Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD be herself

239 replies

Pinpot · 01/11/2022 21:02

DD age 6 is very honest and speaking frankly, can be overly direct and tactless.

If she doesn't want to walk with a friend en route to school or if she doesn't want to play with a friend or see a relative she just blurts it out.

I can see she hurts peoples feelings although she's not malicious at all.

She will also chat on about new toys or holidays, even though she knows some of her friends don't have as much (we live in an area with some deprivation and her friendship group is diverse).

I am now and always have been very careful of peoples feelings. She doesn't seem to care.

I try to gently correct her or to provide strategies to end play dates gently or even at times to accept that she just needs to suck it up and put up with someone she's not sure about.

But part of me absolutely rejoices that she's not a people pleaser and just tells the truth.

What to do? Will life just force her to contort herself into 'be kind' or will she just go through life losing friends and alienating people? And does that matter if she's authentically herself? AIBU to just let her be who she is?

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 02/11/2022 10:36

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 09:47

Why do the majority get to decide what's rude? I find small talk exhausting and a waste of my time, to me that's rude. Why are the majority right just because there's more of them?

Secondly you don't know that either - maybe OPs DD doesn't want to waste her time with people like that, I know I didn't as a child.

But I don't think we will agree on this.

<tiny voice>

I live for small talk . . . 😟

But I can recognise that some people aren't "chatty".

There's a danger that OP's DD will grow into one of those people who needlessly hurt others without perhaps intending to - or worse, not caring. We've all met them - cruel/thoughtless remarks followed by an affronted "It's just my way!" if they are pulled on it. "I don't mean anything. It's just how I am."

In my experience these people are also abnormally sensitive when it comes to their own feelings being hurt.

Kanaloa · 02/11/2022 10:15

Charlize43 · 02/11/2022 03:04

She'll probably end up as a 45 year old childless singleton. When you meet these women it normally doesn't take long to find out why they are in this situation. It does sound like she's destined for a lonely life.

However, people can change. Maybe as she gets older she'll become more of a people person.

😂

Firstly, being childless doesn’t mean you’re a bad person - if anything too many bad people have children!

Secondly, just because a 6 year old says she doesn’t like Sophie doesn’t mean she’s destined for a life of misery. As long as she’s taught better ways to relate to others she’ll learn (like everyone else does) and will likely grow into a perfectly normal adult, albeit possibly one who prefers her own space. Only difference is she’ll learn to say ‘I won’t come to lunch this weekend guys, I need a weekend to myself to chill’ rather than ‘I’m not going out with you Sophie, I don’t like you.’

MadameCholetsDirtySecret · 02/11/2022 10:03

Give me a child until they are 7 and I will show you the woman/man. Aristotle

it’s worth thinking about.

Bobbins36 · 02/11/2022 09:51

Child or adult no one has the right to be hurtful towards others - just because they want to express ‘their truth’

Opinions - like arseholes. We all have one, not everyone wants to see yours.

Thereisnolight · 02/11/2022 09:50

Anonymouseposter · 02/11/2022 09:45

People pleasing is when you are very concerned about what people think of you and are frightened of causing offence. Manners is when you are concerned about other people’s feelings and are considerate. There’s a difference of focus. I was surprised on another recent thread that some people were bringing their children up to focus on their own boundaries and never do anything they don’t feel like doing out of consideration for someone else. I think there needs to be flexibility, in some situations it’s appropriate to smooth relationships and consider other people, in other situations the priority is to assert yourself and get what you want. It’s subtle and difficult to teach to children if you find it difficult yourself.

Good post

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 09:47

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 09:34

Sure, but OP's daughter will have a pretty miserable time of it up until she finds her people, because no one wants their kid to play with the rude little girl who hurts people's feelings.

Why do the majority get to decide what's rude? I find small talk exhausting and a waste of my time, to me that's rude. Why are the majority right just because there's more of them?

Secondly you don't know that either - maybe OPs DD doesn't want to waste her time with people like that, I know I didn't as a child.

But I don't think we will agree on this.

Anonymouseposter · 02/11/2022 09:45

People pleasing is when you are very concerned about what people think of you and are frightened of causing offence. Manners is when you are concerned about other people’s feelings and are considerate. There’s a difference of focus. I was surprised on another recent thread that some people were bringing their children up to focus on their own boundaries and never do anything they don’t feel like doing out of consideration for someone else. I think there needs to be flexibility, in some situations it’s appropriate to smooth relationships and consider other people, in other situations the priority is to assert yourself and get what you want. It’s subtle and difficult to teach to children if you find it difficult yourself.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 09:34

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 09:13

I understand it, I just think it's silly. I wouldn't want people to handhold me. I find it exhausting having to be around people who prefer that kind of communication, they probably don't like being around people like me either, and I think that's okay. People are different and prefer different types of people, its okay to not have to change who you are and instead find your people.

Sure, but OP's daughter will have a pretty miserable time of it up until she finds her people, because no one wants their kid to play with the rude little girl who hurts people's feelings.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 09:14

maddening · 02/11/2022 09:11

Small talk doesn't require that level of depth, the kind of chat that takes place in very superficial relationships and acquaintances, usually when dealing with customer facing staff eg hair dressers, tradesmen, waiting and bar staff, delivery drivers, retail staff, receptionists, or other situations such asparents at the school gate, mixing at a conference etc etc. It is very usual to chat in these situations.

There is no expectation to lay out your entire catalogue of issues, in fact that would be odd, it is just a light social interaction. Over sharing in these situations as you really can't not "tell it like it is" and consider anything less a lie is crazy imo.

I think small talk in general is stupid. I don't want my time wasted with pointless meaningless interactions, I'd rather be alone with my thoughts than have someone droning on at me following an empty script. If you want my time, make it worth my time, otherwise leave me alone to enjoy my peace and solitude

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 09:13

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 09:06

I can't tell if you're being deliberately obtuse or if you really don't understand human emotions at all.

People do want to know if they look alright, they just want to be told kindly. "No, that dress makes you look fat" is rude. "Hmm, I'm not sure it's the most flattering shape on you, I think a flowy skirt would really highlight your curves" has the exact same effect (person changes into a less unflattering outfit) but doesn't cause the hurt feelings.

However irrational and silly it may be, human beings experience emotional reactions. We're not robots. Part of loving people is taking care of them, being considerate of their feelings, even though they might be illogical. You don't have to lie, or pander, but you do need to be gentle with people. We're all fragile in our own way and we're all deserving of care and thought from the people who are close to us.

I understand it, I just think it's silly. I wouldn't want people to handhold me. I find it exhausting having to be around people who prefer that kind of communication, they probably don't like being around people like me either, and I think that's okay. People are different and prefer different types of people, its okay to not have to change who you are and instead find your people.

maddening · 02/11/2022 09:11

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:52

Don't ask then. Same as people who say "do I look alright?" when they mean "validate me and tell me I'm pretty". Don't say anything if you don't want a response, OR say what you really mean.

Small talk doesn't require that level of depth, the kind of chat that takes place in very superficial relationships and acquaintances, usually when dealing with customer facing staff eg hair dressers, tradesmen, waiting and bar staff, delivery drivers, retail staff, receptionists, or other situations such asparents at the school gate, mixing at a conference etc etc. It is very usual to chat in these situations.

There is no expectation to lay out your entire catalogue of issues, in fact that would be odd, it is just a light social interaction. Over sharing in these situations as you really can't not "tell it like it is" and consider anything less a lie is crazy imo.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 09:06

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:52

Don't ask then. Same as people who say "do I look alright?" when they mean "validate me and tell me I'm pretty". Don't say anything if you don't want a response, OR say what you really mean.

I can't tell if you're being deliberately obtuse or if you really don't understand human emotions at all.

People do want to know if they look alright, they just want to be told kindly. "No, that dress makes you look fat" is rude. "Hmm, I'm not sure it's the most flattering shape on you, I think a flowy skirt would really highlight your curves" has the exact same effect (person changes into a less unflattering outfit) but doesn't cause the hurt feelings.

However irrational and silly it may be, human beings experience emotional reactions. We're not robots. Part of loving people is taking care of them, being considerate of their feelings, even though they might be illogical. You don't have to lie, or pander, but you do need to be gentle with people. We're all fragile in our own way and we're all deserving of care and thought from the people who are close to us.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:52

maddening · 02/11/2022 08:50

The tesco delivery driver is not here to take on your woes, smiling and being agreeable to a delivery driver is not lying, it is just not burdening the world with whatever shit is going on for you. That social transaction was never anything more than a polite interaction, the delivery driver asking "how's it going" was never an invitation to divulge problems.

Don't ask then. Same as people who say "do I look alright?" when they mean "validate me and tell me I'm pretty". Don't say anything if you don't want a response, OR say what you really mean.

maddening · 02/11/2022 08:50

UniversalTruth · 01/11/2022 21:44

@AMorningstar every time you eg. thank your MIL for a present you don't want, or smile at the Tesco delivery driver that you're having a good day when you're not you teach your kids how to tell white lies. I stand by my comment.

The tesco delivery driver is not here to take on your woes, smiling and being agreeable to a delivery driver is not lying, it is just not burdening the world with whatever shit is going on for you. That social transaction was never anything more than a polite interaction, the delivery driver asking "how's it going" was never an invitation to divulge problems.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:49

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:48

See to me that's just mincing words. The outcome is either a yes or a no, how you word it shouldn't really matter because the outcome is the same. I also think people shouldn't need someone else's validation and it's totally OK for a friend to not like something you like, or not want to do it at that particular time for whatever reason. People shouldn't take rejection so personally, and shouls be comfortable enough in themselves to get on with it.

Accept this isn't the most popular way of looking at it though.

You're welcome to your opinion, but it won't win you many repeat invites.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:48

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:44

It's rude because it doesn't take into consideration how the other person might feel in the face of rejection. It's not about entitlement at all.

If you've thought of something nice to do with a friend, and suggested it to them, excited to share a new experience with them, and they just go "no I don't want to", of course you'll feel hurt.

By acknowledging the fact that the other person has given time and thought to their offer, thanking them for that, and gently turning it down, you minimise the sting of rejection.

It would be a very rare individual who wouldn't be hurt by an invitation or offer being met by flat rejection.

See to me that's just mincing words. The outcome is either a yes or a no, how you word it shouldn't really matter because the outcome is the same. I also think people shouldn't need someone else's validation and it's totally OK for a friend to not like something you like, or not want to do it at that particular time for whatever reason. People shouldn't take rejection so personally, and shouls be comfortable enough in themselves to get on with it.

Accept this isn't the most popular way of looking at it though.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:44

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:41

Why would it be rude unless the other person either feels a) entitled to your time or b) like their time is such a blessing, everyone should drop everything and immediately take up the offer? When broken down, it's far more rude to be offended by it for the reasons above, imo.

It's rude because it doesn't take into consideration how the other person might feel in the face of rejection. It's not about entitlement at all.

If you've thought of something nice to do with a friend, and suggested it to them, excited to share a new experience with them, and they just go "no I don't want to", of course you'll feel hurt.

By acknowledging the fact that the other person has given time and thought to their offer, thanking them for that, and gently turning it down, you minimise the sting of rejection.

It would be a very rare individual who wouldn't be hurt by an invitation or offer being met by flat rejection.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:41

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:39

It is very possible to assert a boundary without hurting feelings. Just flat out saying "no I don't want to" is rude. It's hardly difficult to say "thank you for asking, I don't feel like it today, that was very kind of you to offer though" instead, is it?

This is what I mean about people who say "oh I'm just honest" when in fact they're just not giving any consideration to how anyone else might feel.

Why would it be rude unless the other person either feels a) entitled to your time or b) like their time is such a blessing, everyone should drop everything and immediately take up the offer? When broken down, it's far more rude to be offended by it for the reasons above, imo.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:39

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:36

Peoples feelings get hurt by any sort of honesty though, that's the issue. Parents should be teaching their kids resilience towards comments like "No I don't want to" rather than their kid getting upset that someone else has asserted a boundary.

Again, I am not condoning insults or anything like that, that would obviously be different.

Just my opinion though.

It is very possible to assert a boundary without hurting feelings. Just flat out saying "no I don't want to" is rude. It's hardly difficult to say "thank you for asking, I don't feel like it today, that was very kind of you to offer though" instead, is it?

This is what I mean about people who say "oh I'm just honest" when in fact they're just not giving any consideration to how anyone else might feel.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:36

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:33

Well, it says in the OP that she's hurting people's feelings. That's not going to win her many friends, and it will lead to other people finding her rude and unpleasant.

Peoples feelings get hurt by any sort of honesty though, that's the issue. Parents should be teaching their kids resilience towards comments like "No I don't want to" rather than their kid getting upset that someone else has asserted a boundary.

Again, I am not condoning insults or anything like that, that would obviously be different.

Just my opinion though.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:33

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:31

Maybe. OPs daughter doesn't sound rude or unpleasant to me personally which is why I don't really see the issue here. If she were calling people names or something I could see it but it doesn't sound like she is.

Well, it says in the OP that she's hurting people's feelings. That's not going to win her many friends, and it will lead to other people finding her rude and unpleasant.

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:31

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:22

@AMorningstar I think you're conflating two different things, to be honest. ND individuals who don't fully conform to the social contract due to their inherent ways of thinking are a different kettle of fish to NT individuals who "tell it like it is" and "value honesty" and "are just direct" - there's a degree of grace and understanding for the first category (one would hope) whereas the second category are almost universally just unpleasant people with a huge sense of their own superiority, and that category do tend to end up lonely.

Maybe. OPs daughter doesn't sound rude or unpleasant to me personally which is why I don't really see the issue here. If she were calling people names or something I could see it but it doesn't sound like she is.

EmmaDilemma5 · 02/11/2022 08:28

If only parenting was as easy as 'letting them be themselves'.

I think you should continue supporting her to improve her relationship skills. It will serve her well in the future.

If she continues to disregard others feelings, it will be her who suffers in the long run.

Having said all that, she's still only 6 and children are naturally selfish. I'd imagine she'll learn over time how to regulate herself better. But some support from you is needed.

Rinatinabina · 02/11/2022 08:24

Teaching your daughter to frame things in a way which means she can still get her desired outcome without hurting is a really good skill. I would absolutely never expect DD to have flexible boundaries but I do expect her to be polite. I do understand if you have people pleasing tendencies that you feel like it makes your daughter stronger and less likely to get walked over, I totally understand that. But she is more likely to be able to form happy close relationships in the future with a bit of tweaking.

“Do you want to play with me”

“no go away I’m busy” vs “maybe later, I’m just playing a game with Peter now but thanks for asking” - which one is more likely to invite a second approach?

At 6 she should be able to understand that some kids don’t have as much as she does and it is really important that spending time with her doesn’t become self esteem destroying for other kids, it will isolate her.

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 08:22

@AMorningstar I think you're conflating two different things, to be honest. ND individuals who don't fully conform to the social contract due to their inherent ways of thinking are a different kettle of fish to NT individuals who "tell it like it is" and "value honesty" and "are just direct" - there's a degree of grace and understanding for the first category (one would hope) whereas the second category are almost universally just unpleasant people with a huge sense of their own superiority, and that category do tend to end up lonely.