Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the answer to ‘bed blocking’?

646 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 01/11/2022 19:07

Another day, another article about ‘bed blockers’ (put in speech marks because I know it’s a bit of a goady term).

I was shocked to find out a third of beds are taken up by ‘social patients’ in some trusts, who are medically fine to be discharged but can’t be because the care they need afterwards isn’t in place. I feel irate that the whole point of lockdowns to ‘stop the NHS from being overwhelmed’ needn’t have happened if it wasn’t overwhelmed in this way to start with.

Whats the answer? Early intervention so they don’t end up in hospital in the first place? A rise in taxes to pay for more services? I’m not sure the working population can afford to pay more tax.

The ‘ageing population’ issue means this can surely only get worse?

OP posts:
Byfleet · 06/11/2022 10:44

In my DMs (ruralish) area the local hospital which had had A and E and several other wards closed down and turned into a convalescent/rehab home with an urgent care facility attached. This is such a good idea. There is a larger than average elderly population in her area. The rehab hospital means that people can be discharged from the big, regular hospital thereby freeing acute beds. Once at the rehab hospital they can concentrate on getting a bit more mobile/stabilising new meds and family and social workers can get new, long term care sorted out. It causes extra problems to discharge people back to homes without proper preparation like making sure they are accessible and there are reliable people able to visit.

This was an absolute god send after DM had a fall and a broken hip. The hospital were making plans to discharge her to home within days when she (and I) were totally unprepared. I am afraid I bed blocked by stalling on her discharge because I knew she wouldn't be safe at home and would end up back in hospital. I then heard about the rehab hospital and pushed for that.

Rhondaa · 06/11/2022 10:25

countrygirl99 · 06/11/2022 10:18

But often people have no need these things until then. One morning 7 years ago my 76 yo MIL walked into town, met a friend to catch up over coffee, paid a bill at yhe bank, did some shopping and got the bus home. She had zero need of any help at all. That afternoon she had a catastrophic stroke and has needed 24 care ever since.

Yes of course some people have sudden catastrophic events but that can happen whether you're 76 or 40.

I'm talking about the 85yr olds who can hardly walk upstairs, the 80yr olds with mild dementia but no one dare get a home care assessment done as it will be awkward and the person still has capacity. Yes they may well do, but get carers in now doing a once a day meal prep or similar and then if you live 300miles away and don't hear from them for 2 days at least you know someone of a professional capacity is involved even at a very basic level, then more can be added to that to prevent lengthy unnecessary hospital stays awaiting a care home place.

countrygirl99 · 06/11/2022 10:18

But often people have no need these things until then. One morning 7 years ago my 76 yo MIL walked into town, met a friend to catch up over coffee, paid a bill at yhe bank, did some shopping and got the bus home. She had zero need of any help at all. That afternoon she had a catastrophic stroke and has needed 24 care ever since.

Rhondaa · 06/11/2022 09:24

'And I do not even blame the elderly relative. Care homes are generally shit and getting good home care is exceptionally hard.'

Care homes are not 'generally shit', what an awful thing to say. There are rules regulations and assessments and to ensure these places are not generally shit. Anyway I'm not talking about care homes I'm saying get the right level of support in at home and then if the elderly person ends up in hospital they can say oh yes I have a home help, meals on wheels, a stair lift, whatever so the poor hospital staff don't have to start from scratch to get things in place.

I'm sure there are people who try to get their relatives to seek help but there are also many, many people who do not and watch while the whole thing deteriorates expecting someone to wave a wand and organise social care. Then we end up with the disrespectful term 'bed blockers'.

vdbfamily · 06/11/2022 00:16

antelopevalley · 01/11/2022 23:24

Even getting a hospital bed delivered takes time. It is all very slow.

If we assess a patient as needing a hospital bed, providing our order is in by 1 pm, it can be delivered same day. However... most people needing a hospital bed will also need a package of care, which can take months to source, so we would normally order the bed on a 7 day order and upgrade to urgent if package of care is found more quickly than we thought.

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 23:47

howmanybicycles · 05/11/2022 22:08

We've had that conversation with FIL. It's not us who have our heads in the sand.

@Janiie You seem to have little understanding. Relatives have normally had those conversation multiple times but the elderly relative is an adult and refuses to consider it. Spend just a few minutes on the elderly parents board on MN and you will see it is a common scenario.
And I do not even blame the elderly relative. Care homes are generally shit and getting good home care is exceptionally hard.

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 23:43

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 05/11/2022 22:03

My elderly neighbour died recently after 6 months in hospital as they couldn't find a suitable care home to manage their dementia. They had a hear attack in a community hospital were revived, and blue lighted to the nearest A&E. Who the hell made that decision? Instead of dying quickly it was a prolonged, painful death that was badly managed. They lost so much condition in hospital they couldn't stand up independently, had dementia and were 95. Why revive them? I'm livid about it tbh. What a waste of resources and a horrible death. No-one wants to have the difficult discussions, but some of these people are so ill it's kinder to let them die than aggressively intervene in what is a natural process.

Legally the paramedics have to unless there is a DNR. This should have been in place. Everyone I know who gets to a certain age has one.

Rilokiley · 05/11/2022 23:05

Love it 😹

VisitingThem · 05/11/2022 22:17

Topgub · 01/11/2022 19:25

@StoneofDestiny

People want to be kept alive at all cost.

They want every effort made even when there is no quality of life or even chance of survival.

They think the nhs should fix every problem. Right now. For free

Except the NHS isn't free, we pay into it our whole working lives. It's not crazy for people who have paid tax and NI for 50-60 years to expect treatment.

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 05/11/2022 22:13

Ganymedemoon · 05/11/2022 22:10

Totally agree. Sadly we have seen this for years in A&E. it's really upsetting to put a patient through all of that when their prognosis is pretty dismal. Give them a peaceful dignified death.

I don't know how to get past it to be honest, the NOK is traumatized by the death and management in the hospital, and have been really concerned they should have asked for more sedation. It's bloody heartbreaking to be honest.

We have to accept we don't live forever.

Ganymedemoon · 05/11/2022 22:10

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 05/11/2022 22:03

My elderly neighbour died recently after 6 months in hospital as they couldn't find a suitable care home to manage their dementia. They had a hear attack in a community hospital were revived, and blue lighted to the nearest A&E. Who the hell made that decision? Instead of dying quickly it was a prolonged, painful death that was badly managed. They lost so much condition in hospital they couldn't stand up independently, had dementia and were 95. Why revive them? I'm livid about it tbh. What a waste of resources and a horrible death. No-one wants to have the difficult discussions, but some of these people are so ill it's kinder to let them die than aggressively intervene in what is a natural process.

Totally agree. Sadly we have seen this for years in A&E. it's really upsetting to put a patient through all of that when their prognosis is pretty dismal. Give them a peaceful dignified death.

howmanybicycles · 05/11/2022 22:08

Rhondaa · 03/11/2022 08:47

Families need to get their heads out of the sand and take some responsibility.

Many hospital admissions are after months if not years of decline. They are frail, they are struggling to manage. Their families know it but seem powerless to intervene then the person has the fall, or the serious uti whatever is the final straw that gets them admitted and lo and behold the nursing staff see what the relatives have seen but not acted on, the person cannot manage at home and a long wait for social care begins from an acute hospital bed.

So if you have a relative over 80 or even younger, who is struggling have that awkward conversation with them and tell them they need to organise social care back up at home now or risk a lengthy hospital admission followed inevitably by a care home afterwards.

How may times do we see it on here, 'my frail 84 yr old lives 200miles away and I can't get hold of him i dont know ayone local to check on him'. Absolutely no plan in place for when these very predictable things happen.

Care home places cannot be organised overnight, it usually takes weeks.

We've had that conversation with FIL. It's not us who have our heads in the sand.

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 05/11/2022 22:03

My elderly neighbour died recently after 6 months in hospital as they couldn't find a suitable care home to manage their dementia. They had a hear attack in a community hospital were revived, and blue lighted to the nearest A&E. Who the hell made that decision? Instead of dying quickly it was a prolonged, painful death that was badly managed. They lost so much condition in hospital they couldn't stand up independently, had dementia and were 95. Why revive them? I'm livid about it tbh. What a waste of resources and a horrible death. No-one wants to have the difficult discussions, but some of these people are so ill it's kinder to let them die than aggressively intervene in what is a natural process.

howmanybicycles · 05/11/2022 21:58

Kenmasterspoloneck · 01/11/2022 19:41

I understand that but my sibling and I both work, several times now I’ve had to travel a significant journey to go and support convalescence for injuries, serious illness and I’ve needed to negotiate time off work. Sometimes paid sometimes not. I’ve had to be creative and set up Rotas with other family members/ neighbours and request flexibility around working remotely and compressed hours. It’s not easy I agree but I don’t think leaving someone alone in that situation is right or fair.

I had to leave FIl in hospital. OH unable to help for health reasons. My job is patient-facing so there is no extra time off if I want to keep the job and you can't WFH. FIL is 4 hour drive away and has no other family. We cannot ask neighbours to help FIL with personal care and they are all in their 70's/ 80's - at least the ones we know. This may work for some but not many and the running of the country cannot be based on the assumption that this will be possible for all but a minority.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/11/2022 21:10

mrshoho · 05/11/2022 21:02

The additional problem is that most social care is provided by corporate businesses whose priority is to make money.

Most should be not for profit organisations, but I agree that carers should be employed by adult social care rather than ASC paying private companies to provide care packages. It’s a broken system.

But the first step is to sort out the huge shortage of carers who are out there. I don’t know how much longer we can go on as we are. It’s a huge issue every day.

mrshoho · 05/11/2022 21:02

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/11/2022 20:38

The answer is to invest in social care. Pay carers a decent wage, treat them like human beings with decent pay and working conditions. Stop viewing it as an unskilled profession (a very popular mumsnet view) and entice people into the domiciliary care sector.

no care in the community is the main reason why I can’t get my patients out of hospital and back to their own homes. Sort out social care and the nhs will follow.

The additional problem is that most social care is provided by corporate businesses whose priority is to make money.

miceonabranch · 05/11/2022 21:01

There will never be enough money to pay carers what they should be paid in order to ensure there is enough social care. Social care is a black hole that swallows vast amounts of money. The elderly population is increasing and will continue to increase. Working families can't be expected to provide the levels of care that will be needed.

If it's bad now, it's going to get a lot worse. The government have promised more cuts and austerity as well. Council Tax will massively increase to try and cover the increased social care which will place yet more pressure on working families.

Worriedddd · 05/11/2022 20:53

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 20:20

@hettie Lots of elderly people are religious and think it is wrong to commit suicide.

Religion goes out of the window when people lose their capacity. Or/are in pain . I've had many people begging to die or ask can I die now. It's horrible , I don't want that for myself.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/11/2022 20:38

The answer is to invest in social care. Pay carers a decent wage, treat them like human beings with decent pay and working conditions. Stop viewing it as an unskilled profession (a very popular mumsnet view) and entice people into the domiciliary care sector.

no care in the community is the main reason why I can’t get my patients out of hospital and back to their own homes. Sort out social care and the nhs will follow.

Kitesk · 05/11/2022 20:34

@hatgirl you have hit the nail on the head. Perhaps the reality of our time is up isn't widely talked about enough whilst we are healthy? I know it's morbid but it's the reality. I absolutely feel the same as you I don't want surgery at 80 odd.

alijangra · 05/11/2022 20:32

What’s the issue with an 82 year old having a stent?

Kitesk · 05/11/2022 20:30

Topgub · 01/11/2022 19:17

Stopping allowing social admissions.

Stopping gps admitting pts to hospital because they are short staffed /can't cope with the work load.

Making the general public take more responsibility for their own health and social care needs

Fixing the social care crisis

addressing public perception of death and dying

Better pay and conditions for hcp.

I don't think the majority are solely social admissions.

People have been admitted with an illness/problem then because of all the paper work nowadays patients are not deemed fit for discharge. I have no idea what the solution is tbh.

Blossomtoes · 05/11/2022 20:27

You don’t know everyone over 80 @antelopevalley.

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 20:24

Blossomtoes · 05/11/2022 20:21

Twenty years ago maybe, not any more.

You are wrong. Anyone I know in their eighties and older are horrified at this idea.

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 20:22

mrshoho · 05/11/2022 19:08

Yes but successive governments forced encouraged women into the workplace once children were in school and most families now rely on double incomes to exist. Also put up the retirement age so women are working til at least 67. The world is a very different place. More women may wish to care for elderly relatives but are financially unable to give up work. If the government actually paid a decent carer's allowance it may help ease the burden on the state.

It was pointed out at the time that making sure women were in the workplace until at least 67 would have social repercussions.
Families can not care if they are all working.

Swipe left for the next trending thread