Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the answer to ‘bed blocking’?

646 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 01/11/2022 19:07

Another day, another article about ‘bed blockers’ (put in speech marks because I know it’s a bit of a goady term).

I was shocked to find out a third of beds are taken up by ‘social patients’ in some trusts, who are medically fine to be discharged but can’t be because the care they need afterwards isn’t in place. I feel irate that the whole point of lockdowns to ‘stop the NHS from being overwhelmed’ needn’t have happened if it wasn’t overwhelmed in this way to start with.

Whats the answer? Early intervention so they don’t end up in hospital in the first place? A rise in taxes to pay for more services? I’m not sure the working population can afford to pay more tax.

The ‘ageing population’ issue means this can surely only get worse?

OP posts:
Topgub · 01/11/2022 20:29

@Tiani4

My area cannot source care at all.

There are no carers. Not private, not LA.

The average wait for a POC is 3 months.

Full poc? No chance

Neome · 01/11/2022 20:29

mummyh2016 · 01/11/2022 19:59

I'm not saying the other poster is right but if I remember correctly you were allowed to travel if it was to care for an elderly or vulnerable person. You would've come under this surely.

This is exactly why competent support was needed. Getting things to work at home might mean sourcing equipment, helping friends and relatives to think through or negotiate time off, and in this instance rapidly assessing the new Covid regulations.

Everyone’s situation is unique and there are widely differing ways to make the jigsaw work for someone to go home with support.

It doesn’t work to say ‘it’s up to the patient to take responsibility’ because I think it is very likely that there are a large percentage of patients stuck like this who really don’t want to be. If they were able to organise their discharge they’d be out of hospital like a shot.

StoneofDestiny · 01/11/2022 20:28

@iwasabedblocker just ignore that poster who won't leave you alone, they seem to obsessively target anyone vulnerable and honest. I'm sorry you went through that through no fault of your own and I'm sorry that that poster is making you feel bad about your experience

Absolutely agree.
If I was a person 'bed blocking' reading this I'd be afraid of someone putting a pillow over my head if any of these posters were in health or social care.
Heaven help they way our society is going - survival of the fittest!

Worriedddd · 01/11/2022 20:28

Social care pay is piss poor for HCAs and conditions. The NHS you will get unsociable hours payments , sick pay and maternity leave. Social care has none of those perks and minimum wage. Social generally pays better for nurses but not carers. They are seriously struggling with recruitment. You can getter perks working in a supermarket.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 01/11/2022 20:28

I actually can't believe people would rather have euthanasia than increased taxes, which is what a lot of this thread boils down to. People with capacity can already refuse care if they want to.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 01/11/2022 20:27

A national care service sounds like a great idea- and could work more closely with the NHS to make things more successful for people. Unlike private care homes, it wouldn't need to be run for a profit, which is already a saving- and if successful, I imagine it would also save the NHS some money.

Yes, there would need to be money paid in from somewhere, but right now it's clear the taxes we are paying are not supporting our national infrastructure- so we need to increase taxes somewhere. It doesn't have to be income tax, there are other taxes which could be looked at- certainly a windfall tax on large profits etc.

That said, I do think our priority should be looking after society as whole, not accumulating increased wealth!

If we could push wages up, an increase in income tax wouldn't be so bad, as well.

I don't think it's viable to force people to rely on friends/family, it's not always realistic, and ultimately it pulls people out of the workforce.

Topgub · 01/11/2022 20:26

@crosstalk

When they are actually dying?

Yes.

But it takes along time sometimes to get to that point.

Lots of interventions. Lots of life extending medications and procedures before the inevitable is accepted.

It's a fact that the largest health care spend per person occurs in the last year of life as we fight the inevitable.

I'm a bit surprised people are denying this is the case.

Lack of actual experience probably.

I'm certainly not suggesting we euthanise elderly people.

But we do have to have serious conversations about what the state can afford or is willing to provide.

Health and social care are expensive. really expensive.

It has to be paid for some how.

Personally I'd massively increase taxes, crack down on tax avoidance and care fee avoidance.

Reverse the govt focus on care in the community and introduce nhs care homes and social care.

Lots of focus on prevention.

And yes. Discussions with pts and families about what is a realistic expectation on prolonging life. And what is reasonable to expect the nhs to provide for what we pay in.

whatami2 · 01/11/2022 20:25

Kenmasterspoloneck · 01/11/2022 19:24

The amount of medication given to elderly patients to prop them up is mind boggling. It’s like a minefield trying to work out what is illness and side effect. With my elderly parents it’s one thing after another a good deal of which are being caused by meds. GPS don’t consider the wider picture anymore it’s just one sticking plaster on top of another kicking the can down the road.

If by Sticking a plaster over another and kicking the can down the road you mean keeping your parents alive: yes that’s what gps do. People with a high amount of comorbilities would be dead 40 years ago. Now we kick the can down the road and we get to live longer, and in a physical and mental condition that you wouldn’t see back then.
people also need to understand how prolonging unnecessarily the life to very frail and sick people is not dignifying nor compassionate. For example, some patients, bed bound, peg fed, advanced dementia and recurrent aspiration pneumonias which mean recurrent hospital admissions for IVs as painful procedures such as nasal suction (aka passing a tube from your nose to your trachea to aspirate all yucky stuck while you choke in these secretions). I would say, why not accepting they are at the end of their lives and further hospital admissions do only prolong suffering speak with palliative care team and try to keep them comfortable in their residences. Before everyone jumps at me, This is only for those very advanced cases were everyone can agree that patient quality of life is extremely poor and health is very fragile with recurrent hospital admissions and no mental capacity (if patient has capacity this should be respected, whatever it is).

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 20:25

Blibbleflibble · 01/11/2022 20:23

Properly funded social care.

Well , now, Wes always live better funding .. most people don't want their taxes increased and social care reform bill (delayed several times) may impact on that.

But I can't comment

dollyblack · 01/11/2022 20:25

Nodding along with a lot of this. I have an elderly relative (who also has a very long term profound disability) who went in to hospital with covid before they knew about covid and was stuck in hospital for over a year as there was nowhere for him to come out to (his needs increased so much in hospital, no regular social contact/physio etc that he could no longer be supported at home- already had 4 x a day carers and his wife). Along the way many infections etc but they kept treating everything despite that fact he is 80+ and unable to eat (tube fed)/sit etc. He was discharged to a nursing home that his wife is now using £4k a WEEK to pay for, for him to be depressed in a bed 24/7. My heart breaks for both of them, neither of them have any quality of life - her life is on hold- and she is so scared about all the money.

Family cannot step up. Not even talking about my situation as his needs were always beyond family support. But we are all working, raising kids. AND for many of us, we are realising our parents have not been there to support us when we were toiling and on our knees with young kids/work etc, they had "raised their kids" and were off on holiday and enjoying themselves. so not only do we not have time, we maybe also don't have the inclination when we were offered no support at our time of need.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 20:23

crosstalk · 01/11/2022 20:22

@Tiani4

Are they spreading the message?

I expect so
We are not the only LA that has these excellent tested arrangements

Blibbleflibble · 01/11/2022 20:23

Properly funded social care.

Raddix · 01/11/2022 20:23

Honestly I think the answer is just for the NHS to draw a line where their responsibility ends. If you’re healthy you get discharged - whether you need additional care after that isn’t their problem. Families would have to step up, or people would have to manage on their own, or organise their own care. I think it’s wrong that this responsibility is being laid on the NHS, it shouldn’t be their job to organise care after people have left hospital.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 20:22

There doesn't need to be "bed blocking" if the LA and health service work together

Expect when court processes override those . Our biggest challenges often aren't about finding what is right fit for our clients but other factors

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 01/11/2022 20:22

@iwasabedblocker just ignore that poster who won't leave you alone, they seem to obsessively target anyone vulnerable and honest. I'm sorry you went through that through no fault of your own and I'm sorry that that poster is making you feel bad about your experience.

crosstalk · 01/11/2022 20:22

@Tiani4

Are they spreading the message?

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 01/11/2022 20:20

Land Value Tax to fund more social care places. Let the Duke of Westminster and other major landowners pay for it.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 20:19
  • for a very large complex care package

Sorry my phone hates me! It autocorrects in bizarre ways!

Theluggage15 · 01/11/2022 20:18

The place they got my dad into was perfect, it used to be a cottage hospital and now provides physical rehabilitation and also has a minor injuries unit. People get the help they need and it enables them to get back to their homes more speedily and takes pressure off the main hospital.

There need to be more of these places, it just makes sense. My dad was in a room with a man in his forties who’d lost part of his leg in an accident so they’re not just for the elderly either.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 20:18

Sorry mistype
*Bit of waiting occasionally for a wet large complex card package at home but days not weeks ...

crosstalk · 01/11/2022 20:18

@Topgub Rubbish. Most elderly people would want to be made comfortable and go their way quietly. They do need to do end of life forms with their doctor saying do not resuscitate or whatever. The problem is that social care is desperately underfunded - so if an elderly person goes home to an unfit house s/he cannot be discharged or is discharged and then readmitted in days costing the hospital a penalty. They also may have a spouse not able to cope with them and no family nearby.

It doesn't help that carers are paid a pittance and there is no defined career path - so carers tend to be stop gap. And run ragged by council demands they spend 15 minutes to visit an elderly person. Private companies here offer half an hour in the morning - can you imagine getting them out of bed, washed and dressed, medications administered and fed in that time? to say nothing of cleaning sheets?

StoneofDestiny · 01/11/2022 20:17

Now this is controversial but in terms of funding, I think we should crack down on those who can afford their own care but who weasel out of paying e.g. by transferring assets to family members in their old age etc. Recoup care costs from the estate once someone is deceased

Back to the argument - do you punish those who have put money aside and saved for their rainy day or old age while giving free care to those who have spent freely on the 'fast life' of foreign holidays, cars, lively social life, big families etc etc. Many have money in the bank because they have saved, not because they earned too much.

What will happen is that people who have 'saved' and lived frugally will shift their money to stop the government getting their hands on it. It's dangerous to punish those who have been saved.

If they earned more, they will have already been taxed more - we shouldn't take money from them twice over!

Are we going to deny other 'services' to those with more money - hospital care? maternity care? education? Or are we just targeting old people?

DamnUserName21 · 01/11/2022 20:17

I disagree that most elderly want to be kept alive at all costs. As PP said, their families are a different matter.

I feel a national care service is a great idea. I also feel there needs to be more rehab (convalescent or step down) hospitals and more state-owned care homes. At present rehab placements are being run through private nursing homes in my area with limited access to OT/physio input.

There needs to be more OT and physios for the above. In terms of the latter, there are loads out there, they've just gone private due to better pay and working conditions.

I do feel this should be uniform around the UK. I don't feel different trusts should have different paperwork, policies, procedures, uniforms, etc. It's inefficient and wasteful. Don't get me started on different software per trust...

I also feel 'the state owes a duty of care' rhetoric needs to be abandoned. This attitude is what is stopping a lot of people (who can afford it) from paying towards their care and disenfranchises family members who can help from doing so.

Along with the 'well, I paid my taxes' talk, which annoys the fuck out of me because most of us will have received more (education, healthcare from gestation, benefits, pension, etc) than we've paid in.

Tiani4 · 01/11/2022 20:16

In our LA (I am an adult and Older adults SW) there are discharge to assess (D2A) beds with non chargeable (to service user) re ablement beds for up to 6 weeks in designated nursing homes with reablement MDT and social workers following up to manage that transition and transition after. Very proactive teams to prevent social care bed blocking but mostly aimed at keeping our clients independent as possible where we can

. We also have MDT (multi disciplinary teams) re-abling , and short term services and rapid response teams to get people out of hospital if not required and prevent hospital admissions . My LA (county council) is leader in these arrangements.

But sometimes there are people without capacity that are objecting without capacity under DOLS (MCA 2005) and it has to wait for Court of protection judge . That is so delayed and so slow a court process (up to a year) it is something legally we cannot make faster as it's a legal court requirement and I cannot comment. But ....

No one is delayed in an unnecessary hospital bed if we can help it as social care here.

A bit of occasional waiting gif a pAckage but we are talking days not weeks, our processes are so resp sure e and fast fast to go home with supprt or to a D2A bed or to a placement of that is certain and wanted .
Sometimes other factors delay it out if our control sometimes families argue amongst themselves, but believe me social care can and do work incredibly hard. At least my LA do.

Topsyturvy78 · 01/11/2022 20:13

We have plenty of care homes where I live. One local hotel is now a care home. The problem is getting enough staff.

Yes earlier intervention will help. I have been there myself with my daughter. There's been a few times If she had been seen sooner she wouldn't have needed to stay in hospital. It's not only the elderly who bed block. But there has to be something better than keeping them in hospital. Which are also short staffed.