the countries he has visited or why their parents don't drive expensive cars or brag about his latest top of the range electronic gadgets.

His mother is concerned about his lack of social skills and empathy. She has tried to correct him but her attempts are pretty feeble.

I asked DC who his friends were and he doesn't have any. That said, he doesn't walk around on his own. He plays with a bigger group but when its time to pair up, he is left on his own. Imo he is probably on the spectrum but hasn't been diagnosed. Or perhaps his parents thought it was wonderful that he is 'being himself'.

Wiluli · 02/11/2022 00:23

I would be worried with her lack of empathy , it may mean something is amiss .

HistrionicNeurotic · 02/11/2022 00:20

There’s a different between being blunt and rude and being blunt and polite. It’s a difficult thing to learn but it can be done. Housemate is neurodivergent (such as I) They are blunt but they are not rude.

me on the other hand have obsessively learnt how to perform social niceties How to always ask about people, be interested in people and most importantly compromise. With my ASD it’s easy to become absorbed in myself. I’ve had pointers (thanks mum), to say please and thank you, to learn how social people behave. I’ve learnt that considering others feeling are important yes I tell white lies to have an easy life. To not hurt other peoples feelings. It’s a NT world and you have to learn how to live in it Even through gritted teeth Do not believe all ND people are blunt. Please stop saying this as it’s not true.

BadNomad · 02/11/2022 00:18

Does she realise when she hurts other people's feelings? I would encourage other people to tell her how she has made them feel. If she cares, she will change her approach. If she doesn't care, then she'll carry on. She will lose friends over the years, and maybe that won't bother her, but it's important for her to understand why it happens.

carefulcalculator · 02/11/2022 00:18

Lalliella · 02/11/2022 00:11

A lot of people on here are criticising the child, when what should be criticised is the parenting. Are you a follower of gentle parenting OP? You’re enabling your child’s poor behaviour. You need to teach her empathy and manners.

It’s all very well to be your “authentic self” if you live on a desert island and never mix with anyone, but we live in a society and need to consider the feelings of others as well as ourselves.

WTF has gentle parenting got to do with anything - gentle parenting is about tackling issues, not ignoring them!

unkownone · 02/11/2022 00:15

My youngest is similar. Though was tought to not be rude to people, so i used to have her cry of a night when little because she really wanted to tell me how fat i was. She has very little tollerance for people now still. My other daughter at 17 is still super sweet and kind and my youngest is just her.

We also are sure she has asperger's. Dr only didn't take it further as she had eye contact but we've since learnt that means nothing. She's 14 and down to a few friends as anyone who's spoken badly about anyone she likes she literally cuts them off no questions asked - teachers included lol.

Lalliella · 02/11/2022 00:11

A lot of people on here are criticising the child, when what should be criticised is the parenting. Are you a follower of gentle parenting OP? You’re enabling your child’s poor behaviour. You need to teach her empathy and manners.

It’s all very well to be your “authentic self” if you live on a desert island and never mix with anyone, but we live in a society and need to consider the feelings of others as well as ourselves.

Clarissa111 · 02/11/2022 00:08

Someone that says it how it is, is usually rude.
I'll say it how it is, and don't care if u hate me.
That's a statement made by someone with no friends, and universally disliked.
Standing up for yourself and being true to yourself, doesn't mean hurting others feelings.
I'm a mother of 5. I've tried to teach them to be true to themselves. But not to hurt someone.

Hagpie · 02/11/2022 00:04

My kid was a bit like this but as she has recovered from not being around other children for 2 years, her teachers have noted she is a “kind and friendly classmate” in her end of year reports.

When she says something rude or overly blunt I just say “you can express any idea you want to my love. I love you, I love when you talk to me ….. but you will talk to me with respect.” Smile. Mean it. Utterly non-negotiable.

Mumwithbaggage · 01/11/2022 23:52

I have come to the realisation late in life (teacher) that my bluntness is connected to ADHD, I have learnt to adapt. Just something that you may wish to be aware of.