Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD be herself

239 replies

Pinpot · 01/11/2022 21:02

DD age 6 is very honest and speaking frankly, can be overly direct and tactless.

If she doesn't want to walk with a friend en route to school or if she doesn't want to play with a friend or see a relative she just blurts it out.

I can see she hurts peoples feelings although she's not malicious at all.

She will also chat on about new toys or holidays, even though she knows some of her friends don't have as much (we live in an area with some deprivation and her friendship group is diverse).

I am now and always have been very careful of peoples feelings. She doesn't seem to care.

I try to gently correct her or to provide strategies to end play dates gently or even at times to accept that she just needs to suck it up and put up with someone she's not sure about.

But part of me absolutely rejoices that she's not a people pleaser and just tells the truth.

What to do? Will life just force her to contort herself into 'be kind' or will she just go through life losing friends and alienating people? And does that matter if she's authentically herself? AIBU to just let her be who she is?

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 04/11/2022 07:01

YABU. Your DD isn’t old enough to understand social conventions and courtesy. It’s your job to teach her. Left to their own devices most children would be self-centred, tactless and a bit rude.

She doesn’t have to be a people-pleaser. She can still say No to play dates but in a more polite way. If we all grew up being allowed to be rude, then the cogs of society wouldn’t run so smoothly and there would be an atmosphere of unpleasantness.

YABU in not teaching your DD manners and empathy. Unreasonable to her because she’ll alienate potential friends, and unreasonable to others around her who’ll have to put up with immaturity and discourtesy as she grows older.

piesforever · 04/11/2022 06:57

My son had a friend like this. This ex-friend has no mates now and the parent claimed in the end that he was being bullied because other kids got sick of the bragging

Iamgrootyesiam · 04/11/2022 06:43

Oh my days, these comments! She’s 6 years old for heavens sake! 🙄

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 04/11/2022 05:38

Can we normalise saying no I don't want to. It's not a personal slight. It's not rude.

Notmrsfitz · 04/11/2022 05:22

Only on Mumsnet would you get a child aged 6 vilified for their behaviour.
She is a baby, still learning and needing guidance - she cannot understand the concept of right and wrong,actions and consequences until the age of 7.

She doesn’t understand that some children don’t have the same environment as her, at that age she is very egotistical and assumes everyone is the same - empathy comes when she understands a situation makes others sad (even children on the spectrum can display empathy).

You can, as her Mum love her as much as possible (obviously) accept that she isn’t (at the moment) a people pleaser and encourage her to say things in a more socially acceptable manner and in time I think she will develop empathy and social awareness.

But in honesty, I’ve spent hours in therapy and been advised that I need to be more like your daughter 😀 and not be such a doormat !!!

Beachloveramy · 04/11/2022 02:57

Wow I’m truly shocked by the amount of grown adults calling a 6yo an arsehole or similar! - would they do that in RL? 🙄

Have you considered she may be on the autism spectrum? A lack of empathy/social skills is the most common sign of this and girls go undiagnosed more often. I just find it really hard to believe she’s just not a nice person, it feels like she doesn’t realise she’s hurting people and there most likely is a reason that she can’t help.

Snoooozzze · 04/11/2022 00:48

YABU not to be asserting some social skills to your DD. As parents we are responsible for raising children who will grow up to be contributing and considerate members of society. Not teaching her how to behave in a normal social setting (playground, school etc) is a sure fire way to ensure you raise an arsehole IMO

My DD is soon to be 17yo and I have literally said to her when she has questioned why I have called out her shitty attitude in the past that it’s my job to make sure I don’t raise an arsehole and unleash it on the world with no social skills.

Children practice their skills at home (push boundaries etc) so it would be interesting to know if when she is rude and blunt to you/your family at home, what consequences does she have if any?

LolaSmiles · 03/11/2022 22:08

I think sometimes people who describe themselves as people pleasers are actually quite passive aggressive and end up getting their own way anyway, while seemingly believing that they are really nice and putting themselves last
That's actually a good point. Now you've said it I can see the martyr persona in some of this as well.

RachelGreeneGreep · 03/11/2022 21:17

I think sometimes people who describe themselves as people pleasers are actually quite passive aggressive and end up getting their own way anyway, while seemingly believing that they are really nice and putting themselves last.

That said, I think it's important for the child to start to understand that other people's feelings matter as well as hers. You won't be doing her any favours longterm OP, imo by not addressing this with her and 'letting her be who she is.'

I mentioned upthread that I have a sibling whose child never heard the word no, and was allowed 'to be who they are'. And who they were, particularly in primary school was the unpopular kid who alienated others and had literally no friends. It was very sad to see.

Saracen · 03/11/2022 08:39

I think it is easier to rein in someone who is tactless than it is to build up the self-esteem of a people-pleaser who is overly concerned about other people's feelings and always puts herself last.

And the capacity to understand other people's needs and feelings and figure out subtleties is not always there in young children.

So I wouldn't be in a great hurry to work on your daughter's behaviour, but she does eventually need to behave more considerately and maturely if she's going to have friends. For my kids, watching TV and reading books together has been a good way to empathise with other people, see things from their point of view and explore ways of helping them. But it didn't work when they were very young. They just didn't get it.

purplewashbag · 03/11/2022 07:48

@chaosmaker but work is a very large part of most peoples life. So being not liked at work because you're rude is not going to get you far. I work in male dominated field where being fairly rude is the norm but saying I don't want to work with you because that's how you feel will literally end you with the sack.

purplewashbag · 03/11/2022 07:45

If everyone was left to 'be their self' we wouldn't have much of a good society left imo. The reason we teach manners is to fit in culturally ti our environment. The old adage manners cost nothing really is true.
If an adult told me they didn't want to walk with me to work outright with no real given reason I'd be hurt, think how blimmin rude and their reputation would quickly build up until they were entirely ostracised.

If that's what you hope for your dd, continue ignoring real life lessons such as how to phrase a refusal to do something and when it's right or wrong to do so.

MolliciousIntent · 03/11/2022 02:00

chaosmaker · 02/11/2022 19:25

Totally with you @AMorningstar people are overly sensitive when really the other person is not wasting their time or their own. Yes you can 'be nice' but life is too short with some people and those that are not offended are the keepers :D

More likely those that aren't offended are the only people who will keep you. Everyone else will opt out.

OldFan · 02/11/2022 23:04

Escape, funny. No one is ever forced to interact with anyone else in life. Except for work.

There are a lot of group social situations where you might have to have something to do with someone unless you want to leave the group.

And work is unfortunately a large amount of a lot of people's time anyway.

Also arseholes as family members or in laws are a regular subject here.

chaosmaker · 02/11/2022 22:11

SoupDragon · 02/11/2022 20:24

Or maybe those you have offended have had a lucky escape.

Escape, funny. No one is ever forced to interact with anyone else in life. Except for work.

LolaSmiles · 02/11/2022 21:54

People pleasing is when you are very concerned about what people think of you and are frightened of causing offence. Manners is when you are concerned about other people’s feelings and are considerate. There’s a difference of focus
This is true, and as parents it's our job to help our DC learn the difference.

Children with no manners will likely turn into teens with no manners, and then adults with no manners who think being rude is a brilliant personality quirk because they tell it like it is

SoupDragon · 02/11/2022 20:24

chaosmaker · 02/11/2022 19:25

Totally with you @AMorningstar people are overly sensitive when really the other person is not wasting their time or their own. Yes you can 'be nice' but life is too short with some people and those that are not offended are the keepers :D

Or maybe those you have offended have had a lucky escape.

OldFan · 02/11/2022 20:19

despite parental guidance and explanations simply do not get what they said or did that was wrong

@Discovereads The thing is she isn't getting this parental guidance. OP thinks her behaviour is something to be celebrated.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/11/2022 20:14

That sounds like “I’ll say what I want, how I want to say it, and I don’t care if I upset someone”, @chaosmaker.

I think it is perfectly possible to get your message across but without being unnecessarily mean - as I have demonstrated above. I could have been far more unpleasant about your post, but chose not to.

chaosmaker · 02/11/2022 19:25

AMorningstar · 02/11/2022 08:48

See to me that's just mincing words. The outcome is either a yes or a no, how you word it shouldn't really matter because the outcome is the same. I also think people shouldn't need someone else's validation and it's totally OK for a friend to not like something you like, or not want to do it at that particular time for whatever reason. People shouldn't take rejection so personally, and shouls be comfortable enough in themselves to get on with it.

Accept this isn't the most popular way of looking at it though.

Totally with you @AMorningstar people are overly sensitive when really the other person is not wasting their time or their own. Yes you can 'be nice' but life is too short with some people and those that are not offended are the keepers :D

MolliciousIntent · 02/11/2022 12:13

@AMorningstar out of interest, do you care about hurting people's feelings?

PotentiallyPolly · 02/11/2022 12:10

Authentic self, telling it like it is, saying you’re honest when you speak etc all translates into “I’m an utter arsehole that doesn’t give a shit about anyone bar myself” in real life. Those that follow that line of thinking often end up alone and isolated or surrounded by other equally arseholish people that back their thinking up.

Cherrytree77 · 02/11/2022 11:35

What is wrong with being kind?

Kindness isnt the same as niceness. Kindness is having empathy.

She's authentically being rude. Not sure why that's something to encourage.

There are other traits you can encourage such as independent thought, forging opinions, sticking up for what she believes is right.

Being a tactless clot will do her no favours.

Diverging · 02/11/2022 11:09

Well, it says in the OP that she's hurting people's feelings. That's not going to win her many friends, and it will lead to other people finding her rude and unpleasant.

Not to mention future potential difficulties in the work place.

BogRollBOGOF · 02/11/2022 11:01

I have a ND child who does sometimes need telling clearly where/ when/ how to apply the social filter because he doesn't reliably learn it by osmosis. A child with this kind of trait probably won't pick up on "gentle" hints and needs a direct approach themself. At 7 we had an incident where a child made a comment about DS's long hair. DS replied back with what he thought was an equal observation about the child's weight. He needed explicitly telling that society places a different value on these observations and not to comment on something that a person can't change, even if it seemed illogical to him.

There's a huge range between people pleasing and being blunt/ rude, and neither of those extremes are happy places to be. She does need to be guided to the middle.

Does school do any social skills interventions? That may be of benefit as you have the peer aspect that can be difficult to manage just at home where it's all hypothetical.

Groups like Scouting/ Guiding are also good for social skills as there's a lot of structured/ semi-structured collaborative work. Guiding has more focused content in its programme in this theme that's good for developing a range of social skills, rather than it being an underlying skill picked up through the rest of the programme.